An accessible ramp leading to a civic building at dawn, for a story on the medically frail ruling and Medicaid work rules

NewsroomDisability advocacyNews

Judge Strikes Narrow โ€˜Medically Frailโ€™ Test: What It Means for OHP

A federal judge struck down CMS's narrow test for who counts as medically frail under the new Medicaid work rules. Here is what it changes for Oregon Health Plan members before Jan. 1, 2027.

The ruling restores the line Congress drew for people who are medically frail.

A federal judge has struck down the narrow test the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) wrote for who counts as medically frail under the new Medicaid work rules. On October 29, 2026, Judge Richard G. Stearns of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts held that the definition was contrary to the law Congress passed, and vacated the offending language. Oregon and Washington were among the 25 states, joined by the District of Columbia, that brought the case.

The medically frail exemption decides whether a disabled adult on Medicaid has to log 80 hours a month of work, school or volunteering to keep coverage. For many disabled people, it is the difference between a quiet automatic exemption and a paperwork test they may not be able to pass. The Medicaid work requirements begin on January 1, 2027. This explainer sets out what the judge decided, what stayed in place, and what Oregon Health Plan members can do now.

01

What the judge decided about medically frail

The columned steps of a federal courthouse at dawn, for the section on what the judge decided about medically frail
Fig. 1The ruling came from the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts. (AI illustration)

The case is Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz, No. 26-12962-RGS. The states sued CMS, its administrator Mehmet Oz, the Department of Health and Human Services and Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. after CMS issued an interim final rule in June 2026 to carry out the work requirements in H.R. 1, the 2025 budget law, Georgetown’s Center for Children and Families reports.

The fight was over one sentence. CMS’s rule said a person counted as medically frail only if their physical, mental or behavioral health condition “significantly impairs” their ability to comply with the community engagement requirement, the opinion records. In plain words, being very sick was not enough. A person had to be too sick to do the hours and the reporting.

Judge Stearns found that limit narrower than Congress allowed. “Every other exemption from the community engagement requirement created by Congress operates categorically,” he wrote. He added that “Congress clearly knew how to qualify classifications and did so where it wished.” Congress put no severity test on the medically frail exemption, so CMS could not add one.

The remedy goes beyond a pause. The court vacated the offending language, granted the states a permanent injunction, and gave them a six-month stay of enforcement on any decision about who is or is not medically frail. Healthcare Dive reports that CMS declined to comment, citing the pending litigation. The judge wrote that the text “can easily be excised” from the rule without affecting its other provisions.

02

Who counts as medically frail under H.R. 1

Under H.R. 1, people who are medically frail are exempt from the Medicaid work requirements. The statute covers an individual “who is medically frail or otherwise has special medical needs,” and the opinion notes that the term must include five listed groups.

Those groups include people who are blind or disabled, people with a substance use disorder, and people with a serious or complex medical condition. Georgetown’s summary of the law also names people with mental health conditions and functional impairments. Congress drew a wide circle. CMS tried to draw a smaller one inside it.

That is why the medically frail ruling matters so much to disabled people. Every other exemption in the law works by category: you are in the group or you are not. The court held that being medically frail works the same way, with no extra test of how much your condition limits you.

03

What the ruling did not change

Not everything CMS wrote fell. The judge rejected the states’ challenges to two other parts of the rule, Healthcare Dive reports. States may still look back only 12 months at medical claims and clinical visit data when they decide who is medically frail, and the limits on how often people can attest to it themselves remain.

The start date did not move either. A footnote in the opinion says the six-month stay does not affect the January 1, 2027 deadline for the Medicaid work requirements to begin. Georgetown notes that Congress allowed “Good Faith Effort” delays for states that are not ready, and that CMS has signaled it would grant them sparingly, if at all.

CMS can still appeal. A separate case brought by Medicaid enrollees and providers, Taylor v. Kennedy, is still pending, according to Georgetown, and Healthcare Dive reports that it was filed in September.

04

Legal words in this story, in plain language

Court rulings come with their own vocabulary. Here is what the key terms mean in this case:

  • Medically frail: the term Congress used for people who are exempt from the work rules because of their health. The law says it includes people who are blind or disabled, people with a substance use disorder and people with a serious or complex medical condition, among others.
  • Community engagement requirement: the formal name in the law for the Medicaid work requirements. It means 80 hours a month of work, school, volunteering or a mix, unless you are exempt or meet the rule another way, such as through income.
  • Interim final rule: a rule an agency puts into effect before it finishes taking public comment. CMS issued one in June 2026 to carry out H.R. 1.
  • Vacated: struck out. The court removed the narrow medically frail language from the rule, so it no longer has legal force.
  • Permanent injunction: a court order that bars the government from doing something. Here it protects the states that brought the case.
  • Stay of enforcement: a pause. For six months, CMS cannot enforce its own view of who is medically frail against those states.
  • Good Faith Effort delay: extra time Congress allowed for states that are working to get ready but are not there yet.

05

What the medically frail ruling means for the Oregon Health Plan

Oregon is one of the plaintiff states, so the injunction and the six-month stay both protect Oregon directly. Georgetown reads the vacatur as nationwide, which would mean the narrow test is gone for every state, not only the ones that sued. Either way, Oregon does not have to apply a severity test to people who are medically frail.

The Oregon Health Authority’s own guidance already reads broadly. Its guide for people with disabilities says the work or activity rules apply to some OHP members ages 19 to 64 starting January 1, 2027, and it lists who may be exempt. You do not need to know which OHP program you are on, or produce a Social Security disability decision, to get an exemption.

“OHP will use information it already has to check your status,” the guide says. Multnomah County tells people in its intellectual and developmental disability services the same thing: “Exemptions are checked automatically: State staff will check your eligibility for exemptions when you apply or renew.”

06

Who is exempt from Oregon’s work rules

Unopened envelopes, reading glasses and a pill organizer on a kitchen table, for the section on who counts as medically frail in Oregon
Fig. 2For many OHP members, the exemption arrives as a notice at the kitchen table. (AI illustration)

According to the Oregon Health Authority, you may be exempt from the Oregon Health Plan work rules if any of these apply to you:

  • You are 65 or older.
  • You get OHP through a disability-based program.
  • You have a disability or a serious or disabling health condition, including a mental health condition.
  • You receive Supplemental Security Income (SSI).
  • You spent at least one night as a hospital patient or in a similar facility.
  • You are a veteran with a total disability rating.
  • You have Medicare Part A or Part B, or you qualify for Medicare.
  • You have an alcohol or drug use disorder, or you are in treatment, including medication for opioid use disorder.

The list is not complete, and OHA says other exemptions may apply. Its advice for anyone unsure is short: “Not sure if one of these applies to you? Tell OHP anyway.”

If you are not exempt, OHA says you can meet the rules with household income of at least $580 a month, half-time school, or 80 hours a month of qualifying activities. The guide counts caregiving among the activities that may help. And in 2027, OHA’s federal changes page says, proof is not needed for exemptions, though more exemptions will require proof in 2028.

07

What to do before January 1

A desk telephone beside a blank notebook and a lamp, for the section on steps medically frail OHP members can take before January 1
Fig. 3One call now can keep your coverage steady later. (AI illustration)

Nobody should have to fight for an exemption Congress already wrote into law. Still, a few small steps now protect your coverage later. These all come from the Oregon Health Authority’s guide:

  • Update your address, phone number and email with OHP so notices reach you. Call 1-800-699-9075 (relay calls welcome) or go to benefits.oregon.gov.
  • Tell OHP about any disability or health need that is not already on your case, even if you think it is on file.
  • Open every OHP notice and answer anything with a due date.
  • Name a trusted person as your authorized representative if you want help with renewals and updates.
  • Ask for help in another language or format, or find a free OHP assister at oregonhealthcare.gov/GetHelp.
  • For questions about disability services, call the Aging and Disability Resource Connection at 855-673-2372.

OHA says notices about the work rules began going out in September 2026. If you received one and it does not reflect your disability, that is exactly the situation to call about. If you are medically frail and OHP does not seem to know it yet, the time to say so is now, not in January.

08

If you get OHP through I/DD services

People who receive intellectual and developmental disability (I/DD) services in Multnomah County got their own explainer from the county in September. Its central message is the one quoted above: state staff check exemptions automatically when you apply or renew.

The ruling helps here too. With the narrow medically frail test gone, the question is whether you fall within the groups Congress listed. It is not whether your condition significantly impairs your ability to meet the work rules.

Automatic checks still depend on the records being right. If you have a services coordinator, a personal agent or a guardian, ask them to confirm that your OHP case lists your disability and your current address. For general county questions, Multnomah County’s information line is 503-823-4000.

09

A note for Washington Apple Health members

Washington is also a plaintiff state, so the injunction and the six-month stay protect Washington the same way they protect Oregon. Washington’s Medicaid program, Apple Health, is run by the Washington State Health Care Authority, and its notices are the ones to watch if you live north of the Columbia.

This guide follows Oregon’s rules, and Washington’s details may differ. The basic steps carry over: keep your contact details current, tell Apple Health about any disability or health need, and answer anything with a due date. If you are medically frail and unsure whether your record shows it, ask.

10

More OHP changes coming in 2027 and 2028

The work rules are not the only part of H.R. 1 arriving in Oregon. Starting January 1, 2027, OHA says, OHP will cover past medical bills from a shorter window. Most adults ages 19 to 64 who do not qualify through disability, pregnancy or certain other factors will get one month of past bills, and others get up to two.

From late 2027, many adults ages 19 to 64 will renew every six months instead of every year. People with Medicare or disability-based OHP keep yearly renewals, as do members with pregnancy-based OHP and American Indian and Alaska Native members. From October 2028, some adults will pay small copays for certain care, though people with disability-based OHP or Medicare are exempt.

For disabled Oregonians who get OHP through a disability-based program, the message is steadier than the headlines suggest. Most of these new hoops are not meant for you. The task is to make sure OHP knows who you are, so the system treats you that way.

11

Why the medically frail ruling matters beyond the paperwork

Work requirements are often described as a test of effort. For disabled people they are mostly a test of paperwork: whether the right box is checked, the right letter is opened and the right record is on file. A narrow medically frail definition would have turned that paperwork into a second disability assessment, decided by a benefits system instead of a clinician.

Judge Stearns’s ruling restores the line Congress drew. If you are medically frail, you are exempt. You do not have to prove you are sick enough.

Anthony Wright of Families USA said the decision “brings a welcome reprieve,” Healthcare Dive reports, and Dr. Willie Underwood, president of the American Medical Association, called it a “victory for patients.” A reprieve is the right word. The start date has not moved, an appeal is possible, and the second lawsuit is still open.

12

What to watch next

The medically frail ruling settles one question, and several others are still open. Here is what Bloom is watching:

  • An appeal. When a federal agency is a party, the federal appellate rules generally allow 60 days after judgment to file a notice of appeal. CMS has not said whether it will.
  • The Taylor case. The separate suit by Medicaid enrollees and providers is still pending, and we will report when the court rules.
  • New guidance from CMS. With the narrow language struck, CMS may send states new instructions on who is medically frail.
  • OHP notices. OHA says more exemptions will require proof in 2028, so the records you fix now will matter again later.

13

What Bloom is doing

Bloom’s newsroom will follow the appeal, if CMS files one, and the Taylor case, and we will link the filings so you can read them yourself. You can follow that reporting in our Disability Advocacy newsroom. Last month we wrote about the caregiving crisis, and this ruling belongs to the same story: care that depends on paperwork working.

Bloom’s disability advocacy work starts from a simple conviction: disabled people should not have to prove their worth to keep their care. If a notice from OHP has you worried, read it with someone you trust, and call OHP before the due date.

And if what you need is a pastor, someone to pray with you or simply to listen, Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

14

Frequently Asked Questions

Under H.R. 1, people who are medically frail are exempt from the Medicaid work requirements. The law says the term includes people who are blind or disabled, people with a substance use disorder and people with a serious or complex medical condition, among others.

He held that CMS’s definition of medically frail was contrary to law because it required a condition that significantly impairs a person’s ability to comply. He vacated that language, granted the plaintiff states a permanent injunction, and gave them a six-month stay of enforcement.

Yes. Oregon and Washington are among the 25 states that sued, along with the District of Columbia, in Commonwealth of Massachusetts v. Oz.

Yes. The opinion says the six-month stay does not affect the January 1, 2027 deadline. The Oregon Health Authority says the rules apply to some OHP members ages 19 to 64.

No. The Oregon Health Authority says you do not need a Social Security disability decision, or to know your OHP program, to get an exemption. OHP will use information it already has and will send a notice if it needs more.

OHA lists receiving SSI as its own exemption, so you do not need to show you are medically frail if you receive SSI. Keep your contact details current with OHP and answer any notice it sends.

Yes. CMS can appeal, and a separate lawsuit by Medicaid enrollees and providers, Taylor v. Kennedy, is still pending. Healthcare Dive reports that CMS declined to comment, citing the litigation.

Call OHP at 1-800-699-9075 (relay calls welcome), visit benefits.oregon.gov, or find a free assister at oregonhealthcare.gov/GetHelp. For disability services questions, call the Aging and Disability Resource Connection at 855-673-2372.

Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ŸŒธ

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.