Shelves of peppers, tomatoes, limes and lemons in a grocery store produce case, for a report on SNAP categorical eligibility

NewsroomDisability advocacyNews

USDA Moves to Narrow SNAP Categorical Eligibility for 6.3 Million

USDA proposed on November 10 to end the broad SNAP eligibility rule that 46 states and territories use, and its own analysis says 6.3 million people would lose food aid by 2029.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture proposed on November 10 to end broad-based categorical eligibility in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, the rule that lets most states open SNAP to working families above the federal income line and to households with modest savings. The proposed rule would limit categorical eligibility to households that receive ongoing cash assistance from Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, known as TANF, and shut the door that non-cash TANF services open today.

USDA’s own analysis estimates that 3.2 million households, about 6.3 million people, would lose SNAP once the change takes full effect in fiscal year 2029. That is about one in six households now in the program. The public has until December 10 to comment. In Oregon and Washington, where state rules set SNAP’s gross income limit at 200% of the federal poverty guidelines and set no asset limit at all, the change would undo the rules that let many households qualify today.

01

What USDA proposed on November 10

The proposed rule is titled “Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program: Reforming Categorical Eligibility.” It comes from USDA’s Food and Nutrition Administration, carries the regulatory identifier RIN 0584-AF10 and sits in public docket FNA-2026-0661. It was scheduled for publication in the Federal Register on November 10, 2026.

The legal starting point is short. Under section 5(a) of the Food and Nutrition Act of 2008, a household in which every member receives benefits from a state program funded by TANF is categorically eligible for SNAP. Current SNAP regulations count both cash assistance and non-cash or in-kind benefits as TANF benefits. That second half is what the proposed rule would remove.

Under the proposal, categorical eligibility would follow the federal definition of TANF “assistance.” News4JAX reports that USDA describes that definition as cash, payments, vouchers and benefits that meet ongoing basic needs. Households that get only a non-cash or nominal TANF service would have to qualify the ordinary way, through SNAP’s income and resource tests.

USDA presents the change as a matter of consistency and stewardship. Gray News reports that the agency says the rule would make eligibility more standardized and “preserve benefits for the truly needy.” The proposed rule itself puts it more sharply: “It is irresponsible to Congress and the taxpayer to support regulations that permit this practice.”

02

How categorical eligibility works today

Broad-based categorical eligibility, often shortened to BBCE, works through a small door. A state uses TANF money to fund a modest service, such as a referral line or a printed pamphlet about other programs. Every household that receives that service becomes categorically eligible for SNAP, and the state can then set its own income and asset limits for SNAP inside federal bounds.

News4JAX describes the kinds of services that count: childcare referrals, or access to a phone line that connects families to other help. States have used broad-based categorical eligibility to reach families just above the federal income line and households with savings that would otherwise disqualify them.

The scale is large. The proposed rule reports that 46 states used broad-based categorical eligibility as of December 2025. Of those, 37 set a gross income limit above SNAP’s federal limit, and 41 set no resource limit at all.

Without categorical eligibility, the federal rules are stricter. Most households must pass both a gross income test and a net income test. USDA’s rules for elderly and disabled households set the resource limit at $3,000 in countable resources for most households, and $4,750 for a household with a member who is 60 or older or disabled, for October 1, 2026 through September 30, 2027.

03

Who would lose SNAP, by USDA’s numbers

The proposed rule’s own executive summary carries the hardest figures. About 16.9% of participating households, or 17.6% of participants, would lose SNAP. That is 3.2 million households and 6.3 million people in fiscal year 2029, the first year of full effect.

The rule also measures today’s baseline. In fiscal year 2024, about 2.5 million households with 5.4 million people had resources above SNAP’s federal resource limit. About 1.2 million households with 2.0 million people had income above the federal income limits. Categorical eligibility is what keeps them in the program now.

Some of the smallest households are touched most directly. One- and two-person households receive a minimum benefit of 8% of the one-person maximum allotment, which was $23 a month in fiscal year 2025. The rule reports that more than 840,000 of those households received the minimum benefit in 2024 only because of broad-based categorical eligibility. That came to nearly $214 million.

The savings USDA projects are just as large. Federal SNAP benefit spending would fall by about $44.649 billion over fiscal years 2027 through 2031. The rule also estimates a net reduction of about $5.243 billion in state SNAP spending over the same five years. It puts the change in federal reimbursement of state administrative costs at about $309.5 million over that period.

04

What the proposal leaves in place

The proposed rule is about who qualifies automatically. It doesn’t end categorical eligibility itself. Section 5(a) of the Food and Nutrition Act still makes a household categorically eligible when every member receives TANF-funded benefits, and the proposal keeps that route open for households that receive TANF cash assistance.

It also doesn’t set new federal income or resource limits. The limits that would apply to households that lose categorical eligibility are the ones USDA already publishes: $3,000 in countable resources for most households and $4,750 for a household with an elderly or disabled member, for the year that began October 1, 2026.

And the special rules for elderly and disabled households described on USDA’s eligibility page are separate from this proposal. USDA’s summary of the proposed rule doesn’t describe changing the net-income-only test, the medical expense deduction or the shelter deduction. Those rules matter for the section below, because they decide how a disabled household is tested once categorical eligibility no longer covers it.

The timing matters too. USDA’s analysis treats fiscal year 2029 as the first year of full effect, which means its estimates describe a change that would phase in after a final rule, not one that happens this winter.

05

Children, school meals and WIC

SNAP eligibility reaches beyond the grocery store. Children in SNAP households are categorically eligible for free school meals, and the proposed rule estimates that about 1.78 million children would lose that automatic route.

USDA’s analysis says about 97% of those children would still qualify for free or reduced-price meals through the income-based application. Its breakdown: about 1.66 million would stay free, about 93,000 would move to reduced price, and about 28,000 would pay full price. Schools would process about 197,000 additional applications, at a cost of about $6.3 million over five years.

Summer meals would shift too. About 42,000 children could lose Summer EBT eligibility starting in summer 2029, a figure that includes about 13,000 children whose families the rule expects would choose not to apply.

News4JAX also reports that about 5,500 women, infants and children who are eligible for WIC through broad-based categorical eligibility would lose that eligibility.

For families, the practical message is simple. A child who loses automatic free school meals can still apply on the school’s income form, and most will still qualify. The paperwork is the risk, and so is the stigma some families feel about filling it out.

06

What it means for disabled and older adults

USDA’s own rules already treat households with an elderly or disabled member differently. The agency’s page on special rules says such a household “only has to meet the net income test.” It also allows a medical expense deduction for costs above $35 a month and an uncapped shelter deduction for those households.

That means the gross income limit, the part of broad-based categorical eligibility that many states raised to 200% of poverty, matters less for disabled and older households than for others. The resource limit is a different story. Under the federal rules, a household with a member who is 60 or older or disabled may hold no more than $4,750 in countable resources.

In a state with no asset limit, that federal resource limit doesn’t apply to households that are categorically eligible. If categorical eligibility narrows to TANF cash recipients, a disabled person who lost it would be tested against the $4,750 resource limit again. An emergency fund or money set aside for a large purchase could put them over.

The proposed rule’s civil rights impact analysis says households with elderly members could be affected. It gives no count of affected elderly or disabled households, and Bloom won’t estimate one. What can be said is that the federal resource limit returns for anyone who loses categorical eligibility, and disabled households are subject to it.

If you’re disabled and on SNAP, three questions are worth asking your caseworker now. Do you qualify through categorical eligibility, or through the standard tests? What countable resources does your file show? And would you meet the $4,750 resource limit if the rule took effect?

07

Oregon, Washington and Idaho

USDA’s broad-based categorical eligibility chart, updated in June 2026, shows how far the Northwest relies on this rule. Oregon sets SNAP’s gross income limit at 200% of the federal poverty guidelines with no limit on assets, and lists a pamphlet as its TANF-funded service. Washington also uses 200% with no asset limit, and puts its information and referral service on the approval letter.

Idaho is different. It keeps SNAP’s 130% gross income limit and a $5,000 asset limit, with a flyer about its referral service. The proposal would change less for Idaho households than for their neighbors to the west.

For Oregon and Washington, the proposed rule would remove the state rule that sets both of those limits. Households above SNAP’s federal income limits, or with countable resources above the federal resource limit, would no longer qualify through categorical eligibility unless they also receive TANF cash assistance.

Bloom wrote about the SNAP crisis a year ago, and this week about how Nebraska’s Medicaid work rules turned paperwork into lost coverage. A proposed rule that moves people from automatic eligibility to individual testing carries the same paperwork risk.

08

The 2019 proposal and what happened to it

This isn’t the first attempt. On July 24, 2019, USDA proposed “Revision of Categorical Eligibility in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP),” published at 84 FR 35570. That version would have limited categorical eligibility to TANF benefits that were “ongoing and substantial.”

The 2019 framework required a benefit to last at least six months and be worth $50 or more a month. It would have limited non-cash benefits to subsidized employment, work supports and childcare. The Biden administration withdrew that proposal on June 10, 2021, at 86 FR 30795.

The 2026 proposed rule goes further than the 2019 version. Instead of setting a floor for which non-cash benefits count, it ties categorical eligibility to cash assistance. USDA argues this is simpler for states than the 2019 framework, News4JAX reports.

USDA’s case rests on program integrity. News4JAX reports that the agency cites a 2012 Government Accountability Office report that found a 17.2% payment error rate in households that qualified through broad-based categorical eligibility, compared with 6.7% for other SNAP households. USDA also points to a Minnesota millionaire who received benefits through the rule.

Readers deserve both sides plainly. USDA says the rule closes a gap that lets households over the federal limits receive benefits. Its own analysis says 6.3 million people would lose food aid as a result. Both of those statements come from the same document.

09

How to comment by December 10

A proposed rule isn’t final. It invites public comment, and the agency’s answer to those comments shapes whatever comes next. The comment period on this proposed rule closes on December 10, 2026, News4JAX reports.

You can comment three ways:

  • Online at regulations.gov, under docket FNA-2026-0661.
  • By email to sm.fn.snappdbrules@usda.gov.
  • By mail to the SNAP Program Development Division, Food and Nutrition Administration, 5601 Sunnyside Ave., Beltsville, MD 20705.

A useful comment is specific. Say who you are and which state you live in. Say how SNAP works in your household, whether you think you qualify through categorical eligibility, and what the federal resource limit or income test would mean for you. Agencies read numbers and lived detail more closely than slogans.

If you’re a provider, a school district or a food bank, say how many people you serve and what the extra applications would cost you. The rule’s own figures on school meal applications show that this work lands somewhere.

Nothing about SNAP benefits changes today because of this proposal. After the comment period closes, USDA reviews the comments before it can publish a final rule, and the final version can differ from the proposal. Keep using your benefits, keep your recertification dates, and keep copies of what you send your caseworker.

10

What Bloom is doing

Bloom’s newsroom will follow this proposed rule through the comment period and report the final rule when USDA publishes it, with the documents linked so you can read them yourself. You’ll find that coverage in the Legislation newsroom and, where it touches disabled readers, in Disability Advocacy.

Bloom is trans-led and disabled-led, and food security is part of the same work as care and dignity. Our disability advocacy work starts with telling disabled readers exactly what a rule says, so the people it reaches can speak for themselves before it’s final.

11

Frequently Asked Questions

Under the Food and Nutrition Act, a household in which every member receives TANF-funded benefits is categorically eligible for SNAP. Broad-based categorical eligibility lets states count a non-cash TANF service, such as a referral pamphlet, so they can set their own income and asset limits.

It would limit categorical eligibility to households that receive TANF cash assistance. Households that get only a non-cash or nominal TANF service would have to meet SNAP’s federal income and resource tests.

USDA estimates that 3.2 million households, about 6.3 million people, would lose SNAP in fiscal year 2029, the first year of full effect. That is about 17.6% of participants.

Comments are due December 10, 2026. You can comment at regulations.gov under docket FNA-2026-0661, by email to sm.fn.snappdbrules@usda.gov, or by mail to the Food and Nutrition Administration in Beltsville, Maryland.

Households with an elderly or disabled member already face only the net income test. But anyone who loses categorical eligibility would face the federal resource limit, which is $4,750 for a household with a member who is 60 or older or disabled.

Both states set SNAP’s gross income limit at 200% of the poverty guidelines with no asset limit, through broad-based categorical eligibility. The proposed rule would remove the basis for those state limits for households that don’t receive TANF cash.

About 1.78 million children would lose automatic free school meals, USDA estimates. About 97% would still qualify through the school’s income application, and about 28,000 would pay full price.

No. It’s a proposed rule, and USDA’s analysis treats fiscal year 2029 as the first year of full effect. Keep using your benefits and keep your recertification dates.

Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ŸŒธ

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.