A residential street lined with single-family homes and bare trees after a snowfall, for a story on the NCUA's fair lending rule

NewsroomDisability advocacyNews

Credit Union Regulator Removes Its 1972 Fair Lending Rule

On December 16, federal credit unions lose a 54-year-old rule that spelled out their fair lending duties, from ZIP codes to appraisals. The laws beneath it stay. Here's what changes.

On December 16, the National Credit Union Administration will remove the fair lending rule it has kept for federal credit unions since 1972. The NCUA Board signed the final rule on November 12, and the Federal Register posted it for public inspection at 8:45 AM Eastern on November 13, ahead of formal publication on November 16. The agency calls the rule, Section 701.31, a “redundant and outdated regulation.” It says the fair lending laws beneath it—the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act—still bind every federal credit union exactly as before.

If you’ve ever sat across a desk from a loan officer and wondered whether the answer was decided before you sat down, this one is about you. Rules like this are the floorboards of fair lending: nobody admires them, and that’s the point—they carry weight quietly. Bloom read the final rule, the January proposal and the text the NCUA first wrote 54 years ago. Here’s what leaves the fair lending rulebook, what stays in the law, and where Oregon and Washington reach further for trans and disabled borrowers.

01

What the fair lending rule said

Section 701.31 sits in Title 12 of the Code of Federal Regulations, and it governed fair lending at federal credit unions—the ones the NCUA charters. It never reached state-chartered credit unions, even federally insured ones, the final rule notes. When the NCUA revised it in the 1980s, the agency said the goal was to “summarize in one place the prohibitions on discrimination in real estate lending activities,” according to its January proposal.

The core of the fair lending rule is subsection (b). A federal credit union may not deny a home loan, set worse terms, or discourage an application because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, handicap—the rule’s older word for disability—or familial status. The protection reached the applicant and any co-applicant, anyone associated with the application, the people who’d live in the home, and even the neighbors in the homes nearby.

Then the rule went past a plain list. Subsection (b)(2) barred any lending criterion or policy “which has the effect of discriminating” on those grounds. That’s an effects test written into the fair lending rulebook in plain words: it asks what a policy does to people, not only what a lender meant by it.

Subsection (b)(3) named five factors a federal credit union could not weigh on a home loan, because each “generally has a discriminatory effect.” They were the age or location of the home, the ZIP code where the applicant lives now, whether the applicant had owned a home before, the age or location of the homes around it, and the income level of the neighborhood. The rule allowed possible exceptions, set out in its guidelines. But the starting point was clear.

Appraisals got their own subsection. A federal credit union could not rely on an appraisal it “knows or should know” was based on a protected trait, or on criteria with a discriminatory effect. If an appraisal did weigh a location factor, the rule required it to be documented, with a brief statement showing why it was necessary.

And the rule governed what members see. A federal credit union that advertised home loans had to say it makes them without regard to race, color, religion, national origin, sex, handicap or familial status; the “Equal Housing Lender” logo was one way to do it. Every federal credit union making home loans also had to post a nondiscrimination notice in its public lobby.

The rule’s guidelines put the whole idea in one sentence. Compliance with the Fair Housing Act, they said, “is achieved when each loan applicant’s creditworthiness is evaluated on an individual basis, without presuming” group traits. That’s the fair lending promise in miniature: you’re judged as yourself.

02

Why the NCUA says fair lending law hasn’t changed

The NCUA’s case is short. The rule’s last substantive amendment came in 2001, so it “does not reflect all case law or regulatory developments” under the Fair Housing Act, the Board wrote. That statute falls mainly under the Department of Housing and Urban Development. And the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA), with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s Regulation B, already covers lending more completely, the Board said.

The Board was plain about intent. The final rule “does not in any way alter” federal credit unions’ duties under the Fair Housing Act, ECOA, or the HUD and CFPB rules that carry them out. It “does not reflect any reduction” in how much the agency values fair lending, the Board wrote. HUD’s fair housing poster and notice rules still apply.

The Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, part of the Office of Management and Budget, found the change is not a “significant regulatory action.” The NCUA counts it as a deregulatory action under Executive Order 14192. The Board also wrote that, as it understands things, federal credit unions “have not generally relied on” Section 701.31 to meet their fair lending duties.

Sixteen comments came in before the March 16 deadline: three from credit unions, seven from state and regional credit union leagues, two from national trade associations, three from individuals and one from a think tank. Twelve supported the repeal. Two opposed it—one read it as a sign the agency supports lending discrimination, and the other warned it would lead to more. The Board adopted its January proposal without change.

Some supporters asked for fair lending guardrails. One commenter wanted the final rule to confirm that examiners will keep checking credit unions directly against the Fair Housing Act, ECOA and Regulation B. Two asked for cross-references and updated supervisory guidance. The Board declined to issue cross-references or new supervisory expectations “at this time,” pointing instead to the Fair Lending Guide on its website, dated December 2025.

03

What leaves the rulebook on December 16

Here’s the honest accounting. On December 16, the words of Section 701.31 leave the Code of Federal Regulations. The fair lending protections behind most of them live on in federal statutes. But some of the rule’s most concrete lines were the NCUA’s own wording, and the Board isn’t writing replacement guidance for now.

What disappears from the NCUA’s fair lending rulebook:

  • The written effects test for federal credit union lending policies, in subsection (b)(2).
  • The named list of five factors, from ZIP code to neighborhood income, that the rule treated as having a discriminatory effect.
  • The appraisal rules, including the duty to document any location factor and show why it was needed.
  • The NCUA’s own advertising and lobby-notice language, though HUD’s poster and notice rules still apply.
  • The NCUA’s own requirement that a federal credit union give a requesting member a copy of the appraisal on a home loan secured by a subordinate lien, available for 25 months after the member hears the decision.

The NCUA did weigh keeping the appraisal section. In January, the Board wrote that it “considered retaining” subsection (c) but found it “unnecessarily duplicative” of the Fair Housing Act and of ECOA, which, in the Board’s words, “prohibits discrimination in every aspect of a credit transaction.”

So why does any of this matter, if the statutes stand? Because rules are where a duty becomes routine. A loan officer, a compliance manager and an examiner each work from the text in front of them, and a named list of red flags is easy to follow. The NCUA’s answer is its Fair Lending Guide. Whether a guide carries the weight a regulation did is a question the next few years will answer.

04

The fair lending law that stays: the Fair Housing Act and ECOA

The Fair Housing Act is Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968, enacted April 11, 1968. Its Section 805 makes it unlawful for anyone whose business includes residential real estate-related transactions to discriminate in making them available, or in their terms, “because of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin.” Those transactions include loans to buy, build, improve, repair or maintain a home, loans secured by a home, and appraisals.

Disability sits in that list under the statute’s older word, handicap. ECOA doesn’t list disability. It protects race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status and age, and it bars discrimination “because all or part of the applicant’s income derives from any public assistance program.” A creditor may ask whether income comes from public assistance only for purposes such as judging how much it is and how long it will likely continue.

ECOA also gives you a right to reasons. A creditor generally must tell you what it decided within 30 days of a completed application, and if it takes adverse action, you’re entitled to a statement of the reasons. Ask for them in writing. They’re the first page of any fair lending complaint.

Time matters, too. Under the Fair Housing Act, you may file a complaint with HUD “not later than one year” after a discriminatory housing practice occurred or ended. You may also sue in federal or state court within two years. Write things down while they’re fresh: names, dates, what you were told, and copies of everything you signed.

05

Where Oregon and Washington law goes further

For readers in Oregon and Washington, state fair lending law reaches further than the federal lists, and for trans borrowers the difference is concrete. Oregon’s ORS 659A.421 bars anyone whose business includes residential real estate related transactions from discriminating “because of race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, national origin, marital status, familial status or source of income.” Those transactions include loans to buy, build, improve, repair or maintain a home, and appraisals.

Oregon law defines gender identity, in ORS 174.100, as a person’s “gender-related identity, appearance, expression or behavior,” whether or not it differs from the gender assigned at birth. A separate section, ORS 659A.145, bars disability discrimination in real property transactions. Complaints go to the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor and Industries and “must be filed no later than one year” after the unlawful practice.

One limit is worth knowing. Oregon’s own effects rule, ORS 659A.425, lets a court or the labor commissioner find a violation when a neutral-looking housing policy falls harder on a protected class. By its terms, though, it reaches rental housing, not loans.

Washington’s civil rights law, RCW 49.60.222, makes it an unfair practice to discriminate in a real estate transaction because of sex, marital status, sexual orientation, race, creed, color, national origin, citizenship or immigration status, honorably discharged veteran or military status, or “the presence of any sensory, mental, or physical disability,” among other grounds. The state defines a real estate transaction to include “transacting or applying for a real estate loan.”

Washington’s definition of sexual orientation, in RCW 49.60.040, includes “gender expression or identity.” Complaints go to the Washington State Human Rights Commission, and a real estate complaint must be filed within one year after the unfair practice occurred or ended.

That’s the heart of it for a trans borrower in the Pacific Northwest. Federal fair lending law names sex. Oregon and Washington name gender identity in the text itself. If you’re weighing where to buy, or whether to move, state law belongs in the calculation, and Bloom’s trans relocation page is a place to begin.

06

What to do about a fair lending problem

You don’t need to know which rule a lender broke to ask for help. You need a record. Keep every letter, email and notice, write down who said what and when, and ask for the reasons in writing.

Then use the deadlines that fit your situation:

  1. File a complaint with HUD within one year of the discriminatory practice, under the Fair Housing Act.
  2. Sue in federal or state court within two years, under the same law.
  3. In Oregon, file with the Bureau of Labor and Industries within one year.
  4. In Washington, file with the Washington State Human Rights Commission within one year.
  5. Ask a fair housing group or a legal aid office to read your papers before any deadline passes.

If your lender is a federal credit union, its fair lending duties under the Fair Housing Act and ECOA haven’t moved an inch. The NCUA said so in the final rule, in writing, and that sentence is now part of the public record you can point to.

07

What’s still unclear

Some questions stay open after December 16. The Board hasn’t said how examiners will test fair lending compliance once Section 701.31 is gone; it declined to issue updated supervisory expectations “at this time.” The final rule lets each credit union update its references to Section 701.31 on its usual schedule, so whether a credit union keeps the five named factors in its own lending policy is now its own call. And the final rule gives no count of the members or loans it touches.

08

What Bloom is doing

Bloom reads the primary documents so you don’t have to. Every rule, statute and section in this report is linked, and every quote comes from the text itself. When a federal agency changes the words that guard against lending discrimination, our job is to show you what moved, what didn’t, and where your fair lending rights still live.

That work is the heart of Bloom Resources, our coming library of verified legal, healthcare, housing and benefits guides for trans and disabled people—dated, primary-sourced and free. You can read more about our disability advocacy as well.

If a housing denial has left you frightened or worn down, you don’t have to carry it alone. Bloom’s crisis support page can point you to help right now, and you can call or text 988.

Bloom’s work is carried by people who give a little every month, the way a household keeps a light on. If this report served you, become a monthly supporter—or make a one-time gift if that suits you better.

09

Frequently Asked Questions

It’s Section 701.31 of Title 12 of the Code of Federal Regulations, the nondiscrimination rule for federal credit unions’ home lending, appraisals and advertising. The NCUA first wrote it in 1972 and last substantively amended it in 2001.

The final rule publishes in the Federal Register on November 16, 2026, and takes effect 30 days later, on December 16.

No. The Fair Housing Act and the Equal Credit Opportunity Act still apply to every federal credit union, and the NCUA says the final rule “does not in any way alter” those duties.

No. Section 701.31 applied only to federal credit unions, so state-chartered credit unions, including federally insured ones, were never covered by it.

Federal fair lending law names sex. Oregon’s ORS 659A.421 names gender identity in home lending, and Washington’s RCW 49.60.222 covers sexual orientation, which state law defines to include gender expression or identity, in real estate loans.

The Fair Housing Act bars home lending discrimination because of handicap, the law’s older word for disability. Washington’s RCW 49.60.222 adds protection for any sensory, mental or physical disability, and Oregon’s ORS 659A.145 covers disability in real property transactions.

Under the Fair Housing Act, you have one year to file with HUD and two years to sue. Oregon’s Bureau of Labor and Industries and the Washington State Human Rights Commission each take complaints filed within one year.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.