
Newsroom·Justice for survivors·News
Bill Would Let Discrimination Victims Recover for Emotional Harm
A deaf woman asked for an interpreter at physical therapy and was refused. The Supreme Court said she couldn't recover for the emotional harm. A bill reintroduced Friday would change that for disabled patients, students and others.
The bill would reverse the Supreme Court's 2022 ruling in Cummings v.
Two U.S. senators reintroduced a bill on Friday, November 20, 2026, that would let people who face discrimination by programs that take federal money recover emotional distress damages in court. The Clarifying Civil Rights Remedies Act would reverse a 2022 Supreme Court decision that closed that door, according to Sen. Patty Murray’s office.
The bill’s sponsors are Murray, of Washington, and Sen. Dick Durbin, of Illinois. Its reach is wide: disabled patients, students who report sex discrimination, older people and others protected by five federal civil rights laws. Here’s what the bill would do, the case behind it, and what it means for the people Bloom serves.
01
What the Clarifying Civil Rights Remedies Act would do
The bill would make explicit that the remedies for violations of five laws include compensatory damages, “including for emotional harm,” according to the bill’s one-page summary. The five laws are:
- Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which bars race, color and national origin discrimination
- Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, which bars sex discrimination in education
- the Age Discrimination Act of 1975
- Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, which bars disability discrimination
- Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act, which bars discrimination in health programs
The one-pager says the bill also states that Congress has the power to pass it under both the Spending Clause and Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment. That second source of power matters, because the 2022 decision rested on the Spending Clause.
02
The case behind the bill
Jane Cummings is deaf and legally blind, and she communicates mainly in American Sign Language. In October 2016, she sought physical therapy from Premier Rehab Keller, a small business in the Dallas-Fort Worth area, the Supreme Court’s opinion says.
She asked the clinic to provide an ASL interpreter at her appointments. Premier Rehab declined, telling her she could communicate with the therapist using written notes, lip reading or gesturing. Cummings then got care from another provider.
She sued, saying the refusal was disability discrimination under the Rehabilitation Act and the Affordable Care Act. Premier Rehab received federal money through Medicare and Medicaid for some of its services, which is why those laws applied, the Supreme Court’s syllabus explains.
The trial court found that the only injuries she could recover for were emotional: the opinion quotes it as finding “humiliation, frustration, and emotional distress.” Because emotional distress damages weren’t available, the court dismissed her case, and the Fifth Circuit agreed. Her case turned on that one question, and the Supreme Court said she couldn’t recover.
03
What the Supreme Court decided in 2022
In April 2022, the Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in Cummings v. Premier Rehab Keller. Chief Justice Roberts wrote for the majority. “Emotional distress damages are not recoverable in a private action to enforce either the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 or the Affordable Care Act,” the court’s syllabus says.
The court’s reasoning turned on the Spending Clause. Laws passed under that power are treated “much in the nature of a contract,” the opinion says, quoting an earlier case: in return for federal money, recipients agree to follow federal conditions. A remedy is available only if the funding recipient is “on notice” that it faces that kind of liability, the court said, and it concluded that emotional distress damages didn’t meet that test.
Justice Breyer dissented, joined by Justices Sotomayor and Kagan. For many people who face discrimination, emotional harm is the main harm, and the 2022 ruling took away the remedy for it under two major laws.
04
What emotional distress damages are
Emotional distress damages are money a court awards for the emotional harm a wrong causes, not for lost wages or medical bills. In discrimination cases, they compensate people for the humiliation, anxiety and anguish the one-pager describes.
The Supreme Court’s 2022 reasoning came from contract law. “Hornbook law states that emotional distress is generally not compensable in contract,” the court’s syllabus says. Because Spending Clause laws work like contracts, the majority held, funding recipients hadn’t agreed to pay emotional distress damages.
Critics of the ruling, including the bill’s sponsors, say civil rights aren’t a business deal. The harm discrimination causes is personal, and emotional distress damages are often the only way a court can recognize it.
05
Why emotional harm is the harm
The bill’s sponsors say discrimination often leaves no broken bones or lost paycheck. The one-pager says victims often suffer “humiliation, anxiety, depression, shame, and anguish, long after the discrimination has occurred.”
Think about what that means in a case like Cummings’s. A patient who is refused an interpreter may never lose money, but she loses dignity, and she has to find care somewhere else. Without emotional distress damages, “those who experience discrimination—even egregious violations of the law—may have no remedy at all,” the one-pager says.
It also argues that the threat of damages keeps institutions honest. Without it, the one-pager says, “bad actors may not be deterred from discrimination.”
06
How the ruling spread to Title IX
The 2022 decision was about the Rehabilitation Act and the Affordable Care Act. But federal district courts have begun to bar emotional distress damages under other laws too, including Title IX’s ban on sex discrimination, the one-pager says.
It cites three 2022 district court rulings, in Nebraska, Missouri and Texas, that refused to allow emotional distress damages under Title IX. For a student who reports sexual harassment or violence and is failed by a school, emotional harm is often the heart of the case.
That’s why survivor advocates support the bill. The National Alliance to End Sexual Violence and Know Your IX are among its endorsers, Murray’s office says.
07
What the senators said
“Victims of discrimination should be able to get damages for the full scope of harm that they suffer,” Murray said in the release. She pointed to recent reports from college campuses, including Cornell, Louisiana State University and Texas Christian University, as one reason the bill is urgent.
Durbin said the ruling “prevents those who have suffered emotional distress due to discrimination from seeking damages.” He added: “No one who faces discrimination should be denied justice in court.”
Bloom reports what lawmakers say, and doesn’t take sides in elections. The question here is a legal one: whether the people these five laws protect can recover for the harm discrimination most often causes.
08
Who the bill would protect
For disabled people, Section 504 dates to 1973. It reaches programs that receive federal money, which can include hospitals, clinics and schools. Cummings’s own case was a Section 504 case.
For patients, Section 1557 of the Affordable Care Act bars discrimination in health programs, and it was the other law at issue in 2022. For students, Title IX covers sex discrimination in schools that receive federal funds.
Title VI and the Age Discrimination Act round out the list. Together, these laws reach most of the places where people seek care, learning and public services.
The bill text also names who could be made to pay. Its rule would apply “in a suit against any entity, private or public, including a State.” That means a state university or a state-run hospital could face emotional distress damages on the same terms as a private clinic, if the bill became law.
09
Who supports the bill
Twelve senators joined Murray and Durbin as cosponsors, according to the release: Senators Baldwin, Blumenthal, Booker, Cantwell, Duckworth, Hirono, Kaine, Sanders, Schiff, Van Hollen, Welch and Whitehouse.
The release lists endorsements from Bazelon, Public Justice, the National Women’s Law Center, the American Association for Justice and the Autistic Self Advocacy Network. The National Alliance to End Sexual Violence, the National Alliance for Partnerships in Equity, Just Solutions, The Trevor Project and Know Your IX also back it.
Disability, survivor and LGBTQ+ groups are on the same list. That’s unusual, and it shows how far the 2022 ruling reaches. The 2024 version drew a similar coalition, Durbin’s office said, including the National Women’s Law Center, the Autistic Self Advocacy Network and the Arc of the United States.
10
What the bill text says about emotional distress damages
The bill text would amend Section 1003 of the Rehabilitation Act Amendments of 1986. It says remedies for a violation of the covered laws, “in a suit against any entity, private or public, including a State,” must include “all types of compensatory damages, including damages for emotional harm.”
The bill’s stated purpose is to “remedy and deter” violations of the five laws “by safeguarding the availability of damages for emotional harm.” It also invokes Congress’s power to enforce the Equal Protection Clause, which would give emotional distress damages a second constitutional footing beyond the Spending Clause.
One detail matters for people with cases now. The new rule on emotional distress damages would apply to violations for which a court hasn’t rendered a final decision on the day the bill becomes law, the text says.
11
The bill’s history
This isn’t the first version. Durbin and Murray introduced a Clarifying Civil Rights Remedies Act in November 2024, according to Durbin’s office. The 2024 bill covered the same five laws.
The 2026 bill text Murray’s office posted doesn’t yet show a bill number or a committee. It would amend the civil rights remedies provision of the Rehabilitation Act Amendments of 1986. Bloom will add the number when the Senate assigns one.
12
Emotional distress damages and disabled patients
Cummings’s case is a familiar one for deaf and disabled patients. An interpreter is refused, a ramp is missing, a service animal is turned away, and the person finds care somewhere else or goes without.
In many of those cases, the real loss is dignity, fear and exhaustion. That’s exactly what emotional distress damages were meant to address, and what the 2022 ruling took off the table under Section 504 and Section 1557.
Cummings’s case shows how that works in practice. Her claim wasn’t lost because the clinic was found to have done nothing wrong. It ended because the only harm she could show was the kind the court said the law couldn’t pay for.
Bloom believes the law should match what disabled people actually live through. A clinic that refuses an interpreter shouldn’t be able to count on the fact that the harm it caused can’t be measured on a bill.
13
A timeline of the emotional distress damages fight
These dates come from the Supreme Court’s opinion, the bill text, the one-pager and the senators’ offices:
- 1972: Congress passes Title IX of the Education Amendments.
- 1973: Congress passes the Rehabilitation Act, including Section 504.
- 1986: The Rehabilitation Act Amendments set out civil rights remedies the new bill would expand.
- October 2016: Jane Cummings seeks physical therapy and asks for an ASL interpreter.
- April 2022: The Supreme Court rules 6-3 that emotional distress damages aren’t recoverable under the Rehabilitation Act or the Affordable Care Act.
- 2022: District courts in Nebraska, Missouri and Texas bar emotional distress damages under Title IX.
- November 2024: Durbin and Murray introduce an earlier version of the bill.
- November 20, 2026: Murray and Durbin reintroduce the Clarifying Civil Rights Remedies Act.
14
What happens next
The bill now goes to the Senate. It would have to pass both the Senate and the House and be signed into law to change the remedies available under the five statutes.
Bills that don’t pass before a Congress ends have to be introduced again. Whatever happens to this version, it puts the question of emotional distress damages back before Congress, where advocates say it belongs.
Bloom will follow the bill and report any action on it, including a committee hearing or a House companion.
For now, the 2022 ruling still stands, as it has since April 2022. People who face discrimination in federally funded programs should know that limit, and know that Congress is being asked to remove it.
15
What you can do now
If you’ve faced discrimination by a hospital, clinic, school or other program that takes federal money, the 2022 ruling limits what you can recover in court. It doesn’t erase your rights, and these steps may help:
- Write down what happened. Note dates, names, what you asked for and what you were told. In the Cummings case, the clinic’s refusal of an interpreter was the key fact.
- Ask for what you need in writing. If you need an interpreter, a ramp or another change, put the request in writing and keep the reply.
- Talk to a civil rights lawyer. A lawyer can explain which remedies are still available to you under federal and state law, and the deadlines that apply.
- Ask about every remedy. Even without emotional distress damages, a court can sometimes order a program to change its practices. A lawyer can tell you what’s possible in your case.
- Tell your senators what this means to you. Bills move when constituents explain how a law affected their lives.
16
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with disabled people, survivors and everyone the civil rights laws were written to protect. I believe a right without a remedy is a promise on paper, and a deaf woman refused an interpreter deserves more than that.
Bloom has reported this week on how civil rights laws work in real life, from a Tennessee hospital’s accessible parking settlement to New York paying a survivor after conceding fault. If this news is heavy for you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and RAINN’s hotline is 800-656-4673.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom explaining the laws that protect you, and a one-time gift helps too.
17
Frequently Asked Questions
It would make explicit that remedies under Title VI, Title IX, the Age Discrimination Act, Section 504 and Section 1557 include compensatory damages, including emotional distress damages.
It was a 2022 Supreme Court case brought by a deaf and legally blind woman refused an ASL interpreter at physical therapy. The court ruled 6-3 that emotional distress damages aren’t recoverable under the Rehabilitation Act or the Affordable Care Act.
For many people, emotional harm is the main harm discrimination causes. Without emotional distress damages, some victims may have no remedy at all, the bill’s sponsors say.
Some federal district courts have applied its reasoning to bar emotional distress damages under Title IX, according to the bill’s one-page summary.
The bill text says its rule on emotional distress damages would apply to violations for which a court hasn’t rendered a final decision on the day it becomes law.
Sens. Patty Murray of Washington and Dick Durbin of Illinois, with 12 cosponsors, according to Murray’s office.
No. It must pass the Senate and the House and be signed by the president. The 2026 text posted by Murray’s office doesn’t yet carry a bill number.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Justice for survivors · 22 November 2026Germany Drafts Law to Punish Femicide as Murder, Not Manslaughter
New York Legislature · 22 November 2026Nursing Aide Admits Sexually Assaulting 2 Residents, One With Dementia
Justice for survivors · 22 November 2026Honduran Court Convicts 4 in Angie Peña Case, but She’s Still Missing