
Newsroom·Mississippi Legislature·News
Appeals Court Lifts Order Blocking Mississippi’s Social Media Age Law
The Fifth Circuit threw out an injunction that shielded nine platforms, including Facebook, YouTube and Reddit, from Mississippi's age verification and parental consent law. It didn't decide whether the law is constitutional.
A federal appeals court on Thursday, November 19, 2026, threw out an order that had shielded nine social media platforms from Mississippi’s age verification and parental consent law. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit sent the case back to the trial judge, according to the opinion, without deciding whether the law is constitutional.
The law is the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act, named for a 16-year-old Mississippi boy who died by suicide after online predators targeted him in a sextortion plot. Its supporters call it child protection. Its challengers call it a burden on free speech. Here’s what the law requires, what the court decided about age verification, and what families can do now.
01
What the court decided
The case is NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348. Judges Richman, Engelhardt and Wilson heard it, and Judge Cory T. Wilson wrote the opinion. NetChoice is a trade association of internet companies, and Lynn Fitch is Mississippi’s attorney general.
The district court had blocked the whole law, but only as applied to nine NetChoice members: Reddit, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, X, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth. The appeals court said that record didn’t support that order. “Accordingly, we VACATE the district court’s preliminary injunction and REMAND for further proceedings,” the court wrote.
The case now goes back to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi. The appeals court didn’t rule on whether the age verification law, or its parental consent rule, violates the First Amendment, WLBT reported.
02
What the law requires
Mississippi passed the law in 2024 as HB 1126. It covers online platforms that let users interact with each other, create profiles others can see, and post content others can see, the opinion explains. It excludes sites that mainly offer news, sports, commerce or online video games with only incidental chat, and sites that offer access to career development.
The law imposes three main duties on covered sites. First, they must make “commercially reasonable efforts to verify” the age of people who create accounts. Second, they must get the “express consent of a parent or guardian” before a known minor can hold an account.
Third, they must make “commercially reasonable efforts” to put in place strategies to “prevent or mitigate” known minors’ exposure to a list of harms. The law also limits how platforms can collect and use minors’ data. Parents and the attorney general can enforce it, and violations can bring civil penalties and criminal liability, the court said.
03
Who Walker Montgomery was
Walker Montgomery was 16. The court’s opinion says he died by suicide after he was the target of a sextortion plot by online predators. His family lost him on December 1, 2022, his father told WLBT.
“It’s encouraging. You know, we know that it’s another one small step,” Brian Montgomery said of the ruling. He said his family isn’t ready to celebrate, and that Thanksgiving is a hard holiday for them. He told WLBT he expected a legal fight because he believes tech companies won’t regulate themselves.
Montgomery said parents know they have a responsibility to protect their children, and that the law’s safeguards are one part of a broader effort. He also recently faced the man indicted in connection with the plot that targeted his son, WLBT reported. “They’re truly two separate fights, but they’re absolutely connected by the loss of our son,” he said.
04
Why the court ruled the way it did
The key question was how NetChoice framed its challenge. NetChoice first argued the law was unconstitutional on its face, meaning in every application. After the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Moody v. NetChoice, the Fifth Circuit sent that first injunction back so the district court could apply Moody’s tougher test.
“The Court has made facial challenges hard to win,” the Supreme Court’s Moody syllabus says. On remand, NetChoice changed its complaint to add an as-applied challenge, saying the law is unconstitutional as applied to its members. But the appeals court said NetChoice barely changed the substance of its pleading and relied mostly on a few declarations.
The panel held that NetChoice “failed to substantiate, with the required granularity, how the Act is unconstitutional as applied to its individual members.” The district court, it said, also didn’t tailor its relief, and blocking the whole law for nine named platforms was “tantamount to facial relief” for them.
05
What the trial court must do next
The appeals court laid out what an as-applied ruling requires. On remand, the district court must determine “the commercially reasonable efforts, as used in the Act, or the Act’s requirements for each” NetChoice member, the opinion says.
Those requirements are “likely to be different with each” platform or feature, the court said, quoting its earlier decision in the same case. In other words, the age verification rules may weigh differently on a video site, a neighborhood app and a small journaling community.
That’s a slower, more detailed path. NetChoice can try again with evidence about how the law works on each platform it represents, and Mississippi can answer each claim with evidence of its own.
06
How age verification works under the law
The law doesn’t spell out one method of age verification. It asks covered platforms to make “commercially reasonable efforts to verify” the age of people who make accounts, the opinion says, and the same standard applies to the other duties.
That flexible standard is part of why the case is hard. What counts as commercially reasonable age verification for a giant video site may not be reasonable for a small journaling community, which is why the court wants evidence about each platform.
For users, age verification can mean proving their age before they can open or keep an account. For a known minor, it also means a parent or guardian has to give express consent. Those two steps, age verification and parental consent, sit at the center of the First Amendment fight.
07
Age verification and the nine platforms
The injunction the court threw out covered only nine NetChoice members. The Fifth Circuit had already paused it on July 17, 2025, while the appeal went on, and the Supreme Court left that pause in place.
Thursday’s ruling ends the injunction for good, unless the district court issues a new one. Mississippi can defend its age verification law against each platform’s specific evidence when the case resumes.
For other platforms the law covers, nothing in the ruling changes their duties. The fight over age verification in Mississippi continues one company, and one feature, at a time.
08
Why age verification is contested
To Mississippi’s attorney general, age verification is one of the “reasonable changes” a responsible company should embrace. To NetChoice, which brought its challenge on First Amendment grounds, it’s a burden on how people speak and read online.
The Supreme Court’s Moody decision made it harder to win a challenge to a law like this all at once. Justice Kavanaugh’s 2025 view that NetChoice was likely to succeed on the merits shows that at least one justice sees real First Amendment problems with age verification laws.
Bloom expects the question to return to the Supreme Court in some form. Until then, courts will keep deciding age verification cases platform by platform.
09
How the case reached this point
The case has moved back and forth between courts for more than two years. Here’s the path, according to the Fifth Circuit’s opinion:
- 2024: Mississippi enacts HB 1126. NetChoice sues before it takes effect, and the district court blocks the law on its face.
- 2024: The Supreme Court decides Moody v. NetChoice on the same day the district court rules.
- 2025: The Fifth Circuit vacates the first injunction so the district court can apply Moody.
- 2025: NetChoice amends its complaint, and the district court blocks the law again for nine platforms.
- July 17, 2025: The Fifth Circuit stays that second injunction while the appeal goes on.
- 2025: The Supreme Court leaves the stay in place, without noted dissent.
- November 19, 2026: The Fifth Circuit vacates the second injunction and sends the case back.
10
What the Supreme Court said in 2025
When NetChoice asked the Supreme Court to lift the Fifth Circuit’s stay, the justices refused. Justice Kavanaugh wrote separately, and the Fifth Circuit’s opinion summarizes his view.
He said NetChoice had “demonstrated that it is likely to succeed on the merits” under current First Amendment precedents, the opinion says. But he agreed the emergency application should be denied because NetChoice hadn’t sufficiently shown that the balance of harms and equities favored it.
That history matters. At least one justice has signaled serious First Amendment doubts about laws like this one, while the courts keep sending the case back for more evidence.
11
The evidence the court found thin
The opinion describes what NetChoice offered. Beyond a declaration from its general counsel, it relied on earlier declarations from people at YouTube, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth, the court said, and neither NetChoice nor its members offered other evidence about how the law would work on their sites.
The district court’s analysis of which platforms and features the law covers was “confined to a single paragraph,” the appeals court wrote. That wasn’t enough for an order that blocked every part of the age verification law for nine different services.
The lesson for future challenges is clear. Courts want to see how age verification, parental consent and the harm-reduction duties would work on a specific platform, feature by feature, before they block a law.
12
What Mississippi parents should know
The law gives parents a role in enforcement. The opinion says the law provides for enforcement by minors’ parents as well as by the attorney general.
For a known minor, the law requires a parent’s or guardian’s express consent before the minor can hold an account on a covered platform. Families may see more age verification prompts and consent requests as platforms respond to the law, and the details may differ from one app to the next.
13
The free speech questions
Age verification laws raise real First Amendment questions, and courts are still working them out. Social media is where many people, young and old, speak, organize and find community. A rule that requires sites to check every account holder’s age touches all of them, not only minors.
Parental consent rules raise their own questions. Most children are safest with involved parents. But Bloom believes some young people, including LGBTQ+ teens, find their first safe community online, sometimes before they can talk to family, and age verification and consent rules can reach them too.
Those concerns don’t erase the harm the law was written to address. Walker Montgomery’s death is the reason this law exists, and predators who target children online are real. The courts’ job is to protect both children and free speech, and to get the balance right.
14
What state officials said
Rep. Jill Ford wrote the law. Her focus, she said, remains “protecting Mississippi children from online predators and giving parents more support in keeping their children safe.” She said writing the law has been one of the greatest honors of her life.
Attorney General Fitch said the law “asks social media companies to make reasonable changes that a responsible corporate citizen should embrace.” She added, “But Big Tech is fighting us every step of the way.”
This report relies on the court’s opinion and WLBT’s reporting. Bloom will add NetChoice’s response if it issues one.
15
What families can do now
Laws and lawsuits move slowly. Families can act today, whatever happens to the age verification rules. Age verification alone won’t stop every predator, and these steps don’t depend on any court:
- Talk about sextortion before it happens. Tell young people that if anyone threatens to share images unless they pay or send more, it isn’t their fault, and they can come to you without shame.
- Know the warning signs. Sudden secrecy, fear around a phone, or a rush to get money can mean someone is under pressure.
- Save evidence and get help. Don’t pay. Keep messages and report the account to the platform and to police.
- Keep crisis lines handy. Call or text 988 any hour. LGBTQ+ young people can reach The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386.
- Check the platforms your kids use. Learn each app’s privacy settings and who can contact your child.
16
What happens next
The Southern District of Mississippi will take the case up again. Brian Montgomery told WLBT he’s continuing the fight in the hope that other families won’t feel the pain his family has. NetChoice can offer new, platform-specific evidence, and Mississippi will defend the law. Either side could return to the Fifth Circuit, and the Supreme Court may yet weigh in on age verification laws like this one.
Bloom will follow the case, and other age verification laws, and report how courts balance children’s safety with everyone’s right to speak and be heard online. Age verification is likely to be one of the defining free speech questions of the next few years.
17
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with grieving families like Walker Montgomery’s, and with young people who need safe places online. I believe we can protect children from predators without shutting the doors that let lonely kids find each other, and our laws should do both.
If this story is heavy for you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, including 988 and Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading the court rulings that shape free speech and safety online, and a one-time gift helps too.
18
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 19, 2026, it vacated a preliminary injunction that blocked the law for nine NetChoice members and sent the case back to the district court. It didn’t decide whether the law is constitutional.
Covered platforms must make commercially reasonable efforts to verify users’ ages, get a parent’s express consent before a known minor holds an account, and try to prevent or mitigate minors’ exposure to listed harms.
Reddit, YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, X, Snapchat, Pinterest, Nextdoor and Dreamwidth.
It said NetChoice didn’t show, platform by platform, how the law is unconstitutional as applied to each member, and that the relief wasn’t properly tailored.
No. The Fifth Circuit vacated the injunction because NetChoice hadn’t shown, platform by platform, how the age verification law is unconstitutional as applied. It didn’t decide the First Amendment question.
He was a 16-year-old Mississippian who died by suicide in 2022 after online predators targeted him in a sextortion plot. The law is named for him.
The district court will reconsider NetChoice’s as-applied challenge. Either side could appeal again after that.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Maryland Legislature · 22 November 2026Glock, Ruger Sue to Block Maryland’s Convertible Pistol Sales Ban
Justice for survivors · 22 November 2026Germany Drafts Law to Punish Femicide as Murder, Not Manslaughter
New York Legislature · 22 November 2026Nursing Aide Admits Sexually Assaulting 2 Residents, One With Dementia