Two metal crowd-control barricades joined by black and yellow caution tape on an empty paved plaza, for a report on the right to protest

NewsroomLegislationNews

Supreme Court Asked to Bar Suing Protest Leaders for Others’ Violence

Can someone who leads a protest be made to pay for a stranger's violence? DeRay Mckesson asked the Supreme Court on Friday to say no. The appeals court rule he's challenging already binds federal courts in Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas.

A federal appeals court has ruled that a protest leader can be sued for negligence over violence committed by someone else in the crowd, and that the First Amendment doesn’t stand in the way. The case began at a 2016 protest in Baton Rouge, where a police officer was badly hurt by a piece of concrete or rock thrown by a person who has never been identified. On Friday, November 20, 2026, DeRay Mckesson, the activist the officer sued, asked the U.S. Supreme Court to rule that the right to protest forbids that kind of liability unless there’s evidence the leader directed, authorized, ratified or intended the violence.

The appeals court’s rule binds federal courts in Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas, and Mckesson’s lawyers warn that other courts may be asked to adopt it. The officer’s lawyers say the evidence entitles him to a jury. Here’s what each court decided, what both sides argue, and what it means for anyone’s right to protest.

01

The right to protest case at a glance

  • The question: whether the right to protest bars a negligence suit against a protest leader for a stranger’s violence “absent evidence that the defendant directed, ratified, authorized, or intended the assault, or violence of any kind.”
  • The petitioner: DeRay Mckesson, represented by David T. Goldberg of Donahue, Goldberg, Herzog & Davidson, David D. Cole, the ACLU and the ACLU of Louisiana.
  • Filed: Friday, November 20, 2026, a week ahead of a November 27 deadline Justice Alito set.
  • The ruling under review: the Fifth Circuit’s 2-1 decision of March 19, 2026, in No. 24-30494.
  • Rehearing: denied July 30, 2026, with ten judges against and six in favor.
  • The injury: a Baton Rouge officer struck in the face at a July 9, 2016 protest; the thrower was never identified.
  • The docket: no case number yet, as of Sunday, November 22.

02

What happened in Baton Rouge on July 9, 2016

People used their right to protest in Baton Rouge in July 2016 after police killed Alton Sterling, a Black man, the petition says. Mckesson, a civil rights activist, traveled there to join them.

The courts tell the day two ways. The Fifth Circuit’s majority wrote that Mckesson met with planners the day before, led protesters in gathering in front of a Baton Rouge Police Department station and later got people ready to walk into the highway. Judge Don Willett, dissenting from the denial of rehearing, wrote that local community members organized the protest and invited Mckesson, who walked with the crowd and filmed on his phone.

Both accounts share the day’s arc. The protest began peacefully. Later, some people looted a convenience store and threw water bottles at police, and as evening came, some moved into the road and officers began clearing it and making arrests. While the officer was arresting someone else, a person in the crowd threw a piece of concrete or a rock that struck him. Mckesson was arrested that day too.

03

An officer hurt in the line of duty

No court has doubted the officer’s injuries. He lost teeth, injured his jaw, suffered a concussion and developed post-traumatic stress disorder, the Fifth Circuit’s March opinion says. He spent 18 hours undergoing dental procedures, and years later his vision is still marked by “black marks” and “squiggly clear lines.”

He left the Baton Rouge Police Department and began a new career in construction. In 2020, the Supreme Court itself described “devastating injuries in the line of duty, including loss of teeth and brain trauma.”

He first sued in 2016 as “Officer John Doe,” and the earlier rulings carry that name. Bloom refers to him as the officer. Whatever the justices decide about the right to protest, his pain is real, and the thrower, who “remains unidentified,” as the ACLU’s case page puts it, has never answered for it.

04

What “negligent protest” means

The officer didn’t sue the unknown thrower. He sued Mckesson, arguing that he negligently organized and led the protest. Louisiana’s Civil Code article 2315 says that every act “that causes damage to another obliges him by whose fault it happened to repair it.”

In 2019, the Fifth Circuit held that a jury could find Mckesson breached “a duty not to negligently precipitate the crime of a third party.” Its reasoning ran in a chain: blocking a highway is a crime in Louisiana, police would foreseeably respond by clearing the road and making arrests, and that response carried a foreseeable risk that someone would turn violent.

Critics call the theory negligent protest and say it puts a price on the right to protest; Judge Willett called it “exotic.” In 2022, the Louisiana Supreme Court answered that, under the facts the officer alleged, Louisiana law does recognize such a duty. It also held that the state’s professional rescuer’s doctrine, which could have barred an injured officer’s claim, had already been abrogated.

05

What the Fifth Circuit decided about the right to protest

After discovery, the federal district court in Baton Rouge granted Mckesson summary judgment in July 2024. It found no evidence that he planned, organized or led the protest as the officer alleged, and no evidence that his actions caused the injury. It also held the First Amendment barred the claim.

On March 19, 2026, the Fifth Circuit reversed, 2-1. “Eight years of pretrial litigation are enough,” Judge Edith H. Jones wrote for herself and Judge Oldham. She pointed to Mckesson’s testimony that he was “part of” a group of leaders, his amplifying of the protest to more than a quarter million Twitter followers, and a class-action filing that described his leadership.

The officer testified that he saw Mckesson “giving orders” to protesters “to go out into that road and block traffic,” the majority wrote. It held that the court’s earlier ruling, that the right to protest doesn’t shield Mckesson from this claim, still binds lower courts. “Counterman’s holding about the elements of an unrelated criminal offense changes nothing about this case,” Jones wrote of a 2023 Supreme Court decision.

06

The officer’s case, in his lawyers’ words

The officer’s lawyer, Donna U. Grodner of Grodner & Associates in Baton Rouge, told the Fifth Circuit that Mckesson “knew or should have known that blocking a public highway would necessitate arrests,” according to the officer’s 2024 brief. She argued that disputed facts meant a jury, not a judge, had to decide the case.

On the right to protest, the brief argued that the Fifth Circuit had twice ruled the First Amendment no bar and that its ruling was the law of the case. It said a statement from a single justice “carries no meaningful weight,” and noted that Counterman had already been decided when the Supreme Court declined to hear the case in 2024.

The majority sided with him, and it answered a fear that leaders could be blamed for opponents’ violence. “It is highly unlikely that a protest leader’s actions would make them accountable for the torts committed by counter-protestors,” Jones wrote. The Advocate in Baton Rouge reported that the ruling cleared the way for a trial.

07

Why Judge King dissented

Judge Carolyn King began her dissent with the officer. “Someone should be held accountable,” she wrote. But she said the officer had not come close to showing that Mckesson was that someone.

The evidence showed Mckesson was a guest of the local organizers, not their host, King wrote. By the officer’s own account, the crowd had been throwing objects at police all day before Mckesson allegedly led anyone onto the highway. That, she said, meant his conduct wasn’t the “necessary antecedent” the Fifth Circuit’s own test demanded.

King also warned that tying liability to how police respond puts the right to protest in the government’s hands, a heckler’s veto “on steroids because now the heckler is the government.”

08

Ten judges let the ruling stand; six objected

On July 30, 2026, the full Fifth Circuit voted 10-6 not to rehear the case, the order denying rehearing shows. Judge James C. Ho, concurring, restated a principle he’d written in 2020: “The First Amendment protects protest, not trespass.” In his view, a jury could find this was trespass.

Judge Willett wrote for the six dissenters. “The First Amendment does not permit prominence to substitute for proof,” he wrote. Willett called the officer’s injuries abhorrent. “He deserves a remedy from whoever is legally responsible for them,” he wrote, but not from the most recognizable speaker in place of an unknown assailant.

Willett warned that the rule wouldn’t narrow the right to protest for one movement alone. “Tomorrow’s may be a gun-rights advocate, a pro-life leader, a pastor protesting a government mandate, or parents addressing a school-board meeting,” he wrote of the next defendant. “The predictable consequence is self-censorship.”

09

What Mckesson is asking the Supreme Court

Mckesson’s lawyers say the Fifth Circuit’s rule conflicts with two Supreme Court decisions, Claiborne Hardware from 1982 and Counterman from 2023. Left standing, the ACLU says, the ruling would gut protections for the right to protest in the Fifth Circuit and potentially nationwide.

They also acknowledge the officer’s loss. “Providing recourse for an officer injured in the line of duty is doubtless a worthy objective,” the petition says. But under Claiborne’s rule, it argues, the injured person’s recourse is against whoever hurt him, or against a leader who intended the violence.

“The threat of an expensive lawsuit could scare people away from protesting at all,” Mckesson said in the ACLU’s announcement. “The right to protest is fundamental to American democracy,” said Vera Eidelman, a senior staff attorney at the ACLU. If the Court doesn’t step in, she said, no one could protest without fearing they’d pay for someone else’s conduct. “That’s the definition of chilling.”

10

The 1982 boycott case at the heart of it

In 1966, a boycott of white merchants in Claiborne County, Mississippi, began at a meeting of a local NAACP branch. It relied largely on speeches and nonviolent picketing, but some acts and threats of violence occurred, and Mississippi’s courts held the NAACP and boycott participants liable for the merchants’ losses.

The Supreme Court reversed on July 2, 1982. “Civil liability may not be imposed merely because an individual belonged to a group, some members of which committed acts of violence,” the Court wrote in Claiborne Hardware.

It named three theories that might make Charles Evers, a principal organizer, liable for others’ unlawful conduct. The first was “a finding that he authorized, directed, or ratified specific tortious activity”; the other two turned on his speeches.

Both sides treat that passage as the key to the right to protest when violence breaks out, and they read it differently. The Fifth Circuit’s 2023 majority said Claiborne’s test for leaders “did not include an intent condition,” as the petition quotes it. Mckesson’s lawyers answer that those verbs already carry intent, and that Evers wasn’t held liable.

11

Why Counterman matters to the right to protest

In Counterman, decided in June 2023, the Supreme Court held that the First Amendment requires more than an objective, negligence-style standard before speech can be punished as a true threat. The Court read Claiborne and other incitement cases as demanding “a showing of intent,” Justice Sonia Sotomayor later wrote.

Counterman came down eleven days after the Fifth Circuit’s 2023 ruling, so that panel never weighed it. When the Supreme Court declined to hear Mckesson’s second petition on April 15, 2024, Sotomayor wrote that the denial “expresses no view about the merits of Mckesson’s claim.”

“I expect them to give full and fair consideration to arguments regarding Counterman’s impact in any future proceedings in this case,” she wrote of the lower courts, in her statement. The district court applied Counterman in 2024. The Fifth Circuit said it changed nothing, and that clash is at the center of the right to protest petition.

12

How the right to protest case got here: a timeline

From the court records:

  • July 9, 2016: The Baton Rouge protest; the officer is injured.
  • November 7, 2016: He sues Mckesson and “Black Lives Matter” as “Officer John Doe.”
  • September 28, 2017: The district court dismisses the suit.
  • April 24, 2019: A Fifth Circuit panel revives the negligence claim; it reissues the opinion twice, the last on December 16 with Judge Willett dissenting.
  • January 28, 2020: The full Fifth Circuit splits 8-8 on rehearing.
  • November 2, 2020: The Supreme Court vacates the ruling and sends the state-law question toward Louisiana’s high court.
  • March 25, 2022: The Louisiana Supreme Court says state law recognizes the duty, on the facts alleged.
  • June 16, 2023: The Fifth Circuit again rejects Mckesson’s First Amendment defense.
  • April 15, 2024: The Supreme Court denies review; Justice Sotomayor writes separately.
  • July 10, 2024: The district court grants summary judgment for Mckesson.
  • March 19, 2026: The Fifth Circuit reverses, 2-1.
  • July 30, 2026: Rehearing denied, 10-6.
  • November 20, 2026: Mckesson files his third petition.

13

What this means for your right to protest

The Fifth Circuit hears appeals from federal courts in Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas, according to the court’s own description. Its First Amendment holding binds those courts until the full Fifth Circuit or the Supreme Court says otherwise, the March majority explained.

Whether a suit can be brought at all is a question of each state’s own law. Louisiana’s Supreme Court has said its law allows the claim on facts like these. The petition notes that Texas’s Supreme Court rejected a negligent protest claim arising from a pro-life protest in 1996, on state-law grounds.

Outside the Fifth Circuit, other courts weigh the right to protest for themselves, and at least one has gone the other way. In 2024, the Oregon Court of Appeals held that “the First Amendment does not allow for the imposition of liability on a protest leader or an organizer under a negligence theory,” the petition says.

The Fifth Circuit’s 2023 majority called proving that a leader caused an injury a “tall task.” The district court warned that extending liability to Mckesson’s disputed role “would dramatically increase the liability faced by all protest participants.” That’s why this right to protest case matters to anyone who carries a sign.

14

Two rights and one injured officer

This right to protest case asks the country to hold two true things at once. The right to protest is how people without power make themselves heard, and the First Amendment protects “the right of the people peaceably to assemble.” An officer who goes to work, is struck in the face and loses his career is owed a remedy too.

The law answers that tension by asking who is responsible. Mckesson’s side says the answer is whoever threw the object, and anyone who directed, authorized, ratified or intended it. The officer’s side, and the Fifth Circuit’s majority, say the right to protest doesn’t excuse a leader whose negligence set the conditions for the harm.

I believe a person who gathers with neighbors to speak shouldn’t have to insure a stranger’s crime, and that the officer hurt that night deserves to see the person who hurt him answer for it.

15

What happens next

As of Sunday, November 22, the Supreme Court’s docket showed no case number for the right to protest petition. A docket search for Mckesson turns up only one 2026 entry, No. 26A538, the extension Justice Alito granted on October 20, according to the Court’s docket.

Once it’s docketed, the officer’s side has 30 days to file a brief in opposition unless the time is extended, under the Court’s rules. A response isn’t required unless the Court asks for one. “Review on a writ of certiorari is not a matter of right, but of judicial discretion,” the rules say.

In both earlier rounds, the officer first waived his right to respond, and the Court then asked for a response, the 2020 and 2023 dockets show. The 2020 petition took about eight months to decide, and the 2023 petition took more than six.

If the justices grant review, the rules say the case will be scheduled for briefing and oral argument. If they deny it, the case returns to the district court, where the Fifth Circuit has opened the door to a jury trial. Bloom found no trial date in the records it read. Until the Court acts, the Fifth Circuit’s rule on the right to protest stands.

16

What you can do

Bloom isn’t giving legal advice; if you face a lawsuit or charges, talk to a lawyer. These plain, lawful steps for your right to protest come from the ACLU’s protesters’ rights guide and the record:

  1. Know where your right to protest is strongest: streets, sidewalks and parks, the ACLU says.
  2. “You don’t need a permit to march in the streets or on sidewalks, as long as marchers don’t obstruct car or pedestrian traffic,” the guide says. A march that blocks traffic or closes a street may need one.
  3. A permit can’t be denied because an event is controversial, the guide says, and counterprotesters have free speech rights too.
  4. If you believe your rights were violated, the guide says to write down what you remember, get witnesses’ contact information and photograph any injuries.
  5. Read the right to protest petition and the Fifth Circuit’s ruling yourself, and watch the docket for a case number.

17

What Bloom is doing

Bloom reports on the right to protest and the freedom to speak because the people we serve depend on both. This week we reported that FIU dropped charges against seven students over a silent protest, that a Mizzou student group sued over a demand for its members’ and donors’ names, and on survivors’ petition to the Supreme Court about clergy. Bloom will report when the Court acts.

If this story leaves you afraid, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps this reporting steady, and Bloom Rising, our campus program, is building chapters that pair education and advocacy for trans equality with the training and guardrails that keep student organizers safe.

18

Frequently Asked Questions

Whether the right to protest bars making a protest leader pay for a stranger’s violence without evidence he directed, ratified, authorized or intended it. He filed on November 20, 2026.

It’s the theory that a protest leader can owe damages if he negligently led a protest in a way that made a third party’s violence foreseeable. The Fifth Circuit accepted it, and Louisiana’s Supreme Court said state law allows the claim on the facts alleged. Mckesson says it chills the right to protest.

The Fifth Circuit’s First Amendment holding binds federal courts in Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas. Whether a suit over your right to protest can be brought also depends on each state’s law, and courts elsewhere aren’t bound by it.

Twice. In 2020 it vacated the Fifth Circuit’s ruling and sent a state-law question toward Louisiana’s high court, and in 2024 it declined review, with Justice Sotomayor writing about Counterman.

Not soon. The petition hadn’t been docketed as of November 22, the officer’s side gets 30 days to respond once it is, and the earlier petitions took six to eight months.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.