An empty yellow armchair beside a small wooden table against a white wall, for a report on the CRUSH rule and home care

NewsroomDisability advocacyNews

The CRUSH Rule: What CMSโ€™s Fraud Crackdown Means for Home Care

CMS published the CRUSH rule on November 19, a sweeping Medicaid and Medicare fraud proposal.

The CRUSH rule would change how states check claims for care delivered in people's homes.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services published the CRUSH rule on Thursday, November 19, 2026, a sweeping proposal to fight fraud in Medicaid, Medicare, the Children’s Health Insurance Program and the health insurance Marketplace. For disabled people who rely on care at home, one change stands out: states would have to check home care claims against electronic visit records before paying them, according to the proposed rule.

CRUSH stands for Comprehensive Regulations To Uncover Suspicious Healthcare. The CRUSH rule runs 167 pages in the Federal Register and is open for public comment until January 19, 2027. Nothing in it is final yet. Here is what the CRUSH rule would change for people who use personal care, home health and medical equipment, what CMS says it is trying to fix, and how to make your voice heard.

01

What the CRUSH rule is

The CRUSH rule is a proposed rule, file code CMS-6098-P, from CMS and the Department of Health and Human Services. It follows a request for information CMS published on February 27, 2026, which asked the public about possible changes, according to the Federal Register.

CMS groups the CRUSH rule into five areas: strengthening state Medicaid and CHIP oversight, reworking audits of Medicare Advantage plans, tightening Medicare provider enrollment, policing durable medical equipment suppliers, and cracking down on Marketplace agents and brokers.

Unless the rule says otherwise, the Medicaid and CHIP changes would take effect 60 days after a final rule is published. CMS estimates the quantified provisions would cost about $379 million from 2027 to 2036, not counting more than $90 billion in transfers between the federal government and states or private entities.

02

Why CMS says it needs the CRUSH rule

CMS frames the CRUSH rule as part of the administration’s push against fraud. “CMS is issuing this proposed rule to solicit stakeholder feedback on proposed regulatory changes that would strengthen CMS’ ability to address vulnerabilities that make Federal health programs attractive targets to fraudsters,” the agency wrote.

On home care, CMS points to real harm. In fiscal year 2025, Medicaid Fraud Control Units reported 326 convictions of personal care attendants for fraud, more than any other provider type, the CRUSH rule says. CMS wrote that fraud in personal care “leaves beneficiaries at risk for harm and neglect, and in severe cases has resulted in hospitalizations and deaths.”

Fraud that steals from Medicaid steals from disabled people first, because it drains the programs we depend on. The question for the disability community isn’t whether to stop fraud. It’s whether the CRUSH rule stops it without delaying the honest care that keeps people at home.

03

Home care: visit records before payment

Electronic visit verification, or EVV, is the system that logs in-home visits. Under the 21st Century Cures Act, states must use EVV for Medicaid personal care services and home health care, the CRUSH rule explains. States generally had to have it in place for personal care by January 1, 2020, and for home health by January 1, 2023.

EVV records six things: the type of service, the person receiving it, the date, the location, the worker providing it, and the start and end times. The law doesn’t require GPS tracking, and states have wide discretion in how their systems work, according to the CRUSH rule. Medicaid.gov has more on how EVV works.

Today, no federal rule says how states must use that data. The proposal would change that in two ways. First, states would have to review EVV records when they open a preliminary investigation into possible fraud by an in-home provider. Second, during prepayment review, states would have to verify that billed in-home services are “supported by an EVV record” before paying the claim.

CMS wrote that states can “automatically compare claims with EVV data and prevent payments for PCS and HHCS claims that do not have matching EVV records.” That covers personal care services and home health care services, and any other services a state chooses to put under EVV.

04

Self-directed care and electronic visit verification

Personal care can be delivered two ways, and electronic visit verification touches both. In agency-based care, “a personal care agency provides oversight, management, and supervision” of a person’s services, the proposal explains. In self-directed care, people or their representatives have decision-making authority in “the planning, accessing, managing, and purchasing” of their services.

“Regardless of the PCS delivery model, the SMA is responsible for monitoring the quality of services,” CMS wrote, meaning the state Medicaid agency. Some states already link electronic visit verification to their claims systems so that claims are compared with visit data automatically, and some have extended EVV beyond personal care and home health, according to the proposal.

States that fall short could face consequences. CMS said it would not tie federal matching funds directly to the new prepayment check, but noncompliance found in an audit could lead CMS to revisit a state’s EVV compliance, which could bring reductions in federal matching rates until the state complies.

05

What EVV prepayment review could mean for you

If you direct your own care or rely on an agency, the electronic visit verification change matters in a practical way. Under it, a claim without a matching visit record would be stopped before payment. A missed check-in or a mismatch in the data could mean a caregiver waits longer to be paid, so accurate visit records become even more important.

Personal care is a big part of how disabled people live at home. In 2023, home and community-based services made up 63.8 percent of Medicaid spending on long-term services and supports, and personal care spending totaled at least $36.1 billion, the CRUSH rule says. CMS itself wrote that these services “provide important supports that allow individuals to remain in home and community settings.”

Bloom has reported on what happens when home care programs are cut, including Connecticut’s Community First Choice changes. If your state’s EVV system already causes problems for your workers, the CRUSH rule’s comment period is the time to say so.

06

Payment suspensions would get harder to avoid

When a state finds a “credible allegation of fraud” against a Medicaid provider, it generally must suspend payments unless a “good cause” exception applies. CMS says states use those exceptions too often. In calendar year 2025, about 75 percent of credible allegation of fraud cases reported to CMS didn’t lead to a payment suspension because a state invoked a good cause exception, the CRUSH rule says.

The proposal would require states to evaluate and document in writing that the criteria for an exception are met in each case. When a state relies on a law enforcement exception, it would have to verify the reason with law enforcement case by case and send CMS the basis. States could also rely on fraud findings by CMS or other federal agencies.

CMS said it wants “to ensure that fraudulent providers are not inappropriately paid, while being circumspect and prudent with exercising authorities to best ensure legitimate providers are not inadvertently ensnared.” For disabled people, a payment suspension against an agency can affect the workers who come to their homes, so how states apply this part of the CRUSH rule will matter.

07

Eligibility checks and state penalties

The proposal also takes aim at mistakes in deciding who qualifies for Medicaid. In fiscal year 2025, beneficiary eligibility determination errors accounted for about 72 percent of Medicaid improper payments, an estimated $27 billion, CMS wrote. Improper payments aren’t the same as fraud; they include errors and missing paperwork.

The proposal would build out a beneficiary eligibility audit program and update how CMS disallows federal money when a state’s eligibility error rate tops the 3 percent threshold in federal law. States with an eligibility improper payment rate above 3 percent for consecutive cycles would face semi-annual reporting.

It would also let states recover managed care payments made for people who have died or moved out of state. But CMS wrote that “existing notice, fair hearing, and eligibility-redetermination requirements would continue to apply before a State may terminate coverage.” If your state asks you to confirm where you live, answer by the deadline, and know that you keep the right to notice and a fair hearing.

08

Medical equipment: no more cold calls at the door

Wheelchairs, oxygen, walkers and supplies come through suppliers of durable medical equipment, prosthetics, orthotics and supplies, known as DMEPOS. The CRUSH rule would expand the ban on unsolicited contact by those suppliers and the marketers working for them.

Today, suppliers generally can’t call Medicare beneficiaries by phone without written permission or an existing relationship. The proposal would add a new standard covering “direct messages from social media platforms, email messages without opt-out provisions, and door-to-door in-person solicitation,” with the same exceptions.

People who answered CMS’s earlier request for information described unwanted calls, texts, emails and visits at home, sometimes with “high pressure sales tactics,” and claims filed as though people had agreed, the CRUSH rule says. Some commenters worried that tighter limits could “disrupt DMEPOS care coordination or patient education.” The rule would also strengthen surety bond requirements for these suppliers.

09

Provider enrollment, Medicare Advantage and the Marketplace

The CRUSH rule would tighten enrollment across Medicare, Medicaid and CHIP with stronger identity checks, faster reporting of changes, and more grounds to deny or revoke enrollment. It would also require every provider and supplier billing a Medicare Advantage plan to be enrolled in Original Medicare.

CMS proposes reforms to Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits, citing $21 billion a year in overpayments from inflated risk scores. In the Marketplace, the proposal would let CMS suspend or terminate agents, brokers and web-brokers who engage in abusive conduct. It would also require consistent National Provider Identifiers for eligible Medicaid provider types.

10

A question about union dues for home care workers

The CRUSH rule includes a request for information on deductions from Medicaid payments to providers, including union dues. Many home care workers are paid through Medicaid, and some states deduct union dues from those payments.

In June 2026, CMS sent letters to nine state Medicaid agencies reminding them of their obligations and of the Supreme Court’s decision in Janus, the CRUSH rule says. CMS wrote that, if its reading of those decisions is correct, a state’s deduction of dues “without the practitioner’s clear and affirmative prior and voluntary consent is unconstitutional.” It is asking whether to set more specific rules on consent and recordkeeping.

This part isn’t a proposed rule yet; it’s a set of questions. Home care workers, their unions and the people they serve may all want to answer them.

11

A timeline of the CRUSH rule

These dates come from the CRUSH rule and the Federal Register:

  • January 1, 2020: States must have EVV in place for Medicaid personal care services.
  • January 1, 2023: States must have EVV in place for Medicaid home health care.
  • February 27, 2026: CMS publishes a request for information on the CRUSH rule.
  • June 2026: CMS writes to nine states about union dues deductions.
  • November 19, 2026: The CRUSH rule is published as a proposed rule.
  • January 19, 2027: Public comments are due.
  • After a final rule: Most Medicaid and CHIP changes take effect 60 days after publication.

12

How to comment on the CRUSH rule

Anyone can comment, and CMS must consider comments received by January 19, 2027. Here’s how:

  1. Go to the Regulations.gov docket and choose “Submit a comment.” Refer to file code CMS-6098-P.
  2. Or mail written comments to Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Department of Health and Human Services, Attention: CMS-6098-P, P.O. Box 8013, Baltimore, MD 21244-8013, allowing time for delivery.
  3. Choose only one way to submit, as CMS asks.
  4. Tell your own story: how EVV works for you or your workers, whether visits get logged correctly, and what a payment delay would mean.
  5. Comments are public, so leave out personal details you don’t want posted.
  6. If you use medical equipment, say whether you’ve received unwanted sales calls, texts or visits.

You can read the full text of the CRUSH rule on GovInfo. CMS says a plain language summary is posted on Regulations.gov.

13

What CMS doesn’t know yet

CMS hasn’t fully measured what the CRUSH rule would cost. Its Office of the Actuary “has not completed a quantitative score of the Federal budgetary or trust fund impacts of this proposed rule,” the agency wrote, and will provide projections in the final rule.

CMS is asking commenters for “data and feedback” on “potential administrative, operational, and utilization impacts.” That’s an open door for disabled people, caregivers and agencies to describe what these changes would mean in daily life, in their own words.

14

What happens next

CMS will read the comments and may change the CRUSH rule before finalizing it. Bloom will follow the CRUSH rule and report what changes.

Bloom has covered Medicaid’s shifting rules this fall, including the hold harmless period for work requirements. We’ll keep watching how fraud rules land on the people Medicaid exists to serve.

15

What Bloom is doing

Bloom stands with disabled people and the caregivers who make life at home possible. I believe fighting fraud and protecting care belong together, and no honest aide or family should go unpaid because a system can’t tell a real visit from a fake one.

If this news is heavy for you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and Bloom’s support groups are a place to be known. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading 167-page rules so you don’t have to, and a one-time gift helps too.

16

Frequently Asked Questions

It’s a proposed CMS rule, Comprehensive Regulations To Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, published November 19, 2026. It targets fraud in Medicaid, Medicare, CHIP and the health insurance Marketplace.

No. It’s a proposed rule. CMS is taking comments until January 19, 2027, and most Medicaid changes would take effect 60 days after a final rule.

States would have to verify, before paying, that billed in-home services subject to EVV are supported by an electronic visit record, and review EVV records in fraud investigations.

CMS says states underuse tools like payment suspensions and visit data. It points to 326 personal care attendant fraud convictions in fiscal year 2025 and billions of dollars in improper payments from eligibility errors.

Possibly. Under the proposal, a home care claim without a matching electronic visit record would be stopped before payment, so accurate check-ins matter.

Not under federal law. States must record the location and start and end times of a visit, but the law doesn’t require GPS. States have discretion in how their systems work.

It would bar suppliers and their agents from contacting people through social media direct messages, emails without opt-outs or door-to-door visits, unless the person gave written permission or another exception applies.

Submit a comment on Regulations.gov in docket CMS-2026-0826, referring to file code CMS-6098-P, or mail it to CMS by January 19, 2027.

Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ŸŒธ

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.