
Newsroom·Oregon Legislature·News
Jury Finds Sandy Punished Its Interim Police Chief for Speaking Out
Public workers keep their right to speak as citizens. On Friday a federal jury found Sandy, Oregon, and three of its leaders punished interim police chief Sean Lundry for questioning a police chief search, and awarded him $935,000.
Sean Lundry was the interim police chief of Sandy, Oregon, when he urged neighbors to ask for the public records behind the city’s search for a permanent chief. Within weeks he was on paid leave and referred for a criminal investigation, and by June 2024 he’d been fired. On Friday, November 20, 2026, a federal jury in Portland found that the City of Sandy and three of its leaders retaliated against him for exercising his First Amendment rights. The retaliation verdict awards him $935,000, including punitive damages against former Mayor Stan Pulliam, City Manager Tyler Deems and Deputy City Manager Jeff Aprati.
The same jury rejected Lundry’s due process claims and his state whistleblower claim, and the city has denied that it retaliated against him. Motions are still pending, so this retaliation verdict isn’t the last word. But it answers a question every public worker carries: can I be punished for speaking up, as a citizen, about how my government works? Here’s what the jury decided, what the law says, and what you can do.
01
The retaliation verdict at a glance
Here’s the retaliation verdict, from the verdict form filed November 20, 2026:
- First Amendment retaliation: “Yes” for the City of Sandy, Pulliam, Deems and Aprati.
- Economic damages: $850,000. Noneconomic damages: $0.
- Punitive damages: $50,000 against Pulliam, $25,000 against Deems and $10,000 against Aprati.
- Name-clearing hearing and procedural due process: “No” for every defendant.
- State whistleblower retaliation: “No.”
- Wrongful discharge: left blank, as the form’s instructions directed.
02
What the jury decided
The case is Lundry v. City of Sandy, No. 3:24-cv-01433, before U.S. District Judge Amy M. Baggio. The jurors wrote that they “do unanimously find” their answers. On the central question, whether each defendant “retaliated against the plaintiff in violation of his First Amendment rights,” they checked “Yes” four times. That’s the heart of the retaliation verdict.
They then put Lundry’s economic damages under his Section 1983 claims at $850,000 and his noneconomic damages at zero. The handwritten figures in the retaliation verdict, which Bloom checked against the page images, add $85,000 in punitive damages, for a total of $935,000. The presiding juror dated the form November 20, 2026, and the juror’s name is redacted.
Lundry had asked for more. His lawyers listed $1,532,062.81 in lost wages, benefits and retirement income in a pretrial filing. The economic award in the retaliation verdict came to a little more than half of that.
03
What Sean Lundry said, and why it mattered
Lundry joined the Sandy Police Department in 2015 and was picked as interim chief in August 2023, according to the agreed facts in the pretrial order. He applied for the permanent job, became one of three finalists, and was told on January 16, 2024, that he hadn’t been chosen.
What followed is the speech at the center of the retaliation verdict. “Plaintiff encouraged others to submit records requests and to share their concerns about the City’s decision-making,” both sides agreed. Lundry and others filed public records requests seeking everything about how the city made its choice.
He also wrote, in a public Facebook comment, that he would never accept the chief’s job “with the current mayor, council, and appointed leadership,” his complaint says. His lawyers argued that the records requests and the criticism were protected speech by a private citizen on a public question. That’s the speech the retaliation verdict turned on.
04
How a police chief search became a public fight
According to the complaint, the city held two public receptions for the three finalists on January 3, 2024, and invited comment cards. Most of the roughly 30 commenters backed Lundry, the complaint says. One anonymous card accused him of shredding records. Weeks later, that allegation became the city’s stated reason for putting him on leave.
The city first refused to release the comment cards to the people who asked for them. It released them after the Clackamas County District Attorney’s Office directed it to, KPTV reported. The complaint dates that decision to February 14, 2024.
Lundry also questioned the use of about $30,000 from the police budget to pay the search consultant, raising it with city staff, Deems and the council president, the complaint says. The city disputed that the spending was improper. Its lawyers said the expense was “within City Manager’s discretion” to assign to the police department.
05
Paid leave, a criminal referral and a firing
On February 23, 2024, Deems placed Lundry on paid administrative leave over the allegation that he had destroyed public records and referred it to the Oregon State Police, the agreed facts say. On March 7, the city told him it would also investigate allegations of bullying, harassment and threats.
On April 15, 2024, the Clackamas County District Attorney’s Office concluded “there was no evidence that Plaintiff had unlawfully destroyed public records,” the pretrial order says. The internal case went on.
On May 22, Deems told Lundry of the investigation’s findings and the city’s intent to fire him. On June 18, 2024, Lundry received a notice of termination. He applied for other police jobs in Oregon and didn’t get one, both sides agreed. The loss of the interim post, the leave and the firing are the actions Lundry asked the jury to call retaliation, and the retaliation verdict sided with him.
06
What the city argued
The city denied every claim and denied causing Lundry any harm. In a joint statement of the case prepared for the jury, the defendants denied that his speech was protected and denied retaliating against him. In its trial memorandum, it said Lundry responded to being passed over with workplace misconduct, including intimidating subordinates and disrupting the department.
It argued that his speech was “objectively regarding a personnel dispute” over not being chosen, not a matter of public concern. It argued that Lundry spoke at least partly as an employee, not a citizen. And it said “The City had an interest in promoting workplace efficiency and avoiding disruption of the Police Department.”
One argument narrowed before trial. At the November 9 pretrial conference, the judge’s minutes note “Defendants’ stipulation that the police chief selection process was a matter of public concern.” That left the city’s other arguments, about whether he spoke as a citizen and whether its interests outweighed his. The retaliation verdict shows the jury wasn’t persuaded.
07
The recording and the after-acquired evidence defense
The city’s only affirmative defense, his lawyers wrote, was something it learned after the firing. During the lawsuit, Lundry disclosed that he had recorded a February 2024 meeting with Deems without Deems knowing, the agreed facts say. The city argued it would have fired him had it known. Lundry’s lawyers called it a non-issue, noting that Deems had no objection when Lundry asked to record a later meeting.
Judge Baggio let the city rely on a police department policy to support that defense. Lundry “withheld this recording for over six months after Defendants issued their request for production,” she wrote in a November 17 order. On November 18 she ruled that, if the defense applied, it would limit economic damages as of December 16, 2024.
Then, on November 19, after both sides rested, the judge granted Lundry’s motion for judgment as a matter of law “regarding after-acquired evidence,” her minutes say. The jury didn’t decide that defense, so it played no part in the retaliation verdict.
08
What the First Amendment protects at work
Public employees can’t be fired for speaking as citizens on matters of public concern, with limits. Every retaliation verdict like this one starts from that rule. The Supreme Court set out the balance in 1968, in Pickering v. Board of Education, the case of a teacher fired for a letter to a newspaper criticizing how his school board raised money.
The Court said its task was “to arrive at a balance” between the employee’s interest in speaking and the government’s interest in “promoting the efficiency of the public services it performs.” On public questions like school funding, it wrote, “free and open debate is vital to informed decision-making by the electorate,” according to the Pickering opinion.
In 2006, Garcetti v. Ceballos drew a line. The Court held that “when public employees make statements pursuant to their official duties, the employees are not speaking as citizens for First Amendment purposes.”
09
Speaking as a citizen about your own workplace
The Court clarified that line in 2014. In Lane v. Franks, it asked “whether the speech at issue is itself ordinarily within the scope of an employee’s duties, not whether it merely concerns those duties.” Speech isn’t stripped of protection just because it’s about information learned at work.
“After all, public employees do not renounce their citizenship when they accept employment,” the Court wrote. That idea sits beneath the retaliation verdict. Lundry’s lawyers argued that he encouraged records requests and criticized city leaders as a private citizen, not as part of his job.
The city’s lawyers cited the Ninth Circuit’s five-step test from Eng v. Cooley. Lundry had to show he spoke as a private citizen, on a matter of public concern, and that his speech was a substantial motivating factor. Then the burden shifted to the city to justify its actions or show it would have acted anyway.
10
Why the retaliation verdict names three officials
Lundry sued Pulliam, Deems and Aprati in their personal capacities, not just the city. The city fought that. “Neither Defendant Jeff Aprati, nor Defendant Pulliam had final decision-making authority regarding Plaintiff’s employment,” its trial memorandum said.
Lundry’s lawyers had told the court that Pulliam helped plan his leave with Deems and the council, and that Deems directed, and Aprati carried out, a strategy of answering critics about Lundry on the city’s Facebook page, according to their trial memorandum. The jury didn’t explain its reasons, but the retaliation verdict found each of the three liable for First Amendment retaliation.
On November 19, the judge denied the defense motion for judgment as a matter of law on the retaliation claim and reserved ruling on the remaining motions, her minutes say.
11
What punitive damages mean here
Punitive damages aren’t payment for a loss. They punish. Under Smith v. Wade, decided in April 1983, a jury may award them in a Section 1983 case when conduct is “motivated by evil motive or intent” or involves “reckless or callous indifference to the plaintiff’s federally protected rights.”
In the retaliation verdict, only the three officials were asked about punitive damages. Cities can’t be made to pay them. “A municipality is immune from punitive damages under § 1983,” the Court held in City of Newport v. Fact Concerts. Bloom hasn’t seen the jury instructions, which aren’t on the public docket.
The punitive damages in the retaliation verdict are small next to the economic award. They’re the part of the award the jury assessed against each official by name.
12
The claims the jury rejected
The retaliation verdict wasn’t a clean sweep. The jury found Lundry hadn’t proved that any defendant violated his right to a name-clearing hearing, a chance for a public employee to answer stigmatizing charges tied to a firing. The city had argued that “Plaintiff was offered a name clearing hearing,” and that he chose to respond in writing instead.
Jurors also found he hadn’t proved a violation of his right to procedural due process in his employment. And they found he hadn’t proved the city, through Deems, retaliated against him for whistleblowing about the consultant payment under ORS 659A.203.
The jury never answered the wrongful discharge question, which rested on his role in organizing public records requests. The form told jurors to skip it once they’d found First Amendment retaliation and no whistleblower retaliation.
13
Why public records requests matter
Oregon’s Public Records Law starts with a promise. “Every person has a right to inspect any public record of a public body in this state,” ORS 192.314 says, except as other statutes provide. A public record includes “any writing that contains information relating to the conduct of the public’s business.”
When a city denies a request, the requester can petition the district attorney of its county, who carries out the role the attorney general plays for state agencies, under ORS 192.415. It’s how a district attorney can end up deciding whether a city’s records come out, as Clackamas County’s did with Sandy’s comment cards. Those requests sit at the center of the retaliation verdict.
The law reached into this lawsuit, too. In an October 6, 2025 order, the judge noted the parties agreed that “writings on personal devices and accounts that contain information relating to city business are subject to Oregon public record retention laws.” Messages on officials’ personal phones about city business can be public records.
14
The retaliation verdict and the wider law
This retaliation verdict sets no precedent for other courts. But it shows how the Pickering balance works in front of ordinary people.
KPTV reported that Lundry’s lawyer, Chris Heywood, said: “This was always a free speech case to us, and we presented it that way.”
“I think it’s absolutely a vindication for Sean,” Heywood said. “He’ll never get his life back. He’ll never get his career back.” He added, “But there is accountability on the other end.”
15
A timeline of the case
How the case reached the retaliation verdict, from the docket, the pretrial order’s agreed facts and the complaint:
- 2015: Lundry joins the Sandy Police Department.
- August 2023: He’s selected interim chief.
- January 16, 2024: He’s told he wasn’t chosen as permanent chief.
- February 23, 2024: He’s placed on paid leave and referred to the Oregon State Police.
- April 15, 2024: The district attorney’s office finds no evidence he unlawfully destroyed records.
- June 18, 2024: He receives a notice of termination.
- August 28, 2024: He files suit in federal court in Portland.
- November 16, 2026: Trial begins.
- November 20, 2026: The jury returns the retaliation verdict.
16
What happens next
The retaliation verdict isn’t a judgment yet. No judgment had been entered as of Saturday, the docket shows. The judge still has to rule on the motions she reserved. After judgment, a losing party may renew a motion for judgment as a matter of law “No later than 28 days after the entry of judgment,” under Rule 50, and may ask for a new trial. In ruling, the judge can let the retaliation verdict stand, order a new trial or direct judgment as a matter of law.
A notice of appeal is due “within 30 days after entry of the judgment or order appealed from,” under Rule 4 of the appellate rules. Oregon sits in the Ninth Circuit, 28 U.S. Code § 41 says, so an appeal would go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Lundry has also asked for attorney fees. A court may award a prevailing party in a civil rights case “a reasonable attorney’s fee as part of the costs,” 42 U.S. Code § 1988 says.
17
What the city has said
KPTV asked the city for comment on the retaliation verdict. Sandy Police Lieutenant Sam Craven said any response would come through the city’s website and social media, and he didn’t expect one, KPTV reported. The station also contacted the city directly and hadn’t heard back.
On Saturday night, the city’s news page carried no statement on the retaliation verdict. In court, the city maintained that Lundry’s firing was lawful, and Bloom will add any statement it makes about the retaliation verdict.
18
What public workers in Oregon can do
The retaliation verdict doesn’t change the law, but it shows the law at work. If you work for a city, county, school district or state agency and fear retaliation for speaking up:
- Write it down. Keep a dated record of what you said, to whom, and what happened next.
- Speak as a citizen where you can. Lane v. Franks protects speech that isn’t part of your ordinary job duties, even when it’s about your work.
- Use the records law. Anyone can ask for public records, and a denial by a city can go to the county’s district attorney.
- Know Oregon’s Whistleblower Law. ORS 659A.203 bars public employers from disciplining you for disclosing what you reasonably believe is evidence of “Mismanagement, gross waste of funds or abuse of authority,” and ORS 659A.199 protects good-faith reports of lawbreaking.
- Report retaliation to BOLI. “A report does not have to be substantiated for the whistleblower to be protected from retaliation,” the Bureau of Labor and Industries says. A complaint generally “must be filed no later than one year after the alleged unlawful practice,” ORS 659A.820 says.
- Talk to an employment lawyer early. Federal and state claims have different deadlines and remedies, as this case shows.
19
Speech cases Bloom has followed this month
The retaliation verdict joins a month of rulings about government punishing speech. A federal judge blocked the search of an immigration lawyer’s phone, finding he was likely to prove it was retaliation for his public speech.
University of Missouri students sued their state’s attorney general, calling his demand for members’ names retaliation for their speech. And Florida International University dropped charges against seven students over a silent protest. Each asks the same thing: can the people with power punish you for what you say?
20
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reports these cases because the right to question power belongs to everyone, the cashier and the police lieutenant alike. I believe a city is stronger, not weaker, when its own people can ask hard questions out loud.
If losing work or standing up at work has left you afraid, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call at any hour, and Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading the verdict forms and dockets behind stories like this retaliation verdict, and a one-time gift helps too.
21
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 20, 2026, a federal jury found the City of Sandy, former Mayor Stan Pulliam, City Manager Tyler Deems and Deputy City Manager Jeff Aprati retaliated against Sean Lundry in violation of the First Amendment. It awarded $850,000 in economic damages and $85,000 in punitive damages.
Lundry encouraged others to file public records requests and share concerns about the city’s police chief search, and he criticized city leadership on Facebook, according to the court record.
No. The retaliation verdict rejected his name-clearing hearing and due process claims and his state whistleblower claim. It didn’t answer the wrongful discharge question.
Not yet. No judgment had been entered as of November 21, the judge reserved ruling on some motions, and either side may file post-trial motions or appeal to the Ninth Circuit.
The Supreme Court held in City of Newport v. Fact Concerts that a municipality is immune from punitive damages under Section 1983. Only the three officials were asked about them in the retaliation verdict.
Keep a written record, talk to an employment lawyer, and consider a complaint with the Bureau of Labor and Industries, generally within one year.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.


