
Newsroom·Minnesota Legislature·News
Judge Orders ICE to Free Willmar Man Detained After Seeking Help
He was robbed and beaten with a pistol, then went to a sheriff's office for help. He walked out of the jail into ICE custody. A federal judge found four separate flaws in the arrest and ordered the Willmar man released by Friday afternoon.
A federal judge ordered the Willmar man released "immediately, without conditions."
A Willmar man was robbed and beaten with a pistol in late September, so badly that his skull and cheekbones were fractured. He went to a sheriff’s office for help. He left in the custody of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, and spent nearly two months detained before a federal judge ordered him freed.
U.S. District Judge Jeffrey M. Bryan of the District of Minnesota ruled on Thursday, November 19, 2026, that the arrest was unlawful for four separate reasons, and ordered ICE to release the Willmar man “immediately, without conditions,” no later than 4 p.m. Central time Friday. Bloom couldn’t confirm by publication whether he had been released; the government has until 11 a.m. Monday to confirm it in court.
01
What happened to the Willmar man
The Willmar man is 48 and a citizen of Guatemala, according to the court’s order. Under the District of Minnesota’s policy for immigration cases, the court identifies him only by his first name and last initial, Yener G. Bloom is calling him the Willmar man.
He entered the United States near Sasabe, Arizona, in August 2023. A Border Patrol agent detained him and then released him after confirming his identity and that he had no criminal record, and he was given a notice to appear in immigration court. For about three years he has lived and worked in Willmar as a laborer, near his two children, who live with their mother there. He attends his immigration hearings and has a pending asylum application, the order says. Aside from two misdemeanor driving or traffic citations, his record is clean.
On or about September 25, 2026, he was mugged and hit in the head and face with a pistol. His attackers took his phone, his passport and other identification. He suffered fractures to his skull and cheekbones.
He then went to the Otter Tail County Sheriff’s Office seeking help, the order says. While he was there, he was held on an outstanding bench warrant: he had missed an arraignment on a January 2026 driving citation. He paid a $400 bail bond and was released on or about September 27. As he was leaving the jail, an ICE agent took him into custody.
02
How ICE built its case against the Willmar man
ICE’s own records describe how the Willmar man came to its attention. A deportation officer “encountered” him on September 25 while doing what ICE calls Criminal Alien Program duties, and reviewed “further records” to learn he was in removal proceedings, the order says. The court noted the record contains no evidence of what records were reviewed or what those duties involve.
An ICE supervisor issued an administrative warrant, a Form I-200, which isn’t signed by a judge. ICE officers can issue it themselves. According to ICE records cited in the order, a deportation officer interviewed the Willmar man by phone in Spanish while he was in the county jail, Patch reported.
His lawyer, Eugene Hummel of the firm Norton Rose Fulbright, filed a petition for habeas corpus on November 13, asking the court to rule that the detention was unlawful. Kandiyohi County Sheriff Eric Tollefson was named as a respondent alongside federal immigration officials, Patch reported. The order doesn’t explain the sheriff’s role, and Bloom isn’t guessing at it.
Habeas corpus is the oldest check on unlawful imprisonment in American law. It lets anyone held by the government ask a judge to decide whether the detention is legal, and the court ordered the government to answer within days.
03
Four reasons the arrest failed
Bryan found the detention of the Willmar man unlawful for four independent reasons. Any one of them would have been enough.
- The warrant rested on statements no one could vouch for. The Form I-200 said probable cause came from “statements made voluntarily by the subject” or other reliable evidence. But the government offered no evidence of the phone interview: how long it lasted, where he was held, whether the officer spoke Spanish well enough, or his mental condition. That mattered, the judge wrote, because he had fractured his skull and cheekbones earlier that day. “Absent any such evidence, the Court cannot conclude that Yener G. voluntarily made any statements.”
- No one could say who served the warrant. The name “Trevino” and the number “10924” appear beside two “markedly different” signatures on two ICE documents, one curved and looping, the other angular. “These obvious differences cast doubt on who the serving officer was,” Bryan wrote, and no officer involved gave a sworn statement.
- No one told him he was under arrest, or why. Federal regulations require an immigration officer, at the time of arrest, to identify themselves and to state that the person is under arrest and the reason. There was no evidence any officer did either, the judge found.
- No argument that he would flee. An immigration arrest without a valid warrant requires reason to believe the person is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. “Respondents make no argument whatsoever that officers satisfied either prong of section 1357(a),” Bryan wrote. The record showed the Willmar man had just been assaulted, had posted bail and had cooperated with agents.
“For each of these independent reasons, the detention of Yener G. is unlawful and immediate release is the appropriate remedy,” the judge concluded.
04
What a lawful ICE arrest requires
The order is also a short guide to the rules ICE must follow, rules that apply to every immigration detention, not only the Willmar man’s.
- A warrant is the default. Under federal regulations, a warrant of arrest “shall be obtained” except when the officer has reason to believe the person is likely to escape before one can be obtained. The rule is part of the Department of Homeland Security’s general procedures for arrests, the order notes.
- Only certain officers may issue and serve it. An administrative warrant may be issued and served only by immigration officers listed in the regulations, so the form has to show who they were, the judge wrote.
- The officer must say who they are. At the time of arrest, the officer must identify themselves as an immigration officer authorized to make the arrest, and state that the person is under arrest and why.
- Arrests without a warrant need real cause. The officer must have reason to believe the person is in the country unlawfully and is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained. In the Eighth Circuit, “reason to believe” means “constitutionally required probable cause,” the order notes, citing a 2010 appeals ruling.
None of these rules were met in the Willmar man’s arrest, by the judge’s count. That’s why the remedy was release, not a hearing.
05
The government’s new reason, rejected
The government didn’t defend the arrest on the terms ICE used. In court, its lawyers argued that the Willmar man was subject to mandatory detention under a different law, 8 U.S.C. 1225(b)(2), as the Eighth Circuit read it in an earlier 2026 case, Avila v. Bondi. That reading requires detention without an individual hearing, even for people found in the interior years after they arrived, according to the order.
Bryan wasn’t persuaded. The warrant itself invoked ICE’s discretionary arrest power, and the judge rejected the attempt to change the basis for the detention after the fact, CBS Minnesota reported.
In a footnote, he added a fifth, alternative ground: due process. Weighing the man’s liberty against the risk of error and the government’s interest, Bryan wrote that the federal government has “very little interest in incarcerating individuals en masse who pose little or no risk of flight or danger.” He noted that the Willmar man had been released into the country in 2023 after officials found he posed no such risk.
06
How the court protected him while it decided
Bryan acted quickly once the petition arrived. On November 16, three days after it was filed, he barred the government from moving the Willmar man out of Minnesota, ordered officials to give him private access to his lawyer and told them to preserve the belongings taken from him, according to the court docket.
The final order goes further. Along with confirming the release, the government must show that his property was returned, using ICE’s own property forms, or explain what it kept and why. For a man whose passport and identification were already stolen in the robbery, that isn’t a small thing.
07
What DHS says
The Department of Homeland Security defended the arrest. A spokesperson told CBS Minnesota that ICE arrested the Willmar man on September 26 after local authorities arrested him on a failure-to-appear bond for two criminal traffic violations. The statement said DHS “complies with lawful court orders” and that he will continue to receive due process while his removal case is pending.
The statement didn’t address the judge’s findings about the warrant, or say whether he had been released, CBS Minnesota reported. The order notes that ICE’s own description of its records, given in a declaration by an officer who didn’t claim personal knowledge of the arrest, was the main evidence the government offered.
08
Why this case matters for crime victims
Strip the legal steps away and the sequence is stark. A man was beaten and robbed. He did what anyone is told to do and went to the authorities for help. He ended up in immigration detention for nearly two months, on paperwork a federal judge found defective on every count he examined. The phone interview that ICE relied on took place the same day his skull and cheekbones were fractured, according to the order.
The order doesn’t decide whether he can stay in the United States. His asylum case continues. What it decides is narrower and still important: the government has to follow its own rules when it takes someone’s liberty, whether that person is a citizen or not.
For crime victims who aren’t citizens, and for the families and advocates who walk with them, the Willmar man’s case shows two things at once. Seeking help can carry real risk, and the courts can still check an unlawful arrest. Both are worth knowing before you need them.
09
A pattern in Minnesota’s federal court
This isn’t the first time Minnesota’s federal judges have ordered someone freed over a defective arrest. In January, Bryan ruled that immigration agents’ arrest of a Minneapolis man was unlawful because officials violated regulations, CBS Minnesota reported.
His order in the Willmar man’s case cites other rulings from the same court this year: judges ordering release where ICE had no valid administrative warrant, where the Form I-200 itself was invalid, and where officers didn’t follow the rules for an arrest without a warrant. In March, one judge concluded that “immediate release is the proper remedy” when a person is taken into custody without a valid administrative warrant, the order notes.
Bloom has reported similar rulings elsewhere this month, including a Maine judge’s order freeing an 18-year-old seized without a warrant and a Colorado judge’s contempt finding against ICE officials over instant re-arrests.
10
Timeline of the Willmar man’s case
- August 2023: He enters the U.S. near Sasabe, Arizona, and is released after Border Patrol confirms he has no criminal record.
- January 2026: He receives a driving citation, then misses the arraignment.
- About September 25, 2026: He is robbed and beaten with a pistol and goes to the Otter Tail County Sheriff’s Office for help, where he is held on a bench warrant.
- About September 27, 2026: He posts $400 bail and is taken into ICE custody as he leaves the jail.
- November 13, 2026: His lawyer files a habeas corpus petition.
- November 19, 2026: Judge Bryan grants the petition and orders his release.
- November 20, 2026, 4 p.m. Central: The deadline for his release.
- November 23, 2026, 11 a.m. Central: The government’s deadline to confirm the release and return his property.
11
What happens next
By Monday morning, the government must file a letter confirming that it released the Willmar man, plus a sworn declaration saying when and where, with proof that his property was returned, the order says. He may also ask the court to make the government pay his legal fees.
His asylum case and removal proceedings go on. The release order doesn’t end them. Bloom will report whether the government confirms his release or appeals.
12
What you can do
If you or someone you love isn’t a citizen, the Willmar man’s case holds lessons worth keeping:
- Know your rights. “Regardless of your immigration status, you have guaranteed rights under the Constitution,” says the ACLU’s know-your-rights guide. Read it before you need it.
- Deal with old citations. A missed court date on a traffic ticket turned into a bench warrant here. If you’ve missed one, ask a lawyer how to resolve it.
- Get a lawyer fast after an arrest. A habeas corpus petition can bring a detention before a federal judge quickly. In this case, the judge ruled six days after the petition was filed.
- Keep documents safe and copied. His passport and identification were stolen in the robbery. Keep copies of key papers somewhere separate and secure.
- Don’t carry fear alone. If you’ve been hurt and are afraid to ask for help, Bloom’s crisis support page lists places to turn right now, and 988 answers by call or text.
13
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reads the court record so readers can see what the government did and what the law required. We’ll report whether the Willmar man was released and what comes next in his case.
If violence, detention or fear has touched your family, Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. Reporting like this takes hours inside federal court records. If it helps you, a monthly gift keeps it steady for the long haul, and a one-time gift helps too.
14
Frequently Asked Questions
Judge Jeffrey M. Bryan found the arrest unlawful for four independent reasons: the warrant’s basis was unsupported, the serving officer couldn’t be identified, no one told him he was under arrest or why, and the government didn’t argue he would flee.
After he was robbed and beaten, he went to the Otter Tail County Sheriff’s Office for help and was held on a bench warrant for missing a court date on a driving citation. ICE took him into custody as he left the jail.
The judge ordered his release by 4 p.m. Central time on November 20, 2026. The government must confirm the release in a filing by 11 a.m. on November 23.
A Form I-200 administrative warrant is issued by an immigration officer, not a judge. The judge found the one used to arrest the Willmar man invalid.
No. His removal proceedings and his asylum application continue. The order only decides that his detention was unlawful and that he must be released.
Habeas corpus lets a person held by the government ask a court to rule on whether the detention is lawful. If it isn’t, the usual remedy is release.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Minnesota Legislature · 12 November 2026Minneapolis Names Stella Nez Perce Ahead of the Day of Remembrance
Disability advocacy · 7 November 2026Oregon Leads 4 States Suing Over Medicaid Work Requirements
Disability advocacy · 20 November 2026Bipartisan Bill Would Stop Social Security Clawbacks From Children