A historic town-square courthouse with a clock dome under a blue sky, illustrating the dropped CAIR lawsuit

NewsroomTexas LegislatureNews

Ken Paxton Drops Lawsuit That Sought to Bar CAIR From Texas

Texas has dropped its court bid to brand the nation's largest Muslim civil rights group a terrorist organization and bar it from the state. But the governor's designation still stands, and the state can refile.

Texas has walked away, for now, from its courtroom bid to brand the nation’s largest Muslim civil rights organization a terrorist group and push it out of the state. On Monday, November 16, the state filed a notice of nonsuit without prejudice in the CAIR lawsuit in Collin County, court records show, KERA News reported.

The filing ends the case Attorney General Ken Paxton brought in February against the Council on American-Islamic Relations and its Texas chapters. The CAIR lawsuit had been pending for about nine months. It doesn’t end the fight, though. Gov. Greg Abbott’s separate terrorist designation of CAIR still stands, and a dismissal without prejudice leaves the state free to bring the CAIR lawsuit back.

01

What Texas filed on Monday

A notice of nonsuit is the way a party that brought a case tells a Texas court it’s no longer pursuing it. According to KERA, Collin County court records show the state filed one in the CAIR lawsuit on Monday.

The state withdrew the CAIR lawsuit before a judge could rule on its allegations, KPRC 2 in Houston reported, citing the Texas Tribune. That matters. No court found that CAIR or its Texas chapters did what the state accused them of doing.

“Without prejudice” matters too. Because the case was dropped that way, KPRC noted, the state has left the door open to bringing it back. A notice of nonsuit closes this CAIR lawsuit; it doesn’t promise there won’t be another.

KERA reported that it had asked the attorney general’s office for comment and would update its story with any response. Neither KERA’s report nor KPRC’s included an explanation from the state for dropping the CAIR lawsuit. KPRC said a CAIR spokesperson told the station the organization was working on a statement.

That leaves the public with a filing and a silence. For a case that asked a court to treat a civil rights group as a terrorist organization, the reasons for ending it matter almost as much as the reasons for starting it.

02

What the CAIR lawsuit claimed

The state filed the CAIR lawsuit in February 2026. According to KERA, it sought to stop CAIR and its Texas chapters from operating in the state, and to have them named foreign terrorist organizations.

KPRC reported that the CAIR lawsuit asked a judge to declare CAIR and its Texas chapters foreign terrorist and transnational criminal organizations. It accused the group of working with the Muslim Brotherhood to undermine government authority.

CAIR rejected the allegations. The organization said the CAIR lawsuit was politically motivated, KPRC reported, and an attempt to punish it for speaking out against Israel’s war in Gaza.

Those are two very different accounts, and Bloom isn’t in a position to settle them. What the record shows is narrower and plain: the state made serious accusations in court, and then it withdrew them before any judge weighed the evidence.

03

Who CAIR is

The Council on American-Islamic Relations is the nation’s largest Muslim civil rights and advocacy organization, according to KPRC. CAIR’s website says the group was established to challenge stereotypes about Islam and Muslims, KERA reported, and most of its work focuses on civil rights and anti-defamation.

For CAIR’s Texas chapters, the CAIR lawsuit was more than a legal threat. It asked a court to stop them from operating in their own state. Mustafaa Carroll, executive director of CAIR-Dallas, told KERA the group hopes for a push toward unity under the incoming administration.

“We’re tired of fighting this fight,” Carroll said. “We want to get along with folks.”

04

The terrorist designation still stands

The CAIR lawsuit wasn’t the state’s only move. Gov. Greg Abbott designated CAIR a foreign terrorist and transnational criminal organization last year, KERA reported. KPRC reported that the CAIR lawsuit followed that designation, and that Abbott urged Paxton to take legal action against the group.

Abbott’s proclamation letter cited accusations that CAIR was created as a “front group” for Hamas, according to KERA. CAIR denies those claims. Abbott also claimed CAIR has “repeatedly employed, affiliated with, and supported individuals promoting terrorism-related activities.”

Dropping the CAIR lawsuit doesn’t erase Abbott’s terrorist designation, KPRC reported. That remains a separate matter.

Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has told The Washington Post she would remove CAIR’s terrorist designation when she takes office, according to KERA. “We have to use public safety measures for public safety,” she said, dismissing what she called “nonsense happening with power that should be used for public safety.”

That’s a promise from an incoming official, not yet an act. Until it happens, the designation remains in force, with or without the CAIR lawsuit.

05

What the dismissal changes, and what it doesn’t

What changes:

  • The state is no longer asking a court to declare CAIR and its Texas chapters foreign terrorist and transnational criminal organizations.
  • The state is no longer asking a court to stop CAIR’s Texas chapters from operating in Texas.
  • No court will rule on the CAIR lawsuit’s allegations in this case.

What doesn’t change:

  • Gov. Greg Abbott’s terrorist designation of CAIR stays in place until it’s withdrawn.
  • The state can bring the CAIR lawsuit back, because the dismissal was without prejudice.
  • The accusations and CAIR’s denials remain where they were: on the record, and untested by any judge.

06

How terrorist labels usually work

Under federal law, the power to name a foreign terrorist organization belongs to the Secretary of State. The statute lets the secretary designate a group only after finding that it’s a foreign organization, that it engages in terrorist activity or terrorism, and that its activity threatens the security of Americans or the national security of the United States.

That federal process has guardrails. Seven days before a designation, the secretary must notify congressional leaders in writing. The designation is published in the Federal Register. And within 30 days of publication, the designated organization may seek review in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

Texas’s terrorist designation of CAIR came from the governor, not from that federal process. The CAIR lawsuit then asked a state court to add a declaration of its own. A state label and a federal one aren’t the same thing, and readers should be careful not to treat them as if they were.

07

Why the CAIR lawsuit was a civil liberties case

Strip away the names, and the CAIR lawsuit asked a hard question: when can a state use its courts to shut an advocacy group out of public life? Americans have watched a state try this before.

In 1956, the attorney general of Alabama brought a suit in state court to stop the NAACP from conducting activities in the state and to oust it from Alabama. Among other things, the state’s complaint pointed to the group’s legal help for Black students seeking admission to the state university, and its support for the bus boycott in Montgomery. A state court then issued an order restraining the group from further activities there while the case went on.

Alabama’s legal theory was technical. It said the NAACP had broken a law requiring out-of-state corporations to register before doing business there. The NAACP answered that the law didn’t apply to it, and that what the state wanted to accomplish would violate rights to freedom of speech and assembly.

The state also demanded the NAACP’s membership lists. When the group refused to hand them over, a court held it in contempt and fined it $10,000, a fine set to rise to $100,000.

The fight reached the Supreme Court in NAACP v. Alabama ex rel. Patterson, decided June 30, 1958. In a dispute over the NAACP’s membership lists, the Court sided with the group. It called the “freedom to engage in association for the advancement of beliefs and ideas” an inseparable part of the liberty the Constitution protects, and it reversed the contempt judgment.

The justices also saw how pressure works. “Compelled disclosure of affiliation with groups engaged in advocacy may constitute as effective a restraint on freedom of association” as more direct government action, the Court wrote.

The two cases aren’t the same, and the allegations in them aren’t the same. But the principle reaches both. Freedom of association protects groups people love and groups people distrust. That’s the point of it. A state that wants to end a group’s work has to prove its case in court, under rules that bind the state as much as the group.

In Texas, that proof never came. The state filed the notice of nonsuit before any judge ruled.

08

What the First Amendment protects

The First Amendment bars laws “prohibiting the free exercise” of religion and protects “the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.” In NAACP v. Alabama, the Court explained that the freedom to associate is part of the liberty the Fourteenth Amendment’s due process clause guards against state action.

Put plainly, Americans may gather around a faith, a cause or a complaint, and speak together about it, without first asking the state’s permission. That freedom doesn’t shield crime. It does mean a state that wants to shut a group down carries the burden of proving its case.

09

Names carry weight

When a government attaches the word “terrorist” to a community’s civil rights group, the people who belong to it, give to it or simply share its faith can feel that word land on them too. That’s the quiet cost of a case like this one, and it doesn’t disappear when a notice of nonsuit is filed.

Bloom is a ministry, and we believe a person’s faith is never, by itself, a threat to the state. We also believe the state has every right to prosecute real crimes, by real evidence, in open court. Those two convictions don’t compete. They’re the same commitment to truth.

Faith communities know what it is to be spoken about before they’re spoken to. The healthier path runs the other way: listen first, prove what you allege, and let the courts do their work in the open.

10

A timeline of the Texas CAIR lawsuit

  • Last year: Gov. Greg Abbott designated CAIR a foreign terrorist and transnational criminal organization, KERA reported.
  • February 2026: The state filed the CAIR lawsuit in Collin County, seeking to stop CAIR and its Texas chapters from operating in Texas.
  • Before November 16: No judge ruled on the CAIR lawsuit’s allegations, according to KPRC.
  • November 16, 2026: The state filed a notice of nonsuit without prejudice, according to Collin County court records cited by KERA.
  • When she takes office: Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has said she would remove the terrorist designation, KERA reported.

11

What this means for Muslim Texans and their neighbors

For Muslim Texans, the CAIR lawsuit carried a message beyond one organization. It brought into the state’s courts a claim that a civil rights group serving their community was a terrorist front. Monday’s filing takes that claim out of court, at least for now.

It doesn’t settle the designation, and it doesn’t stop the state from trying again. If you’ve faced discrimination at work, at school or in public because of your faith, write down what happened, when, and who was there. Keep copies of messages and letters. A civil rights lawyer or a legal aid office can tell you what your options are.

Your right to join, give to and gather with lawful organizations is protected. The Supreme Court made that plain in NAACP v. Alabama, when a state tried to pry loose a civil rights group’s membership lists. The end of the CAIR lawsuit doesn’t create that right; it simply removes one court case that pressed against it.

For neighbors of other faiths, and of none, this is a moment to remember how civil liberties work. They aren’t prizes handed to the groups a government happens to like. They’re limits on what any government may do to any group, and they mean the most when the group is unpopular. The protections that shield one disfavored group shield every group that might be disfavored next.

12

What’s still unclear

  • Whether the attorney general’s office will explain why it dropped the CAIR lawsuit.
  • Whether the state, under this or a later attorney general, will refile the case, which a dismissal without prejudice allows.
  • When Governor-elect Hinojosa will act on the terrorist designation, and how.
  • What legal effect the designation has while it stays in place.
  • What CAIR will say in the statement its spokesperson told KPRC the organization was preparing.

13

What Bloom is doing

Bloom reports on civil rights and civil liberties for everyone, because rights only hold when they hold for all of us. We’ve covered civil liberties fights this month from an immigration lawyer’s phone search to the Supreme Court’s turn-away of a challenge to Colorado’s misgendering rules, and we’ll follow what happens to the CAIR designation next.

If fear for your family has become too much to carry, Bloom’s crisis support page is a place to start, and 988 answers by call or text.

Independent reporting like this lasts when readers stand behind it month after month. If you can, become a monthly supporter, or make a one-time gift.

14

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. On November 16, 2026, the state filed a notice of nonsuit without prejudice in Collin County, ending the CAIR lawsuit it brought in February, according to court records cited by KERA News.

It sought to stop the Council on American-Islamic Relations and its Texas chapters from operating in Texas, and asked a judge to declare them foreign terrorist and transnational criminal organizations.

No. The state withdrew the CAIR lawsuit before a judge ruled on its allegations, KPRC 2 reported. CAIR rejected the allegations as politically motivated.

It means the dismissal doesn’t bar the state from filing the case again. KPRC reported that the state has left the door open to bringing it back.

Yes, for now. Gov. Greg Abbott’s separate designation remains, and dropping the CAIR lawsuit doesn’t erase it. Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has said she would remove it when she takes office.

The Secretary of State, under 8 U.S.C. 1189. The secretary must find that the group is a foreign organization that engages in terrorist activity threatening Americans or U.S. national security, and a designated group may seek review in the D.C. Circuit.

In 1958, the Supreme Court reversed a contempt judgment against the NAACP for refusing to give Alabama its membership lists, recognizing freedom of association as part of the liberty the Constitution protects.

Because it asked a state court to shut an advocacy group out of public life. In NAACP v. Alabama, the Supreme Court recognized freedom of association as part of the liberty the Constitution protects.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.