Close-up of a microphone grille, illustrating public testimony and rules against misgendering at legislative hearings

NewsroomColorado LegislatureNews

Supreme Court Turns Away Challenge to Colorado’s Misgendering Rules

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a case over Colorado legislators' rules against misgendering witnesses at public hearings. The ruling it left standing turned on legislative immunity, not free speech.

The Supreme Court on Monday, November 16, 2026, declined to hear a challenge to Colorado legislators’ rules against misgendering and deadnaming witnesses at public hearings. The one-line order ends Gays Against Groomers v. Garcia and leaves in place a Tenth Circuit ruling that the five lawmakers who set and enforced those rules are shielded by legislative immunity.

What the order doesn’t do matters as much. No court in this case decided whether a rule against misgendering in a public hearing fits the First Amendment. For trans people who testify about bills that shape their lives, Colorado’s committee rules against misgendering stand, and the larger free-speech question waits for another case.

01

What the Supreme Court decided on misgendering, and what it didn’t

The justices denied the petition without comment, according to the docket and The Advocate. The case had been set for the justices’ private conference on November 6, was rescheduled, and was considered on November 13 before the denial three days later.

A denial of review isn’t a ruling on the merits. As The Advocate put it, the decision “ends the case without settling whether restrictions on misgendering violate the First Amendment.”

The petitioners asked two questions. The first was whether legislative immunity is a personal defense that can’t be used against official-capacity claims for court orders. The second: “Is enforcing a facially viewpoint-discriminatory public comment policy subject to legislative immunity?”

The Supreme Court answered neither. That leaves the published opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, issued March 10, 2026, as the last word in this misgendering case.

02

What misgendering and deadnaming mean in this case

The plaintiffs’ own complaint supplied the definitions the courts used. Misgendering, it said, “is the act of referring to others, usually through pronouns or form of address, in a way that does not reflect their self-perceived gender identity.”

Deadnaming, the complaint said, “is the act of referring to a transgender person by a name they used prior to ‘transitioning,’ such as their birth name.” Calling a trans man by his birth name, the Tenth Circuit explained, would be both deadnaming and misgendering.

The court acknowledged why the question stings on both sides. “For people who are transgender, these practices can be deeply offensive, disrespectful, and perhaps discriminatory,” it wrote. For some other people, it said, rules against misgendering and deadnaming “offend their sincerely held belief” about gender.

That’s the human stake under a case decided on procedure. A rule against misgendering at a hearing tells a trans witness that the room will use their name. The plaintiffs saw the same rule as a limit on what they could say about a bill.

03

What happened at the Colorado hearings

The case grew out of Tiara’s Law, House Bill 24-1071, which the Colorado General Assembly took up in its 2024 session. Colorado had barred people convicted of a felony from changing their legal name except for “good cause.” As introduced, the bill clarified that good cause exists when a person seeks a name that conforms with their gender identity.

The bill was later amended to let courts require publication of such a name change for someone with a felony conviction. It passed both chambers, was signed by Governor Jared Polis, and is now Section 13-15-101 of the Colorado Revised Statutes, the Tenth Circuit’s opinion recounts.

The facts that follow come from the plaintiffs’ complaint, which the courts accepted as true at this early stage. On January 30, 2024, the House Judiciary Committee heard public testimony on the bill. Representative Lorena Garcia thanked colleagues for “not using derogatory language or misgendering witnesses, or using a witness’s deadname.” The committee chair, Representative Mike Weissman, affirmed her comments.

Rich Guggenheim, who heads the Colorado chapter of Gays Against Groomers, declined to testify under those conditions. Christina Goeke of the Rocky Mountain Women’s Network testified and referred to Tiara Kelley, the transgender woman the bill is named for, with masculine pronouns. After back-and-forth with the chair, the committee stopped her testimony and went into recess.

On March 27, 2024, the Senate Judiciary Committee heard the bill. The chair, Senator Julie Gonzales, warned that witnesses would be removed “if they failed to exhibit decorum, dignity, or respect.” Senator Dafna Michaelson Jenet said witnesses shouldn’t misgender or deadname others, and the chair agreed.

When Goeke again used masculine pronouns and a former name for Kelley, the chair stopped her, and Goeke alleges her comments were later removed from the official audio recording. Guggenheim was also stopped when he described Kelley as a gay man rather than a transgender woman.

04

How the case moved through the courts

The two activists and their organizations sued the five legislators in April 2024. They claimed viewpoint discrimination, vague “decorum” rules and compelled speech, plus a claim over the erasure of Goeke’s partial testimony from the Senate audio record, according to their petition to the Supreme Court.

On November 27, 2024, the federal district court in Colorado dismissed the case with prejudice on legislative immunity and mootness grounds. The plaintiffs appealed.

The Tenth Circuit affirmed in an opinion by Judge Federico, on a panel with Judges Carson and Ebel. It held first that the case wasn’t moot, because the legislators “have confirmed that the challenged conduct will continue.” Then it held that legislative immunity barred the suit, so it never reached the free-speech claims about misgendering.

Legislative immunity is available, the court wrote, “regardless of whether a lawsuit is styled” as an official-capacity or individual-capacity suit. Judge Carson disagreed with parts of the majority’s reasoning but concurred in the judgment, according to the legislators’ brief.

The Tenth Circuit denied rehearing on April 23, 2026. The Institute for Free Speech filed the petition for review on July 21, 2026, and four amicus briefs supported it: Women’s Declaration International USA, the LGB Courage Coalition and two co-signers, the Foundation for Moral Law and the Women’s Liberation Front.

05

What legislative immunity means

The Tenth Circuit’s opinion opens with history. “For millennia, deliberative bodies across the world have set their own rules for debating matters of concern,” it begins, citing Thomas Jefferson’s aim of “order, decency, and regularity.” Today, it said, legislatures are debating “the rights of transgender persons” within those rules.

Legislative immunity protects lawmakers from being sued over their legislative acts. The Tenth Circuit framed the question narrowly. “This appeal concerns not the substance of these debates, but rather their procedural rules,” Judge Federico wrote, and whether a federal court may examine those rules in a suit against legislators in their official capacity. “We hold that it may not.”

The court treated both writing the rules against misgendering and enforcing them at these hearings as legislative acts. It held “only that the narrow enforcement actions alleged here are sufficiently legislative in character” to be covered, and it said it wasn’t announcing that enforcement is always immune.

Its closing paragraph explains the reasoning in plain terms. “The legislative process is inherently political, and therefore not easily amenable to federal judicial inquiry,” the court wrote. “People injured by this process are generally not free to sue legislators for their legislative acts.”

Instead, quoting a 1915 Supreme Court decision, the court said people’s rights are protected “by their power, immediate or remote, over those who make the rule.” In other words, the remedy for a hearing rule you oppose runs through the ballot box and the legislature, not a federal courtroom.

06

What each side argued

The Institute for Free Speech, representing the plaintiffs, argued that legislative immunity is a personal defense that shouldn’t block official-capacity claims for court orders. It also argued that enforcing a rule against misgendering isn’t a legislative act at all. It said the Tenth Circuit’s decision conflicts with other courts, pointing to a 2024 Ninth Circuit decision, Bols v. Newsom.

The legislators answered in their brief in opposition that legislative immunity predates the federal civil rights statute and applies to official-capacity suits. They said the First, Second, Third, Fourth, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth, Tenth and Eleventh Circuits have essentially recognized that rule.

They called Bols an unpublished, nonprecedential memorandum decision in a case about San Diego’s pandemic eviction moratorium. And they argued this case would be a poor vehicle for the Supreme Court in any event.

The two sides didn’t even describe the hearings the same way. The legislators called them hearings held “for the sole purpose of receiving public comment directed to the merits of pending legislation.” The petitioners said they used the term decorum rules only for convenience, and didn’t accept that their testimony breached decorum at all.

After the denial, the plaintiffs’ attorney, Del Kolde, said: “We’re disappointed that the Court declined to take up this case.” The Advocate reports that the Southern Poverty Law Center lists Gays Against Groomers as an anti-LGBTQ+ hate group. The Tenth Circuit described it as a national nonprofit that opposes concepts like misgendering and deadnaming.

07

What it means for trans people who testify

For trans people and their families who speak at the Colorado Capitol, the rules against misgendering and deadnaming remain in place. The Tenth Circuit noted that the Senate Judiciary Committee has continued to remind participants in hearings on bills touching transgender rights that misgendering and deadnaming aren’t permitted.

The underlying committee rules are broader than misgendering. Colorado’s House and Senate rules let committee chairs remove people who are “impeding, disrupting, or hindering a committee meeting,” according to the public-hearing guides the court cited.

That matters for anyone weighing whether to show up. Testifying about your own life before lawmakers takes courage. Under Colorado’s rule, witnesses can still argue against a bill, but they can’t misgender or deadname the people it’s about.

The law that started it all is in force, too. Under Tiara’s Law, a person with a felony conviction who seeks a name matching their gender identity has good cause for the change, though a court may require that the change be published.

08

What it means in Oregon and Washington

Bloom’s readers in the Pacific Northwest live under a different federal appeals court. The Ninth Circuit serves nine western states, Oregon and Washington among them.

That’s why the Bols citation is worth watching. The petitioners said the Ninth Circuit came out the other way on official-capacity suits. Colorado’s lawmakers answered that Bols is unpublished and sets no precedent.

With the denial, the Supreme Court hasn’t resolved that argument. A future case over rules like Colorado’s in another state’s legislature could raise the same questions about misgendering, and the Tenth Circuit’s opinion would be one of the first places lawyers look. Bloom will follow any such case.

09

What’s still unclear

Three questions are left open after Monday’s order.

  • The free-speech merits. No court has ruled on whether a legislature’s rule against misgendering at a public hearing is consistent with the First Amendment.
  • The circuit question. The Supreme Court didn’t say whether official-capacity claims can get around legislative immunity, the argument the petitioners pressed using Bols.
  • The audio record. Goeke’s claim that her remarks were erased from the Senate’s audio was swept up in the immunity ruling, so no court weighed it on its own facts.

What is clear is that the dispute isn’t over in the hearing room. The Tenth Circuit noted that Goeke and Guggenheim both want to attend bill hearings and speak in line with their beliefs, and the legislators have confirmed that the rules will keep being enforced.

10

A timeline of Gays Against Groomers v. Garcia

  1. January 30, 2024: The Colorado House Judiciary Committee hears Tiara’s Law and stops a witness’s testimony.
  2. March 27, 2024: The Senate Judiciary Committee hears the bill and stops two witnesses.
  3. April 4, 2024: The plaintiffs file their complaint in federal court in Colorado.
  4. November 27, 2024: The district court dismisses the case on legislative immunity and mootness grounds.
  5. March 10, 2026: The Tenth Circuit affirms on legislative immunity.
  6. April 23, 2026: The Tenth Circuit denies rehearing.
  7. July 21, 2026: The petition reaches the Supreme Court as No. 26-120.
  8. September 25, 2026: The legislators file their brief in opposition.
  9. November 16, 2026: The Supreme Court denies the petition.

11

What you can do

Public hearings belong to everyone, and a witness who knows the rules is a stronger witness. Here’s what the record points to.

  • Read the rules before you testify. Committees publish guides to public hearings, and Colorado’s let chairs remove people who disrupt a meeting.
  • Ask the chair to enforce the rules. Where a committee bars misgendering and deadnaming, the chair is the one who enforces it.
  • Talk to the people who make the rules. The Tenth Circuit said rights in this setting are protected by the public’s power over those who make the rule, so your legislators are the place to start.
  • Take care of yourself afterward. Testifying about who you are can be draining. Trans Lifeline is at 877-565-8860, and 988 takes calls and texts.

12

What Bloom is doing

Bloom read the Supreme Court docket, the Tenth Circuit’s opinion and both sides’ briefs, so this report rests on the record and not on either side’s account of it. Dignity and free speech aren’t enemies, and a hearing room can hold both.

Bloom has followed the Court’s orders closely this fall. On November 9, we reported that the Court sent a transgender jail case back to the Tenth Circuit, and on Monday we explained how it left a First Amendment win for University of California researchers in place.

If news about misgendering and deadnaming weighs on you, Bloom’s crisis support page is a place to start.

Bloom’s newsroom reads the filings so you don’t have to. If that’s worth something to you, a monthly gift keeps this reporting going, and a one-time gift helps too.

13

Frequently Asked Questions

On November 16, 2026, it denied review without comment. That leaves in place the Tenth Circuit’s ruling that five Colorado legislators are protected by legislative immunity.

No. Neither the Supreme Court nor the Tenth Circuit reached the First Amendment question about rules against misgendering at hearings.

It’s a doctrine that protects lawmakers from being sued over their legislative acts. The Tenth Circuit held that writing and enforcing these hearing rules were legislative acts.

Committee chairs told witnesses not to misgender or deadname anyone, and Colorado’s hearing rules let chairs remove people who disrupt a meeting. The Senate Judiciary Committee still applies the rule in hearings on bills about transgender rights.

House Bill 24-1071 made clear that people with felony convictions may change their legal name to match their gender identity. It became law in 2024.

Not directly. Oregon and Washington are in the Ninth Circuit, where the petitioners said a 2024 decision went the other way, though Colorado’s lawmakers called it nonprecedential.

Yes. The Tenth Circuit noted that both want to keep speaking at bill hearings, and the rules against misgendering and deadnaming still apply when they do.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.