
Newsroom·California Legislature·News
California Was Warned About 3 Educators and Let Them Keep Working
California's teacher credentialing agency had district reports on three educators accused of abusing students, and let all three keep working with children until they were charged.
In the summer of 2019, a Southern California school district sent the state a detailed report: at least seven students said their elementary school counselor had touched them inappropriately. California’s teacher credentialing agency closed the case without discipline. The counselor went on to work at three more schools before police arrested him in 2024, according to an investigation by KQED and ProPublica published Thursday, November 19, 2026.
He wasn’t the only one. The reporters found two more educators whom school districts reported to the Commission on Teacher Credentialing, and whom the state let keep working with children until they were criminally charged. Both were later convicted. Now the commission’s spokesperson says “a deep and comprehensive review of the educator discipline system, prioritizing student safety in the schools, is in order.” Here is what the investigation found, how teacher credentialing discipline works in California, and what parents can do today.
01
What the investigation found
KQED and ProPublica traced three educators through California’s teacher credentialing system. In each case, a school district reported the educator to the state, as the law requires, and police were told. And in each case, according to the investigation, the teacher credentialing system let the educator keep a license and keep working with children until prosecutors filed charges.
The reporters also found that in all three cases, state investigators didn’t interview some of the students who had reported abuse, according to the students, parents and attorneys who spoke to them. Several former agency staffers, including investigators, said the volunteer panel that reviews accusations at times overlooked evidence of wrongdoing.
That view was backed up by two former members of the panel and two people who served on the Commission on Teacher Credentialing itself, the news outlets reported. Another former panel member said they were alarmed to hear fellow members dismiss children as unreliable sources. “I was consistently shocked,” they said.
The teacher credentialing agency’s spokesperson didn’t answer questions about specific cases or about how the agency investigates. She did say the Commission on Teacher Credentialing expects to take up a full review of its discipline system soon.
02
How teacher credentialing discipline works in California
The Commission on Teacher Credentialing decides who may work in California’s public schools. Its Division of Licensure Enforcement investigates allegations of misconduct by credential holders and applicants. A panel called the Committee of Credentials reviews those allegations and may recommend that the commission act against a credential, and the commission votes on whether to adopt the recommendation.
The Committee of Credentials is created by state law. Its seven members are appointed by the commission and represent the public, elementary teachers, secondary teachers, school board members and school administrators. By statute, it’s responsible for starting every investigation into educator misconduct.
Reports reach the teacher credentialing agency from several directions. School districts and charter schools report educators, members of the public file complaints, applicants disclose past problems, and the state Department of Justice tells the commission when a credential holder is arrested or convicted, according to the commission’s page on reporting educator misconduct. School districts must report educators who resign or are fired after allegations of misconduct.
The bar for discipline is low on paper. The committee needs only “probable cause” before it recommends a reprimand, far less than the proof a criminal jury requires, KQED and ProPublica reported. A retired law enforcement officer who served on the committee put it simply: “It’s a low threshold. You know it when you see it.”
Yet the teacher credentialing agency’s own spokesperson, Anita Fitzhugh, told the reporters that short of a conviction for a crime that requires it, “there are no written criteria that set the level of adverse action for educator discipline matters.” The state gives teacher credentialing reviewers no guidelines on when discipline is warranted, she said.
03
The counselor the state cleared
The first case began at McKevett Elementary School in the Santa Paula Unified School District. David Braff had been a guidance counselor there for four years when at least seven students complained that he touched them inappropriately. He resigned in the middle of the district’s investigation, and in the summer of 2019 the district sent its report to the state, according to the investigation.
Braff denied the accusations to the district at the time, saying he gave students only side hugs, high-fives, fist bumps and taps on the knee. One of the students, now 18, told the reporters that no one from the teacher credentialing agency ever called her or her mother to check her account, even though the district’s report included their contact information.
In December 2020, the Committee of Credentials took up Braff’s case during a three-day phone meeting that addressed 198 cases. The committee decided against recommending discipline. By then, Braff had been working as a counselor at an elementary school in Los Angeles for more than a year.
After Braff’s 2024 arrest, Santa Paula’s superintendent blamed the state. The district had reported him to the state and to police, the superintendent wrote to a parent. “We sent all the evidence we had gathered,” the superintendent said. Braff is soon to stand trial on charges of sexually abusing 15 students, 13 of them from Santa Paula. He has pleaded not guilty and has been in jail since November 2024.
04
Two teachers, the same pattern
The second case involved Brashawn Washington, a middle school math teacher in the Romoland school district in Southern California. In May 2020, a mother gave his school screenshots of messages he had sent her 11-year-old son through a video game, including inappropriate content. The district alerted police, opened its own investigation and reported him to the state that summer, district records show.
Washington resigned and was hired at Pasadena High School for the fall of 2020. He had taught there for seven months when the Committee of Credentials recommended a 21-day suspension in March 2021, and commissioners didn’t approve it until after school let out. State law didn’t require Washington to tell Pasadena about the recommended suspension.
In July 2021, just as that suspension was set to begin, Washington was arrested, and the state suspended his credentials indefinitely. At his 2024 trial, a Pasadena High student testified about messages Washington had sent him. Washington was sentenced to eight years and eight months in prison for multiple sex offenses.
The third case reaches back almost 20 years. Matthew Shelton was acquitted in 2008 of abusing students at a Napa charter school, and the teacher credentialing agency issued him a private admonishment, KQED reported. Such punishments are hidden from the public and must be expunged within three years.
Shelton was hired in Benicia months after his acquittal. In 2022, students there began accusing him, and the district and a student’s parents reported him to the state in 2023. He resigned and quickly found another teaching job. In October 2026, a jury convicted him of sexually abusing four students at Robert Semple Elementary School in Benicia, on 11 of 12 felony counts, and he is due to be sentenced in December.
05
Children the state never called
In each case, the investigation found, state investigators didn’t interview some of the students who had reported abuse. In Romoland, the boy’s mother told the reporters that neither she nor her son was ever interviewed. In Napa, two of the former students who had accused Shelton as third graders said state investigators never spoke with them.
In the Santa Paula case, the investigation found, the teacher credentialing agency assigned Braff’s file to a staffer whose job description didn’t include interviewing victims. A former agency investigator who reviewed the district’s report for the news outlets said cases involving inappropriate touching should always go to investigators trained to interview victims.
The cost of that silence falls on the children who spoke up. One of the students who accused Shelton in Napa said she and her classmates were treated as liars after they reported him. “It could’ve been stopped with us, but it wasn’t,” she told the reporters. “They didn’t believe us.”
A child who tells an adult about abuse takes an enormous risk. When the adults with the power to act never pick up the phone, that child learns that telling changes nothing. That’s the harm this investigation documents, and it reaches far past these three cases.
06
What the teacher credentialing agency says
Fitzhugh said the state automatically revokes credentials when educators are convicted of sexual criminal offenses. Short of that, she said, it’s the commission’s role to balance “protecting students as well as the legal rights of educators who have been accused but not convicted.”
She also said California’s system for disciplining educators dates to the 1970s. “We expect the Commission to take this up in the near future,” she said of a full review. She didn’t answer questions about why students in these cases weren’t interviewed or how investigators decide whom to call.
The commission’s words matter, and the Commission on Teacher Credentialing will be judged by what its review changes. A review that starts with the students who weren’t heard would be a real beginning.
07
Why a closed case stays invisible
When the teacher credentialing agency disciplines an educator, a red flag appears next to that person’s name in the state’s public online database. But when an educator is fired or pushed to resign and the state takes no action, nothing appears, KQED and ProPublica reported. A confidential warning letter, like the one Shelton received, doesn’t create a red flag either.
That gap left each new employer in the dark. Shelton’s last school learned of the earlier accusations from a parent, not the teacher credentialing agency. The red flag also doesn’t explain the reason for a sanction, and the state’s disciplinary process typically takes about a year, during which a reported educator can be hired elsewhere, ProPublica reported in July.
The problem is larger than three people. An earlier KQED and ProPublica investigation found that California’s teacher credentialing agency hadn’t revoked the credentials of at least 67 educators whom school districts had found sexually harassed students or committed other sexual misconduct. At least 14 of them were rehired by other schools.
08
Lawmakers tried, and stalled
California lawmakers in both parties have tried to close that gap. In June 2026, Assemblymember Al Muratsuchi, a Democrat, introduced a misconduct database that would have let schools see whether a teaching applicant had been reported to the state after being fired or resigning over misconduct claims. A similar effort by Republican lawmakers hit roadblocks earlier in the year.
Teachers unions and the Commission on Teacher Credentialing itself opposed the misconduct database. A California Teachers Association lobbyist warned it would bring “employment consequences for innocent teachers based on allegations later determined to be unfounded.” The commission said the bill, as written, would expose the agency to significant liability. Muratsuchi scrapped the database idea within weeks.
“When the safety of a child does not meet a legislative priority, that’s a head-scratcher for me,” said Republican Assemblymember Tom Lackey, who co-authored the first attempt. Muratsuchi, whose term ends in December, was blunt. “I tried,” he said. “I hope future Legislatures pick up the ball.”
Some protections did pass. A 2024 law requires teaching candidates to list their full job history in education and requires school districts to ask each past employer whether the candidate was reported for credible or substantiated complaints of egregious misconduct. A 2025 law requires a misconduct database for school support staff, such as bus drivers, custodians and teaching assistants, but it doesn’t cover credentialed teachers.
09
A timeline of the three cases
These dates come from the KQED and ProPublica investigation and KQED’s reporting on the Shelton verdict:
- 2008: A jury acquits Shelton in Napa, and the teacher credentialing agency issues him a private admonishment.
- Summer 2019: Santa Paula Unified reports Braff to the state after at least seven students complain.
- May 2020: A Romoland mother gives the school her son’s messages from Washington.
- Fall 2020: Washington starts teaching at Pasadena High School.
- December 2020: The Committee of Credentials declines to recommend discipline for Braff.
- March 2021: The committee recommends a 21-day suspension for Washington.
- July 2021: Washington is arrested, and the state suspends his credentials indefinitely.
- 2023: Benicia’s district and a student’s parents report Shelton to the state.
- February 2024: Prosecutors charge Shelton, and his credentials are automatically suspended.
- 2024: Police arrest Braff, who has been jailed since November of that year.
- October 2026: A jury convicts Shelton on 11 of 12 felony counts.
- November 19, 2026: KQED and ProPublica publish their investigation.
10
What parents and students can do
Parents don’t have to wait for the teacher credentialing agency to act. These steps use tools that already exist:
- Look up any educator on the Commission on Teacher Credentialing’s website, which offers a public “Search for an Educator” tool. A red flag means the state disciplined that person. No red flag doesn’t mean no reports.
- Ask your school district how it vets new hires, including whether it asks every past employer about misconduct reports, as the 2024 law requires.
- If you have a concern about an educator, report it to the school, and to the Commission on Teacher Credentialing through its public complaint process.
- If you believe a child is being hurt, call local police or child protective services right away. A report to the teacher credentialing agency doesn’t replace a police report.
- Write down what you saw and heard, with dates, and keep copies of any messages.
Children need to hear one thing from the adults around them: if you tell me, I’ll believe you, and I’ll act. The KQED and ProPublica investigation shows what happens when no one acts.
Wherever you live. In Oregon, call the Oregon Child Abuse Hotline: 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233). Anywhere in the country, RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline is 800-656-4673.
11
What happens next
Braff is soon to stand trial, where the charges against him will be tested in court. Shelton is due to be sentenced in December. The Commission on Teacher Credentialing says it expects to take up a review of its educator discipline system in the near future, and Bloom will report what it changes.
In Sacramento, the misconduct database for teachers has stalled, and its Democratic author leaves office in December. Whether the next Legislature picks it up, and whether the teacher credentialing agency adds written criteria and interviews of every child who reports, will decide whether this investigation changes anything for the next student who speaks up.
12
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reports on institutions that hold children in their care and then fail them, from the Glen Mills Schools lawsuit to the Oakland diocese verdict and the federal prisons that kept failing women. I believe a child who finds the courage to tell deserves an adult who calls back, and a state that treats that call as sacred.
If this story stirs up something you carry, you’re not alone, and what happened wasn’t your fault. Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight, and Bloom’s support groups are there when you want company. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom following stories like this one until the system changes, and a one-time gift helps too.
13
Frequently Asked Questions
It found that California’s teacher credentialing agency received school district reports about three educators accused of abusing students and let all three keep working with children until they were criminally charged. In each case, state investigators didn’t interview some of the students.
It’s a seven-member panel, created by state law and appointed by the Commission on Teacher Credentialing, that reviews allegations of educator misconduct and recommends whether to discipline a credential. The commission votes on its recommendations.
Yes. The teacher credentialing agency’s spokesperson said the state automatically revokes credentials after a conviction for sexual criminal offenses. Short of a conviction, she said, there are no written criteria for the level of discipline.
Use the “Search for an Educator” tool on the Commission on Teacher Credentialing’s website. A red flag means the state disciplined the person, but a firing or resignation without state discipline doesn’t appear.
A 2026 bill by Assemblymember Al Muratsuchi drew opposition from teachers unions and the commission, which raised privacy, fairness and legal concerns. He dropped the database idea within weeks. A 2025 law created one for school support staff only.
Call local police or child protective services right away, and tell the school. In Oregon, call 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233). RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline is 800-656-4673.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
California Legislature · 20 November 2026Appeals Court Revives Challenge to Gun License Pulled Over Club Ties
California Legislature · 20 November 2026Chino Valley Board Bars Trans Girls From Girlsโ Sports and Restrooms
California Legislature · 18 November 2026Jury Awards $14.3 Million Against Oakland Diocese in Clergy Abuse Case