
Newsroom·California Legislature·News
Jury Awards $14.3 Million Against Oakland Diocese in Clergy Abuse Case
A jury ordered the Oakland Diocese to pay $14.3 million to a woman abused by a priest when she was 11. It's the second bellwether verdict this year, and about 350 more claims are waiting.
A woman who was abused by a Catholic priest when she was 11 years old won a $14.3 million verdict against the Oakland Diocese on Tuesday, November 17, 2026. An Alameda County jury reached it after a day of deliberations, the second eight-figure judgment against the Oakland Diocese this year, Bay Area News Group reported.
The verdict reaches far past one courtroom. It is the second of six bellwether trials that test what roughly 350 abuse claims against the Oakland Diocese are worth, and it lands while the church tries to settle those claims in bankruptcy. Here is what the jury decided, what it means for the survivors still waiting, and what the law allows for survivors in Oregon and Washington.
01
What the jury decided about the Oakland Diocese
The jury found for the woman, who sued as Jane Doe, according to EWTN News. She was 11 in 1976 when Stephen Kiesle, then a priest of the Oakland Diocese, abused her after a church group trip to a baseball game, according to her attorney, Parker Estenson. Bloom does not name survivors, and we won’t name her here.
Kiesle has since been removed from the priesthood. He has multiple sexual abuse convictions, and he did not appear at the trial because he is serving a prison sentence in a 2022 vehicular manslaughter case. He has been named in dozens of other lawsuits pending against the Oakland Diocese.
Trips to sporting events were routine for Kiesle, and victims have described them as a way for the priest to get time with young people away from their parents, according to earlier court testimony reported by Bay Area News Group. The woman also testified at the first bellwether trial in April. She had played on the same basketball team as the plaintiff in that case.
The first bellwether verdict came in April, when a jury awarded $16 million to a former Union City altar boy. He said the same priest abused him twice in 1975 during church sleepovers with other boys. Two juries, hearing two survivors seven months apart, have now reached the same conclusion about the harm done in the Oakland Diocese.
Jurors did not agree easily on the amount. One juror, Roberta Ross, said she wanted to award $18 million and saw the final figure as a compromise among the 12. One juror wanted between $20 million and $22 million, she said, and another wanted close to $8 million. Ross called the case a “tragedy.” “It was such a betrayal,” she said.
02
The priest at the center of the Oakland Diocese cases
Stephen Kiesle’s record runs through decades of court files. In 1978 he pleaded no contest to lewd conduct involving two boys and received probation, EWTN News reported. In the early 2000s he was sentenced to six years in prison after pleading no contest to abusing a girl near Sacramento.
His most recent conviction has nothing to do with the church. In 2022 he was charged with vehicular manslaughter and drunk driving after a crash that killed a man in Rossmoor, California. He pleaded no contest in 2023 and was sentenced to more than six years in state prison, where he remains.
None of those criminal cases ended the civil claims, and a prison sentence pays no survivor’s medical bills. The civil lawsuits are aimed at the Oakland Diocese itself, the church in which Kiesle served as a priest. They ask a question criminal courts don’t: what did the church owe the young people in its care?
03
What the survivor said after the verdict
When the verdict was read, the woman wiped her eyes and mouthed “thank you” to the jurors as they left the courtroom. She later said she felt relieved, and still “numb.” She called the result “a very good verdict,” but said that for someone who has lived through abuse, “it’s kind of never over.”
“It’s not finished for me,” she said. “I still have a lot of work to do, and a lot of healing to do. I still feel like a victim.”
She said lawsuits like hers are “the only platform that we have now,” and that she has tried to “speak for people who can’t speak.” Her message for the Oakland Diocese was direct: “They need to step up and do the right thing.” She added, “They’ve forgotten what God is all about.”
Those words carry a weight a dollar figure can’t. A verdict can name a harm and assign a cost, but it can’t give back a childhood. What it can do is tell a survivor, in public and on the record, that she was believed.
04
Why the Oakland Diocese verdicts matter for 350 survivors
The two trials so far are bellwether cases: the first two of six chosen to go to trial so both sides can see how juries value claims. About 350 people have sued the Oakland Diocese over abuse dating back decades. Those lawsuits became possible when California temporarily lifted the statute of limitations on such claims.
The flood of cases led the Oakland Diocese to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2023, which put the lawsuits on hold. In October 2026, a federal bankruptcy judge rejected the church’s plan to exit bankruptcy, and Tuesday’s verdict was the first civil trial judgment since that ruling. A new mediator has been brought in, said the woman’s attorney, Rick Simons.
The money on the table is far apart. One recent Oakland Diocese proposal offered $172.3 million to local survivors, including $30 million from a related corporation that oversees the diocese’s schools. Survivors have asked for much more: one court filing earlier this year sought $314.1 million from the diocese and its schools corporation.
The two verdicts together bring to $30.3 million what the Oakland Diocese has been ordered to pay in recent months. EWTN News noted that awards this size to a single survivor are rare in diocesan abuse cases, because most dioceses settle claims as a group in bankruptcy.
Individual clergy abuse trials are sometimes allowed to go forward and be settled separately, EWTN News reported, as happened in both Oakland Diocese cases this year. That is why these two verdicts carry weight beyond the two survivors who won them.
Time is part of the harm. Several people who sued the Oakland Diocese have died while their cases sat on hold in bankruptcy, Bay Area News Group reported. Each month of delay is a month some survivors don’t get back.
05
What the diocese and the lawyers say
The Oakland Diocese acknowledged the verdict in a statement from its spokesperson, Helen Osman, saying the church “is committed to providing fair and just compensation to all victims/survivors” and continues to work toward that in the bankruptcy process. The diocese did not respond to EWTN News when it asked for comment on November 18.
Simons urged Oakland Bishop Michael Barber to raise his settlement offer. “Wake up, Bishop Barber, these people are suffering, do your job,” he said. He added that the church “needs to quit counting its assets and start looking after the kids who were harmed by this diocese’s priests.”
The national firm Jeff Anderson & Associates, which announced the verdict, called it “a powerful reminder that when survivors stand up, speak out, and demand accountability, their voices can no longer be ignored.”
For a church, a verdict is also a pastoral moment. The Oakland Diocese can treat the bellwether as a price signal, or it can hear what a survivor said outside the courthouse and act on it.
06
What happens next
Four of the six bellwether trials remain. Each verdict gives survivors and the Oakland Diocese a clearer sense of what juries think these claims are worth, and each one adds pressure on the bankruptcy talks, where a new mediator is now working with both sides.
So far, the church’s proposals have drawn near-unanimous opposition from the hundreds of people who say priests abused them, Bay Area News Group reported. Simons’s message after the verdict was aimed squarely at the bishop. For survivors, the question is whether the Oakland Diocese raises its offer before the next jury speaks.
07
What a verdict can and can’t give a survivor
A verdict is a public word. For decades, many survivors of clergy abuse were told, in one way or another, to keep quiet. Twelve strangers in an Alameda County courtroom listened to this woman and said, on the record, that what happened to her mattered, and that the Oakland Diocese must answer for it.
But listen to what she said afterward. It isn’t finished for her. Money can pay for therapy and time and a measure of security, and it can make an institution count the cost of its silence. It can’t give back the years that followed for an 11-year-old who trusted her priest.
That is why survivors and their advocates speak of accountability, not closure. Accountability is something the Oakland Diocese can still give: a fair settlement for the hundreds of people still waiting, before more of them die without seeing their day in court.
08
A timeline of the Oakland Diocese abuse cases
Here is how the record built up, according to Bay Area News Group and EWTN News:
- 1975: The plaintiff in the April trial, then an altar boy in Union City, is abused by Kiesle.
- 1976: The woman in this week’s trial is abused at age 11.
- 1978: Kiesle pleads no contest to lewd conduct involving two boys and receives probation.
- Early 2000s: Kiesle is sentenced to six years in prison after pleading no contest to abusing a girl near Sacramento.
- 2022 and 2023: Kiesle is charged in a fatal crash in Rossmoor, pleads no contest, and is sentenced to more than six years in state prison.
- 2023: The Oakland Diocese files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy as hundreds of abuse lawsuits mount.
- April 2026: A jury awards $16 million in the first bellwether trial.
- October 2026: A federal bankruptcy judge rejects the diocese’s plan to exit bankruptcy.
- November 17, 2026: A jury awards $14.3 million in the second bellwether trial.
09
What the law allows in Oregon and Washington
The Oakland Diocese lawsuits exist because California opened a window. Survivors in the Pacific Northwest live under different rules, and both Oregon and Washington have rewritten theirs in the last two years. Deadlines depend on when the abuse happened, so talk with a lawyer before you assume a door is closed.
Oregon. Under ORS 12.117, a lawsuit based on child sexual abuse “may be commenced at any time.” A 2025 law made that rule apply to claims arising on or after June 26, 2025. For abuse before that date, a claim against those who allowed or encouraged it must generally be filed before the survivor turns 40, or within five years of discovering the link between the abuse and the injury, whichever is longer.
Oregon’s law for adults is broader still. Under ORS 12.118, a lawsuit based on sexual assault that happened when the survivor was 18 or older “may be commenced at any time,” and a 2019 note says that rule applies to all actions filed on or after June 20, 2019, even ones an older deadline would have barred. A claim against an institution that allowed or encouraged an adult’s assault before June 26, 2025, generally must be filed within five years of discovering the link between the assault and the injury.
Washington. Under RCW 4.16.340, there is no time limit for a lawsuit over childhood sexual abuse that occurs on or after June 6, 2024. For abuse before that date, a claim must generally be filed within three years of the act or of discovering that it caused the injury, and the clock doesn’t start until the survivor turns 18.
If abuse is happening now. In Oregon, call the Oregon Child Abuse Hotline: 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233). Anywhere in the country, RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline is 800-656-4673.
If you’re a survivor of clergy abuse. You don’t need a lawsuit to deserve care, and you can move at your own pace. When you’re ready, these steps can help:
- Write down what you remember: dates, places and the names of people who knew.
- Keep any records you have, such as letters, school or parish papers, and medical records.
- Ask a lawyer who handles abuse cases how your state’s statute of limitations applies to you.
- If the church or institution is in bankruptcy, as the Oakland Diocese is, ask the lawyer about any deadline to file a claim in that case.
- Lean on people who are safe for you, and on professional care, before, during and after any case.
10
What Bloom is doing
Bloom follows survivors’ cases from the first filing to the last verdict, from the lawsuits against a Cedars-Sinai doctor to the Arkansas ruling that reopened old abuse claims. As a pastor, I believe a church’s first duty is to the people its priests harmed, not to its balance sheet.
If this story touched something in you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight, and Bloom’s support groups are there when you want company. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom on these cases until the last one closes, and a one-time gift helps too.
11
Frequently Asked Questions
An Alameda County jury awarded $14.3 million on November 17, 2026, to a woman abused by priest Stephen Kiesle in 1976, when she was 11. It’s the second eight-figure verdict against the Oakland Diocese this year.
A bellwether trial is an early test case chosen from a larger group of lawsuits. Its result helps both sides estimate what the other claims are worth. This verdict was the second of six bellwether trials against the Oakland Diocese.
The Oakland Diocese filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2023 after hundreds of people sued over decades-old abuse; about 350 have sued so far. In October 2026, a federal bankruptcy judge rejected the church’s plan to exit bankruptcy.
One recent proposal offered $172.3 million, including $30 million from the corporation that oversees the diocese’s schools. One survivors’ filing earlier this year sought $314.1 million.
For abuse on or after June 26, 2025, Oregon law says a lawsuit may be filed at any time. Older claims can face deadlines, such as before age 40 or within five years of discovery, so ask a lawyer.
Stephen Kiesle is a former priest of the Oakland Diocese, now removed from the priesthood, with multiple sexual abuse convictions. He is in state prison for a 2022 vehicular manslaughter case and is named in dozens of pending lawsuits.
Call RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline at 800-656-4673. To report abuse happening now in Oregon, call 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233). Bloom’s crisis support page lists more people to call.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
California Legislature · 20 November 2026Chino Valley Board Bars Trans Girls From Girlsโ Sports and Restrooms
California Legislature · 19 November 2026California Was Warned About 3 Educators and Let Them Keep Working
California Legislature · 16 November 2026Supreme Court Leaves First Amendment Win for UC Researchers in Place