Empty blue bleachers beside a wood gym floor, for a report on Colorado's Proposition 134 guidance for school sports

NewsroomColorado LegislatureNews

Colorado: Schools Don’t Have to Verify Athletes’ Sex Under Prop 134

Colorado's education department says schools don't have to verify a student's sex to follow Proposition 134, and shouldn't inspect bodies, request photos or order DNA tests. The law takes effect January 1.

Colorado schools won’t have to inspect, photograph or DNA-test students to decide who can play on girls’ teams. New guidance from the Colorado Department of Education says schools don’t need to verify whether a student is male or female to comply with Proposition 134, the voter-passed measure that bars transgender girls from girls’ school teams, Chalkbeat Colorado reported.

The six-page guidance went to schools and districts on Wednesday, November 18, about six weeks before Proposition 134 takes effect on January 1. It still requires every school to designate its teams as male, female or coed. But it tells schools they may trust students and families to follow those policies, instead of checking bodies, papers or genes.

Following this story: Colorado’s Proposition 134. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.

01

What the Proposition 134 guidance says

The guidance keeps the core of Proposition 134 in place. Schools and districts must pass policies that designate sports teams as male, female or coed, according to Chalkbeat. Girls’ teams shouldn’t be open to males, and boys’ teams shouldn’t be open to females unless there is no girls’ team in that sport.

What changes is how schools carry it out. The guidance says schools don’t have to change their existing practices for sports physicals, records or registration. “A school or district may reasonably trust that students, parents, and guardians will comply with school or district policies,” the guidance states, as quoted by Chalkbeat.

That sentence matters more than any other in the document. It means a school can run its Proposition 134 policy on trust, the way it runs most rules, instead of building a system to inspect children.

The guidance also acknowledges that questions about Proposition 134 remain, and that they may be answered through lawsuits or changes in the law, Chalkbeat reported.

Chalkbeat noted that the guidance shows state officials aren’t reading the measure the same way its supporters do, and that it could anger backers who expected schools to verify sex.

02

Six checks schools shouldn’t use

The Colorado Department of Education directs schools and districts not to use six kinds of checks to decide a student’s sex, according to Chalkbeat. Under the guidance, schools shouldn’t:

  1. inspect a student’s body;
  2. request photographs of a student’s body;
  3. ask for DNA or genetic testing;
  4. require physical exams to determine sex;
  5. require affidavits related to a student’s reproductive system;
  6. question students about intimate medical information.

Each item on that list was a real possibility. During the campaign, backers of Proposition 134 said cheek swab DNA tests or doctor’s notes would be acceptable ways to verify sex, Chalkbeat reported. After the election, Erin Lee, who leads Protect Kids Colorado, told KUNC that schools could use a doctor’s note, a cheek swab or an original birth certificate.

03

Why the guidance says sex checks could break the law

The guidance warns that physical exams, genetic testing, parent affirmations or medical documentation about a student’s sex could violate students’ constitutional rights and their right to be free from discrimination and harassment, according to Chalkbeat.

Colorado law already protects transgender students. The Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act bars discrimination based on sex, sexual orientation, gender identity and gender expression, and public schools and colleges may not exclude students from extracurricular activities that align with their gender identity, according to the state’s Blue Book analysis of Proposition 134.

The Blue Book, the legislature’s analysis for voters, said it was unclear how Proposition 134 would affect that state law. The new guidance is the Colorado Department of Education’s answer for schools.

Nadine Bridges, executive director of One Colorado, which opposed the measure, said the guidance makes clear that district policies should protect student privacy, avoid invasive checks and comply with the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act, Chalkbeat reported.

04

What Proposition 134 requires

Proposition 134 changes Colorado statutes. It requires every school-based team or sport to be designated for biological males, for biological females, or as coeducational, according to the Blue Book. Students compete on teams that match their biological sex or on a coed team, and girls may join a boys’ team when no equivalent girls’ team exists.

The measure defines sex by reproductive biology, but it “does not impose a specific method for determining or demonstrating biological sex,” the Blue Book says. Each school or district must decide its own verification procedures. That gap is exactly what the new guidance fills.

Proposition 134 reaches far. It covers public, charter, private and religious schools from elementary through high school, plus Colorado colleges and universities, according to the Blue Book. It includes intramural sports and school-sponsored after-school programs, but not youth leagues that operate separately from schools.

It also bars any government entity, licensing or accrediting body, or athletic association from investigating or penalizing a school for keeping a team only for biological females.

05

How Proposition 134 is enforced

The governing body of every school or district must adopt a policy to carry out Proposition 134. For public K-12 schools, if a district doesn’t follow the measure, the state Commissioner of Education must first notify the district, and then take corrective action if the district doesn’t make a good-faith attempt to comply, the Blue Book explains.

The measure sets no enforcement mechanism for private K-12 schools, colleges and universities, or athletic associations, according to the Blue Book. The state’s own role, in other words, runs through the Colorado Department of Education, the same agency that just told districts they don’t need to check students’ sex.

06

Why verification was the fight

Supporters of Proposition 134 argued it was needed to protect girls’ safety and opportunity in school sports, Chalkbeat reported. Lee told KUNC that leaving verification to schools respected local control.

Opponents warned that the measure would subject both cisgender and transgender students to invasive gender checks. Scott Skinner-Thompson, a law professor at the University of Colorado Boulder, told KUNC that an invasive process could be imposed “not just on trans kids, but on anybody who is gender divergent and doesn’t comply with the norm.”

That’s the quiet truth of sex verification in school sports: it never stays with one group of students. The share of transgender student athletes in school sports is exceedingly small, Chalkbeat noted. Any system built to find them would have to question every girl on the team.

07

How federal law and sports bodies fit in

Colorado’s guidance doesn’t settle every conflict. Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 bars sex discrimination in federally funded education programs, and courts and presidential administrations have read it in different ways, sometimes including gender identity and sometimes not, according to the Blue Book.

On February 5, 2025, President Trump signed Executive Order 14201, “Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports,” which directs federal agencies to read Title IX as barring biological males from girls’ and women’s teams, the Blue Book says. It adds that states that don’t follow federal policy may face cuts in federal funding, and that in June 2026 the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that Title IX permits states to keep separate sports by biological sex.

Sports bodies have moved too. The Colorado High School Activities Association, which oversees high school sports, recognizes a right for transgender athletes to take part, but in December 2025 it settled a federal lawsuit with eight schools and districts in a way that lets schools keep separate teams by biological sex without penalty from the association, the Blue Book explains. The part of that lawsuit challenging the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act is still going.

At the college level, NCAA rules limit women’s competition to athletes assigned female at birth, though those rules don’t cover intramural sports, according to the Blue Book.

08

The arguments voters heard

The Blue Book gave voters the strongest case on each side, and both sides are worth hearing now that schools must write their policies.

Supporters argued that girls should compete against girls, that a single statewide rule would make competition fair everywhere in Colorado, and that physical differences and shared locker rooms raise safety and privacy concerns. In the Blue Book’s words, the measure “creates a reasonable policy grounded in biological sex that promotes the safety of all participants.”

Opponents argued that the measure “turns athletic eligibility into a body inspection and manufactures new grounds for discrimination.” They warned that, without a clear method, districts would write uneven policies, that some athletes could face invasive or expensive testing while others brought a doctor’s note, and that athletes could be singled out for more testing because of their strength, appearance or success.

They also argued that school sports are where children build confidence and belonging, and that the rules reach even young children who just want to play with their friends. The new guidance answers the first of those warnings directly: no inspections, no tests, no affidavits about a child’s body.

09

What students said before the vote

Before the election, KUNC asked students at Front Range Community College about Proposition 134. One student who favored the idea said his only concern was a desire for non-invasive tests or procedures when identifying biological sex, KUNC reported.

Another student, Chris Ortiz, said he saw concerns on both sides. “That’s really difficult, right? Because you don’t want to take away people’s identities,” he told KUNC.

Even among people who backed the measure, then, the fear of invasive checks was real. The state’s guidance takes that fear off the table for Colorado schools, at least for now.

10

What the Blue Book said about cost

The Blue Book expected Proposition 134 to add workload and legal costs at the Colorado Department of Education only if a district is intentionally out of compliance and the commissioner has to act, according to the Blue Book. Legal services for the department come from the state Department of Law.

Colleges and universities will have to adopt or update policies for their sports programs, with costs expected to come from tuition, fees or athletic revenue. For schools and districts, the Blue Book expected the cost of updating and carrying out their policies to be minimal.

11

What this means for families

For transgender girls, the guidance doesn’t change the core of the law: starting January 1, the measure bars them from girls’ teams in Colorado schools. What it changes is how every student on every team is treated, because no one should be asked to prove their body to play.

If you have a child in a Colorado school, the guidance gives you something concrete to point to. Your school still has to adopt a Proposition 134 team policy, but the state’s education department says it doesn’t need to verify your child’s sex, and it lists six checks schools shouldn’t use.

Bloom has seen how other states are handling the same question. In Washington, where Initiative 638 now governs girls’ sports, Bloom reported that girls need a signed sex attestation by December 3 to compete. Colorado’s guidance takes a different path, telling schools not to require affidavits about a student’s reproductive system.

12

What you can do

  1. Ask your school district for its written Proposition 134 policy, and ask when the school board will vote on it.
  2. If a coach or school asks for photos, a DNA test, a physical exam, an affidavit about your child’s body, or intimate medical answers, ask them to put the request in writing and point them to the Colorado Department of Education guidance.
  3. Keep copies of any form or message about your child’s eligibility.
  4. Tell your school board how a policy built on trust protects every girl’s privacy, not only transgender students’.
  5. Follow the 2027 legislative session, which can change Proposition 134 by a simple majority vote.

13

A timeline of Proposition 134

These dates come from KUNC, Chalkbeat and the Blue Book:

  • Before the election: The Blue Book tells voters that Proposition 134 leaves verification to schools and districts.
  • November 5, 2026: The Associated Press calls Proposition 134 as passed, KUNC reported.
  • November 18, 2026: The Colorado Department of Education sends its six-page guidance to schools and districts.
  • January 1, 2027: Proposition 134 takes effect.
  • January 2027: Colorado’s 2027 legislative session begins.

14

What happens next

Proposition 134 passed 52% to 48%, Chalkbeat reported. Because it changes statutes and not the Colorado Constitution, lawmakers can tweak or overturn it by a simple majority vote, KUNC reported.

Gov.-elect Phil Weiser and other lawmakers have described Proposition 134 as problematic and suggested the legislature will make changes during the 2027 session, according to Chalkbeat. Democrats hold supermajorities in both chambers. After the election, Weiser said lawmakers would need to “take a long, hard look at what makes sense,” KUNC reported.

Supporters have started a petition pushing back against any legislative changes, Chalkbeat reported. Lee told KUNC: “If Phil Weiser intends to use the legislature to undermine the same democratic process that elected him, that’s his decision.” Chalkbeat said Lee couldn’t be reached for comment on the guidance Wednesday.

Bloom explained what Proposition 134 does when it passed, in our guide to Propositions 134 and 135, and we’ve followed the Jeffco lawsuit over the same question. We’ll keep reporting each step here.

15

What Bloom is doing

Bloom stands with every Colorado student who just wants to play. I believe no child should have to prove their body to a stranger to join a team, and a policy built on trust protects every girl’s dignity.

If this news is heavy for you or your family, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, including Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, and 988 by call or text. Bloom’s support groups are a place to be known.

A monthly gift keeps Bloom following Proposition 134 from guidance to legislature, and a one-time gift helps too.

16

Frequently Asked Questions

The Colorado Department of Education says schools don’t need to verify whether a student is male or female to comply with Proposition 134. Schools still must designate teams as male, female or coed.

Schools shouldn’t inspect a student’s body, request photographs of it, ask for DNA or genetic testing, require physical exams, require affidavits about a student’s reproductive system, or ask intimate medical questions.

Proposition 134 takes effect January 1, 2027. The guidance went to schools and districts on November 18, 2026.

Yes. It covers public, charter, private and religious K-12 schools and Colorado colleges. The Blue Book says the measure sets no enforcement mechanism for private schools, colleges or athletic associations.

Yes. Proposition 134 changed state statutes, not the Colorado Constitution, so lawmakers can amend or repeal it by a simple majority vote.

It may. The Blue Book notes that Executive Order 14201 directs federal agencies to read Title IX as barring biological males from girls’ teams, and that the Supreme Court ruled in June 2026 that Title IX permits separate sports by biological sex.

Ask for the request in writing, keep a copy, and point the school to the Colorado Department of Education’s guidance, which says schools shouldn’t use such checks.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.