Five motorcycles parked along a mountain road under storm clouds, illustrating the concealed carry license ruling

NewsroomCalifornia LegislatureNews

Appeals Court Revives Challenge to Gun License Pulled Over Club Ties

San Diego's sheriff revoked Kenneth Shilling's concealed carry license because he belongs to a motorcycle club.

Kenneth Shilling had a clean record and a concealed carry license from the San Diego County Sheriff. In December 2023, the sheriff took the license away because he belongs to the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, which she called a “criminal street gang.” On Friday, a federal appeals court said he can fight that decision in court.

A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit unanimously revived Shilling’s lawsuit, holding that his freedom of association claim should never have been dismissed. The court also ruled that California sheriffs are not arms of the state, so they cannot use the Eleventh Amendment to keep civil rights suits like his out of federal court. The case goes back to the trial judge in San Diego.

01

What the Ninth Circuit decided about the concealed carry license

The opinion in Shilling v. County of San Diego, No. 25-291, was filed on November 20, 2026. Judge Patrick J. Bumatay wrote it, joined by Judges Kenneth K. Lee and Jennifer Sung. The panel ruled for Shilling on all four questions it decided and sent the case back “for further proceedings.”

The court answered four questions. The San Diego County Sheriff is not an “arm of the state” and has no Eleventh Amendment immunity. San Diego County can be held liable, because revoking a concealed carry license for “good moral character” was a county policy. Shilling’s Second Amendment claim is not moot. And his First Amendment freedom of association claim was properly pleaded.

None of this means Shilling has won his concealed carry license back. The ruling came at the earliest stage of the case, when a court asks only whether the claims, taken as true, state a violation of law. But it means the county now has to defend the revocation on the merits, under a demanding First Amendment standard.

The opinion drew quick notice from legal commentators. The Volokh Conspiracy, a legal blog hosted by Reason, published long excerpts on Friday under the headline “Gun Rights and Guilt by Association”, focusing on the court’s free-association analysis.

02

How a motorcycle club cost one man his concealed carry license

Shilling lives in San Diego and belongs to the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club. According to Shilling, the club was founded in 1946 by World War II veterans and focuses on charitable work and the “core values of family, work, and community.” The opinion, which at this stage accepts his account, says plainly: “Shilling’s record is clean; he has no criminal history.”

In June 2022, while California still used a “good moral character” standard for every concealed carry license, Shilling applied for and received one from then-Sheriff Anthony Ray. Less than a year and a half later, in December 2023, Sheriff Kelly Martinez used the same standard to revoke it.

The department’s definition of good moral character excluded anyone with “a pattern of or propensity for criminal conduct,” including “a close nexus to a criminal gang.” The revocation letter said Shilling’s concealed carry license was revoked because of his association with the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, which the sheriff described as a “criminal street gang.” Shilling was not given a chance to contest the allegation before the revocation, though he could ask for reconsideration.

He sued San Diego County and the San Diego County Sheriff under the federal civil rights law, 42 U.S.C. § 1983. He alleged that the revocation violated his freedom of association and his Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms, falsely tied him to criminal conduct, and could make it harder to get a license again. He asked for damages, an injunction and the destruction of his revocation records.

03

Guilt by association and the First Amendment

The heart of the opinion is about association. The trial court had dismissed Shilling’s First Amendment claim because, in its view, he had to show the revocation stopped him from associating with the club. The Ninth Circuit said the district court “misunderstood the nature of the free-association right.”

Government can violate that right in many ways, the panel explained, including by punishing people for their affiliations. Under Supreme Court precedent, before the government denies someone a benefit or right because of a group’s alleged crimes, it must establish “that the group itself possessed unlawful goals and that the individual held a specific intent to further those illegal aims.” The burden is on the government, not the citizen.

Measured against that rule, the panel wrote, “Shilling easily pleaded a violation of his freedom of association.” The sheriff’s letter “conclusorily labeled” the club a criminal street gang and revoked the concealed carry license on that basis. The court quoted the Supreme Court’s warning that “guilt by association alone” is “an impermissible basis upon which to deny First Amendment rights.”

The panel also explained why the right matters so much. Without it, the opinion said, quoting a 2026 Supreme Court decision, the government could stop Americans from sharing “the same church” or the same soapbox. Freedom of association protects clubs and congregations, unions and student groups, people the government likes and people it doesn’t.

04

The civil rights roots of the rule

The test the court applied did not come from a gun case. It comes from NAACP v. Claiborne Hardware Co., a 1982 Supreme Court decision that grew out of a 1966 boycott of white merchants in Claiborne County, Mississippi. The Court held there that regular attendance at NAACP branch meetings was not enough to make individual members liable for what others did.

The Ninth Circuit quoted that case directly: “Civil liability may not be imposed merely because an individual belonged to a group, some members of which committed acts of violence.”

The panel also relied on Healy v. James, a 1972 case in which a state college refused to recognize a local chapter of Students for a Democratic Society. The Supreme Court held that students could not be denied the benefits of official recognition merely because of their affiliation with a national group linked to campus disruption.

A civil rights boycott, a student protest group and now a motorcycle club: the same constitutional rule protects all of them. That is the point of a right. It does not depend on whether the people exercising it are popular with the official in charge.

05

Why California sheriffs can’t claim the state’s immunity

The Eleventh Amendment protects states, and “arms of the state,” from many lawsuits in federal court. The trial judge ruled that the San Diego County Sheriff was an arm of the state and dismissed the claims against her on that ground.

The Ninth Circuit disagreed, applying the three-factor test it adopted in 2023 and refined this year. Under that test, an entity “either is or is not an arm of the state” for every case, regardless of what function is being challenged. The panel found that California’s Constitution designates sheriffs as county officers, that the state is not formally liable for judgments against them, and that some state supervision does not outweigh those signals.

The result is broad. California sheriffs are not “arms of the State,” the panel concluded, so the San Diego County Sheriff has no Eleventh Amendment immunity. The court also held that the sheriff acted as the county’s final policymaker on concealed carry license revocations, which means San Diego County itself can be held liable under § 1983.

For anyone who brings a civil rights claim against a California sheriff’s office in federal court, that holding matters. It takes away an Eleventh Amendment defense that, in Shilling’s case, ended the suit at the start.

06

Who decides who gets a concealed carry license in California

California writes the rules for a concealed carry license, and county sheriffs carry them out. Under state law, as the opinion describes it, applicants must complete training, pass background checks and submit fingerprints, and each sheriff must publish a written policy summarizing the state’s requirements.

The state keeps some control. Every concealed carry license application uses the same forms prescribed by the Attorney General, fingerprints go to the California Department of Justice, sheriffs must notify the state whenever they grant, deny or revoke a license, and no license may go to a person barred from having firearms under federal or state law.

Still, the panel held that those statewide rules did not turn the revocation into a state decision. Before 2024, California ran a “may issue” system. In December 2023, Sheriff Martinez had the discretion to both define and enforce the good moral character requirement, and she made her choice “from among various alternatives,” the court said. That made her the county’s final policymaker, and it is why San Diego County may have to answer for the revocation, including in damages, if Shilling proves his case.

California’s reform replaced that system with a “shall issue” one that required sheriffs to either deny or grant licenses when certain criteria were met. A concealed carry license decision today runs under different rules than the one that cost Shilling his license.

07

Why the Second Amendment claim is still alive

On January 1, 2024, shortly after Shilling’s revocation, California replaced the “good moral character” requirement with an exclusion based on a likelihood of dangerousness. The legislature made that change in response to the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen.

The trial court ruled that the new law made Shilling’s Second Amendment claim over his concealed carry license moot, at least as to injunctive and declaratory relief. The Ninth Circuit disagreed. If Shilling proves a violation, the panel said, the court can still give him real relief by ordering the destruction of his concealed carry license revocation records. Shilling alleged that the record of the revocation could make it harder for him to get a license again.

08

A timeline of the concealed carry license case

  • 1946: The Boozefighters Motorcycle Club is founded by World War II veterans, according to Shilling.
  • June 2022: Shilling receives a concealed carry license from then-Sheriff Anthony Ray.
  • December 2023: Sheriff Kelly Martinez revokes the license, calling the club a “criminal street gang.”
  • January 1, 2024: California’s new dangerousness standard replaces “good moral character.”
  • After the revocation: Shilling sues; the district court dismisses his claims.
  • May 20, 2026: The Ninth Circuit hears argument in Pasadena.
  • November 20, 2026: The panel reverses and remands.

09

What this means for Californians with a concealed carry license

The good moral character standard behind Shilling’s revocation is gone, so the ruling does not reopen every past decision on its own. But it sets clear rules for the cases that remain and for the future.

  • A county can be sued under § 1983 for a sheriff’s concealed carry license revocation policy when the sheriff acts as its final policymaker.
  • A California sheriff cannot use the Eleventh Amendment to block a federal civil rights suit, under this ruling.
  • A license holder who is penalized only for belonging to a lawful group can state a First Amendment claim.
  • A Second Amendment claim can survive a change in the law when the person still carries a record of the revocation.

10

What happens next

The case returns to U.S. District Judge Cathy Ann Bencivengo in the Southern District of California. Under the panel’s reasoning, the sheriff cannot punish Shilling for his affiliation unless she meets her burden of showing that the Boozefighters “possessed unlawful goals” and that Shilling had a “specific intent to further those illegal aims.”

On remand, the county will have to defend the concealed carry license revocation itself, not just argue that it cannot be sued. Shilling is represented by Gary W. Gorski of the Veterans Law Center. Deputy County Counsel David M. Stotland argued for the county. Bloom will report the next ruling in the case, including any request by San Diego County for further review.

11

What you can do

  • Get reasons in writing. If a sheriff denies or revokes your concealed carry license, or any office denies you a benefit, because of a group you belong to, ask for the reason in writing and keep every letter.
  • Use the reconsideration process. Shilling’s revocation letter allowed him to ask for reconsideration. Ask about every appeal route, and note the deadlines.
  • Talk to a civil rights lawyer. Claims under § 1983 have rules and time limits, and an early consultation can protect your options.
  • Know the rule. The government must show a group’s unlawful goals and your specific intent to further them before it can penalize you for belonging.

These rights protect everyone, whether the question is a concealed carry license, a church membership or a student club. Bloom reported this week on a Missouri student group suing over a demand for its members’ and donors’ names, another freedom of association fight. On gun rights, Bloom also covered the Supreme Court’s decision to turn away a challenge to Maryland’s sensitive places gun law.

12

What Bloom is doing

Bloom reports on civil rights and civil liberties for everyone, including speech, assembly, association and the Second Amendment, because a right that protects only the people we agree with is not a right at all. We report the record, not the politics, and we follow cases from the first filing to the final word. As the Ninth Circuit’s opinion in Shilling’s case put it, the government cannot impose “guilt by association alone.”

If any of this news weighs on you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists help that answers any hour, and 988 is there by call or text.

Independent reporting on these cases depends on readers. A monthly gift lets Bloom keep reading the opinions and filings so you don’t have to, and a one-time gift helps too.

13

Frequently Asked Questions

In December 2023, San Diego County Sheriff Kelly Martinez revoked it under California’s former “good moral character” standard because of his membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club, which she called a “criminal street gang.” The opinion says he has no criminal history.

On November 20, 2026, the panel reversed the dismissal of Shilling’s lawsuit. It held that the sheriff has no Eleventh Amendment immunity, that the county can be liable, that his Second Amendment claim is not moot, and that he adequately pleaded a freedom of association claim.

Not yet. The ruling lets his claims go forward. The case returns to the district court in San Diego, where the county must defend the revocation on the merits.

It means penalizing someone only for belonging to a group. Under Supreme Court precedent, the government must show the group had unlawful goals and that the person intended to further them.

Under this ruling, California sheriffs are not arms of the state and cannot claim Eleventh Amendment immunity. Counties can be held liable under § 1983 when a sheriff acts as the county’s final policymaker.

No. Since January 1, 2024, California has used an exclusion based on a likelihood of dangerousness instead of the good moral character requirement, under a “shall issue” system.

The case involved the old standard. The court’s holdings that California sheriffs lack Eleventh Amendment immunity and that the First Amendment forbids guilt by association do not depend on that standard.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.