
Newsroom·Louisiana Legislature·News
Appeals Court: Second Amendment Covers Selling Guns, Not Just Owning
A Fifth Circuit panel held that the Second Amendment's plain text covers the sale of firearms, sending back the case of a Louisiana man convicted of dealing guns without a federal license. One judge dissented.
Does the Second Amendment protect only owning a gun, or selling one too? A federal appeals court has answered that the right reaches sales. “The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms,” a panel of the Fifth Circuit held on Thursday, November 19, in the case of a Louisiana man convicted of dealing guns without a federal license.
The two-paragraph holding could reshape how courts in the Fifth Circuit judge the federal license required to engage in the business of dealing firearms. The panel vacated the trial court’s refusal to dismiss the charges and sent the case back for a new look. One judge dissented. The ruling does not strike down the license law, but it means the government must now defend it under the Supreme Court’s history-and-tradition test.
01
What the Fifth Circuit decided about the Second Amendment
The case is United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241. The unsigned per curiam opinion came from a panel of Judges Haynes, James C. Ho and Andrew S. Oldham.
The core of the ruling is short. Citing its 2025 decision in Reese v. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives, the court repeated that “the right to ‘keep and bear arms’ surely implies the right to purchase them.” It then noted that, at oral argument, the government “conceded that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms.”
From there, the panel vacated the district court’s order denying the motion to dismiss the indictment and remanded the case “for further proceedings.” The opinion did not decide whether the federal license requirement is constitutional. It decided only that the Second Amendment applies, which shifts the burden to the government.
02
The case against Jeremiah Deare
Jeremiah Micah Deare was indicted in the Western District of Louisiana for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal firearms license, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1). He was also charged with making false statements with respect to the records of licensed firearms dealers.
Before trial, Deare asked the court to dismiss the indictment, broadly challenging the constitutionality of the federal firearms license requirement and related record-keeping rules. The district court refused. It held that those rules do not touch the Second Amendment because they do not affect an individual’s right to keep or bear arms, and that even if they did, they fit the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
The district court described the law as “a modest regulation of the commercial activity of selling/transferring firearms to others.” A jury convicted Deare on all counts, and he was sentenced to 97 months in prison.
Deare also raised three other challenges on appeal: that the statute’s wording is unconstitutionally vague, that his sentence is unreasonable and that the evidence was insufficient. The unsigned opinion lists those arguments in a footnote but rests its ruling on the Second Amendment question.
03
How the Bruen test applies now
The Supreme Court set the framework in 2022 in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen. When the Second Amendment’s plain text covers someone’s conduct, the Constitution presumptively protects it. To justify a firearm regulation, “the government must demonstrate that the regulation is consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation,” the Court held.
That is why the Fifth Circuit’s holding matters. The district court had ruled at the first step that the Second Amendment did not reach the license requirement at all. The Fifth Circuit has now said gun sales are covered, so the case moves to the second step, where the government carries the burden.
On remand, the district court will have to decide whether the federal firearms license requirement and the related record-keeping rules are consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. That is a harder question, and the opinion does not answer it.
04
What the government conceded
One detail in the short opinion carries unusual weight. At oral argument, the government “conceded that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms,” the panel wrote, citing the recording of the hearing.
That concession narrowed the fight. The district court had held that licensing and record-keeping rules do not touch the Second Amendment at all, reasoning that the requirements “affect only the seller.” Once the government agreed that commercial sales fall under the amendment, the remaining question became whether the rules are consistent with history, not whether the Second Amendment applies.
Judge Haynes noted the concession in her dissent, writing that she respected the majority’s reading in part because of “what the government said.”
05
The concurring opinions
Judge Ho wrote separately to welcome the ruling, writing that the court “reaffirms what we should have long understood” about the Second Amendment. “It seems obvious,” Ho continued, that “constitutional rights are meaningless if the Government can simply prohibit the means by which citizens are able to exercise those rights.” He compared gun sellers to booksellers, writing that the First Amendment does not mention sellers either, yet clearly protects them.
Judge Oldham, joined by Judge Ho, concurred in the judgment. He wrote that an earlier Fifth Circuit decision, United States v. Peterson, “was wrong and should be overturned,” and that at a minimum it should not be extended to firearm sales under § 922(a).
Oldham explained his reasoning in terms of both sides of a sale. Restrictions on sales burden the seller’s right to keep and bear arms, he wrote, and they burden the buyer’s right too, “because the right to keep an item always includes the right to acquire it.” He pointed to the Second Amendment’s command that the right “shall not be infringed,” and wrote that at the founding, “infringe” meant “violate,” “destroy,” or “hinder.”
He also drew on property law, writing that the right to possess an article “includes the right to acquire, use, and dispose of it.” On that view, a law that hinders selling a lawfully owned gun touches the owner’s rights as well as the buyer’s.
As for Peterson, Oldham wrote that it involved a man “indicted for possessing an unregistered suppressor,” and that the decision “has nothing at all to do with § 922(a).”
Oldham also gave the district court guidance for remand. It should be guided by the court’s 2026 decision in Elite Precision Customs LLC v. ATF, “which enjoined enforcement of certain provisions of 18 U.S.C. § 922(a),” he wrote, and it “should ignore our decision in Peterson.” The government had argued in a supplemental brief that Peterson makes § 922(a) “presumptively constitutional.”
06
Why one judge dissented
Judge Haynes dissented. “I do not think that the sellers of guns are covered by the Second Amendment,” she wrote, noting that the amendment does not mention sellers. She said she respected the majority’s reading given the court’s earlier cases and the government’s concession.
Even assuming sellers are covered, Haynes wrote, she saw nothing showing that the rules for sellers in this context are inappropriate or unconstitutional, and Deare had not properly challenged the rules as abusive. “I would simply affirm,” she wrote. Her dissent is short, but it frames the question the trial court now faces: whether these rules for sellers are proper.
The disagreement between Ho and Haynes over the First Amendment comparison runs through the opinions. Haynes argued that the two amendments are written differently: freedom of speech applies to people broadly, while the Second Amendment speaks of the right “to keep and bear Arms” without mentioning selling.
07
What the Second Amendment ruling does not decide
The ruling does not free Deare, and it does not strike down any federal law. It vacates one order, the denial of his motion to dismiss, and sends the case back to the trial court. It also concerns a federal statute, 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1), not any state’s gun laws, so state licensing rules are untouched by this decision.
It also leaves open how the ruling affects Deare’s conviction on the false-statements count. A post at The Volokh Conspiracy, a legal blog hosted by Reason, offered one reading: “As I read the opinion, it doesn’t affect the false statements charge.” That is commentary, not a ruling, and the district court will decide.
And it does not settle the law nationwide. The ruling binds federal courts within the Fifth Circuit, not the rest of the country. Other circuits may see the Second Amendment and gun sales differently, which is how questions like this one often reach the Supreme Court.
08
Where Deare fits in the Fifth Circuit’s gun cases
Deare is the latest in a run of Fifth Circuit decisions on federal gun laws since Bruen. In Reese, in 2025, the court said the right to keep and bear arms implies the right to purchase them. In Elite Precision, in 2026, it enjoined enforcement of certain provisions of § 922(a), according to Judge Oldham’s concurrence.
Peterson, also decided in 2025, pointed the other way in the government’s view. The government argued in a supplemental brief that Peterson makes § 922(a) “presumptively constitutional,” while Oldham wrote that Peterson was about an unregistered suppressor and should not be extended to firearm sales.
For people who buy, sell or own guns in the Fifth Circuit, those decisions together will shape how the Second Amendment applies to the gun trade. The trial court’s ruling on remand will be the next piece.
09
A timeline of the Second Amendment case
- Before trial: Deare is indicted in the Western District of Louisiana, case No. 6:21-CR-212-1.
- 2022: The Supreme Court decides Bruen and sets the history-and-tradition test.
- 2023: The district court denies Deare’s motion to dismiss the indictment.
- After trial: A jury convicts Deare on all counts, and he is sentenced to 97 months.
- 2025: The Fifth Circuit decides Reese, saying the right to keep and bear arms implies the right to purchase them.
- November 19, 2026: The Fifth Circuit holds that the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms, vacates the denial of the motion to dismiss and remands.
10
Why the Second Amendment ruling matters to civil liberties
Bloom covers the whole Bill of Rights, the Second Amendment included, because rights belong to everyone or they belong to no one. The question in Deare is one that courts ask about every right: whether a protected activity includes the practical means to carry it out.
Ho’s booksellers comparison makes the point in First Amendment terms. A right to read means little if no one may sell a book. The dissent answers that the two amendments are worded differently. Both views are now part of the public record, and both will matter as the case continues.
Many people who face threats, including survivors of violence and trans people targeted for who they are, think hard about self-defense and the law. Bloom has reported on that intersection, including RÃhanna Kelver’s plea in a self-defense case that let her keep her gun rights, and on the Supreme Court’s decision to turn away a challenge to Maryland’s sensitive places gun law.
11
What happens next
The case returns to the district court in Louisiana. There, the government will have to show that the federal firearms license requirement and the related rules, as applied in Deare’s case, are consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. The court will also have to decide what the ruling means for Deare’s conviction.
The government could also seek further review of the panel’s decision. Bloom will report the district court’s ruling on remand, any appeal, and any word from Deare’s lawyers or the government.
12
Questions the district court must now answer
The remand leaves several questions open, drawn from the opinions and the issues Deare raised:
- History and tradition. Is the federal firearms license requirement for people engaged in the business of dealing consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation?
- Record-keeping. Do the related record-keeping rules fit that tradition?
- The conviction. What does the vacated order mean for Deare’s conviction and his 97-month sentence?
- Other claims. Deare also argued that the statute is vague, that his sentence is unreasonable and that the evidence was insufficient.
- Precedent. How should the trial court weigh Elite Precision, as Judge Oldham urged, against the government’s reliance on Peterson?
Each answer will shape how far the Second Amendment reaches into the business of selling guns within the Fifth Circuit.
13
What you can know and do
- The ruling applies within the Fifth Circuit. It binds federal courts there, not the whole country.
- The license law is still in force. The panel did not strike down § 922(a)(1); it sent the case back for the government to defend it.
- Get legal advice before selling firearms. Federal law still requires a license to engage in the business of dealing firearms, and this ruling does not change that today.
- Follow the remand. The district court’s answer under Bruen will decide how far this ruling reaches.
14
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reports on constitutional rights without taking a side in the politics around them. We read the opinions, quote the judges accurately, including the dissent, and explain what changes for readers and what does not. The Second Amendment belongs to every person the Constitution protects, and so does the right to know exactly what a court decided.
If the news of the day is heavy, Bloom’s crisis support page lists help that answers any hour.
Bloom’s court reporting depends on readers who value careful work. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading the opinions so you don’t have to, and a one-time gift helps too.
15
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 19, 2026, in United States v. Deare, a Fifth Circuit panel held that “the plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms” and sent the case back to the district court.
No. The panel vacated the order denying Deare’s motion to dismiss and remanded the case. The government must now show the license requirement fits the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation.
Under Bruen, when the Second Amendment’s text covers conduct, the government must show a regulation is consistent with historical tradition. Covering gun sales moves the burden to the government.
Judge Haynes dissented. She wrote that she does not think sellers of guns are covered by the Second Amendment and would have affirmed Deare’s conviction.
The ruling binds federal courts within the Fifth Circuit, including the Louisiana trial court where Deare’s case began. Courts elsewhere are not bound by it.
At oral argument, the government conceded that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms, the panel wrote. The dispute now turns on whether the license rules fit the nation’s history and tradition.
The ruling does not change the law today. Federal law still requires a license to engage in the business of dealing firearms, and anyone considering sales should get legal advice.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.


