
Newsroom·Wyoming Legislature·News
Ríhanna Kelver Takes Plea in Self-Defense Case, Keeps Her Gun Rights
A Laramie woman who drew a pistol after a man shoved her to the pavement will keep her gun rights and could clear her record. A judge decides on December 7 whether to accept her plea deal.
Ríhanna Kelver will keep her guns, her vote and, if she completes two years of probation, a clean record. The Laramie, Wyoming, woman, who drew a pistol after a man shoved her to the pavement in a downtown crosswalk, agreed to a plea deal on Tuesday morning, November 17, in Albany County Circuit Court, the Laramie Reporter reported. She pleaded no contest to one misdemeanor, and two felony charges that together carried up to 15 years in prison are to be dismissed.
The deal ends a case that tested what Wyoming’s stand your ground law protects when someone draws a gun but never fires. In August, a judge ruled that Kelver, a transgender activist, had no duty to retreat, then denied her stand your ground immunity because a shove, in the judge’s words, “does not equate to a risk of imminent death or serious bodily injury.” Kelver still says she acted in self-defense. “Justice would have been dismissal,” she told the Laramie Reporter. Here is what the court record shows, what the stand your ground statute says, and why it matters to anyone who carries for protection.
01
What the stand your ground plea deal does
Kelver announced the deal herself in a statement posted to her Facebook page, WyoFile reported. Her attorney, Andrew Holcomb, confirmed the terms but declined to comment because his client has not been sentenced. The deal has six parts:
- One misdemeanor, no contest. Kelver pleaded no contest to reckless endangering, which is punishable by up to one year in jail when not capped by a plea agreement, Cowboy State Daily reported.
- Two years of unsupervised probation. She must avoid alcohol and other substances, criminal activity and contact with the man who shoved her, the Laramie Reporter reported.
- A 301 deferral. Prosecutors agreed to what’s known as a 301 deferral, “which means she would not be formally convicted if she successfully completes probation,” WyoFile reported.
- Felonies dismissed. The charges of aggravated assault and possession of a deadly weapon with unlawful intent will be dismissed. Prosecutors also asked the court to dismiss a misdemeanor charge of police interference, according to Cowboy State Daily.
- Rights kept. She keeps her gun rights, during probation and after, and her voting rights, the Laramie Reporter reported.
- A judge has the last word. At sentencing on December 7, a judge must still decide whether to abide by the terms of the deal, WyoFile reported.
02
What happened in the crosswalk
The confrontation took place on the night of September 13, 2025, outside the Crowbar & Grill in downtown Laramie, where Kelver worked and was about to clock in for a late-night shift. She and a man walking with two companions across the street give different accounts of what was said.
Kelver testified at an August hearing that the man used an antigay slur and threatened to kill her, The Advocate reported. He told police he had yelled an insult about the bar and denied directing slurs at her, according to an investigator’s affidavit. Kelver had not told police about the threats that night, according to court testimony reported by Cowboy State Daily. Bloom does not repeat the words either of them described.
Surveillance video showed what came next, WyoFile reported. Kelver walked toward the man and his companions, her right hand near a satchel at her hip that held her gun. In the crosswalk, he shoved her to the ground. Still on the pavement, she pulled a pistol, racked the slide and pointed it at him as he kept walking past. She then lowered it and stood up.
She never fired. Within seven seconds of drawing, she put the pistol back in her satchel, and the shove was the only physical attack she experienced, the Laramie Reporter reported. Kelver testified that the shove left her with a bulging spinal disk. Police later found a round in the pistol’s chamber, according to body camera video and testimony shown in court, Cowboy State Daily reported.
03
Why the judge denied stand your ground immunity
Kelver asked the court to dismiss the case before trial under the stand your ground law. Albany County District Judge Misha Westby heard the request on Wednesday, August 26, and ruled on Monday, August 31, according to Cowboy State Daily and WyoFile.
The ruling split in two. Westby found that Kelver “did not have a duty to retreat because she was not the initial aggressor,” citing Wyoming Supreme Court precedent that “words alone” do not make someone the initial aggressor. The first aggressive act, she noted, was the man’s shove. She also found no evidence challenging Kelver’s “honest belief that she was in danger of further attack.”
But Westby ruled that Kelver “was not entitled to use deadly force because she was not in danger of imminent death or serious bodily injury.” “He was walking past her position,” she wrote. “His hands were visible on the video from the shove and even when he is walking past her.” There was “no evidence” that he “possessed or mentioned a weapon of any kind.”
The deciding question was necessity. “A shove to the ground in this situation does not equate to a risk of imminent death or serious bodily injury,” Westby wrote. Losing stand your ground immunity did not end Kelver’s self-defense claim, and she could still argue it to a jury at a trial set for November 30, WyoFile reported.
04
How each side argued the stand your ground question
At the August hearing, Albany County Attorney Kurt Britzius argued that Kelver started the incident by approaching the men with one hand on the satchel, Cowboy State Daily reported. “This was threatened deadly force,” he said. “Ms. Kelver cannot assert self-defense for a situation she created.”
Holcomb answered that the man made the first physical contact, and he pointed to higher rates of violence documented against transgender people. “So when Ms. Kelver heard targeted slurs, heard threats, then was shoved to the ground, her fear did not come from nowhere,” he said. In a footnote, Westby wrote that the prosecutor had shown “by the low burden” that “there are concerns with Ms. Kelver’s recollection of the exact statements made during the event.”
05
What Wyoming’s stand your ground law says
Wyoming’s self-defense statute is section 6-2-602 of the state’s criminal code. Defensive force “whether actual or threatened” is reasonable when it is the force “a reasonable person in like circumstances would judge necessary to prevent an injury or loss, and no more.” That includes deadly force “if necessary to prevent imminent death or serious bodily injury.” The necessity can arise from an honest belief, “whether the danger is real or apparent.”
Then comes the part most people mean by stand your ground. A person “who is attacked in any place where the person is lawfully present shall not have a duty to retreat,” the statute says, “provided that he is not the initial aggressor and is not engaged in illegal activity.” And a person who uses reasonable defensive force “shall not be criminally prosecuted for that use of reasonable defensive force.”
Read together, the stand your ground statute asks two separate questions, and Kelver’s case split along that seam. Did she have to retreat? The judge said no. Was pointing a loaded pistol the force a reasonable person would judge necessary? The judge said no to that, too.
06
What a stand your ground immunity hearing is
The stand your ground clause that bars prosecution never uses the word immunity. In State v. John, a 2020 decision, the Wyoming Supreme Court held that it is “a mandatory immunity provision carrying with it a judicial gatekeeping function.” The defendant must first make a prima facie, or at-first-glance, showing. Then the burden shifts to the state to “establish by a preponderance of the evidence” that the immunity does not apply.
At Kelver’s stand your ground immunity hearing, Westby found that she made her first showing of self-defense, then ruled that the prosecutor had proved his case against it. A defendant who loses at that stage can still raise self-defense at trial, where the state must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
07
What no contest and a 301 deferral mean
A no contest plea “functions like a guilty plea but isn’t an admission of guilt and can limit civil action,” Cowboy State Daily explained.
The 301 deferral takes its name from section 7-13-301 of Wyoming’s code. For a person never convicted of a felony who pleads guilty or no contest, a court may, with the consent of the defendant and the state and “without entering a judgment of guilt or conviction,” defer the case and order probation of up to 36 months. If the court finds the probation fulfilled, it may dismiss the proceedings, and that discharge “is not a conviction for any purpose.”
A person gets “only one (1) discharge and dismissal.” If a term of probation is broken before discharge, the court may enter a conviction and sentence, or order a trial on the original charge, depending on the plea.
08
How two felonies became one misdemeanor
The misdemeanor carries its own self-defense language. Under Wyoming’s reckless endangering law, a person who “knowingly points a firearm at or in the direction of another” is guilty “unless reasonably necessary in defense of his person, property or abode,” or as the stand your ground statute allows.
The felonies were heavier. Aggravated assault includes threatening “to use a drawn deadly weapon on another unless reasonably necessary in defense,” with up to 10 years in prison, and the weapon charge carries up to five.
There was a second weight on the scale. Convicted of the felonies and sentenced to a year or more, Kelver would have been sent to the Wyoming State Penitentiary in Rawlins, a men’s prison, the Laramie Reporter reported. “That would have been a very dangerous situation for me,” she said. Bloom has reported on that danger, from the killing of a transgender prisoner in Hawaii to Ruby Corado’s request for early release after repeated assaults in federal custody.
09
What Kelver says now
Kelver, 28, is one of Wyoming’s most outspoken transgender activists, Cowboy State Daily reported. On July 1, 2025, she used the women’s restroom at the Wyoming State Capitol to protest a new restroom law on the day it took effect.
She calls the deal “bittersweet,” according to the Laramie Reporter. In her Facebook post, reported by Cowboy State Daily, she wrote: “I am innocent, I broke no Wyoming statute, and this is not justice.” But, she continued, “it is safety and it is security and it guarantees a future in advocacy that I wish to continue for our community.”
Her statement said she will “maintain my firearms rights and my right to defend myself.” Written in the third person, it added: “To this day ChasingStars believes her actions were necessary in the moment to protect herself.” Kelver also goes by the name Ríhanna Novalee ChasingStars, WyoFile reported.
Before court, she told the Laramie Reporter: “I agree it’s the best option for the system we have, but no, it doesn’t feel like justice for me.”
10
The only person charged in the stand your ground case
“She was the only person charged in connection with the altercation,” WyoFile reported. The man who shoved her was never charged, and Kelver told the Laramie Reporter she still believes he “should have been charged that night.”
Before trial, Kelver’s defense subpoenaed the man’s disciplinary file from a university he previously attended, and Holcomb cited news reports about his past. Westby reviewed it in her chambers and ruled earlier this month that it “is not relevant or material to any element of the charges or any defense,” Cowboy State Daily reported. Bloom is not naming the man, who was never charged with a crime, and does not repeat claims about him that no court has tested.
11
What this stand your ground case means for people who carry
Media and observers questioned why Kelver faced criminal charges in a state with a stand your ground law and broad support for gun ownership, WyoFile reported. For anyone who carries a firearm for self-defense, here is what this record shows, read alongside the statute:
- No duty to retreat is not a license for deadly force. Westby found that Kelver did not have to retreat and still found her force unjustified. Under stand your ground, those are separate questions.
- Drawing counts. The statute covers defensive force “whether actual or threatened.” Westby weighed the drawn, pointed pistol under the deadly force standard, though no shot was fired.
- Police apply a threshold too. A Laramie officer testified that he would not draw his gun to deter someone, and would draw only if the circumstances met the threshold for returning deadly force, Cowboy State Daily reported.
None of this is advice about when to draw a gun, and Bloom offers none. It is what one judge, applying one statute, found on one record. Laws differ from state to state, and no jury heard this case.
12
Why trans gun owners watched this case
The stand your ground statute asks two things about fear. Was it honest, and would a reasonable person in like circumstances have judged the force necessary? Westby found no evidence to doubt Kelver’s honest belief that she was in danger of further attack. She found the second test unmet, and that is the line every gun owner in Wyoming lives under.
If you carry because you have known fear, the statute does not dismiss that fear. It asks one more thing of it: what a reasonable person, in that same second, would judge necessary.
Holcomb asked the court to see Kelver’s fear in light of the violence documented against transgender people. The judge applied the stand your ground law to the facts of one night in Laramie, and Kelver doesn’t expect the outcome to set a rule for anyone else. “There’ll be no case law,” she told the Laramie Reporter. “Nothing really substantial is decided here.”
This report appears on the eve of Transgender Day of Remembrance, observed each November 20, which Bloom wrote about last week when Minneapolis named Stella Nez Perce. No shot was fired in Laramie, and no one died. Two truths can be held at once: the relief that this night ended without a death, and a fear that, as her lawyer put it, “did not come from nowhere.”
13
A timeline of the stand your ground case
These dates come from the Laramie Reporter, WyoFile and Cowboy State Daily:
- September 13, 2025: A man shoves Kelver to the ground in a downtown Laramie crosswalk. She draws a pistol, points it at him and lowers it without firing.
- August 26, 2026: Westby holds a stand your ground immunity hearing.
- August 31, 2026: Westby rules that Kelver had no duty to retreat but denies immunity.
- Early November 2026: Westby rules that the man’s university disciplinary file is not relevant.
- November 17, 2026: Kelver pleads no contest to reckless endangering under the plea deal.
- December 7, 2026: Sentencing, when a judge decides whether to accept the terms.
14
What happens next
The next date is December 7 at 9 AM, the Laramie Reporter reported. If the judge accepts the terms, Kelver begins two years of unsupervised probation under a 301 deferral, and the stand your ground case is resolved without a trial.
Under section 7-13-301, a court that finds the probation fulfilled may dismiss the case, as early as one year in. If she completes it, her record will be wiped clean, the Laramie Reporter reported. Bloom will report the sentencing, and any court ruling that changes how Wyoming reads its stand your ground law.
15
What you can do if you carry, or if police question you
These steps come from Wyoming’s statutes and the American Civil Liberties Union. They are general information, not legal advice for any case.
- Read your own state’s law. Wyoming’s stand your ground statute is section 6-2-602, published by the Wyoming Legislature.
- You can stay silent. If you are arrested or detained, the ACLU’s know-your-rights guide says: “Say you wish to remain silent and ask for a lawyer immediately.”
- You have a right to a lawyer. “If you can’t pay for a lawyer, you have the right to a free one,” the ACLU says.
- Stay calm and truthful. “Don’t run, resist, or obstruct the officers,” the ACLU advises. “Do not lie or give false documents.”
- Get support tonight. Trans Lifeline is 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project is 1-866-488-7386, and you can call or text 988. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more people to call.
16
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reports on the law where it meets the people it protects, from the Supreme Court turning away a challenge to Maryland’s sensitive places gun law to the safety of trans people in custody. Self-defense rights and trans safety are both on this beat, and this stand your ground case sat where they meet. I believe every person who carries for protection deserves to know where the law draws its lines before the worst night of their life, not after.
If this story stirred up a fear you already carry, you don’t have to carry it alone. Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight, and Bloom’s support groups meet people where they are. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
Reading a statute line by line, and coming back on December 7, takes steady work. A monthly gift keeps Bloom on stories like this one all year, and a one-time gift helps too.
17
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 17, 2026, she pleaded no contest to one misdemeanor, reckless endangering, under a deal that calls for two years of unsupervised probation and a 301 deferral. Two felony charges are to be dismissed.
Judge Misha Westby found that Kelver had no duty to retreat because she was not the initial aggressor. But she ruled that Kelver was not in danger of imminent death or serious bodily injury, so deadly force was not justified.
Section 6-2-602 says a person attacked where they are lawfully present has no duty to retreat if they are not the initial aggressor and not engaged in illegal activity. The force must still be what a reasonable person would judge necessary.
It is a pretrial hearing where a judge decides whether a defendant is immune from prosecution. The defendant makes a first showing, and then the state must prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the immunity does not apply.
Yes. She keeps her gun rights during probation and after, along with her voting rights, the Laramie Reporter reported. A judge decides on December 7 whether to accept the deal.
No. WyoFile reported that Kelver was the only person charged in connection with the altercation.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
New York Legislature · 20 November 2026Liverpool Students Walk Out Over Rule to Tell Parents About Gender
Wisconsin Legislature · 20 November 2026Madison Prosecutor Won’t Charge Officer Who Killed Corey Ruiz
Tennessee Legislature · 20 November 2026Tennessee Hospital to Fix Accessible Parking and Pay $25,000