The curved concrete Robert C. Weaver Federal Building, HUD's headquarters in Washington, under a blue sky, for a report on the Continuum of Care ruling

NewsroomJustice for survivorsNews

Judge Strikes HUD’s $1.3 Billion Shift Away From Permanent Housing

A federal judge ruled Friday that HUD broke the law when it steered $1.3 billion in Continuum of Care homelessness money away from permanent housing. Communities can resubmit Tier 2 applications until December 1.

A federal judge ruled Friday, November 20, 2026, that the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development broke the law when it tried to steer $1.3 billion in Continuum of Care homelessness money away from permanent housing. U.S. District Judge Mary S. McElroy in Rhode Island struck down that set-aside and a series of other 2026 grant rules, including scoring that left domestic violence providers unable to compete on equal terms, according to her 59-page order.

The ruling changes how the country’s largest homelessness grant competition ends this year. HUD must reopen part of it: communities can resubmit Tier 2 applications until 11:59 PM Eastern on December 1, and HUD must award that money by December 31. For people in permanent supportive housing, many of them disabled or fleeing violence, the order is about whether the program that keeps a roof overhead is judged by the rules Congress wrote.

01

What the Continuum of Care ruling decided

McElroy decided two related cases together. In National Alliance to End Homelessness v. HUD, homelessness and housing groups challenged HUD’s 2026 Notice of Funding Opportunity. In Washington v. HUD, twenty states, the District of Columbia, and the governors of Kentucky and Pennsylvania brought a parallel challenge, the order says.

The court granted and denied each side’s motions in part. It vacated, severed and declared unlawful the $1.3 billion set-aside, the scoring rules that rewarded mandatory services, the anti-harm reduction provisions, HUD’s definition of “self-sufficiency,” a set of grant conditions tied to executive orders, and limits on bonus funding, among other provisions.

The Continuum of Care program is large. It’s a $4 billion program that, since 1987, has funded states, local governments and nonprofits to serve people experiencing homelessness, “with a focus on veterans, families, and people with disabilities,” Reuters reported.

02

Who brought the Continuum of Care case

The state case is led by Washington, and Oregon is among the plaintiffs. When the coalition first won in this case on August 7, 2026, the New York Attorney General’s office listed the attorneys general of Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Massachusetts, Maryland, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, Wisconsin and the District of Columbia, plus the governors of Kentucky and Pennsylvania.

That office said Continuum of Care funding supports people “most at risk of homelessness, such as veterans, those with disabilities, and transgender individuals.” In New York alone, it said, 24 regional Continuum of Care organizations receive over $320 million, and 94 percent of those funds go to permanent housing for 13,861 households.

The August win didn’t last. That order vacated the 2026 notice in its entirety, the office said at the time, and the appeals court later stayed it. Friday’s ruling is narrower, and it rests on different grounds.

03

The $1.3 billion set-aside

HUD’s 2026 notice set aside $1.3 billion of the more than $4 billion Congress appropriated for new transitional housing and supportive-services-only projects, according to Reuters and the order. The plaintiff states called it a “De Facto Cap,” because it limited permanent housing to roughly 68% of available Continuum of Care funds.

McElroy found HUD exceeded its authority under the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act. Congress let the secretary add criteria for awarding funds, she wrote, but “this residual clause cannot be read as allowing HUD to nullify the other congressionally established mandatory factors.”

With the set-aside gone, HUD must select Tier 2 projects, “new and renewal alike,” in order of project score until the money runs out, the order says. In plain terms, a permanent housing project that scores higher can no longer be pushed aside for a lower-scoring project in a favored category.

04

How Tier 1 and Tier 2 work

Each local Continuum of Care ranks its projects into two tiers. Tier 1 must total at least 60 percent of each applicant’s annual renewal demand, and HUD funds Tier 1 projects first, as long as they pass three stages of initial review, according to the order.

Everything else goes into Tier 2. “Tier 2 projects compete nationally,” the order notes, and they face a merit review that scores the whole Continuum of Care on a long list of criteria. That community score is the most heavily weighted factor in each project’s score.

That’s why the set-aside mattered so much. The plaintiffs argued it “would privilege these new housing programs even if permanent housing projects scored higher on merits-based criteria,” as the order summarizes their claim. The court agreed the set-aside was unlawful.

05

Domestic violence providers were left out

Some of the most consequential findings concern domestic violence providers. HUD’s notice awarded points to projects that required participants to take part in services. Domestic violence providers commonly combine Continuum of Care money with funds from the Violence Against Women Act and the Family Violence Prevention and Services Act, and both laws bar grantees from mandating services, the court found.

So those providers couldn’t earn the points. HUD argued that a separate pool of domestic violence bonus funds and a VAWA protection solved the problem. McElroy disagreed. The bonus pool comes from a congressional earmark of $52 million, she wrote, and it isn’t a fix for rules that disadvantage domestic violence providers in the competition for everything else.

The court found HUD hadn’t considered how domestic violence providers would be disadvantaged across all non-bonus Continuum of Care funding, or the “chilling effect” the criteria could have on communities choosing to serve survivors. That made the service requirement criteria arbitrary and capricious, and the court vacated them.

For a survivor who needs a safe place to live, this is personal. Housing that comes with no strings is often the only kind a survivor can safely accept.

06

Harm reduction rules struck down

HUD’s notice also required applicants to certify they wouldn’t run drug injection or “safe consumption” sites or distribute drug paraphernalia in violation of federal law, and it attached a matching condition. The court found those terms reached an organization’s conduct outside its HUD-funded projects, beyond what the statute allows.

McElroy vacated the certification and the condition to the extent they reach conduct outside Continuum of Care projects. She also vacated the certification in the application form, which wasn’t limited to illegal conduct.

The court then struck the remaining anti-harm reduction provisions as arbitrary and capricious, including the points for projects that promised not to do harm reduction. “The studies in the record that address harm reduction point the other way,” she wrote.

07

What “self-sufficiency” can’t mean

HUD defined self-sufficiency as the ability to meet basic needs “without public or private assistance.” That would have counted against projects whose participants use benefits like disability income or health coverage.

McElroy held the definition contrary to the statute. Congress told HUD to “promote access to, and effective utilization of, mainstream programs,” she noted, and criteria “cannot penalize applicants for doing what the part directs HUD to promote: connecting participants with mainstream programs.”

This finding matters for disabled people in particular. A person who will always rely on disability benefits isn’t failing at self-sufficiency. Congress designed the Continuum of Care program to connect them with those benefits, and the court held HUD can’t score that against them.

08

Conditions tied to executive orders

The 2026 notice required grantees to follow “Presidential Executive Actions affecting federal financial assistance programs” and an executive order on immigration, according to the order. The court found that neither the notice nor HUD’s explanatory memo explained why those conditions were included.

That made them arbitrary and capricious, and McElroy vacated them. Because they fell on that ground, the court didn’t reach the plaintiffs’ other arguments, “including their statutory and First Amendment challenges” to conditions requiring compliance with the executive orders on “gender ideology.”

For trans people experiencing homelessness, that’s a meaningful result even without a constitutional ruling. The conditions are gone from this year’s Continuum of Care grants. Bloom reported a similar outcome this week when a federal judge struck down limits on HIV care for transgender patients in the Ryan White program.

09

Bonus limits and budget footnotes

Two more pieces of the Continuum of Care ruling will matter to local planners. First, HUD capped bonus funding in a way that, combined with its scoring formula, let a smaller community’s project outscore an otherwise identical project from a larger one in the competition for all Tier 2 money, the court found. HUD never addressed that effect, so the limits were vacated. Communities may apply for bonus funding of up to 15% of their Final Pro Rata Need, as the notice otherwise provides.

Second, the court struck two budget footnotes from the White House Office of Management and Budget, known as A2 and A3, as they apply to Continuum of Care programs. The problem, McElroy wrote, is that “OMB considered nothing beyond the executive orders.”

Taken together, these findings mean the 2026 Continuum of Care competition must be scored on the criteria Congress set, not on policies layered on top without explanation.

10

What the court didn’t decide

The plaintiffs also challenged a statement in the notice that people “likely to never be able to return to the workforce” should be prioritized for permanent supportive housing. They argued it favored some disabilities over others, such as mental disabilities including substance use disorders, in violation of the Rehabilitation Act and the Americans with Disabilities Act.

The court dismissed that claim without prejudice for lack of standing. The statement awards no points, HUD said, and with a related criterion vacated, the plaintiffs couldn’t show how HUD would apply it, McElroy wrote. That means the claim could return if HUD gives the statement real effect.

The ruling is also partial in other ways. Some criteria were vacated only as applied to Tier 1 projects, and on several provisions the court reached one legal ground and didn’t decide the others.

11

What HUD says

HUD Secretary Scott Turner said the agency reserves the right to appeal, Reuters reported. He said the ruling “disrupts $4 billion for our most vulnerable, just days before funding awards were set to be made.”

Turner also defended the policy. “HUD is no longer in the business of throwing taxpayers’ money at a status quo that has repeatedly failed America’s most vulnerable,” he said.

The groups behind the case said in a joint statement that the ruling “protects the ability of communities and service providers to compete fairly for essential funding without being penalized for providing permanent housing,” according to Reuters.

12

What happens next: the December deadlines

The order sets a tight schedule. These dates come from the court:

  • November 24, 2026: Any party may file a two-page letter objecting to the deadlines.
  • November 25, 2026: HUD must file a compliance report on how it will make Tier 1 and Tier 2 awards without the vacated rules.
  • December 1, 2026: HUD must make Tier 1 awards, as the appropriations law requires. Tier 2 resubmissions close at 11:59 PM Eastern.
  • December 31, 2026: HUD must award all Tier 2 funds under the 2026 notice.
  • January 1, 2027: Existing grants begin to expire.
  • January 8, 2027: HUD must file a final compliance report, signed under penalty of perjury.

The court said the delay in Tier 2 awards should have minimal impact, because they’ll be complete before existing grants begin to expire. HUD can appeal, and the Continuum of Care fight has already gone up once.

13

How we got here

McElroy blocked HUD’s changes in 2025 and again earlier this year, only to have a federal appeals court lift that order, Reuters reported. The order says the First Circuit stayed her August 7 order in September 2026.

The plaintiffs then waived their claim that HUD skipped required notice and comment. The appeals court vacated the judgment and sent the cases back. They renewed their challenge on other grounds, and Friday’s ruling is the result.

HUD issued the 2026 notice in June 2026. The statute behind it tells HUD to “promote a community-wide commitment to the goal of ending homelessness” and to “quickly rehouse homeless individuals and families.”

14

What this means for people who need housing

The program has traditionally followed a Housing First model, placing people in permanent housing “without preconditions such as sobriety or employment,” Reuters reported. HUD has sought to move money toward interim housing and required services.

Supporters of Housing First say stable housing comes first because everything else, from treatment to work, is easier with a door that locks. Friday’s ruling doesn’t end that debate. It decides that HUD can’t use this year’s Continuum of Care competition to override what Congress wrote, or to penalize domestic violence providers, harm reduction programs and people who rely on benefits.

Bloom has also reported on HUD’s mixed-status families rule, another housing rule that will decide who keeps a home.

15

What you can do

If you depend on a Continuum of Care program, or you run one, here’s what to know now:

  1. If you lead or work for a local Continuum of Care, watch for HUD’s reopening of Tier 2. Resubmissions are due by 11:59 PM Eastern on December 1, 2026, and HUD must explain its process in a report due November 25.
  2. If you live in permanent supportive housing, ask your provider whether its grant is in Tier 1 or Tier 2 and when it renews. Tier 2 awards must be made by December 31.
  3. If you’re a survivor looking for safe housing, the National Domestic Violence Hotline, 800-799-7233, can connect you with local shelter and advocates any hour.
  4. If you run a harm reduction or domestic violence program, review the order with your Continuum of Care before you resubmit, since the vacated criteria can’t be applied.
  5. Share accurate information. Rumors spread fast when housing money is at stake.

16

What Bloom is doing

Bloom believes a home is the ground on which every other kind of healing stands, for a disabled neighbor, for a survivor, for a trans young person with nowhere else to go. The law Congress wrote for the Continuum of Care program says the same thing, and on Friday a court held HUD to it.

If this news weighs on you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach any hour, and Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading the rulings that decide who stays housed, and a one-time gift helps too.

17

Frequently Asked Questions

Judge Mary S. McElroy held that HUD’s 2026 rules unlawfully set aside $1.3 billion for transitional and services-only projects. She also vacated scoring and conditions that penalized domestic violence providers, harm reduction and people who rely on benefits.

Communities can resubmit Tier 2 applications until 11:59 PM Eastern on December 1, 2026. HUD must award all Tier 2 funds by December 31.

No. HUD must still make Tier 1 awards by December 1, 2026, as the appropriations law requires, without applying the vacated rules.

Federal laws bar many domestic violence providers from mandating services, so they couldn’t earn HUD’s points for service requirements. HUD didn’t consider that, the court found.

It vacated the executive order conditions because HUD never explained them. It didn’t reach the First Amendment challenges.

Twenty states, the District of Columbia, and the governors of Kentucky and Pennsylvania, according to the order. The state case is led by Washington, and Oregon is among the plaintiffs.

HUD Secretary Scott Turner said the agency reserves the right to appeal, according to Reuters.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.