
Newsroom·Justice for survivors·News
Canada’s Supreme Court: Survivors Don’t Have to Say No for It to Count
Canada's Supreme Court ruled Friday that no law requires a person to communicate their non-consent to sexual contact. The unanimous result upheld a conviction even though the woman never testified.
Canada’s Supreme Court ruled Friday, November 20, 2026, that there is “no legal requirement to communicate non-consent to sexual contact.” The ruling in R. v. Degale settles a basic question of consent law: a person who was assaulted doesn’t have to prove they said no, or showed it, for the law to protect them, according to the court’s judgment.
All nine justices agreed that the man’s conviction for aggravated sexual assault should stand, even though the woman never testified. A trial judge had acquitted him because there was no evidence she communicated her lack of consent. The Supreme Court of Canada called that “a clear legal error.” Here is what the consent law ruling says, where the justices split, and what it means for survivors in Canada and everywhere consent law is still being argued.
01
What the Supreme Court of Canada decided
The court dismissed Bevin Kerry Degale’s appeal. Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justice Mary Moreau wrote the main reasons, joined by Justices Côté, Rowe and Jamal. Justice Sheilah Martin wrote concurring reasons, joined by Justices Karakatsanis, Kasirer and O’Bonsawin, agreeing that the appeal should be dismissed, the judgment shows.
The trial judge “made a clear legal error when he required evidence that the complainant communicated her non-consent to the accused,” the court wrote, “as there is no legal requirement to communicate non-consent to sexual contact.”
That sentence will be quoted in Canadian courtrooms and law classrooms for years to come. Under Canada’s consent law, the question for the act itself is whether the complainant, in her own mind, did not consent. It isn’t whether she announced it.
02
What consent law requires for the act itself
The judgment lays out the basics of Canada’s consent law in plain terms. The physical act of sexual assault has three elements, the court wrote: “touching, the sexual nature of the touching, and the absence of the complainant’s subjective consent.”
For that act, consent “is determined solely by the complainant’s subjective mental state,” the court said. It’s enough for the Crown to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that, at the time of the touching, “the complainant did not, in her own mind, consent.”
That is the heart of the consent law ruling. The law looks first at the person who was touched and what they wanted, not at how loudly they objected. “Sexual touching is not itself blameworthy and it only becomes a crime in the absence of the complainant’s consent,” the court wrote.
03
The case behind the ruling
The facts come from the judgment. The complainant emerged from a van in a state of extreme distress, knocked on a neighbour’s door crying, and said someone was trying to kill her. She then went into the unit where the accused lived with his brother and sister-in-law and said the accused had raped her.
Police found physical evidence in the building and the van, and medical records showed she had “serious and multiple injuries requiring surgery,” the court wrote. She did not testify at trial or otherwise cooperate in the prosecution. The accused did not testify either.
Bloom names the convicted man because the court did. Bloom does not name the woman, and never will.
04
Why the trial judge got it wrong
The trial judge accepted that the Crown had proven the physical act of aggravated sexual assault. But he wasn’t satisfied about the man’s state of mind. He found “there was no evidence that the complainant communicated her lack of consent to the accused,” and without her account, he had a reasonable doubt, the judgment says.
In 2024, the Court of Appeal for Ontario set aside the acquittal and substituted a conviction. The same evidence that proved the act also proved the man’s state of mind, it held, and the only reasonable inference was that he knew of, or was wilfully blind or reckless about, her lack of consent.
The Supreme Court of Canada agreed. The trial judge focused on “the absence of direct evidence of communication” between the two, the court wrote, “while overlooking the evidence that was available to prove mens rea.” Mens rea is the legal term for a guilty state of mind.
05
What the Crown still has to prove
The ruling doesn’t lower the bar for convictions. The Crown must still prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused intended to touch the complainant and “knew of, or was wilfully blind or reckless as to, the complainant’s lack of consent,” the court wrote.
“This subjective fault standard for sexual assault has been settled law for decades,” Wagner and Moreau wrote, according to The Canadian Press.
What the ruling clarifies is how that can be proven. A guilty state of mind “may be proven through direct or circumstantial evidence, or a combination of both,” and evidence that proves the act can also be used to prove what the accused knew. When the Crown relies on circumstantial evidence, a judge may convict only when guilt is the only reasonable inference.
Here, the court found it was. “Guilt is, in this case, the only reasonable inference that can be drawn from the substantial circumstantial evidence led by the Crown,” the justices wrote, according to the Canadian Press.
None of this shifts the burden onto the accused. Under Canada’s consent law, the Crown carries the burden of proof, and the ruling says it must prove the accused’s guilty state of mind beyond a reasonable doubt in every case. What changes is that a judge can’t add a requirement the consent law never contained, such as proof that the survivor objected.
06
Consent law and the honest but mistaken belief defence
Canada’s consent law gives accused people a defence called honest but mistaken belief in communicated consent. It applies when the accused honestly believed the complainant had communicated consent, through words or conduct.
Parliament has restricted that defence in section 273.2 of the Criminal Code “to preclude claims of honest but mistaken belief based on myths and stereotypes about sexual consent,” the court explained. The accused must point to some evidence beyond a bare assertion, and the defence can’t go to the trier of fact without it.
In this case, the defence wasn’t available. The court’s point is that the Crown must still prove the accused’s guilty state of mind even then, and that the trial judge was wrong to treat the woman’s silence at trial as a gap in that proof.
07
Where the justices split
The nine justices agreed on the result. They disagreed about section 273.2(b), which bars the mistaken-belief defence when the accused didn’t take reasonable steps to ascertain consent.
Justice Martin’s concurrence found that the provision creates “a second, modified objective pathway to liability” in addition to proving what the accused actually knew. The majority rejected that view. “A new modified objective pathway to conviction is not mandated by the text, context and purpose of s. 273.2(b),” Wagner and Moreau wrote.
The majority acknowledged a cost to its approach. There “may be rare cases” where the accused can’t raise the defence and the Crown still can’t prove the accused’s fault, Wagner and Moreau wrote. They found that consistent with how criminal law treats defences and elements, and with what Parliament wrote.
In practice, the majority held that the Crown must always prove a subjective guilty state of mind. The concurring justices would have allowed a conviction in some cases based on a failure to take reasonable steps. Five justices make a majority on a nine-member court, so the majority’s view is now the law.
08
From “no means no” to “only yes means yes”
The concurring reasons trace how Canada’s consent law has changed. Consent “must be affirmatively communicated through the complainant’s words or conduct and cannot be implied from silence, passivity, or ambiguous behaviour,” Martin wrote.
In that sense, the concurrence said, the law has moved from a “no means no” framework to an “only yes means yes” understanding. Friday’s ruling builds on that shift from the other direction: a survivor’s silence is never consent, and the law never required a survivor to speak up first.
For survivors, this part of consent law matters in a simple way. Many people freeze, stay quiet or can’t resist. Canada’s highest court has now said, plainly, that the absence of a spoken or shown no isn’t a gap the accused can hide in.
09
A second consent law ruling the same day
The court decided a related case from Alberta on Friday. A woman had told a man more than once that he had to wear a condom, and he removed it during the encounter, according to the Canadian Press. A jury acquitted him, and the Alberta Court of Appeal ordered a new trial.
The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the new trial. The jury should have been told it couldn’t conclude the man believed the woman consented to unprotected sex unless that consent was communicated by words or conduct, the court said. “Legally impermissible paths were open to the jury,” Justice Martin wrote for the majority.
Together, the two rulings send one message about consent law in Canada, and it is the same message survivors have been trying to say for generations. Consent has to be communicated, and the absence of a no is not a yes.
10
Who else took part in the case
The court heard the appeal on May 21, 2026, according to the judgment. Several groups intervened, among them the Vancouver Rape Relief Society and the Barbra Schlifer Commemorative Clinic, which joined the case to address how consent law applies.
Prosecutors from across the country also took part. The Director of Public Prosecutions and the attorneys general of British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Alberta intervened, as did the Criminal Lawyers’ Association of Ontario, the judgment shows.
11
What the consent law ruling means for survivors who can’t testify
The woman in this case didn’t testify. Some survivors can’t, out of fear, trauma or danger. The ruling shows that a conviction can still rest on physical, forensic and medical evidence and on what witnesses saw and heard, when that evidence leaves no other reasonable explanation.
That is a meaningful change in how consent law works in practice. That doesn’t mean every case can go forward without a survivor’s account. Each case turns on its evidence, and the Crown’s burden doesn’t change. But it does mean that a trial judge can’t demand proof that a survivor said no, when the law never required it.
Bloom has followed consent law in other countries this month. In the United Kingdom, a jury convicted four men in the Joanne Young case, a case about who can consent for another person. In the United States, survivors asked the Supreme Court to decide who must report abuse disclosed to clergy.
12
What you can do
If this ruling brings up your own experience, you’re not alone. Here’s where to start:
- If you’re in the United States, RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline, 800-656-4673, answers any hour.
- If you’re in Canada, a local sexual assault centre can help you understand your options, whether or not you want to report.
- If you’re supporting a survivor, believe them. The Supreme Court of Canada has now said in plain words that no one has to communicate a no for the law to protect them.
- If you work in law, advocacy or health care, read the judgment’s summary of consent law. It sets out what the Crown must prove and how it can be proven.
- Share the ruling’s central line with care. “There is no legal requirement to communicate non-consent” is a fact survivors deserve to hear.
13
A timeline of R. v. Degale
These dates come from the judgment and the Canadian Press:
- Trial: An Ontario trial judge acquits the accused of aggravated sexual assault, finding no evidence the complainant communicated her lack of consent.
- 2024: The Court of Appeal for Ontario sets aside the acquittal and substitutes a conviction.
- May 21, 2026: The Supreme Court of Canada hears the appeal.
- November 20, 2026: The court dismisses the appeal. The conviction stands.
14
What happens next
The Supreme Court of Canada’s ruling is final, and the conviction stands. Trial courts across Canada are bound by its statement of consent law: there is no requirement to communicate non-consent, the Crown must prove the accused’s guilty state of mind, and circumstantial evidence can do that.
Prosecutors and defence lawyers will now cite this consent law ruling in sexual assault trials across the country. The split over section 273.2(b) may come back. Four justices would have read the provision more broadly, and advocates will be watching how lower courts apply the majority’s view. Bloom will follow consent law in Canada and beyond.
The case file is public at the Supreme Court of Canada’s docket, number 41525, which lists the May 21, 2026 hearing. For survivors and their advocates, the judgment itself is worth reading in full: it is one of the clearest statements of consent law any high court has written this year.
15
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with every survivor who froze, who couldn’t speak, or who never got the chance to tell a judge what happened. I believe the law should start where this court started: with what the survivor did not choose, not with whether they said so out loud.
If this story weighs on you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach any hour, and Bloom’s support groups are a place to be heard. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reporting on survivors’ rights at home and abroad, and a one-time gift helps too.
16
Frequently Asked Questions
It ruled on November 20, 2026, that there is no legal requirement to communicate non-consent to sexual contact. A trial judge who demanded that evidence made a clear legal error.
It doesn’t lower the standard. The Crown must still prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused knew of, or was wilfully blind or reckless about, the lack of consent.
No. Neither the complainant nor the accused testified. The conviction rests on physical, forensic and medical evidence and on witness testimony.
No. The court said there’s no legal requirement to communicate non-consent. For the act itself, consent depends only on the complainant’s own state of mind.
All nine agreed the appeal should be dismissed. Four justices, in reasons by Justice Sheilah Martin, disagreed with the majority about section 273.2(b) of the Criminal Code.
It lets an accused argue they honestly believed the complainant communicated consent. Parliament has restricted it to bar claims based on myths and stereotypes.
Consent must be communicated through words or conduct and can’t be implied from silence, passivity or ambiguous behaviour, the concurring justices wrote.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Justice for survivors · 20 November 2026Judge Strikes HUD’s $1.3 Billion Shift Away From Permanent Housing
New Jersey Legislature · 20 November 2026New Jersey Ends Statute of Limitations for Human Trafficking
Minnesota Legislature · 20 November 2026Minnesota Finds Bemidji Schools Failed to Protect Students From Staff