A historic building on the state hospital campus in Pueblo, Colorado, for a report on the forced medication ruling

NewsroomColorado LegislatureNews

Colorado Court: Forced Medication by Nose Tube Needs Its Own Proof

A Colorado appeals court says a judge can't let a state hospital force medication through a tube in a patient's nose unless the state separately proves no less intrusive way will work. The published ruling came Thursday, November 19.

A historic building on the grounds of Colorado's state hospital in Pueblo.

This article discusses involuntary psychiatric treatment. It contains no graphic detail.

A Colorado appeals court ruled on Thursday, November 19, 2026, that a judge can’t approve forced medication through a tube in a patient’s nose just because the medicine itself has been approved. The state must separately prove, by clear and convincing evidence, that no less intrusive way of giving the drug would work, the Colorado Court of Appeals held.

The decision is published, so it can be cited as precedent in Colorado courts. It treats a nasogastric tube as what it is: a separate intrusion into a person’s body, not a detail in a treatment plan. For people with psychiatric disabilities, and for families who love them, here is what the court decided about forced medication, why it matters, and what you can do.

01

What the court decided about forced medication

The case is No. 26CA1595, decided by a three-judge division of the Colorado Court of Appeals. Judge Lipinsky wrote the opinion, and Judges Harris and Gomez agreed. The court vacated part of an order from the Pueblo County District Court.

That order had let staff at the Colorado Mental Health Hospital in Pueblo give a patient valproic acid, a mood stabilizer, against his will “by mouth or [NG] tube.” The appeals court left the rest of the order alone but threw out the authorization to use the tube.

The court “expressly” held that “a request for authorization to administer medication through an NG tube requires its own Medina analysis,” backed by clear and convincing evidence. A record that supports forced medication with a particular drug “is not, by that fact alone, sufficient to justify administration of the medication by NG tube.”

02

The patient at the center of the case

Bloom isn’t naming the patient, a man treated at the state hospital in Pueblo, or describing his health beyond what the ruling needs. The opinion says the hospital began giving him two medications on an emergency basis in July 2026, after what it described as aggressive behavior and threatening statements.

Later that month, the state asked the court to approve involuntary medication: up to 40 milligrams of olanzapine a day by mouth or injection, and up to 4,000 milligrams of valproic acid a day by mouth or NG tube. The petition didn’t explain why the state wanted the option of a tube, the appeals court noted.

The patient testified at the hearing, along with his treating psychiatrist. On appeal, his lawyer argued that the state never showed that a tube was the least intrusive way to give him the medicine.

03

What happened at the hearing

The district court held a hearing in August 2026 and granted the petition. According to the appeals court, the nasogastric tube came up only twice, both times when the doctor confirmed the request for the drug “by mouth or [NG] tube daily.”

The state’s lawyer asked the psychiatrist one question about alternatives: whether any other way of treating the patient would be “both effective and less intrusive than the requested medications.” The answer was, “No, I don’t believe so.”

No one asked whether giving the drug by mouth would work as well as a tube, or why the tube was needed at all. “The People presented no evidence, and the court made no findings,” the appeals court wrote, on why a tube was needed on top of giving the drug by mouth. That gap sank the forced medication order’s tube provision.

04

Why a tube is its own question

The court explained why a tube is different from the drug it carries. It pointed to a 1990 U.S. Supreme Court case, Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health, and to Justice Sandra Day O’Connor’s concurring opinion there.

O’Connor wrote that feeding a patient by nasogastric tube “requires a physician to pass a long flexible tube through the patient’s nose, throat, and esophagus and into the stomach.” Because of the discomfort, she wrote, many patients have to be restrained.

The Colorado court drew the lesson plainly. “The intrusion worked by forcing a tube into a resisting patient is distinct in kind from the intrusion worked by the drug itself,” it wrote. That’s why forced medication by tube must be judged as its own question, with its own proof.

05

A question Colorado hadn’t squarely answered

The court said the case raised a question that earlier Colorado opinions hadn’t squarely addressed: whether forced medication by tube is a separate question from forced medication itself. Its answer was yes.

An earlier Colorado appeals decision, from 2016, had touched the issue in a footnote. That division said, “without significant analysis,” that the Medina test governed a patient’s challenge to medication by NG tube, and it upheld the tube order for some drugs in that case.

This time the court took the question head on. It rejected the state’s argument that Medina’s third element doesn’t cover “the route of administration.” Earlier decisions had already applied that element to different forms of a drug, the court noted, such as pills instead of injections. A tube, it reasoned, belongs in the same analysis of forced medication.

06

The four-part Medina test

Since 1985, Colorado has used a four-part test from People v. Medina, a Colorado Supreme Court case, to decide when the state may medicate a patient against their will. The state must prove each part by clear and convincing evidence, which the court describes as evidence that is “highly probable and free from serious or substantial doubt.”

Under Medina, the state must show all four of these:

  1. The patient can’t effectively take part in the treatment decision.
  2. The medication is needed to prevent a significant and likely long-term decline in the patient’s mental condition, or to prevent serious harm to the patient or others.
  3. A less intrusive treatment alternative isn’t available.
  4. The patient’s need for treatment is compelling enough to override the patient’s legitimate interest in refusing it.

This ruling is about the third part. Medina says that “if less intrusive methods are available to effectively redress these concerns, then clearly the court should deny the motion for nonconsensual treatment.” The court held that this applies to how a drug is given, not just to which drug is given.

07

Medina, Sell and the purpose of forced medication

Colorado courts use different tests depending on why the state wants forced medication. A test from the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2003 decision in Sell v. United States applies when the state wants to medicate a person to make them competent to stand trial, the opinion explains.

This case wasn’t about that. The state sought forced medication to prevent the patient’s long-term deterioration, so both sides agreed that Medina applied. The court still looked to cases decided under Sell, including the 2006 Virginia case, because they ask the same basic question about tubes.

For families, the lesson is simple. Ask which test applies, because the purpose of forced medication shapes what the state has to prove.

08

What the doctor said about side effects

At the hearing, the psychiatrist described valproic acid’s main side effects, including hair loss, weight gain, an unsteady gait, stomach upset, tremors and sweating. In rare cases, he said, it can cause liver injury or inflammation of the pancreas. He explained how staff watch for side effects and that other medicines can ease them.

On appeal, the patient’s lawyer also argued that those side effects weighed against forced medication by tube under Medina’s fourth element. Because the court ruled for the patient on the third element, it didn’t need to decide that argument.

09

What the Constitution protects

Forced medication is never a small thing in American law, and courts have long treated it that way. The opinion opens by quoting an earlier Colorado case, which quoted the U.S. Supreme Court: giving medication to a person who doesn’t consent “represents a substantial interference with that person’s liberty.”

That Supreme Court case is Washington v. Harper, decided in 1990. The justices allowed a state to medicate a prisoner with a serious mental illness in some circumstances. But they also recognized that the prisoner had “a liberty interest under the Clause in being free from the arbitrary administration of such medication.”

The Colorado court said the intrusion is “particularly severe” with psychotropic drugs, because they threaten a patient’s “mental and bodily integrity.” Bodily integrity is the heart of this case. A person doesn’t lose it by being sick, or by being in a hospital.

10

What other courts have said

The Colorado court found support in other states and in federal court. In a 2006 case, a federal judge in Virginia approved an antipsychotic medication but refused to approve giving it by NG tube, because the government hadn’t proved the tube was needed and a dissolving tablet was available.

An Illinois appeals court reached a similar result in 2014, ruling that the state must present specific testimony about the procedure, not just name it in a petition. A Minnesota court went the other way in 1995, but only because experts testified that a tube was the only way left to give a necessary drug.

Taken together, the Colorado court said, these cases show that a petition for forced medication by tube must be backed by evidence about the tube itself.

11

What the ruling changes in Colorado

The opinion sets a clear rule for Colorado’s involuntary medication hearings. If a hospital wants permission to use a nasogastric tube, it has to ask for it and prove it, under the third Medina element, with clear and convincing evidence.

In practice, that means a doctor should explain why a tube is needed, what less intrusive options were considered, and why they won’t work. A judge should then make findings on those questions. A bare request in a petition, or a doctor’s one-word confirmation, isn’t enough.

The ruling doesn’t stop hospitals from seeking forced medication, and it doesn’t bar tubes in every case of forced medication. It requires proof. For a person who can’t consent, that proof is the line between care and force.

12

Why this matters to disabled people

People with psychiatric disabilities are among the few Americans whom the state may medicate against their will. That power is real, and sometimes it’s used to save a life. But it has to be used with care, and the law has to make the state show its work.

This ruling does that. It reminds every court in Colorado that a patient’s body is not a place where the state’s convenience wins by default. If medicine can be given by mouth, a tube through the nose has to be justified by evidence, not assumed.

Bloom has long reported on disabled people’s right to live and be treated with dignity, from Hoosiers rallying to keep in-home care to a Justice Department lawsuit over service animals. Dignity in a hospital ward is part of the same fight.

13

A timeline of the case

These dates come from the Colorado Court of Appeals opinion:

  • 2025: The patient is admitted to the Colorado Mental Health Hospital in Pueblo.
  • July 2026: The hospital begins emergency medication, then the state files a petition for involuntary medication, including valproic acid “by mouth or NG tube.”
  • August 2026: The Pueblo County District Court holds a hearing and grants the petition.
  • November 19, 2026: The Colorado Court of Appeals vacates the part of the order allowing the NG tube, in a published opinion.

14

What patients and families can do

If someone you love is facing a petition for forced medication in Colorado, these steps may help. None of them replaces a lawyer’s advice about a specific forced medication case.

  1. Get a lawyer involved early. In this case, the patient had a lawyer who challenged the tube on appeal, and won.
  2. Read the petition closely. Look for the drug, the dose and the method. If it says “by mouth or NG tube,” ask why a tube is included.
  3. Ask about less intrusive options. Under this ruling, the state must prove by clear and convincing evidence that a tube is needed. Ask what else was tried, and whether a dissolving or liquid form exists.
  4. Ask the judge for findings. The ruling faults the lower court for making no findings on the tube. Findings matter on appeal.
  5. Call for help. Disability Justice, formerly Disability Law Colorado, is the state’s protection and advocacy organization. Its website explains how to ask for help.
  6. In a crisis, call or text 988. The Suicide and Crisis Lifeline is open any hour.

15

What happens next

The order allowing the tube is gone, and the rest of the order stands. The state could ask the Colorado Supreme Court to review the decision. Unless that court steps in, Colorado judges and hospitals now have a published opinion that requires separate proof before forced medication by NG tube.

Bloom will watch for how state hospitals change their forced medication petitions, and whether other states follow Colorado’s reasoning. We’ll report what we find.

16

What Bloom is doing

Bloom stands with disabled people in every place where their bodies are at stake, including psychiatric hospitals. I believe a person who can’t consent deserves more protection, not less, and a court that asks the hard questions is a court doing its job.

If this news stirs up hard memories, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and Bloom’s disability advocacy work and support groups are here for you.

A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading rulings like this one and explaining them in plain words, and a one-time gift helps too.

17

Frequently Asked Questions

It held on November 19, 2026, that a request to give medication against a patient’s will through a nasogastric tube needs its own clear and convincing evidence that no less intrusive method would work.

It’s a tube passed through the nose, throat and esophagus into the stomach. Courts have recognized it as an intrusion separate from the medication it carries.

It’s the four-part test from People v. Medina, a 1985 Colorado Supreme Court case, that the state must meet by clear and convincing evidence before forced medication of a patient who can’t consent.

No. Hospitals can still seek forced medication, and a court can approve it when the state proves all four Medina elements. The ruling requires separate proof before a tube is used.

The court describes it as evidence that is “highly probable and free from serious or substantial doubt.” It’s a higher bar than the usual civil standard, and it applies to every part of the Medina test for forced medication.

It applies in Colorado involuntary medication cases. Because the opinion is published, it can be cited as precedent in Colorado courts.

Disability Justice, formerly Disability Law Colorado, is the state’s protection and advocacy system. In a mental health crisis, call or text 988.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.