A lone cloud over sagebrush on Wyoming's high desert, for a report on the punitive isolation verdict

NewsroomWyoming LegislatureNews

Jury Awards $6 Million for Punitive Isolation at Wyoming Boys’ School

A teenager in Wyoming's custody was locked alone in a cinderblock room as punishment, a federal jury found, and it awarded him $6 million. It's the first of six former residents' trials; the next starts December 7.

A teenager in Wyoming’s custody was locked alone as punishment, not for safety, a federal jury in Casper, Wyoming, decided late Thursday, November 19, 2026, and it awarded him $6 million. The unanimous verdict holds two Wyoming Boys’ School staff members liable for punitive isolation, in the first of six former residents’ trials. Blaise Chivers-King spent several stretches in 2020 and 2021 locked in 7-by-10-foot cinderblock detention rooms at the state facility, WyoFile reported.

Those two are Superintendent Dale Weber and Dorm Supervisor Mike Nelson. The next former resident’s trial is set to start December 7. Here’s what punitive isolation means, what the jury decided and what it didn’t, what due process requires when the state holds a child, and what families can do now.

01

What the jury decided in the punitive isolation case

Jurors in the U.S. District Court in Casper took about seven hours to reach their decisions after an eight-day trial, WyoFile reported. They found that Weber and Nelson subjected Chivers-King to punitive isolation, in violation of the 14th Amendment. They didn’t rule for him on a claim of excessive force against Thad Shaffer, a security manager at the school.

Of the $6 million, $5 million is punitive damages and $1 million is compensatory damages, his attorney Ciara Anderson Boerman confirmed to Cowboy State Daily. Punitive damages are “money intended to punish particularly wrongful conduct,” the outlet explained. Boerman said the bulk of the damages stemmed from the punitive isolation claim, and the damages were assessed against two of the three defendants.

The jury also found for Chivers-King on a due process claim, Cowboy State Daily reported. But the defendant “successfully asserted an affirmative defense that prevented that finding from producing liability.”

“We are so proud of our client,” attorney Allison Mahoney told WyoFile. “This was not easy for him to sit in court and listen to testimony.”

02

Who Blaise Chivers-King is

Chivers-King was 15 when he was first admitted to the Wyoming Boys’ School, and he spent two stints there between 2020 and 2022, between the ages of 15 and 17. The school detains delinquent boys ages 12 to 21 on a 38-acre campus near Worland overseen by the Wyoming Department of Family Services, WyoFile reports.

He and two other former residents filed their federal lawsuit in February 2024, and three more joined later that year. Six former residents now have claims, alleging abuse that includes extended periods of solitary confinement and physical harm, WyoFile reported in October. Now a young man, Chivers-King testified about his confinement in open court.

“Instead of helping him manage his emotions, they locked him away,” Boerman told jurors in her opening statement. She called him “a difficult child, but still a child.” At some points, she said, he no longer wanted to live. If that sentence lands heavy, you can call or text 988 at any hour.

03

What punitive isolation means

Punitive isolation means locking a young person alone to punish them, or keeping them locked away after the danger has passed. The school doesn’t call it isolation. It calls the practice “detention status,” and the state denies it uses solitary confinement.

U.S. District Judge Scott Skavdahl wasn’t persuaded the name settled anything. Many of the school’s uses of detention status “bear the hallmarks of isolation,” he wrote in an October ruling, Cowboy State Daily reported.

The line between safety and punishment is the heart of a punitive isolation claim. Skavdahl pointed to evidence that some uses of isolation “were, or became, simply punishment or unrelated to management of a safety threat.” Staff expected Chivers-King to show a “credible” commitment to safety with two days of good behavior in detention before release, WyoFile reported.

Skavdahl pointed to November 18, 2021, when Chivers-King broke a sprinkler head. Weber and Nelson then signed a memo placing him in isolation “at least until November 22, 2021.” Notes said he “began to calm down” that evening. Release dates “being fixed and noncontingent on behavior, were divorced from the safety risks,” the judge wrote.

04

Inside the detention rooms

WyoFile described 7-by-10-foot cinderblock rooms. Skavdahl’s ruling put them at about 8 by 10 feet, Cowboy State Daily reported. The white rooms are bare except for a toilet and a mattress that staff provided at night. They don’t have windows that look outside, and staff at times covered the window in the door with a magnet.

During his first placement, Chivers-King was kept in isolation conditions for more than 42 days in all, and during his second for more than 32 days, the October ruling states. One stretch lasted 15 days. His punitive isolation claims at trial covered several periods in 2020 and 2021.

“I felt like I was tricked,” he told the jury, describing how good behavior didn’t get him out. Without people or sunlight, time moved “extremely slow,” he said. “It felt like a never-ending whirlpool, like a blackhole.” And simply: “I just needed someone to talk to,” he testified, as WyoFile reported.

05

What due process requires for young people in custody

Boys’ School residents are adjudicated delinquents, a legal category distinct from convicted criminals. That’s why Chivers-King’s claims ran through the 14th Amendment’s guarantee of due process. For juveniles judged delinquent, force claims that would normally fall under the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment go under the 14th instead, Cowboy State Daily explained.

Due process works in two ways here. The first is about substance: the state can’t punish a young person it holds without a legitimate purpose, and the 14th Amendment protects detained people from arbitrary punishment, WyoFile explained. That’s the punitive isolation claim the jury decided. The second is about process: Skavdahl let a claim go to trial that Weber put Chivers-King in punitive isolation without notice or a hearing.

The judge cited two 10th Circuit decisions, Milonas v. Williams and Blackmon v. Sutton. They “clearly establish such use of isolation to punish juveniles not convicted of a crime is unconstitutional,” he wrote. The 10th Circuit has voiced “clear skepticism of the use of isolation, especially for children,” he added.

06

The ruling that sent punitive isolation claims to a jury

Before trial, the state asked for qualified immunity. That doctrine shields officials unless their conduct violates “clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known,” the ruling explains. Skavdahl denied it on the punitive isolation claims.

Not every claim survived. The judge reviewed video of one incident and threw out an excessive force claim against Mike Nelson. He denied a disability discrimination claim, and Chivers-King dropped a claim about medical needs. On September 10, the court granted the state’s request for separate trials for each of the six former residents.

07

The state’s answer to the punitive isolation claim

Lawyers for the state said staff were responding to safety concerns and did their best in hard circumstances. Defense attorney Scott Ortiz reminded jurors that Chivers-King’s time there overlapped with the COVID-19 pandemic. “I cannot think about a more difficult task than having to fulfill their legitimate governmental objectives under those circumstances,” he said.

Chivers-King testified that there were times he assaulted staff, and he agreed he should have been separated for some time, WyoFile’s Maya Shimizu Harris told Wyoming Public Radio. His lawyers argued he stayed locked in after he’d calmed down. “He was unpredictable, volatile,” Weber testified. “We believe he presented a fairly significant danger.”

The defense also tried to shift responsibility to the former superintendent, Gary Gilmore, who has since died. “I don’t believe I had any authority to challenge his decisions,” Weber testified. Boerman noted that Nelson and Weber signed documents on Chivers-King’s detention. “That’s convenient, but that’s not accountability,” she said.

08

What the expert witnesses said

Forensic psychologist Dr. Max Wachtel testified that Chivers-King had PTSD “directly caused by his isolation time at the Wyoming Boys’ School.” He said the detention rooms “were well below the standard of care and, when compared to other juvenile facilities, way more dangerous,” WyoFile reported.

Massachusetts psychiatrist Stuart Grassian described “a culture of total control and domination,” in WyoFile’s account.

Another expert, Dr. Dominique Sotelo, an associate professor of clinical mental health counseling, disagreed. “I believe that the strict definition of solitary confinement pertaining to Blaise Chivers-King was not met,” Sotelo testified. The defense also said Chivers-King’s mental health struggles, including PTSD, began before he came to the school. The experts argued over the label, but the jury’s question was narrower: was this punitive isolation?

09

The logbooks at the center of the trial

Staff are required to check students in detention by camera every five minutes and in person every 15 minutes, Harris told Wyoming Public Radio. The dorm logbooks record those checks.

Based on the logbook entries, Chivers-King on most days interacted with other people for less than an hour and was let out of the room only to shower, WyoFile reported. Entries didn’t show that he got schoolwork on most days.

Staff told the jury the logbooks were an incomplete picture. “The kid wanted somebody to love him and care about him, and that’s what we tried to do,” supervisor Bryan DuPree testified, as WyoFile reported. Nelson called the logbooks “incredibly incomplete.” The jury weighed both accounts and found punitive isolation.

10

The court record: what the state told the court

Bloom read the state’s own answer to the lawsuit, dated April 29, 2024, from the Wyoming Attorney General’s Office in Case No. 24-CV-00039-SWS and posted by WyoFile. Again and again, it says the defendants “deny that the Wyoming Boys’ School uses solitary confinement.”

The answer admits that, under school policy, “detention status may be used when a resident is an immediate threat to himself or others for the least amount of time necessary.” It admits that detention over one hour requires approval from the superintendent, the deputy superintendent or the duty superintendent.

That policy is a measure a jury could weigh against a claim of punitive isolation. Chivers-King’s lawyers argued that a fixed two-day minimum kept him locked in long after “the least amount of time necessary” had passed. The answer also pleads “Qualified, governmental, and/or sovereign immunity” and says punitive damages would violate the defendants’ own due process rights.

11

The federal standard for room confinement

Congress drew a clear line for federal cases on December 21, 2018. Federal law now bars room confinement of young people in federal juvenile facilities “for discipline, punishment, retaliation, or any reason other than as a temporary response” to a serious and immediate risk of physical harm, under section 5043 of Title 18.

A young person must be released “immediately when the covered juvenile has sufficiently gained control,” the law says. The outer limit is three hours when the risk is to others and 30 minutes when the risk is only to the young person.

That law covers young people in federal cases, not a state facility like the Wyoming Boys’ School. It shows how far a two-day minimum sits from the federal rule against punitive isolation. “I hope this sends a message that legislation needs to be enacted in Wyoming to address solitary confinement,” Mahoney said after the verdict.

12

What the verdict settles, and what it doesn’t

It settles that a unanimous jury, after hearing both sides, found two state employees subjected a child in their care to punitive isolation. That finding now sits in the public record.

It doesn’t settle the money or the last word. The court must still enter judgment, and the defendants could ask the judge to overturn or reduce the award, or appeal, Cowboy State Daily reported. Any appeal would go to the 10th Circuit, the federal appeals court over Wyoming’s federal courts. “There could be appeals, or it’s unclear what the defense will do,” Boerman said.

It doesn’t find that every day he spent in detention was punitive isolation; the judge wrote that some placements may have been legitimate. It doesn’t decide the five cases still to come, and it doesn’t tell us what happens inside the school today.

13

Five more trials ahead

The court split the six former residents’ claims into separate trials. Another former resident’s trial, also alleging improper isolation, is scheduled to start on December 7, Wyoming Public Radio reported.

All six asserted claims relating to isolation, WyoFile reported, so the punitive isolation question will return at each trial. Some of the former residents allege psychological and emotional abuse and improper use of restraints, Wyoming Public Radio reported. The school denies the claims. Bloom isn’t naming the other former residents, who haven’t yet had their day in court.

14

A timeline of the punitive isolation case

These dates come from WyoFile, Cowboy State Daily, Wyoming Public Radio and the court record:

  • 2020 to 2022: Chivers-King spends two stints at the Wyoming Boys’ School, between the ages of 15 and 17.
  • 2021: With juvenile justice the Joint Judiciary Committee’s top interim priority, State Rep. Karlee Provenza says she questions officials about solitary confinement and restraints.
  • November 18 to 22, 2021: A signed memo holds him in isolation for a fixed period, the judge later notes.
  • February 2024: Chivers-King and two others file their federal lawsuit.
  • April 29, 2024: The state’s answer denies that the school uses solitary confinement.
  • September 10, 2026: The court orders separate trials for the six former residents.
  • October 2026: Judge Skavdahl sends the punitive isolation claims to a jury.
  • November 9, 2026: Trial opens in Casper before eight jurors.
  • November 19, 2026: Closing arguments in the morning; the unanimous punitive isolation verdict comes late that day.
  • December 7, 2026: The next former resident’s trial is scheduled to begin.

15

Lawmakers, the state and the call for oversight

Provenza, a Laramie Democrat, wants the school overhauled after the punitive isolation verdict. “We have failed so many young people in our state,” she told Cowboy State Daily. She said Weber should be removed and called for a full investigation. “A third, independent party should be responsible for investigating youth-detention facilities,” she said.

“The Department refutes any allegations of wrongdoing,” a Department of Family Services spokesman said in February 2024. “We do not tolerate abuse and deny any allegations of wrongdoing,” the department said in July 2024. Citing juvenile privacy laws, the department has shared little about conditions at the school, WyoFile reports. Its news page listed no statement on the verdict when Bloom checked November 21.

According to U.S. Justice Department data, Wyoming has long had some of the highest rates of locking up young people in the nation, Harris told Wyoming Public Radio. The rate has gone down, but it’s still above the national average.

16

What happens next

The court must still enter judgment, and the defense may ask the judge to overturn or reduce the award, or appeal. On December 7, the next former resident’s trial is scheduled to begin in federal court.

Provenza says the Legislature and Wyoming’s incoming governor should take up how the state treats young people, from detention to mental health care. “There are many aspects of how we handle youth that are not adequately addressed, most importantly mental health,” she said. Bloom will follow each punitive isolation trial and report what changes.

17

What families can do: a checklist

If someone you love is in a juvenile facility, in Wyoming or anywhere, and you fear punitive isolation, here’s where to start:

  1. If a young person is in danger now, call 911. The Department of Family Services says so plainly.
  2. Report suspected abuse or neglect of a child. In Wyoming, contact the local DFS office, as its reporting page says. State law says any person who suspects child abuse or neglect “is required to report.” DFS’s toll-free line is 800-457-3659.
  3. Bring a complaint about a DFS case to the ombudsman. The DFS Ombudsman is at 307-777-6597.
  4. If the young person has a disability, including a mental health condition, call Protection & Advocacy System. Wyoming’s protection and advocacy system “has federal authority to gain access to facilities, records, and persons to investigate allegations of abuse and neglect.” Call (307) 632-3496.
  5. Report a civil rights violation to the U.S. Justice Department. Use the Civil Rights Division’s online form or call 1-855-856-1247. Its Special Litigation Section works to protect children’s rights “in all stages of the juvenile justice system” and reviews youth detention facilities under the Civil Rights of Institutionalized Persons Act.
  6. Ask, in writing, why a young person is confined and what will end it. Due process starts with knowing the reason and the way out, and it’s the first protection against punitive isolation.
  7. Write everything down. Keep dates, times, names and what the young person tells you, and ask their lawyer about records like detention logbooks.

18

Where to get help now

If this story stirs up your own time in a locked room, you’re not alone, and it wasn’t your fault. Call or text 988 any hour. Trans Lifeline is 877-565-8860, and The Trevor Project is 1-866-488-7386.

For readers in Oregon, here’s the line to call about a child’s safety. Oregon Child Abuse Hotline: 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233). Bloom’s crisis support page lists more people you can call.

19

What Bloom is doing

Bloom has followed people hurt inside institutions that were supposed to keep them safe, from the Glen Mills Schools lawsuit in Pennsylvania to New York’s first Adult Survivors Act prison trial. A boy who is struggling is still a child of God, and the state that locks the door owes him a way out. No child should learn what punitive isolation means from the inside.

Hear me, if you were ever that child: what was done to you was not your sentence to carry. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reporting every trial still ahead, and a one-time gift helps too.

20

Frequently Asked Questions

On November 19, 2026, a unanimous federal jury in Casper found that Superintendent Dale Weber and Dorm Supervisor Mike Nelson subjected former resident Blaise Chivers-King to punitive isolation. It awarded $6 million and rejected an excessive force claim against a third staff member.

It’s locking a young person alone to punish them, or keeping them there after any danger has passed. The 14th Amendment protects detained young people from arbitrary punishment.

His attorney told Cowboy State Daily that $5 million is punitive damages and $1 million is compensatory damages, assessed against two of the three defendants.

Not yet. The court must enter judgment, and the defendants could ask the judge to overturn or reduce the award, or appeal to the 10th Circuit.

Yes. Six former residents have claims, and each gets a separate trial. The next is scheduled to start December 7, 2026.

Call 911 in an emergency, report suspected abuse to the local DFS office in Wyoming, and contact Protection & Advocacy System at (307) 632-3496 or the U.S. Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division at 1-855-856-1247.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.