
Newsroom·Trans advocacy·News
West Bengal Police to Vet Who Counts as Transgender for State Jobs
West Bengal says trans people who want jobs in its new Transgender Brigade, directing traffic or collecting property tax, must first pass police checks of identity and citizenship. In three cities, the checks run until December 10.
Transgender people in Kolkata, Howrah and Bidhannagar who want paid work in West Bengal’s planned Transgender Brigade, directing traffic or collecting property tax, will first have their identity and citizenship checked by police. The police checks run until December 10, and only after them will officials draw up the final list of people eligible for the jobs, Millennium Post reported on Saturday, November 21, 2026.
Officials say the screening is meant to keep out people they call impostors, along with people from Bangladesh who they allege are living in the state and posing as hijras. For trans applicants, it means a police station now stands between them and a stipend. Here’s what the Transgender Brigade is, who asked for the screening, what India’s law says about who decides whether someone is transgender, and the questions the plan leaves open.
01
The Transgender Brigade at a glance
What the reports say, in brief:
- The jobs: traffic management and municipal property-tax collection, for a stipend or fixed honorarium.
- The screening: police checks of identity and citizenship in Kolkata, Howrah and Bidhannagar, until December 10.
- Who oversees it: a screening committee led by Moumita Godara Basu, a senior official of the state’s women and child development department.
- The model: what officials call the Maharashtra or Mumbai model.
- The start: recruitment under the Transgender Brigade in January 2027, Millennium Post reports.
- Later cities: Siliguri, Asansol and Haldia are likely in a second phase.
02
What police are checking for the Transgender Brigade
Police will carry out “special surveillance and investigations” across police station areas in the three cities until December 10, before anyone is hired for the Transgender Brigade, Millennium Post reported. The aim, the paper said, is to find people the state counts as members of the third gender and to detect people it says are posing as transgender.
The Times of India described a plan to “verify the credentials of transgender applicants for govt jobs.” Officials told the paper that identity and citizenship checks for Transgender Brigade applicants would happen at police stations, with help from established transgender associations.
The reports differ on timing. Millennium Post says the screening has begun. The Times of India and the IANS news agency describe it as planned. All three agree on who would screen the Transgender Brigade: the police.
03
What the Transgender Brigade jobs would be
Urban Development and Municipal Affairs Minister Agnimitra Paul announced the Transgender Brigade on Thursday, November 19. “We are creating a brigade comprising our friends from the third-gender community,” Paul said, according to UNI, which reported the initiative would be called the Brihannala Brigade.
Under the plan, people in the Transgender Brigade would help manage traffic and run road-safety campaigns on “wearing helmets, fastening seat belts and refraining from spitting on roads,” Millennium Post reported. They may also collect municipal house and property taxes for a “fixed honorarium.”
“We want to provide them with a dignified livelihood,” Paul said, the Times of India reported. “The govt will pay them a stipend for their work.” Transgender Brigade volunteers would get police training before working at traffic intersections, and municipal inspectors would teach them to collect overdue property taxes.
04
Why officials say the Transgender Brigade needs screening
The state began the identification work after complaints from trans people about others “posing as third-gender persons,” Millennium Post reported. The complaints described people who beg at traffic signals and “visit households to bless newborn babies,” which the NALSA judgment describes as part of the traditional work of hijras.
Officials also say they’ve received information about alleged extortion, including by people suspected of entering West Bengal from Bangladesh. The Times of India reported that trans rights activists told Paul about such claims, and that Paul then directed police and officials to find the people involved.
These are allegations from officials and activists. None of the reports Bloom read describes a charge, a case or a count of people involved. The state hasn’t said how police will tell a Transgender Brigade applicant from someone it suspects is posing as one.
05
What trans leaders in Bengal have said
The push for screening came partly from within. Activist Ranjita Sinha, whom IANS calls one of the leading faces of the trans rights movement in West Bengal, gave the state information on alleged extortion, IANS reported. She called the Transgender Brigade plan a positive step and said “only genuine transgender persons of Indian origin should get the benefit of the exercise.”
Debika Barua, a content creator and trans rights activist, agreed. “There is no point in enabling outsiders to enjoy the benefits of such exercises,” Barua told IANS.
Bloom found no public statement opposing the police screening from a West Bengal trans group in the coverage it read. So this isn’t a simple story of officials against trans people. Some trans leaders want the Transgender Brigade jobs protected, and the real question is who does the checking, and how.
06
The “Maharashtra model” Bengal says it will copy
“The Maharashtra model of screening will be adopted here as well,” an official told the Times of India. According to IANS, a state government source said Maharashtra had begun giving trans people government assignments “after conducting a similar screening exercise to verify their credentials.”
Millennium Post calls it the Mumbai model, “where transgender persons have been recruited to help enforce traffic regulations.” Bloom couldn’t find a separate published account of how Maharashtra’s screening works, so we can’t say what Bengal is copying for the Transgender Brigade.
07
Who runs the Transgender Brigade screening
A screening committee oversees the work. The Times of India and IANS describe its head, Moumita Godara Basu, as secretary of the state’s women and child development and social welfare department; Millennium Post calls her principal secretary of women and child development.
The department is working with “established transgender organisations to prepare police station-wise lists,” Millennium Post reported. “The screening will be done at the police station level,” IANS reported, with associations of trans people helping the police.
IANS also reported that the Transgender Brigade plan covers “biological transgender persons and those who have undergone sex reassignment surgery (SRS).” That phrase matters, because India’s top court has said surgery can’t be the price of recognition.
08
What India’s Supreme Court said in 2014
On April 15, 2014, the Supreme Court of India decided National Legal Services Authority against the Union of India, known as the NALSA judgment. It declared that “Transgender persons’ right to decide their self-identified gender is also upheld,” and told the national and state governments to grant legal recognition.
The NALSA judgment went further. It said “any insistence for SRS for declaring one’s gender is immoral and illegal.” It described gender identity as “each person’s deeply felt internal and individual experience of gender,” and it said “Self-determination of gender is an integral part of personal autonomy and self-expression.”
The court also directed governments to treat trans people as socially and educationally backward classes and to extend reservation in public appointments. In plain words, the Supreme Court told the state to recognize people as they know themselves, and to open doors to public jobs. Those words are the backdrop for the Transgender Brigade.
09
What the 2019 Transgender Persons Act promised
After the NALSA judgment, Parliament passed the Transgender Persons Act of 2019. Section 4 said: “A person recognised as transgender under sub-section (1) shall have a right to self-perceived gender identity.”
Under sections 5 and 6, a District Magistrate issues a certificate of identity. Section 9, which matters most for the Transgender Brigade, says, “No establishment shall discriminate against any transgender person in any matter relating to employment including, but not limited to, recruitment.” Section 8 says government welfare schemes must be “transgender sensitive, non-stigmatising and non-discriminatory.”
The 2020 Rules spelled out the process. A District Magistrate processes the application based on the applicant’s affidavit, “without any medical or physical examination,” the Rules say.
10
How Parliament changed the law in 2026
That isn’t the whole law anymore. In March 2026, Parliament passed the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Amendment Bill, 2026, by voice vote. LiveLaw reported that it takes away the right of self-determination of gender.
The bill struck section 4’s promise of a self-perceived gender identity. It rewrote the definition of a transgender person around socio-cultural identities such as kinner, hijra, aravani and jogta, people with intersex variations, and people forced into a transgender identity. The new definition excludes “persons with different sexual orientations and self-perceived sexual identities,” Bar and Bench noted, “removing self-identification as a standalone basis for recognition under the Act.”
A District Magistrate now issues a certificate of identity only “after examining the recommendation of the authority,” which the bill defines as “a medical board, headed by a Chief Medical Officer or a Deputy Chief Medical Officer.” The government’s statement of reasons says the law should “protect only those who face severe social exclusion due to biological reasons.”
11
The Supreme Court challenge, still pending
The amendment received the President’s assent on March 30, 2026, according to LiveLaw and the Supreme Court Observer; Bar and Bench reported March 31. A lawyer for the petitioners told the Supreme Court it took effect on May 25, 2026, the Supreme Court Observer reported.
On May 4, the court refused to pause the law and sent the case to a three-judge bench, LiveLaw reported. Chief Justice Surya Kant asked whether people could pose as transgender for benefits. “In this country of 140 crore people, some can masquerade this facility for the grant of reservations also, isn’t it?” he asked, Bar and Bench reported. Senior Advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi answered, “I have checked up. There is no reservation.”
On August 17, the national government said identity cards issued before the amendment will continue, subject to the outcome of the case, the Supreme Court Observer reported. The case, led by Laxmi Narayan Tripathi, is pending before three judges.
12
The question this police screening raises
Put the pieces side by side. The NALSA judgment calls self-identification a right. The 2026 amendment replaced that with a medical board and a District Magistrate. The Transgender Brigade screening adds a third gatekeeper: police officers, working from lists drawn up with community organizations.
Neither version of the national law Bloom read gives the police the job of deciding who is transgender. Both give the certificate of identity to the District Magistrate. The reports don’t say whether a certificate of identity, or a card issued before the amendment, will settle a Transgender Brigade applicant’s case.
“Self-identification is replaced with medical evaluation,” Justice Joymalya Bagchi observed in May, Bar and Bench reported. In three cities of West Bengal, for Transgender Brigade jobs, it may now be replaced with a police check too.
13
Citizenship checks and people without papers
Governments often check citizenship before hiring, and Bloom doesn’t suggest the state can’t. But the Transgender Brigade check comes bundled with a test of identity, run by police, aimed at one group.
Identity papers already decide a great deal for trans people in India, as the Supreme Court has heard this year. After the amendment, the national portal for identity cards had become “completely defunct,” petitioners told the Supreme Court in August, the Supreme Court Observer reported. “I cannot even rent a home without the card,” Advocate Kanmani R., a transgender lawyer, told the court.
One person said in a court filing that a card issued in 2023 had been replaced on the national portal with a new one bearing their earlier birth name, Bar and Bench reported. None of the West Bengal reports say which documents Transgender Brigade applicants must show, or what happens to someone who can’t produce them.
14
An old history of police lists
India has been here before. The NALSA judgment recalls the Criminal Tribes Act, 1871, a colonial law that provided for “the registration, surveillance and control of certain criminal tribes and eunuchs.”
Under that law, the local government had “to register the names and residence of all eunuchs residing in that area,” the Supreme Court wrote. The court said the law treated the whole hijra community as criminal.
The Transgender Brigade is a job program, not a criminal law, and Bloom isn’t saying otherwise. But it explains why police-held lists of trans people carry a weight in India that officials can’t wish away. Trust has to be earned, and safeguards have to be written down.
15
A job quota the Calcutta High Court ordered
There’s another thread. In June 2024, Justice Rajasekhar Mantha of the Calcutta High Court directed West Bengal’s chief secretary to ensure 1 percent reservation for transgender persons in all public employment, PTI reported.
The court relied on the NALSA judgment. It noted that the state’s social welfare department had declared, on November 30, 2022, that transgender persons were entitled to equal opportunity in employment without discrimination. Bloom couldn’t confirm whether the state has carried out the 2024 order, and none of the Transgender Brigade reports mention it.
16
What the reports don’t say yet
Several basic facts are missing from every report Bloom read:
- How much the stipend or honorarium pays, and how many jobs there are.
- Whether a certificate of identity under the Transgender Persons Act counts as proof.
- Which documents prove citizenship, and whether applicants without those papers have another way.
- Whether applicants can see what police record about them, and who keeps those lists.
- How someone turned away by the police screening can appeal.
Bloom will add answers when West Bengal publishes them.
17
A timeline of the Transgender Brigade
These dates come from the court, Parliament’s bill, the national government’s rules and the outlets cited here:
- April 15, 2014: The Supreme Court decides the NALSA judgment.
- January 10, 2020: The Transgender Persons Act takes effect.
- September 25, 2020: The 2020 Rules say no medical or physical examination is needed.
- June 2024: The Calcutta High Court orders a 1 percent job reservation in West Bengal.
- March 24 and 25, 2026: Parliament passes the amendment.
- May 4, 2026: The Supreme Court refuses to pause the amendment.
- August 17, 2026: The national government says existing identity cards will continue.
- November 19, 2026: Paul announces the Transgender Brigade.
- November 21, 2026: Police screening in three cities is reported.
- December 10, 2026: The police screening period ends.
- January 2027: Recruitment is expected to begin.
18
What happens next
After December 10, officials will prepare the final list of eligible candidates for the Transgender Brigade. The Kolkata Police Traffic Department is preparing a training syllabus on traffic rules, and Siliguri, Asansol and Haldia are likely to join in a second phase, Millennium Post reported.
In New Delhi, the Supreme Court said in August that it will list the challenge to the amendment for a final hearing, LiveLaw reported, and states including Andhra Pradesh and Uttarakhand have filed replies. Whatever the court decides about self-identification will shape who can claim the rights the Transgender Persons Act still promises, including in a program like the Transgender Brigade.
19
What you can do
If you’re applying to the Transgender Brigade in Kolkata, Howrah or Bidhannagar, or helping someone who is:
- Ask in writing which documents the police screening will check, and keep copies of everything you hand over.
- Bring your certificate of identity or transgender identity card if you have one. The national government told the Supreme Court cards already issued will continue.
- Ask who makes the final decision and how to challenge it. None of the reports describe an appeal.
- Go with someone you trust, such as a member of an established community organization.
- Seek free legal help. The Supreme Court described India’s National Legal Services Authority as a body set up “to provide free legal services to the weaker and other marginalized sections of the society.”
- Write down what happens at the police station: the date, the officers’ questions and any record they make.
Readers outside India can follow the Supreme Court case and share accurate reporting about it.
20
Bloom’s reporting on India
Bloom has reported on trans rights in India twice this week. India’s top court ordered Delhi to drop gender from teacher job ads so trans applicants can be considered on merit.
Delhi also approved health cover for transgender people and their families, tied to the same certificate of identity. Taken together, these stories ask one question: who decides that a person is who they say they are?
21
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reports on trans lives across the world because the same questions travel. I believe no one should have to prove who they are to a police officer to earn a living. If the Transgender Brigade is about dignity, as the minister says, it should begin by trusting the people it serves.
If this news brings up fear about your own papers or safety, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call at any hour. In the United States, Trans Lifeline is at 877-565-8860, and you can call or text 988. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading the laws and court records behind stories like this one, and a one-time gift helps too.
22
Frequently Asked Questions
It’s a planned state program to pay trans people a stipend or honorarium for traffic management and municipal property-tax collection. UNI reported it would be called the Brihannala Brigade, and Millennium Post says recruitment is expected in January 2027.
Police in Kolkata, Howrah and Bidhannagar will check applicants’ identity and citizenship until December 10, with help from established trans organizations. A committee led by Moumita Godara Basu oversees the work.
Officials say they want to keep out people they call impostors and people they allege came from Bangladesh. Some trans activists in Bengal asked for the checks.
The Supreme Court’s 2014 NALSA judgment upheld that right, and the 2019 Transgender Persons Act wrote it into law. A 2026 amendment removed it and requires a medical board’s recommendation, and the Supreme Court is hearing a challenge.
The reports Bloom read don’t say. The national government told the Supreme Court that identity cards issued before the 2026 amendment will continue while the case is pending.
Ask in writing which documents are needed, keep copies, bring any certificate of identity, ask how to appeal, and seek free legal help if you’re turned away.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Trans advocacy · 22 November 2026Kelantan Charges Trans Woman With ‘Posing as a Woman’ Over a Kaftan
New York Legislature · 22 November 2026Liverpool Superintendent Apologizes but Keeps Gender Memo in Place
Trans advocacy · 21 November 2026India’s Top Court Orders Delhi to Drop Gender From Teacher Job Ads