A black desk telephone with its handset off the cradle on a wooden table, illustrating the Liverpool superintendent's letter about when a school calls home

NewsroomNew York LegislatureNews

Liverpool Superintendent Apologizes but Keeps Gender Memo in Place

Liverpool's superintendent apologized Friday for how he explained his memo on telling parents about students' gender, and said talking to a counselor won't, by itself, mean a call home.

Hundreds of students walked out of Liverpool High School on Friday morning, November 20, 2026. By late that afternoon, their superintendent had written to Liverpool families. Liverpool Superintendent Richard Chapman apologized for how he explained his November 12 memo on student confidentiality, and he drew a new line: “A student talking with a teacher or counselor about who they are does not, by itself, mean a call home.” He did not withdraw the memo.

It’s the Liverpool superintendent’s first public explanation after a week of declined interview requests, as Bloom reported Friday. The letter changes what a student can expect when they confide in an adult at school. It leaves open the question many students care about most: whether asking a teacher to use a new name or pronouns now means a parent gets a call. And one school board member is asking the board to seek an independent legal opinion.

Following this story: the Liverpool schools gender memo. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.

01

What the Liverpool superintendent wrote to families

Chapman sent the letter through the district’s ParentSquare portal late Friday afternoon, CNY Central reported. That morning he had spoken to students through a bullhorn during the walkout, the station reported the next day. NewsChannel 9 WSYR published the full letter.

The Liverpool superintendent began with the week itself. He wrote that he’d spent much of it “talking with staff, with students at the high school, and with parents.” Then came the apology. “The answers in the memo came from our attorneys and were written for staff, in legal terms,” he wrote.

“It was my responsibility to take something this complicated and nuanced and explain it clearly to everyone in our community,” the Liverpool superintendent continued. “I didn’t do that as well as I should have, and I’m sorry.”

He closed with an invitation. “Please reach out to me directly with questions or concerns. I’ll answer everything I can.”

02

What changed, and what didn’t

The Liverpool superintendent apologized for the explanation, not the instruction. He “stands by the decision,” CNY Central reported, and the letter doesn’t rescind any part of the November 12 memo.

The letter adds three statements of the district’s position. The first is about conversations. “Since the memo went out, our attorneys have clarified one point that has caused a lot of confusion,” Chapman wrote. A student talking about who they are doesn’t, on its own, lead to a call home.

The second is about scope. “This isn’t a new policy voted on by our Board of Education, and it doesn’t apply to students who are 18 or older,” the letter says. The third is about reach: “Our attorneys’ advice is that this decision applies to schools across the country, not only Liverpool,” the Liverpool superintendent wrote, referring to a recent Supreme Court decision.

03

What may still trigger a call home

The memo still governs, and it’s specific. If a staff member learns a student is using different pronouns, clothing or a name consistent with a different gender identity, “the District must both inform the parent and obtain their consent before honoring the child’s gender preferences,” WSYR reported, quoting the memo.

The letter adds a new test. “A parent would be contacted by the school if a child needs an adjustment to their educational setting,” the Liverpool superintendent wrote.

The letter doesn’t define an adjustment. It also doesn’t say whether asking a teacher to use a different name or pronouns in class counts as one, CNY Central noted. Until the Liverpool superintendent answers that in writing, a student can’t safely assume that a request to be called by a new name won’t lead to a call home. The memo itself still names names, pronouns and clothing.

04

What doesn’t, in the district’s own words

The letter sets out what the Liverpool superintendent says will not, by itself, bring a call home:

  • Talking. A conversation with a teacher or counselor about who you are is not, on its own, a reason to call home.
  • Being 18 or older. The guidance “doesn’t apply to students who are 18 or older.”
  • Seeing an outside clinician. Students who want a confidential place to talk can still find one with a clinician outside the school, the letter says.

The Liverpool superintendent’s letter is silent on the rest of the memo. CNY Central reported that the memo told staff to share what a student discloses about physical or mental health with district leaders and parents, including pregnancy. WSYR reported that it requires disclosure of a student’s sexual orientation when staff believe a parent doesn’t know, according to FingerLakes1.com.

Yet the district’s attorney, Kate Reid, told the board on November 16 that staff don’t necessarily need to call a parent when a student says they’re gay, Newsweek reported. The letter doesn’t say which account the district follows.

05

If the school decides to call home

The Liverpool superintendent makes a promise about how a call home would happen. “If family needs to be involved, the student won’t face that alone,” Chapman wrote. “A trusted staff member will talk it through with them first, help them prepare, and can be there for the conversation.”

The Liverpool superintendent also described what he’s asking of staff. “This guidance asks our staff to be honest with students and to stay with them through these conversations,” he wrote.

That promise matters, and families can hold the Liverpool superintendent to it. A student who is warned first can plan and reach a trusted adult. But preparation isn’t the same as safety. For a student who fears rejection at home, the question is whether the call is made at all.

06

Why the district says it has no choice

The Liverpool superintendent’s letter rests on legal advice: that “after a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision, school staff can’t keep certain information about a student from that student’s parents.” He added, “That has been true for a long time when a student’s health or safety is at risk.” Now, he wrote, “The decision broadens the situations where parents need to be involved.”

The district has pointed to the Supreme Court’s March 2, 2026 order in Mirabelli v. Bonta, Newsweek and FingerLakes1.com reported. That order reinstated a ruling that bars California schools from “misleading parents about their children’s gender presentation,” SCOTUSblog reported. The majority wrote that parents have “the right not to be shut out of participation in decisions regarding their children’s mental health.”

The district’s attorney pressed that reading on the board. “What it means is that that is the law of the land,” she said, according to Newsweek. She also told members, “The federal government said they will be actively investigating districts that keep secrets from parents.”

07

Does the Supreme Court order require this?

Not every lawyer reads the order the way the Liverpool superintendent’s attorneys do. Derek Black, a constitutional law scholar interviewed by WSYR, questioned whether the order requires that much, Newsweek reported. “The court is saying you cannot make it your policy that we’re going to hide information from parents,” Black said. “That’s different than saying our policy is now that we’re going to tell parents everything.”

CNY Central’s own review found the ruling “does not set a general rule for confidential conversations between students and school staff,” the station reported November 18. Mirabelli is still being litigated in California, Newsweek noted, and no court has ruled on the Liverpool memo itself. The Liverpool superintendent’s letter treats his attorneys’ advice as settled. It’s one reading of an emergency order, and a board member now wants another.

09

What students are saying

Students said they wanted the district to reconsider and make sure every student feels safe turning to a trusted adult at school, WSYR reported. Bloom isn’t naming them.

“Right now, I feel the students don’t feel safe being themselves,” a Liverpool High School senior told WSYR. She said students should not be outed, and that “you should be able to come out when you’re ready.”

A young person who tells a counselor something true is offering trust. The students in that parking lot were asking the Liverpool superintendent whether that trust can still be kept.

10

What parents and neighbors are saying

Many adults in Central New York believe parents should know. When CNY Central asked neighbors, many said they want what’s best for students. “It’s more for the parents; they would like and love to know about their child,” said Rivaldo Ramirez of North Syracuse. John DeLeo, a Liverpool grandfather, worried that bullying could go unseen if parents “weren’t made aware.”

Some saw limits. One neighbor said confidential services matter when a young person isn’t comfortable talking at home, and Ramirez said older students should have more freedom. Parents and students want the same thing: a child who is safe. They differ on who decides when a family hears the news.

11

What New York’s guidance says about student confidentiality

New York’s State Education Department set out its view in 2023 guidance on transgender and gender expansive students. On student confidentiality, it starts from the student. “When TGE students disclose their gender identity to school personnel, it is because they feel safe,” it says.

Staff who hear it should “keep it confidential, unless the student explicitly states otherwise,” the guidance says. On names and pronouns, students “are not required to obtain parental/guardian consent” before being addressed by their affirmed name and pronouns. That sits directly against the consent rule in the Liverpool superintendent’s memo.

The guidance doesn’t promise parents will never learn. It tells schools to warn students that “parents/guardians may become aware of the use of an affirmed name in school and on school records.” And it names the test: “The most important consideration in these situations is the health and safety of the student.”

None of the reports Bloom reviewed included a response from the State Education Department to the Liverpool superintendent’s memo or letter.

12

The Dignity Act and New York’s Human Rights Law

New York law also protects students. Under the Dignity for All Students Act, “no student shall be subjected to harassment or bullying by employees or students on school property or at a school function,” the state’s guidance quotes. The act also bars discrimination by school employees or students based on sexual orientation, gender or sex, and the guidance lists name and pronoun complaints among the reports it covers.

New York’s Human Rights Law, as amended by the Gender Expression Non-Discrimination Act, “expressly prohibits discrimination by educational institutions against students,” the guidance says, including on gender identity or expression. Intentionally calling a student by a name or pronoun other than their affirmed ones “is a NYS Human Rights Law violation and is unacceptable,” it says. Neither law, as the guidance describes it, sets out when a school must call home, and the Liverpool superintendent’s letter doesn’t mention either one.

13

What federal law says about parents and records

The federal Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, known as FERPA, is a law about records. It gives parents “the right to inspect and review the education records of their children,” the statute says. Education records are those that “contain information directly related to a student” and are kept by the school. Records a teacher or administrator keeps “in the sole possession of the maker thereof,” shown to no one else, are excluded.

When a student turns 18, FERPA’s rights move to them: they “shall thereafter only be required of and accorded to the student.” The Liverpool superintendent’s 18-and-older line falls at the same age, though the letter doesn’t give its reason. New York’s guidance adds that school “health records are part of the student’s education records and therefore are protected under FERPA.”

“FERPA gives parents the right to access their children’s education records,” the U.S. Department of Education said in an action against districts in Maryland and Michigan. This week it opened investigations into five districts’ gender support plans, and the Justice Department has sued two districts, Newsweek reported.

14

What this means for a trans or questioning student in Liverpool now

If you’re a student in Liverpool and you’re trans, questioning, or still finding words for who you are, here is what the Liverpool superintendent’s own words say today. You can talk with a teacher or counselor about who you are, and that alone shouldn’t bring a call home. If you ask the school to change something, such as the name or pronouns staff use, the memo still says your parents must be told and must consent.

If the school decides to call, the Liverpool superintendent promises a staff member will tell you first and help you prepare. If you’re 18, the guidance doesn’t apply to you. For a fully confidential talk, the district points you to a clinician outside school.

You haven’t done anything wrong by being honest. You deserve adults who keep their word, at school and at home.

15

Questions the letter leaves open

The Liverpool superintendent’s letter answers one question and raises others. Families may want these answered in writing:

  • What is an “adjustment”? Does asking a teacher to use a new name or pronouns count?
  • What about health information? Does the memo’s rule on physical and mental health disclosures, including pregnancy, still stand?
  • What about sexual orientation? WSYR’s account of the memo and Reid’s remarks differ.
  • What about staff? The memo said staff members wouldn’t be entitled to a defense at the district’s expense if they were sued, CNY Central reported November 17.
  • When will the steps come? The letter promises staff “clear steps for these conversations” in the coming weeks.

16

Timeline: the Liverpool superintendent’s memo

  • March 2, 2026: The Supreme Court reinstates a ruling on California schools’ policies in Mirabelli v. Bonta.
  • November 12: The Liverpool superintendent sends staff his memo on student confidentiality.
  • November 16: The district’s attorney presents the legal reasoning to the Board of Education, and two board members object.
  • November 17 and 18: WSYR and CNY Central report the memo’s terms.
  • November 20, morning: Hundreds of students walk out of Liverpool High School.
  • November 20, late afternoon: Chapman’s letter reaches families through ParentSquare.
  • November 20, evening: Board member Matt Jones asks the board to seek an independent second legal opinion.
  • January 1, 2027: Jones joins the Onondaga County Legislature.

17

What happens next

The Liverpool superintendent says more is coming. “Over the coming weeks, we’ll give our staff clear steps for these conversations,” he wrote, and he’ll be “meeting with students at the high school to talk about what it means for them.”

As of Friday night, Chapman hadn’t answered CNY Central’s questions directly, the station reported, and Newsweek said it had asked the district for comment. None of the reports say whether the board will take up Jones’s request for an independent legal opinion, or name a date for its next meeting.

The wider legal question is moving too, in California’s Mirabelli case and in federal FERPA investigations elsewhere. Bloom will follow each step.

18

What students and families can do

Whatever you believe about parental notification, these steps help:

  1. Ask for the guidance in writing. The Liverpool superintendent invited families to reach out directly. Ask for the full memo and the staff steps.
  2. Ask what “adjustment” means. Ask whether a request to use a name or pronouns counts, before a student makes one.
  3. Know your records rights. Under FERPA, parents may ask to inspect their child’s education records. Students who are 18 or older hold those rights themselves.
  4. Know New York’s guidance. Bring the 2023 state guidance to a principal, counselor or board meeting.
  5. Report harassment. The Dignity Act covers harassment and discrimination by staff or students, including over names and pronouns.
  6. Speak at the board. Ask whether the board will seek the independent legal opinion Jones requested.
  7. Choose a safe first call. The Trevor Project answers at 1-866-488-7386, Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860, and 988 by call or text.

19

What Bloom is doing

Bloom first reported the Liverpool superintendent’s memo the day students walked out, and the box above will gather each new report. I believe a student who tells the truth to a trusted adult should never be punished for that honesty.

If this has frightened you or someone you love, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people to call any hour, and Bloom’s support groups welcome trans people and the families who love them. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. Bloom has also reported on a California board’s new limits on trans students.

Reporting like this means reading every letter and every law so families don’t have to. A monthly gift keeps that work steady, and a one-time gift helps too.

20

Frequently Asked Questions

Richard Chapman apologized for how he explained his November 12 memo and said a student talking with a teacher or counselor “does not, by itself, mean a call home.” A parent would be contacted if a student needs an adjustment to their educational setting.

No. CNY Central reported that he stands by the decision. The letter clarifies one point but doesn’t rescind any part of the memo.

The Liverpool superintendent’s letter doesn’t say. The memo still says staff must inform parents and get their consent before honoring a student’s name, pronouns or clothing tied to a different gender identity.

No. The letter says it doesn’t apply to students who are 18 or older. Under FERPA, records rights pass from parents to the student at 18.

The State Education Department’s 2023 guidance tells staff to keep a student’s gender identity confidential unless the student says otherwise, and says students don’t need parental consent to use their affirmed name and pronouns.

Board member Matt Jones asked the board to seek an independent second legal opinion on the advice behind the memo, which he said was never presented to the board for approval.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.