
Newsroom·Legislation·News
UK Tribunal Confirms Secret Order to Apple Over Encrypted Data
A UK tribunal ruled that the government can't keep secret the fact that it served Apple a technical capability notice over encrypted data. Much of the fight over iCloud encryption will now be heard in public.
A British tribunal has ruled that the UK government can’t keep secret the fact that it served Apple a technical capability notice, an order that reportedly demanded access to users’ encrypted data. In a judgment dated Thursday, November 19, 2026, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the Home Office’s claim that confirming the order would damage national security, according to the tribunal’s OPEN judgment.
That changes how one of the world’s most important encryption cases will be fought. Much of Apple’s challenge, and a parallel case brought by civil liberties groups, can now be heard in public. The notice’s exact content stays secret for now. Here is what the tribunal decided, what a technical capability notice is, and why it matters to anyone who counts on a private message staying private.
01
What the Investigatory Powers Tribunal decided
The tribunal, made up of Lady Carmichael, its president, and Mr Justice Chamberlain and Mr Justice Johnson, heard two cases together. One was brought by Apple against the Secretary of State for the Home Department. The other was brought by Privacy International, Liberty, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner, according to the judgment.
The government argued that it would damage national security for it to confirm or deny whether Apple had received a technical capability notice. The claimants said open justice required that this “central feature of the case” not be kept secret, because it was already clear from the public record.
The tribunal sided with the claimants. It rejected the government’s contention that “it would be damaging to national security to confirm the fact that the respondent has given Apple a technical capability notice,” the judges wrote.
The ruling followed a hearing on September 17, 2026, which had public, private and closed parts. The tribunal handed down separate private and closed judgments at the same time, but it said the substance of its decision is in the public one.
02
What a technical capability notice is
A technical capability notice is an order the UK Home Secretary can give a “relevant operator” under section 253 of the Investigatory Powers Act 2016, the judgment explains. These orders compel “companies to build and/or maintain technical capabilities to respond to lawful requests for data,” Reason reported.
The order to Apple reportedly targeted Advanced Data Protection, “an opt-in setting which largely protects users’ iCloud data with end-to-end encryption,” Reason wrote, citing The Washington Post, which first exposed the order on February 7, 2025.
With end-to-end encryption, only the user holds the keys to the data. A technical capability notice that requires access to that data goes to the heart of how the protection works, which is why privacy advocates have fought this case so hard.
03
How the technical capability notice became an open secret
The government has kept to its policy of neither confirming nor denying the order. But the facts leaked out over nearly two years, and the tribunal laid them out.
Two weeks after The Washington Post’s report, Apple confirmed it was no longer offering Advanced Data Protection to new UK users, Reason reported. The Times reported that the Home Office had issued an order under the 2016 Act requiring Apple to provide access to encrypted material, and that this had been “confirmed by Home Office sources,” the judgment notes.
On August 19, 2025, Tulsi Gabbard, then the US Director of National Intelligence, posted that the UK had agreed to drop its mandate for a “back door” into the encrypted data of American citizens, according to the judgment. On October 1, 2025, The Financial Times reported that the UK had made a new attempt, with an order issued in September. That order applied only to British users’ data, according to the FT, as Reason reported.
The tribunal found that “there was extensive media coverage both before and after that decision to the effect that a technical capability notice had been given,” and that the coverage matched public statements by US officials, according to Reason.
04
How the technical capability notice case got here
The case has a long history, much of it fought over secrecy itself. A secret hearing of the tribunal was scheduled for March 14, 2025, and ahead of it Privacy International, Liberty and two individual claimants filed complaints, according to Privacy International. One asked for the hearing to be public. The other disputed “the lawfulness, necessity and secrecy of the legal regime” behind every technical capability notice.
On April 7, 2025, the tribunal released a public judgment rejecting the government’s claim that it would be “contrary to the public interest” for any information about the case to be public, Privacy International says. Recipients of a technical capability notice are normally under gagging orders, and the notices themselves are never published, the group explains.
In October 2025, after the Financial Times reported that the UK had withdrawn its first technical capability notice and issued a second one targeting British users, Apple’s first challenge was dismissed because of a “change in circumstances,” according to Privacy International. Apple filed a new claim in August 2026. Thursday’s judgment covers that new claim and the groups’ case, which never stopped.
05
Why “neither confirm nor deny” didn’t hold
The Home Office’s policy is known as NCND, for neither confirm nor deny. The judgment calls it “an important Government policy for the protection of national security,” and says its effectiveness depends on it being maintained generally.
But NCND is “not an absolute or blanket rule of law,” the tribunal wrote. Courts give weight to the government’s national security assessments, but they don’t simply accept them when the facts are already public.
Here, the judges concluded that confirming what the world already knew couldn’t harm national security. That is a meaningful limit on government secrecy. A government can’t keep a fact out of court just because it would rather not say it out loud.
06
What open justice means here
Open justice is the principle that courts work in public, so people can see how power is checked. The tribunal said the key question now is “the extent to which the open justice principle requires public disclosure, so far as that can be secured without damaging national security.”
That framing matters. It puts the burden of explaining secrecy where it belongs, on the government, rather than treating a technical capability notice as untouchable. Every claim of secrecy will now have to be weighed against the public’s right to see the case argued.
07
What stays secret
The ruling is narrow in one important way. It confirms the existence of a technical capability notice. It doesn’t reveal what the order says.
“There may be some information that could be disclosed publicly without damaging national security,” the tribunal wrote, but “it is not, however, practical to determine the precise boundaries now.” All parties accepted that some details must stay secret, and the tribunal agreed that publishing everything, including the content of the notice, would damage national security.
The judges said those lines will be drawn later, after the parties exchange evidence and arguments. Some issues might be argued on assumed facts or on general summaries of the real ones.
08
Apple’s five grounds
The practical result of the ruling is that “much of the substantive hearing in these claims can take place in OPEN,” the tribunal wrote. It described Apple’s five grounds of challenge:
- Whether the government has power to issue warrants for targeted interception of communications outside the United Kingdom.
- Whether the statutory power can be used to regulate the security or privacy services a technology company offers its customers.
- Whether the consultation process was lawful.
- Whether the technical capability notice is a disproportionate interference with rights protected by the European Convention on Human Rights.
- Whether Apple has been treated differently from other technology companies.
The first two are questions of law that “can be determined entirely in OPEN,” the tribunal said. The third can largely be decided in public too. The fourth and fifth are likely to involve evidence that can’t be disclosed.
09
The legal test the technical capability notice will face
Apple’s fourth ground asks whether the technical capability notice is a disproportionate interference with human rights. To answer it, the tribunal said it will apply four tests from a UK Supreme Court case, Bank Mellat:
- whether the objective is important enough to justify limiting a protected right
- whether the measure is rationally connected to that objective
- whether a less intrusive measure could have been used without unacceptably compromising the objective
- whether the measure’s severity on the people affected outweighs the importance of the objective
The first three “can largely be determined in OPEN,” the judges wrote. The fourth, the balancing test, may involve evidence that would damage the public interest if disclosed. That is where the hardest part of the technical capability notice fight will happen.
10
Who brought the cases
Apple brought its own claim against the Home Secretary. Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner, brought a separate claim and complaint, according to the judgment.
Akiko Hart, director of Liberty, called the judgment a “victory for transparency,” Reason reported. “Encryption protects the things that matter most to us,” she said, describing family photos, personal messages, bank details and health records.
Governments “should be rising to the challenge to strengthen digital security protections rather than opening the door to hackers and hostile actors,” Hart said, according to Reason.
11
Why encryption matters to people at risk
Bloom’s readers know why privacy is more than a technical setting. A survivor planning to leave an abusive home may depend on messages no one else can read. A trans person may keep medical records, chosen-name documents and private conversations on a phone that holds their safety. A disabled person may store health records in the cloud.
End-to-end encryption protects all of that by design. When a government demands a way in, it doesn’t only reach suspects. A technical capability notice that weakens encryption weakens it for everyone who uses the same service.
That is why this case, in a British tribunal, matters well beyond Britain. Bloom believes the right to a private life includes the right to a private message, and that people at risk should never have to choose between their safety and their phone.
12
Why Americans are watching the technical capability notice
When The Washington Post first reported the order, its reporter Joseph Menn noted that if the UK gained access to encrypted data, other countries “might be prompted to demand equal backdoor access,” Reason reported. China was one example he gave.
US lawmakers took notice. Sen. Ron Wyden of Oregon and Rep. Andy Biggs of Arizona referred to the first order in a letter to Gabbard, according to Reason. The first order reportedly reached users beyond the UK, which is why US officials said they pressed London on Americans’ data.
Bloom has reported on privacy fights closer to home, including a federal judge’s order blocking a search of an immigration lawyer’s phone and a lawsuit over an AI gun-detection system that sent police after teenagers.
13
What happens next
The cases now move toward a substantive hearing, most of it in public. Liberty will keep challenging the technical capability notice in court, and a final hearing is expected in 2027, Reason reported.
Before then, the parties will exchange evidence and written arguments. Only after that, the tribunal said, will it be possible to decide what evidence is truly relevant, what is truly damaging to national security, and where the public, private and closed boundaries should fall.
The Investigatory Powers Tribunal’s ruling doesn’t decide whether the technical capability notice is lawful. It decides that the public gets to know the order exists, and that much of the argument about it will happen where people can see it.
14
A timeline of the Apple technical capability notice
These dates come from the tribunal’s judgment and from Reason:
- February 7, 2025: The Washington Post reports the UK ordered Apple to provide access to encrypted iCloud data.
- February 2025: Apple stops offering Advanced Data Protection to new UK users.
- April 2025: The tribunal issues an earlier OPEN judgment in the case.
- August 19, 2025: Gabbard posts that the UK agreed to drop its mandate for a back door into Americans’ encrypted data.
- September 2025: The Home Office issues a second order, limited to British users’ data, according to The Financial Times.
- September 17, 2026: The tribunal holds a hearing on whether the notice can be confirmed.
- November 19, 2026: The tribunal rules the government can’t keep the notice’s existence secret.
- 2027: A final hearing is expected.
15
What you can do
You can’t change a British court case, but you can protect your own privacy:
- Learn which of your apps and cloud services use end-to-end encryption, and turn it on where it’s offered as an option.
- If you’re a survivor of abuse or stalking, talk with an advocate about a safety plan for your phone and accounts. The National Domestic Violence Hotline, 800-799-7233, answers any hour.
- Keep sensitive documents, like medical or legal records, in services whose privacy protections you understand.
- Follow the case. Privacy International and Liberty are parties, and the hearings will now be largely public.
- Tell your representatives that encryption protects ordinary people, not only the powerful.
16
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands for the dignity of every person, and dignity includes privacy. I believe a government that wants a key to everyone’s private life should have to say so in the open, and on Thursday a tribunal agreed that this government must.
If this news stirs worry about your own safety, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach any hour. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reporting on civil liberties at home and abroad, and a one-time gift helps too.
17
Frequently Asked Questions
It rejected the UK government’s claim that confirming its technical capability notice to Apple would damage national security. The order’s existence can now be acknowledged in the case.
It’s an order under section 253 of the UK’s Investigatory Powers Act 2016 that can require a company to build or maintain the ability to respond to lawful requests for data.
No. The tribunal said the notice’s detailed content may stay secret, and it will decide later what, if anything, can be disclosed.
No. Apple’s challenge and the civil liberties groups’ case continue, and a final hearing is expected in 2027.
The first order reportedly reached users beyond Britain, and reporters warned other countries might demand the same access. US officials said they pressed the UK on Americans’ data.
Apple stopped offering it to new UK users in February 2025, and existing users were given time to turn it off, according to Privacy International. It remained available elsewhere.
Apple brought one claim. Privacy International, Liberty, Ian Hosein and Ben Wizner brought the other, according to the judgment.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Kentucky Legislature · 20 November 2026Kentucky SB 150 Trial Ends as Trans Students Await a Judge’s Ruling
Justice for survivors · 20 November 2026Judge Strikes HUD’s $1.3 Billion Shift Away From Permanent Housing
New Jersey Legislature · 20 November 2026New Jersey Ends Statute of Limitations for Human Trafficking