The columned steps of a federal courthouse at dawn, for a report on the DOJ subpoenas for trans care records and the courts that ruled on them

NewsroomTrans advocacyNews

DOJ Official Behind Trans Care Subpoenas Resigns: What Stays

The head of the Justice Department's Civil Division, whose 2025 subpoenas sought trans patients' records, resigned on November 9, but the appeals go on and states are writing their own protections.

Six federal district courts had ruled against the subpoenas by the end of January 2026.

Brett Shumate, the head of the Justice Department’s Civil Division, submitted his resignation on Monday, November 9, ABC News reported. His division sent the DOJ subpoenas of June 2025 to hospitals and clinics that provide gender-affirming care, seeking records that reached as far as patients’ home addresses. Attorney General Todd Blanche announced the departure in a social media post praising work that, in his words, “shuttered dozens of clinics which were providing so-called ‘gender affirming care’ to minors.”

A resignation doesn’t withdraw a subpoena. By the end of January 2026, six federal district courts had ruled against the DOJ subpoenas, and the government has appealed. On the same Monday Shumate resigned, New York Attorney General Letitia James released guidance on how her state’s Shield Law protects people who “receive, provide, or help others access abortion and gender-affirming care.” For trans patients, their families and the clinicians who care for them, this week brought a departure, not an ending.

01

What happened at the Justice Department on November 9

ABC News reported that Shumate “submitted his resignation Monday.” The report describes him as the head of the Civil Division, the part of the Justice Department that litigates on the government’s behalf and defends its policies against civil lawsuits. It doesn’t give a date when his departure takes effect.

Blanche announced the resignation in a post that, as ABC described it, highlighted “a series of civil litigation priorities.” The attorney general credited the division with litigation challenging sanctuary policies and settlements over corporate DEI practices. Then came the line about clinics, the one that matters most to Bloom’s readers: Blanche counted closing clinics that gave gender-affirming care to young people as an achievement of Shumate’s tenure.

ABC reported that Shumate is “the fourth top official to resign since last week’s midterm elections.” The others it named were Harmeet Dhillon, who led the Civil Rights Division; Jason Reding Quiñones, the U.S. attorney in South Florida; and John Eisenberg, who led the National Security Division. ABC added that it wasn’t immediately clear whether the administration would push for permanent replacements.

On Wednesday, Truthout republished a report from Erin in the Morning tying the resignation to trans care directly. “Under Shumate’s leadership, the DOJ aggressively targeted providers of gender-affirming care,” it reads. The report adds that “a replacement for Shumate has not yet been announced.”

02

How the DOJ subpoenas began in June 2025

The DOJ subpoenas didn’t arrive as lawsuits. They came as administrative subpoenas, a tool that lets an agency demand documents during an investigation without first going to a judge. According to an analysis by the law firm Faegre Drinker, the Civil Division issued more than 20 of them on June 11, 2025.

The DOJ subpoenas went to hospitals, physician groups and other providers of gender-affirming care. Faegre Drinker describes them as HIPAA administrative subpoenas, tied to an investigation of health care offenses. As the courts later described it, the investigation concerned how products were labeled, marketed and billed.

The Civil Division is the one Brett Shumate has led. Erin in the Morning’s account, as republished by Truthout, says the division used subpoenas for patient records and False Claims Act investigations against hospitals. Bloom hasn’t independently reviewed each of those investigations, so we report them as that outlet describes them.

What the DOJ subpoenas changed first wasn’t the law. It was the temperature inside clinics. A provider who receives one of the DOJ subpoenas for patient files has to answer it, fight it in court, or both, and every one of those choices costs time, money and nerve.

03

What the DOJ subpoenas asked hospitals to hand over

Faegre Drinker summarized what the DOJ subpoenas sought, based on publicly reported information. The list is long, and it’s personal:

  • personnel files for staff
  • billing-code documents for gender-affirming care of minors
  • communications with drug manufacturers and marketers
  • information about prescribers
  • minor patients’ medical records, consent forms and billing records
  • patients’ Social Security numbers and home addresses

That last item stands out. A billing investigation doesn’t obviously need to know where a teenager sleeps at night. Several courts later asked the same question in legal language: what did the government actually need, and why?

For trans young people and their parents, the DOJ subpoenas turned a private medical decision into a file that could leave the clinic. Even where no record was ever handed over, the request itself told families that the government wanted to look.

04

Six federal courts and the DOJ subpoenas

The hospitals and clinics that went to court won every ruling Faegre Drinker tracked. Faegre Drinker’s January 5, 2026, analysis described three rulings on the DOJ subpoenas, and its January 29 update added three more.

  • Boston: the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts quashed a subpoena to Boston Children’s Hospital on September 9, 2025.
  • Seattle: the Western District of Washington quashed a subpoena to QueerDoc, a telehealth practice, on October 27, 2025.
  • Philadelphia: the Eastern District of Pennsylvania ruled for Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia on November 21, 2025, finding the patient records not relevant and, in the alternative, limiting the subpoena.
  • Western Pennsylvania: the Western District of Pennsylvania ruled against a subpoena to UPMC on December 24, 2025.
  • Colorado: the District of Colorado quashed another of the DOJ subpoenas on January 5, 2026.
  • Maryland: the District of Maryland ruled against a subpoena to Children’s National Hospital on January 21, 2026.

According to Faegre Drinker, the Boston and Seattle courts quashed the DOJ subpoenas in full because they were issued for an improper purpose. The firm writes that the Justice Department offered no evidence of improper billing or marketing, and that those courts found the real aim was to end lawful care. Truthout’s report quotes the Boston judge calling the effort “a fishing expedition.”

The Philadelphia court took a narrower path. It held that patients’ records “do not speak to how products were labeled, marketed, introduced into interstate commerce, or billed to health care benefit plans.” In other words, children’s charts couldn’t answer the question the government said it was asking.

05

A Seattle telehealth practice and the Pacific Northwest

QueerDoc’s case is the closest of the six to home for Bloom. The ruling came from the federal court in Seattle, the Western District of Washington, on October 27, 2025. Faegre Drinker describes QueerDoc as a telehealth practice serving patients in 10 states.

Telehealth lets one practice reach patients across many states. When a federal demand lands on a small telehealth practice, it doesn’t stay in one city. It reaches everyone whose chart sits on that practice’s servers, wherever they live.

The Seattle court quashed the subpoena in full, finding it was issued for an improper purpose. That ruling didn’t make QueerDoc’s patients safe forever, and it didn’t bind courts in other parts of the country. But it showed that a small provider could stand up to the DOJ subpoenas and win.

06

A resignation isn’t a reversal

Shumate’s departure changes who leads the Civil Division. It doesn’t, on anything Bloom has read, change the division’s position in court. Faegre Drinker reported that the government has appealed the decisions that quashed the DOJ subpoenas, and Bloom couldn’t confirm this week where each appeal stands.

Blanche’s own post points the same way. He didn’t describe the clinic closures as a mistake to be corrected. He listed them among the Civil Division’s accomplishments. A new division chief, whenever one is named, inherits the appeals over the DOJ subpoenas and that record.

So the honest answer for trans patients is mixed. The official most closely tied to the DOJ subpoenas is leaving. The legal fights his division started are still alive, and so is the pressure that led some providers to stop offering care.

07

New York’s Shield Law guidance, released the same day

On November 9, the New York Attorney General’s office published guidance on the state’s Shield Law. Its subhead says the new resource outlines who the law protects and what to do if asked for information about reproductive or gender-affirming care. The NY Daily Record reported it the next day.

The office says the guidance is for “patients, families, health care providers, attorneys, businesses, and anyone else who may receive a subpoena or other request.” According to the release, the Shield Law means:

  • New York officials, police and courts can’t enforce subpoenas, warrants or extradition requests that seek to punish protected care.
  • New York courts can’t treat evidence of protected care as evidence against the person.
  • Parents can’t be punished for allowing their children to receive protected care.
  • Licensing boards can’t discipline providers or attorneys for protected care.
  • Malpractice insurers can’t penalize providers for it, including by raising rates or refusing policies.

“This guidance gives New Yorkers a clear roadmap for protecting their private health information,” James said. She added: “My office will always defend New Yorkers’ right to make personal health care decisions free from interference.”

The release says the original Shield Law passed in the wake of the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision, and that Governor Kathy Hochul signed “Shield Law 2.0” in December 2025. That update reaches therapists, speech pathologists and other mental health practitioners. The guidance page adds that telehealth is protected when the provider is physically in New York, wherever the patient is.

08

Four steps before anyone hands over records

The heart of New York’s guidance is a pause. “The Shield Law prohibits New Yorkers and New York companies from immediately handing over protected health information,” the release says. The guidance defines that information to include medical records, internet search histories, location information and billing records.

Before producing anything, the guidance sets out four steps:

  1. Confirm whether the request is covered, meaning it concerns protected care or asks for protected health information.
  2. Obtain a sworn Affirmation of Permitted Purpose, signed under penalty of perjury, before producing any records.
  3. Notify the Attorney General’s office within five business days of receiving the request, or five business days before the response date if that comes sooner, and make a reasonable effort to notify the people whose records are sought.
  4. Wait. The release puts it plainly: “Wait 30 calendar days after notification before turning over any information.”

The penalties are real. “Anyone who ignores the required steps or improperly shares protected information can face a $10,000 penalty,” the release says. It adds: “Lying in a sworn statement to circumvent the Shield Law carries a $15,000 penalty.” The guidance adds that people who follow the steps generally can’t be punished or held in contempt for the delay. Questions go to shield.law@ag.ny.gov.

One caution matters here. The New York release doesn’t say how these steps apply to the DOJ subpoenas or any other federal subpoena, and Bloom won’t guess. The providers that beat the DOJ subpoenas did it in federal court, with lawyers. A Shield Law buys time and sets rules inside one state; it isn’t a substitute for counsel.

09

What Oregon’s 2023 law already says

Bloom is based in Oregon, and Oregon passed its own protections three years ago. House Bill 2002 of the 2023 session, which became chapter 228, declared an emergency and took effect on passage, according to the Oregon Legislature’s measure summary.

The summary opens: “Declares public policy regarding interstate actions arising out of reproductive health care and gender-affirming treatment.” Another line reads: “Prohibits public body from participating in interstate investigation or proceeding involving reproductive health care and gender-affirming treatment.”

Two more lines matter for anyone worried about records. One: “Prohibits clerk of court from issuing subpoena if foreign subpoena relates to reproductive health care or gender-affirming treatment.” The other: “Declares that Oregon law governs certain actions arising out of reproductive health care or gender-affirming treatment provided or received in this state.”

Read those words carefully. They speak of interstate actions and foreign subpoenas, meaning demands from other states. Like New York’s Shield Law, Oregon’s law is written to keep another state’s case out of Oregon’s courts and agencies. Neither summary says a state can stop the DOJ subpoenas on its own.

10

What patients and providers can do now

None of this is legal advice, and nothing here guarantees an outcome. But a few steps are within reach of most people this news touches.

  • Patients: ask your clinic how it responds to requests for records, including DOJ subpoenas, and keep your own copies of your care documents.
  • Parents: if your child’s provider tells you it received a demand for records, ask what it plans to do and whether you’ll be notified before anything is shared.
  • Providers: don’t hand over records the day a demand arrives. Call a lawyer. The courts that quashed the DOJ subpoenas did so because providers asked them to.
  • New Yorkers: if you receive a covered request, follow the four steps above and write to shield.law@ag.ny.gov.
  • Oregonians: know that HB 2002 bars Oregon court clerks from issuing subpoenas based on out-of-state subpoenas tied to gender-affirming treatment.

If this news has you frightened, you don’t have to carry it alone. Trans Lifeline answers at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by call or text at 988, and RAINN at 800-656-4673. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more help.

11

The people behind the billing codes

Strip away the docket numbers and the subpoena language, and these fights are about teenagers, their parents and the doctors they trusted. Each chart the DOJ subpoenas sought belongs to someone who walked into a clinic hoping to be seen as they are. The courts that ruled said those charts weren’t the government’s to take on these facts.

A resignation doesn’t heal the fear that the DOJ subpoenas planted. Some families still wonder who has read what. Some clinics stopped offering care, and that loss is real whether or not a judge ever rules again. Protecting someone’s medical record is a way of protecting their dignity, and dignity shouldn’t depend on which state a person lives in.

12

What Bloom is doing

Bloom’s newsroom will follow the appeals over the DOJ subpoenas, report who is named to lead the Civil Division, and link the rulings and records so you can read them yourself. You’ll find that coverage in the Trans Advocacy newsroom.

This is one of several federal fights over trans care we’re tracking. On November 7 we reported on federal workers asking a judge to restore FEHB coverage for gender-affirming care, and on November 10 on New Hampshire teens asking a court to pause the Medicaid gender-affirming care rule. If your family is weighing whether to move to a state with stronger protections, start with Bloom’s Trans Relocation page.

And if this story touches fear for your own records, or grief for care your family lost, Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

13

Frequently Asked Questions

Brett Shumate has headed the Justice Department’s Civil Division, which issued more than 20 DOJ subpoenas to gender-affirming care providers on June 11, 2025. ABC News reported that he submitted his resignation on November 9, 2026.

The DOJ subpoenas were administrative demands to hospitals, physician groups and other providers. According to Faegre Drinker, they sought billing documents, communications with drug makers, prescriber information and minor patients’ records, including Social Security numbers and home addresses.

Not in the rulings Faegre Drinker tracked. By January 29, 2026, Faegre Drinker counted six federal district courts that had quashed or limited the DOJ subpoenas, in Massachusetts, Washington, Pennsylvania, Colorado and Maryland. The government has appealed.

No. A resignation doesn’t withdraw a subpoena or drop an appeal. The Civil Division’s next leader inherits those cases, and Attorney General Todd Blanche listed the clinic closures among the division’s accomplishments.

Released on November 9, 2026, it explains protections for people who receive, provide or help others access abortion and gender-affirming care. It sets four steps, including notifying the Attorney General’s office and waiting 30 calendar days, before anyone hands over protected health information.

Yes. House Bill 2002 of 2023 bars Oregon public bodies from joining interstate investigations into reproductive health care and gender-affirming treatment, and bars court clerks from issuing subpoenas based on out-of-state subpoenas about that care.

Trans Lifeline answers at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by call or text at 988, and RAINN at 800-656-4673. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸