Cars on a highway at sunrise under scattered clouds, illustrating the commutes interrupted by warrantless arrests

NewsroomLegislationNews

Class Action Accuses ICE of Warrantless Arrests Across Virginia

A new Virginia lawsuit says ICE agents arrest first and ask questions later, including, the complaint says, an 18-year-old U.S. citizen. Federal law sets a higher bar. Here's what the case asks a judge to do.

An 18-year-old U.S. citizen, handcuffed beside a busy road in Norfolk while her four-year-old sister cried near traffic. That’s the scene a new class action uses to open its case against Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which it accuses of making warrantless arrests across Virginia without the probable cause federal law requires.

The complaint, filed Monday, November 16, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, asks a federal judge to stop that practice. It was brought on behalf of the Centreville Immigration Forum and six Virginia residents. None of its claims has been tested in court yet, and what follows is the plaintiffs’ account.

01

What the lawsuit says happened

According to the complaint, the young woman had come with her little sister to the scene of an earlier immigration arrest to retrieve a vehicle. She told officers again and again that she was a U.S. citizen and that her identification was in her wallet. The complaint says they refused to release her.

Instead, the lawsuit says, agents shackled her in handcuffs, ankle cuffs and a waist chain, took her to ICE’s Norfolk office and held her for hours. The complaint says her sister was left crying and wandering near traffic while she was restrained.

Another plaintiff, the complaint says, is a 41-year-old mechanic from Mexico who has lived in Newport News for about 14 years, goes to church regularly and has close family in Virginia, including U.S. citizens. On July 13, 2026, while he was driving alone to work shortly after 8 in the morning and obeying traffic laws, an unmarked SUV cut him off and switched on flashing emergency lights.

He handed over a valid Virginia driver’s license, the lawsuit says. Officers in tactical vests surrounded his car, and one raised a baton as if ready to break the window. After an officer asked where he was from and heard Mexico, he was ordered out and handcuffed. The complaint says the officers didn’t identify themselves, explain the stop, show a warrant or ask about his immigration status before the arrest.

The lawsuit says these warrantless arrests aren’t outliers. It describes people stopped on ordinary trips to work or to run errands, with agents in unmarked cars boxing in their vehicles, displaying weapons, handcuffing them and taking them to immigration facilities. When agents made these stops, the complaint says, “the agents often knew little about them beyond their names, if anything at all.”

The plaintiffs call it an arrest-first, investigate-later approach to warrantless arrests. That, they argue, is exactly what the law forbids.

02

What the law requires for warrantless arrests

Congress gave immigration officers the power to arrest without a warrant, but only in narrow circumstances. Under 8 U.S.C. § 1357(a)(2), an officer may arrest someone without a warrant if the officer has “reason to believe” that the person is in the United States in violation of immigration law and “is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained for his arrest.”

Both parts matter. The lawsuit says those determinations “must be individualized and particularized to the person being arrested and must be made before the arrest.” Put simply, an officer can’t make warrantless arrests first and look for probable cause later. The reason has to exist, and be about the person in front of the officer, before the handcuffs come out.

The complaint’s claims rest on that statute, on ICE’s own regulations at 8 C.F.R. § 287.8(c)(2), on the principle that federal agencies must follow their own rules, and on the Administrative Procedure Act. It also argues ICE is acting beyond the authority Congress gave it.

The statute’s standard echoes an older promise. The Fourth Amendment protects “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures.” This lawsuit leans on the statute and regulations rather than on the amendment, but the idea underneath is the same: the government needs a reason, about you, before it takes you.

03

Who is suing, and what they want

The ACLU of Virginia filed the class action with Bailey & Glasser, Covington & Burling, the Legal Aid Justice Center and the Washington Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights and Urban Affairs. The defendants are the Department of Homeland Security, ICE and three officials sued in their official capacities.

The lead organizational plaintiff, the Centreville Immigration Forum, is a nonprofit membership group founded in 2011 that serves working-class and immigrant communities, the complaint says. It runs a labor resource center, helps workers recover stolen wages and offers English classes.

According to the complaint, the forum has received reports of about 61 arrests or detentions involving its members or their family and friends since February 2025. Thirty-five of them happened at or near places where it holds programs, or while members were traveling to or from them.

The six individual plaintiffs want to represent two classes of people arrested in Virginia since January 20, 2025, without a warrant:

  • An immigration status class: people arrested without a pre-arrest, individualized assessment of probable cause that they were in the United States unlawfully.
  • An escape risk class: people arrested without a pre-arrest, individualized assessment of probable cause that they were likely to escape before officers could get a warrant.

The class action asks the court to certify those classes, declare the practice unlawful, set it aside and bar ICE from continuing it. It also challenges agents’ failure to identify themselves and explain the reason for an arrest, which the plaintiffs say ICE’s own regulations require.

04

The numbers behind the class action

The lawsuit says immigration arrests in Virginia rose sharply in the first year of the current administration, the backdrop for the warrantless arrests it challenges. ICE averaged about 970 arrests a month in Virginia and Washington, D.C., the complaint says, nearly five times the 2024 monthly average.

The ACLU of Virginia says ICE’s own data show 8,835 arrests in Virginia between January 20, 2025, and August 5, 2026 of people who weren’t already in custody. By the group’s count, that’s a jump from about six such arrests a week in 2024 to 109 a week, a 1,724 percent increase in the weekly rate.

The complaint also says the administration has publicly imposed immigration arrest quotas reaching 3,000 arrests a day nationwide, and argues those pressures drive warrantless arrests without individualized probable cause.

Those figures come from the plaintiffs. They don’t show, on their own, how many arrests skipped probable cause. That’s the question the court will have to answer about warrantless arrests in Virginia.

05

The fight over “likely to escape”

On January 28, 2026, then-Acting ICE Director Todd M. Lyons issued a memorandum to all ICE personnel, according to the complaint. The plaintiffs say it offered “guidance for the lawful and consistent exercise of warrantless arrest authority for civil violations of immigration laws.”

The class action argues the memo didn’t change how warrantless arrests are carried out in Virginia. It asks the court to declare the memo’s reading of “likely to escape” contrary to law, set it aside and bar ICE from relying on it.

ICE has been here before. In 2018, Chicago residents and nonprofit groups sued over warrantless arrests in the Chicago area, according to the complaint. That case, Castañon Nava v. Department of Homeland Security, ended in a settlement that required ICE to adopt a nationwide policy against warrantless arrests that didn’t meet the statute’s requirements.

On November 23, 2021, as part of that settlement, ICE issued what it called a Broadcast Statement of Policy, the complaint says. It made clear that “mere presence within the United States in violation of U.S. immigration law is not, by itself, sufficient” to show someone is likely to escape. It listed factors that could matter, including “ties to the community (such as a family, home, or employment) or lack thereof.”

The complaint says a federal court in Illinois ruled on February 23, 2026, that the Broadcast Statement was the ICE policy governing warrantless arrests, and that in April 2026 the Chicago plaintiffs agreed to relieve ICE of those provisions outside the Chicago area. The Virginia plaintiffs say that since about January 20, 2025, ICE has disregarded those safeguards in their state.

That phrase, “likely to escape,” carries more weight than it seems. If “likely to escape” can be assumed about almost anyone, the warrant requirement shrinks to almost nothing. If it has to be shown about the particular person, case by case, warrantless arrests become the exception Congress wrote them to be.

06

Other courts have weighed similar warrantless arrests

The Virginia case isn’t the first challenge to warrantless arrests of its kind. The complaint cites rulings from federal courts in Colorado, the District of Columbia, California and Oregon, and says courts have concluded that materially similar warrantless arrests violate federal law.

For readers in the Pacific Northwest, one of those cases is close to home: M-J-M-A- v. Lyons, decided in 2026 by the federal court in Oregon, according to the complaint’s citations. The complaint also points to a 2026 order in a long-running Illinois case, Castañon Nava v. Department of Homeland Security, about ICE’s written policy on warrantless arrests.

Rulings on warrantless arrests in other districts don’t bind the court in Alexandria. But they show this isn’t a fringe argument. Federal judges in several states have taken the same statute seriously.

07

Neighbors, not numbers

Behind every figure in this complaint is a morning that went wrong: a commute that ended in handcuffs, a four-year-old left crying by the road. The law Congress wrote doesn’t ask officers to stop enforcing immigration law. It asks them to know who they’re arresting, and why, before they do it.

That’s not a partisan demand. It’s the oldest promise in our legal tradition, that liberty isn’t taken on a hunch. Whatever happens to this lawsuit, the people in it deserve to be seen as what they are: neighbors, workers, parishioners and family members, not quotas.

08

A timeline of the Virginia class action

  • 2011: The Centreville Immigration Forum is founded in Centreville, Virginia.
  • November 23, 2021: ICE issues its Broadcast Statement of Policy on warrantless arrests, as part of the Castañon Nava settlement.
  • January 20, 2025: The start date for both proposed classes of people arrested without a warrant in Virginia.
  • February 2025: The forum begins receiving reports of members and their loved ones being arrested or detained, about 61 by the time of filing.
  • January 28, 2026: Then-Acting ICE Director Todd M. Lyons issues his memorandum on warrantless arrest authority.
  • February 23, 2026: A federal court in Illinois rules the Broadcast Statement is the ICE policy governing warrantless arrests, according to the complaint.
  • July 13, 2026: A Newport News mechanic is arrested without a warrant on his way to work, the complaint says.
  • August 5, 2026: The end of the ICE data period the ACLU of Virginia cites.
  • November 16, 2026: The class action is filed in Alexandria as No. 1:26-cv-03777.

09

What to do if ICE stops you

The ACLU of Virginia’s know-your-rights guide for Virginia, Maryland and Washington, D.C., gives this advice. It’s general guidance, not legal advice for your situation, so talk to a lawyer when you can.

  1. You don’t have to answer questions about your immigration status, where you were born or how you entered the country, the guide says.
  2. Say “no” if you’re asked for permission to search. If officers search anyway, the guide says not to resist.
  3. Never show false documents, and never lie about being a U.S. citizen.
  4. If you have lawful immigration status and ICE asks for proof, the guide says you must present your valid immigration documents.
  5. If agents come to your home, don’t open the door. Ask them to show any warrant through the peephole or slip it under the door. The guide says an ICE warrant doesn’t give agents permission to enter your home, while a criminal warrant signed by a judge may.
  6. Make a plan now: emergency contacts, a lawyer’s number, and someone with authority to care for your loved ones if you’re detained.

These steps can’t stop one of the warrantless arrests this lawsuit describes. They can protect your words, your records and your family while a lawyer works to sort out what happened.

10

What’s still unclear

  • How the government will respond to the complaint, and whether it will dispute the plaintiffs’ accounts and figures.
  • Whether the court will certify the two proposed classes.
  • Whether the plaintiffs will ask for faster, temporary relief while the case proceeds.
  • How the court will read “likely to escape,” the phrase at the center of the warrantless arrests dispute.
  • Whether ICE will change how its officers document probable cause before warrantless arrests in Virginia while the case is pending.

11

What Bloom is doing

Bloom reports on civil liberties for everyone, because a right that can be skipped for one neighbor can be skipped for any of us. This month we’ve covered an immigration lawyer’s phone search and the Justice Department’s new 10-day deadline for most immigration appeals, and we’ll follow this class action on warrantless arrests as it moves.

If an arrest in your family has left you frightened or in crisis, Bloom’s crisis support page is a place to start, and 988 answers by call or text.

Reporting that stays with a case until it’s decided depends on readers who stay with us. If you can, give monthly; a one-time gift helps too.

12

Frequently Asked Questions

It’s a class action over warrantless arrests, filed November 16, 2026, in federal court in Alexandria. It says ICE makes warrantless arrests in Virginia without first deciding, about each person, whether there’s probable cause they’re here unlawfully and likely to escape.

Under 8 U.S.C. 1357(a)(2), only when an officer has reason to believe the person is in the United States in violation of immigration law and is likely to escape before a warrant can be obtained.

The ACLU of Virginia and four other legal groups, on behalf of the Centreville Immigration Forum and six Virginia residents. They sued the Department of Homeland Security, ICE and three officials.

The complaint says an 18-year-old U.S. citizen was arrested without a warrant in Norfolk and held for hours. That account is the plaintiffs’; the court hasn’t ruled on it.

A January 28, 2026 memo from then-Acting ICE Director Todd M. Lyons on warrantless arrest authority. The lawsuit asks the court to set aside its reading of the phrase “likely to escape.”

No. The proposed classes cover warrantless arrests in Virginia. The complaint cites similar cases in other states, including Oregon, and the federal standard for warrantless arrests applies nationwide.

It means a reasonable, fact-based belief about the specific person. The lawsuit says officers must have probable cause that a person is unlawfully present and likely to escape before warrantless arrests, not after.

The ACLU of Virginia’s guide says you don’t have to answer questions about your immigration status, should refuse consent to searches, and should never show false documents or claim to be a U.S. citizen falsely.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.