A plain gray cinder-block wall, for a report on a seclusion lawsuit against an Indiana school district

NewsroomIndiana LegislatureNews

Lawsuit Says Indiana School Shut First Grader Alone in Padded Closet

A federal lawsuit says an Indiana school shut a first grader alone in a cinder-block room, then a padded closet, when his disability made him cry, scream or leave class. The district's own tracker counts 10,887 minutes out of class.

A first grader at an Indiana elementary school was shut alone, again and again, in a cinder-block “reflection room” and later in a padded closet about three and a half feet wide, whenever his disability made him cry, scream or leave class. That’s what a federal seclusion lawsuit filed Friday, November 20, 2026, says. The district’s own tracker, cited in the seclusion lawsuit, shows the school removed him from instruction for 10,887 minutes between November 6, 2025, and May 1, 2026.

His family is suing Northwest Allen County Schools, which runs Oak View Elementary School in Allen County, under federal disability law and Indiana law. Nothing in the complaint has been proven, and the district hasn’t yet responded in court. Superintendent Wayne Barker called the claims “unproven allegations.” Here’s what the seclusion lawsuit says, what Indiana’s seclusion law requires, and what parents of disabled children can do if they fear something like this is happening to their own child.

Following this story: children held in seclusion and isolation. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.

01

What the seclusion lawsuit says happened

The family filed in the Fort Wayne Division of the United States District Court for the Northern District of Indiana, The Journal Gazette reported. The parents and their son appear in court papers as Jane, John and James Doe, to protect the boy’s privacy. He’s 7 now. He was 6, and in first grade at Oak View, when the seclusion lawsuit says it began.

The complaint says the district knew the boy’s behavior was caused by his disabilities, WPTA 21Alive reported in a detailed account of the filing. He has autism, both outlets reported. Staff began placing him in a separate room in October 2025, before the district had evaluated him for special education, the seclusion lawsuit says.

Every claim below is an allegation in the seclusion lawsuit, and a court hasn’t tested any of it.

02

The reflection room

The first room was what the school called the “reflection room.” The complaint describes a cinder-block room about six feet wide and eight feet long, whose only window is a small, high, narrow window in the door. Staff allegedly closed the door with the boy inside and at times removed the only chair.

On October 28, 2025, a school administrator documented that the boy had been confined there for about 80 minutes across two placements in a single afternoon, according to the seclusion lawsuit. The chair was removed and the door closed. He was alone while staff stood outside and watched through the window, and he screamed and cried so long that staff finally went in, afraid he’d make himself sick.

He told staff, according to the seclusion lawsuit: “I am just sitting here waiting for the end of the day.”

The seclusion lawsuit says the same thing happened on December 2: the chair removed, the door closed, and a boy who’d turned 7 screaming and crying until staff went in. It also says that at least once, an administrator picked him up off his feet and carried him into the room.

03

What the parents say they told the district

The boy’s parents met with two district administrators and told them the reflection room was seclusion, the seclusion lawsuit says. One answered that when a student is screaming or rolling on the floor and won’t stop, “we have to do something to kind of cut that attention response.”

According to the seclusion lawsuit, neither administrator acted to stop the practice, and the school kept secluding the boy the same way. That alleged meeting may matter later, for reasons the Supreme Court has explained, which we cover below.

04

The padded closet the school called a calm-down space

In late March or early April 2026, the school moved the boy into an even smaller space, without holding an IEP meeting or telling his parents, the seclusion lawsuit says. An IEP, or individualized education program, is the written plan for a disabled student’s special education.

The padded closet was about three and a half feet wide. Three walls were covered floor to ceiling in padded vinyl, and the fourth was a heavy padded metal door. There was no furniture, and the only window sat at adult eye level, too high for him to see out while standing. The school called it his “calm-down space,” the Journal Gazette and WPTA reported.

Staff wouldn’t let him out until he performed what they called “whole body listening,” the seclusion lawsuit says: sitting cross-legged against the back wall, motionless and silent, for three minutes. WISH-TV reported the same detail from the family’s attorneys. The district’s own evaluation had documented that he has severe sensory difficulties.

On April 17, 2026, the seclusion lawsuit says, an administrator held the padded closet’s door shut with his foot and let the boy out only when his father arrived at the school. His parents didn’t learn the school was using the padded closet for their son until April 28.

05

10,887 minutes out of class

The district kept what the complaint calls a Removal Tracker. According to the seclusion lawsuit, it shows the school removed the boy from instruction for 10,887 minutes between November 6, 2025, and May 1, 2026. That’s more than 181 hours, or more than 28 full school days.

Counting ten days of suspension, the seclusion lawsuit says, the district kept him out of his classroom for the equivalent of more than 38 school days, more than one-fifth of Indiana’s school year. It says even those numbers “understate his loss,” because the tracker shows nothing from October 2025, when the confinements began.

Staff repeatedly called his parents to pick him up midday and told them the school “can’t handle him,” the seclusion lawsuit says. His parents withdrew him from the district before the 2026-2027 school year.

06

What the district says

Barker answered by email to WPTA. “The claims in the lawsuit are unproven allegations,” he said. “I have every confidence in our highly trained educators, support staff, and administrators and in their commitment to the students they serve.”

“Our educators and staff address a range of behavioral needs every day,” Barker said, adding that their training helps them respond while keeping a safe and appropriate learning environment for every student. “We look forward to addressing the allegations and defending the district’s actions in court.”

07

What the family’s attorney says

“This little boy was punished for his disability,” Catherine Michael, an attorney for the family, said in a statement reported by the Journal Gazette. “He was locked away from his classroom, his teachers, and his friends for the equivalent of more than a month of school.”

“Children with disabilities depend on the adults around them to keep them safe. Here the opposite occurred,” Michael said.

08

The claims in the seclusion lawsuit

The seclusion lawsuit brings two federal claims and several under Indiana law, according to WPTA’s account of the complaint:

  • Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act, which bars disability discrimination by public entities, including public schools.
  • Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, which bars disability discrimination by recipients of federal financial assistance.
  • Negligence and negligence per se, the second for violating Indiana’s seclusion and restraint law.
  • False imprisonment.
  • Intentional and negligent infliction of emotional distress, plus the parents’ own claim for expenses and losses.

The seclusion lawsuit says the district secluded the boy because of disability-related behavior and failed to train staff in de-escalation and positive behavior supports. The family seeks compensatory damages, including therapy costs, lost wages and attorney’s fees.

09

What seclusion means under Indiana law

Indiana’s seclusion law defines seclusion as “the confinement of a student alone in a room or area from which the student physically is prevented from leaving.” That’s Indiana Code 20-20-40-9, in the Indiana Code’s Title 20.

The same section leaves out a supervised time-out or scheduled break, written into a student’s IEP, “in which an adult is continuously present in the room with the student.” The state’s model plan puts it plainly: “Time out does not constitute seclusion.”

That line matters for this seclusion lawsuit, which describes a boy alone behind a closed door, with staff outside watching through a window. Whether the court sees that as seclusion under Indiana law may become a central question.

10

What Indiana’s seclusion law requires of schools

Every Indiana school corporation must adopt a restraint and seclusion plan with at least the elements of the state’s model, effective “not later than July 1, 2014,” under Indiana Code 20-20-40-14. The Indiana seclusion law, at section 13, sets those elements:

  • Last resort: seclusion is used “as a last resort safety procedure, employed only after another, less restrictive procedure has been implemented without success.”
  • Imminent risk: only when there’s “an imminent risk of injury to the student, other students, school employees, or visitors to the school.”
  • Short: only “for a short time period, or until the imminent risk of injury has passed.”
  • Documentation: a record of how every incident is documented and debriefed, and who keeps those records.
  • Parent notice: parents are told “as soon as possible,” and sent a copy of an incident report.
  • Training: recurrent training in alternatives, including positive behavior support and de-escalation.

The model plan adds that seclusion should usually last “a matter of minutes,” and says, “Seclusion shall never be used as a punishment, or to force compliance with staff commands.” It recommends, though the law doesn’t require it, that a seclusion space be large enough for the student “and at least one adult.”

The seclusion lawsuit says the district never documented the confinements in incident reports or told the family, as Indiana’s seclusion law has required of every school corporation since 2014.

11

A limit written into Indiana’s seclusion law

Indiana’s seclusion law also says the chapter “may not be construed to give rise to a cause of action, either civil or criminal” against a school corporation, among others. And it gives school staff qualified immunity for actions under a plan “if the action is taken in good faith and is reasonable.”

The family’s state claims are negligence, false imprisonment and emotional distress claims. One of them, negligence per se, rests on the Indiana seclusion law, according to WPTA. How the court handles that claim next to the statute’s own limit is one of the questions to watch.

12

How federal civil rights enforcers define seclusion

The U.S. Justice Department’s Civil Rights Division defines seclusion as “the involuntary confinement of a student alone in any room or area.” On its seclusion explainer, it says seclusion can happen “even if school staff monitors a student through an observation window or video feed,” and even when an unlocked door is held closed by staff.

The department enforces those limits under Title II of the ADA, the law behind this seclusion lawsuit’s first claim. In Indiana, it reached a settlement on December 31, 2020, with the North Gibson School Corporation in Princeton, and closed its monitoring in 2024 after the district ended the practice of secluding students, its enforcement page says. On February 23, 2026, it found that the Special School District of St. Louis had secluded over 300 students almost 4,000 times in two years.

13

Three Supreme Court rulings behind cases like this

Three recent rulings shape any seclusion lawsuit seeking money for a disabled student.

In 2023, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously for Miguel Luna Perez, a deaf student from Michigan. A student suing under the ADA for compensatory damages doesn’t first have to exhaust the special education hearing process, because that process can’t award those damages, the court held.

In 2025, a unanimous court held that students’ education claims under the ADA and Section 504 don’t require proof of “bad faith or gross misjudgment,” a standard some lower courts had used. For damages, most appeals courts require intentional discrimination, which they find in “deliberate indifference,” the opinion explains. What district leaders knew, and when, can matter.

In 2022, the court held that “Emotional distress damages are not recoverable in a private action to enforce either the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 or the Affordable Care Act,” its ruling says. Section 504 is part of the Rehabilitation Act. Bloom has reported on a bill that would restore emotional distress damages.

14

Why this matters to parents of disabled children

If you’re the parent of a disabled child, you may know the midday phone call. Come get him. We can’t handle him.

This seclusion lawsuit hasn’t been decided, and the district deserves its day in court. But one line from the complaint should stay with all of us: a 6-year-old telling staff, “I am just sitting here waiting for the end of the day.” A child who cries, screams or runs is telling us something. The law asks schools to listen with support first, and to use seclusion only when someone is about to get hurt.

Your child has rights that don’t depend on how hard a day is. Section 504 and the ADA, the laws behind this seclusion lawsuit, bar a public school from discriminating because of disability. You’re allowed to ask questions, and to ask for help.

15

A second isolation case this week

This is the second case of a young person held alone that Bloom has reported this week. A federal jury found that a teenager in Wyoming’s custody was locked alone in a cinderblock room as punishment and awarded him $6 million. The settings differ, and that case ended in a verdict while this seclusion lawsuit has just begun.

Both cases ask the same question: when adults shut a young person away, who’s protected? Bloom is following both.

16

A timeline of the seclusion lawsuit

These dates come from Indiana law and from the seclusion lawsuit as news outlets reported it:

  • 2013: Indiana’s General Assembly creates the Commission on Seclusion and Restraint in Schools, the Indiana Department of Education says.
  • July 1, 2014: Every Indiana school corporation’s restraint and seclusion plan must be in effect.
  • October 2025: Staff begin placing the boy, then 6, in the reflection room, the seclusion lawsuit says.
  • October 28, 2025: About 80 minutes in the reflection room in one afternoon, across two placements.
  • November 6, 2025: The Removal Tracker’s count begins.
  • December 2, 2025: Another confinement until staff go in.
  • Late March or early April 2026: The move to the padded closet, without an IEP meeting or notice to his parents.
  • April 17, 2026: An administrator holds the padded closet door shut until the boy’s father arrives, the complaint says.
  • April 28, 2026: His parents learn of the padded closet.
  • May 1, 2026: The tracker’s count ends at 10,887 minutes.
  • Before the 2026-2027 school year: His parents withdraw him.
  • November 20, 2026: The family files the seclusion lawsuit in Fort Wayne.

17

What happens next in court

First, the district has to be served. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12, a defendant answers “within 21 days after being served with the summons and complaint,” or within 60 days after a request to waive formal service is sent, if it agrees to waive. Instead of answering, it may ask the court to dismiss some or all claims, for example for “failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted.”

CourtListener lists the case as Doe against Northwest Allen County Schools, with seven docket entries on November 20. Bloom will follow the seclusion lawsuit and report each ruling.

18

What parents can do now

Whatever happens to this seclusion lawsuit, if you worry your child is being secluded at school, here’s a checklist:

  1. Ask for the records. Indiana’s seclusion law says parents get a copy of an incident report after seclusion. Ask the school, in writing, for every incident report and every removal or behavior log about your child.
  2. Ask for the school’s plan. Every Indiana school corporation must have a restraint and seclusion plan. Ask for a copy.
  3. Ask for a meeting. Request an IEP or Section 504 meeting. Ask about a functional behavioral assessment and a behavioral intervention plan, which Indiana law ties to the IEP.
  4. Write it down. Keep dates, times, who called you and what they said.
  5. File a civil rights complaint. The Education Department’s Office for Civil Rights says, “A complaint must ordinarily be filed within 180 days of the last act of discrimination.”
  6. Tell the Justice Department. “If you believe a child with a disability has been improperly secluded, you can file a complaint through the Civil Rights Division Portal,” its seclusion page says.

19

Where to get help in Indiana

Indiana Disability Rights is Indiana’s protection and advocacy system for people with disabilities. Call toll-free at 800-622-4845, or locally at 317-722-5555.

The Indiana Department of Education also takes reports about seclusion and restraint for its commission. The form asks families to use it once other steps at the school haven’t worked, and says it doesn’t replace a special education complaint. At the federal level, OCR says, “Anyone may file a complaint.”

20

What Bloom is doing

Bloom’s disability advocacy work exists for families like the one in this seclusion lawsuit, who are told a classroom can’t hold their child. I believe no child should spend a school day alone behind a door, waiting for it to end.

If this story brings back your own child’s hardest days, or your own, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and Bloom’s support groups are there for you. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reporting on cases like this one, and a one-time gift helps too.

21

Frequently Asked Questions

It says Oak View Elementary repeatedly confined a first grader with autism alone, first in a cinder-block reflection room and later in a padded closet, when his disability made him cry, scream or leave class. The district’s tracker shows 10,887 minutes out of instruction from November 6, 2025, to May 1, 2026.

No. The seclusion lawsuit was filed November 20, 2026, and every claim in it is an allegation. Superintendent Wayne Barker called the claims “unproven allegations” and said the district will defend its actions in court.

Indiana defines seclusion as confining a student alone in a room or area the student is physically prevented from leaving. It doesn’t include a supervised time-out with an adult continuously present in the room.

Only as a last resort, after less restrictive steps fail, when there’s an imminent risk of injury, and only for a short time. Parents must be notified as soon as possible and sent a copy of an incident report.

Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, which both bar disability discrimination. It also brings Indiana claims, including false imprisonment.

Ask the school in writing for every incident report and its seclusion plan, request an IEP or Section 504 meeting, and keep notes. You can also file a complaint with the Office for Civil Rights or the Justice Department, or call Indiana Disability Rights at 800-622-4845.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.