Old leather-bound record books on gray archive shelves, illustrating the documents under review in the Presbyterian Church investigation

NewsroomJustice for survivorsNews

Police Send 10 Files to Prosecutors in Presbyterian Church Abuse Probe

A year after the Presbyterian Church in Ireland admitted it failed people who sought its help, 168 people have gone to police. Detectives have made two arrests and sent 10 files to prosecutors, who will decide whether anyone is charged.

This article discusses sexual abuse. It contains no graphic detail.

One hundred sixty-eight people have now come to police in Northern Ireland to report concerns or share information about harm connected with the Presbyterian Church in Ireland, the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) said on Thursday, November 19, 2026. Detectives have sent 10 files to prosecutors, who will decide whether anyone is charged, and have made two arrests over alleged offences that include sexual communication with a child, sexual assault of a child and rape, according to the BBC.

The update comes one year after the Presbyterian Church admitted “serious and significant failings” in how it protected people from 2009 to 2022. No charge has been reported, and Bloom names no suspect and no survivor. Here’s what police said, what the Presbyterian Church admitted, what happens to the files now, and how a survivor can report in Northern Ireland, Ireland or the United States.

01

What police said on November 19

The PSNI said that over the past year detectives had “continued to assess and investigate information received from victims, witnesses, safeguarding partners and other parties,” the BBC reported. As of Thursday, 168 people had contacted police directly to report concerns or give information.

The other figures matter as much. Two people have been arrested. Ten files have gone to the Public Prosecution Service, and 10 voluntary interviews have taken place, The Irish Times and The Irish News reported. A “significant volume of documents are under review by the dedicated PSNI team,” police said.

RTÉ reported the update on Saturday, November 21, describing the 10 files as files on 10 people and saying 10 people had attended voluntary interviews. None of the reports Bloom read names anyone arrested, reports a charge, or names a congregation.

02

The Presbyterian Church investigation at a glance

  • People who contacted police directly: 168, up from 127 on September 4.
  • Arrests: two, over alleged offences including sexual communication with a child, sexual assault of a child and rape.
  • Files sent to prosecutors: 10.
  • Voluntary interviews: 10.
  • Charges: none reported in the coverage Bloom read.
  • The Presbyterian Church in Ireland: more than 185,000 members in more than 500 congregations on both sides of the border, RTÉ reports.

03

Why 41 more people came forward since September

On September 4, 2026, police reported 127 contacts from potential victims or witnesses, the BBC reported. Eleven weeks later the number is 168. When the PSNI investigation began in November 2025, Assistant Chief Constable Davy Beck said a “small number” of victims had come forward.

The PSNI hasn’t said why the number keeps rising. But Beck’s own words on Thursday point toward part of the answer. “We recognise that behind these figures are people, some of whom have carried difficult experiences for many years,” he said.

That’s the human truth inside every number. Many people carry harm for years before they can name it, and a church admitting its failure in public can be the first sign that someone will finally listen. “It is not too late to come forward,” Beck said.

04

What the Presbyterian Church admitted in November 2025

On Wednesday, November 12, 2025, the Presbyterian Church in Ireland published a report by its own safeguarding team. It found a “number of situations between 2009 and 2021, with one as late as 2022, where we have failed to deliver an adequate safeguarding service,” The Irish Times reported.

The report described failures “to make referrals to statutory authorities when these were required,” the paper said. The Presbyterian Church also failed “to respond to people who, having suffered harm, have sought our help.” And there were “situations where some offenders returning to worship in Church, following referrals to us by statutory bodies, were inadequately monitored.”

“As a result of this, people have been placed at risk,” the Presbyterian Church’s leader said that day, adding “we believe there may well be others as yet unknown to us.”

05

Why the moderator stepped down

That leader was the Rev Trevor Gribben, the Presbyterian Church’s moderator, or chief public representative. He had taken office in June 2025 and had been the church’s general secretary, or clerk, since 2014, and its deputy clerk from 2008, The Irish Times reported.

Gribben said he wasn’t directly responsible for delivering safeguarding, but that “serious and significant failings in our central safeguarding functions occurred partly during my tenure as general secretary.” He announced he would step aside as moderator at the end of November 2025 and retire as clerk and general secretary.

His predecessor, the Rev Dr Richard Murray, returned to the office. By September 2026, the Rev Dr Richard Kerr was the Presbyterian Church’s moderator, the BBC and the church’s own statement show.

06

What a safeguarding failure looks like

The Presbyterian Church later explained what had gone wrong. At an emergency General Assembly on December 18, 2025, the Rev Dr David Bruce, convener of the church’s general council, said, “Often these responses were slow, and in some cases, completely absent,” the BBC reported.

“It was clear that emails had not been opened, or that phone calls had not been returned,” Bruce said. He added that many requests were handled well, but the overall picture was one of significant failings.

Safeguarding failures rarely look dramatic from the outside. They look like an unopened email, a call no one returns, a referral never made. For the person who finally found the courage to ask for help, that silence can feel like a second wound.

07

What the former head of safeguarding said

Dr Jacqui Montgomery-Devlin became the Presbyterian Church’s head of safeguarding in 2019 and was the only person responsible for safeguarding congregations in more than 500 churches, the BBC reported. She left in June 2024.

Speaking publicly in November 2025, she said it was a “struggle” for the church’s higher authorities to take safeguarding seriously, and accused the church of a “culture of control,” the BBC reported. She said the internal report should be published, even if partly redacted, and called for an external public inquiry.

“This is about protecting the innocent, protecting the victims and survivors now,” she said. Asked to respond, the Presbyterian Church said it had nothing to add to what it had already made public, according to the BBC.

08

How the PSNI investigation began

The PSNI announced its criminal investigation on Monday, November 17, 2025, setting up a dedicated team led by detectives in its Public Protection Branch, according to the BBC and RTÉ. Beck said the investigation would look at offending and also “if criminal offences have been committed by those responsible for safeguarding.”

The PSNI had confirmed that it was talking with the Presbyterian Church after concerns it raised following an individual’s 2024 conviction for child sex offences, The Irish Times reported. Beck also said there was “potential for this to be a cross-Border and cross-jurisdictional investigation,” and that he’d spoken with An Garda Síochána, Ireland’s police.

The Presbyterian Church said it welcomed the investigation. “We will make available all relevant files, reports and information to assist police with their inquiries,” a spokesperson said.

09

A timeline of the Presbyterian Church investigation

These dates come from the BBC, RTÉ, The Irish Times, the Irish Examiner, the PSNI and the church:

  • November 12, 2025: The Presbyterian Church publishes its safeguarding report, and its moderator announces he’ll step down.
  • November 17, 2025: The PSNI launches a criminal investigation.
  • December 15, 2025: Police say the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland’s new statutory inquiry won’t affect their investigation.
  • December 18, 2025: The Presbyterian Church apologizes publicly at an emergency General Assembly.
  • February 19, 2026: The PSNI reports 101 referrals.
  • March 27, 2026: The Presbyterian Church appoints INEQE for an independent review.
  • June 24, 2026: Ireland’s police appeal for victims to contact them.
  • September 4, 2026: Police report two arrests and 127 contacts.
  • September 21, 2026: The review’s surveys close.
  • November 19, 2026: Police report 168 contacts, 10 files and 10 voluntary interviews.

10

Two arrests, and why no one is named

An arrest isn’t a charge, and a file sent to prosecutors isn’t a finding of guilt. The coverage Bloom read names no one who was arrested and reports no charges. Everyone keeps the presumption of innocence.

Bloom doesn’t name people who are under investigation but not charged, and it never names survivors. That rule protects the people who came forward, and it protects the fairness of any trial that may follow.

11

What happens to the 10 files

The Public Prosecution Service for Northern Ireland decides whether to prosecute. It applies a two-stage Test for Prosecution, its guidance says. First, “the evidence which can be presented in court is sufficient to provide a reasonable prospect of conviction.” Second, “prosecution is required in the public interest.”

Both parts must be passed, and the evidential test comes first. “Where available, the views of the victim will also be taken into account,” the Public Prosecution Service says.

If prosecutors decide not to prosecute, a victim has “a right to ask us to review a decision we have taken not to prosecute,” the service’s review page says. The request should normally come in writing “within one month of the victim having been informed of the decision not to prosecute.”

12

The independent review and the Charity Commission inquiry

The police aren’t the only ones looking. On March 27, 2026, the Presbyterian Church appointed Jim Gamble, who formerly headed the Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre, to carry out an independent external review of its governance and safeguarding, working with the safeguarding group INEQE, the BBC reported. Murray said it would be “victim focused and trauma informed.”

The independent review ran surveys, including one for victims and survivors. “All contributions are anonymous, are submitted directly to INEQE (not to PCI),” the church said. “The surveys close on 21 September 2026.” The Presbyterian Church hasn’t given a date for findings.

Separately, the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland has opened a statutory inquiry. Police said their work “remains active and will not be affected by the Charity Commission’s Inquiry processes,” in a PSNI statement dated December 15, 2025.

13

What happens next in the Presbyterian Church investigation

Three processes are now running side by side. Prosecutors will weigh the 10 files. The independent review’s findings are still to come, and the Presbyterian Church hasn’t given a date. And the Charity Commission for Northern Ireland has its own statutory inquiry, opened in December 2025.

The PSNI investigation isn’t finished either. “This remains an active investigation,” Beck said on Thursday. “Its scale and complexity mean that it will take time, but we remain committed to investigating criminality, protecting those at risk and supporting victims.”

Police are still asking people to come forward, so the 168 figure may keep rising. Bloom will report charging decisions if prosecutors announce them, and the review’s findings when they’re published.

14

What the Presbyterian Church has said since

At the December 2025 assembly, Murray apologized. “And to them we say sorry, that you have been hurt or harmed, or both, by our failings,” he said. He also admitted, “As yet, we do not know the extent of our failings.”

In February 2026, after police reported 101 referrals, Murray said, “To those who have done so, we want to acknowledge their bravery,” RTÉ reported. In June, Bruce told the annual assembly, “I suspect our reputation will need to be rebuilt from the ground up,” The Irish Times reported.

After the September arrests, Kerr said, “We also recognise the bravery and strength of those who have already come forward.” The Presbyterian Church has created a standalone safeguarding department and trained about 2,800 people in May and June, according to its statement and the BBC.

15

What churches owe survivors

The Presbyterian Church’s own report on its safeguarding failures is a list of what any church owes the people in its care. Answer the call. Make the referral to the authorities when it’s required. Watch closely when someone who has offended returns to worship. And never let a person who has been harmed knock on a door that no one opens.

Bruce spoke of “a commitment that their stories, their needs and their voices will help to shape best practice as we look ahead.” That’s the right order. Survivors aren’t a problem a church manages; they’re people a church serves.

Repentance in public is a start, and accountability is what proves it. That means full cooperation with police, an independent review that survivors can trust, and findings people can read.

16

What police are asking of survivors

Beck’s message on Thursday was written for people who haven’t spoken yet. Police want to hear about “safeguarding concerns that were known by, reported to, or otherwise connected with the Presbyterian Church in Ireland,” he said.

“You do not have to have all the answers, and you do not have to decide immediately what you want to happen next,” Beck said. “Our specialist detectives will listen to you, explain the process and treat you with sensitivity, respect and professionalism.”

Northern Ireland’s Commissioner for Victims of Crime, Geraldine Hanna, said, “Deciding on whether to come forward, or not, is an intensely personal decision.” Choosing not to report is also a choice you’re allowed to make. Support is there either way.

A year ago, Hanna named why this kind of harm cuts so deep. When an institution that fails someone “is their church,” she said, “it can be devastating,” the BBC reported. If that’s your story, your faith isn’t the thing that failed you. People did, and the Presbyterian Church has said so itself.

17

How to report in Northern Ireland

You can reach the PSNI investigation team by calling 101 or emailing PCIenquiry@psni.police.uk, The Irish News reported. In an emergency, call 999.

“You don’t have to come to a police station, we can come to you, on your terms,” Beck said when the investigation began. Victim Support NI offers confidential support to anyone affected by crime at 028 9013 0405, the PSNI’s investigation page says.

18

How to report in Ireland

The Presbyterian Church has about 22,000 members in the Republic of Ireland, The Irish Times reported. In June, An Garda Síochána invited anyone living in Ireland who believes they were a victim of a crime connected with the Presbyterian Church to contact gardaí, the Irish Examiner reported.

You can go to your local Garda station, email GNPSB_SCMU@garda.ie, or call the Garda Child Sexual Abuse Reporting Line on 1800 555 222, a free and confidential line open 24/7. “Your contact will be handled with sensitivity and empathy,” a Garda spokesperson said. At that time, gardaí said they hadn’t received any direct complaints.

19

How to get help in the United States

If you live in the United States and were harmed in a church here or abroad, you can call RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline at 800-656-4673. If a child is in danger right now, call 911.

Oregon Child Abuse Hotline: 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233). If you’re in crisis, call or text 988.

20

What you can do

  1. Report when you’re ready. In Northern Ireland, call 101 or email the investigation team. In Ireland, contact a Garda station or 1800 555 222.
  2. Bring what you have. Police say you don’t need all the answers.
  3. Write down what you remember, including who you told and when.
  4. Ask about support first, through Victim Support NI or RAINN, if you aren’t ready to report.
  5. If prosecutors decide not to prosecute, ask the Public Prosecution Service for a review within one month.
  6. If you see a child at risk now, call 999 in Northern Ireland or 911 in the United States.

21

Bloom’s reporting on churches and abuse

Bloom has followed how churches answer for abuse in the United States this week. Survivors have asked the Supreme Court who decides what clergy must report, and the Baltimore archdiocese reached a tentative deal with abuse survivors.

A former Rhode Island priest avoided prison with a no contest plea. Different churches, different countries, one question: will an institution tell the truth about harm done under its roof?

22

What Bloom is doing

Bloom is a ministry, and we believe a church’s first duty is to the person who was hurt, not to its own name. I pray that every survivor who has gone to police this year is met with patience and truth, and that every one still holding their story knows it isn’t too late.

If this story stirs up your own memories, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call at any hour. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

A monthly gift keeps Bloom reporting on institutions that fail survivors, and a one-time gift helps too.

23

Frequently Asked Questions

On November 19, 2026, the PSNI said 168 people had contacted police directly, two people had been arrested, 10 files had gone to the Public Prosecution Service and 10 voluntary interviews had taken place.

The coverage Bloom read reports no charges. Prosecutors will decide whether the evidence and the public interest support a prosecution.

In November 2025, the Presbyterian Church said it found “serious and significant failings” in its central safeguarding functions from 2009 to 2022, including failures to make referrals and to respond to people who sought help.

Gribben, then the Presbyterian Church’s moderator, said the failings occurred partly while he was general secretary. He stepped down at the end of November 2025.

In Northern Ireland, call 101 or email PCIenquiry@psni.police.uk. In Ireland, contact a Garda station or the Garda Child Sexual Abuse Reporting Line on 1800 555 222.

Victim Support NI is at 028 9013 0405. In the United States, RAINN is at 800-656-4673.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.