Empty pews facing the altar of the historic Baltimore Basilica, for a report on the Baltimore archdiocese settlement talks with abuse survivors

NewsroomMaryland LegislatureNews

Baltimore Archdiocese Reaches Tentative Deal With Abuse Survivors

About 1,000 survivors of clergy sexual abuse have waited three years for the Baltimore archdiocese to settle. A mediator now reports a tentative agreement, but lawyers told the judge a final deal likely won't come before late January 2027.

About 1,000 survivors have filed claims in the Archdiocese of Baltimore's bankruptcy case.

This article discusses sexual abuse. It contains no graphic detail.

About 1,000 survivors of clergy sexual abuse have waited more than three years for the Baltimore archdiocese to make things right in bankruptcy court. This week, they heard the most hopeful news yet: the retired federal judge mediating the talks reported that the Archdiocese of Baltimore and the committee representing survivors have reached a tentative agreement, “subject to various conditions.”

It isn’t a settlement yet. Insurance companies, parishes and schools still have to agree, and attorneys told U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Michelle Harner at a hearing on Thursday, November 19, 2026, that a final deal would likely take until at least the end of January 2027, CBS News Baltimore reported. Here is what the tentative agreement means, who still has to sign on, and what survivors in the Baltimore archdiocese case should know now.

01

What the mediator reported

Retired U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Thomas Catliota, who is mediating the settlement talks, filed a report on Monday, November 16. He wrote that “the mediation resulted in a tentative agreement between them, subject to various conditions that remain,” the Maryland Daily Record reported. “Them” means the Baltimore archdiocese and the committee that represents survivors in the bankruptcy case.

A dollar amount is far from settled. “A wide gap remains,” Catliota wrote. “But slow progress does not mean no progress. Incremental progress is occurring although not at anyone’s preferred pace.”

No one has threatened to walk away from the table, he wrote. He recommended that Judge Harner extend the “status quo” until the end of January to give the talks more time, according to the Daily Record.

02

What the judge said on Thursday

Judge Harner has spent months pressing both sides, and on Thursday she said so plainly. “The survivors have waited long enough. They should not have to endure endless legal disputes,” she said, according to CBS News Baltimore. “Whatever it takes to get it done, we will do.”

She said she believed there was a way to reach a fair and equitable result, The Baltimore Banner reported. But at some point, she said, “counsel needs to make that happen or we need to go in a different direction.” She added, “I just feel really strongly that we’ve got to find a way to crack this nut.”

The judge also said she gets physically upset thinking about how much money is going to attorney fees, calling it disheartening, the Banner reported. “Creditors in this case are being prejudiced” by the slow pace, she said, according to the Daily Record. “These are real people.”

03

What lawyers for the Baltimore archdiocese and survivors said

Blake Roth, an attorney for the Baltimore archdiocese, told the court the two sides have made real progress. “We’re much, much closer than we’ve ever been to a resolution in this case,” he said, according to CBS News Baltimore. He told the Banner he’s optimistic about a deal after January 1, 2027. “I remain firmly convinced that we are very, very close,” he said.

Edwin Caldie, who represents the survivors’ committee, said a resolution should have come long ago. “We need to find a way to do better,” Caldie said, according to the Banner. “We’re making progress.”

To keep the talks moving, the survivors’ committee is no longer asking, for now, for permission to file lawsuits against the Baltimore archdiocese in state court. Caldie said it wouldn’t be “prudent” to lift that bar at this time, the Daily Record reported. That request had been a way to raise the threat of large jury verdicts and push insurers to settle.

04

What the Baltimore archdiocese has said

Several leaders of the Baltimore archdiocese attended Thursday’s hearing, CBS News Baltimore reported. Archbishop William Lori wasn’t among them. A year ago, outside the federal courthouse, he told the station that the church was committed to reaching a settlement. “From the very beginning, we said we would put the resources of the church into a settlement,” Lori said.

The Baltimore archdiocese has long said bankruptcy is the fairest path. “By filing Chapter 11, the Archdiocese is seeking to provide the most orderly process in which victim survivors can be compensated,” it told CBS earlier in the case. In April, it said it “continues to be committed to the process” of reaching an agreed resolution with the survivors’ committee and others.

Survivors have waited more than three years for those words to be kept. Roth, the archdiocese’s attorney, told the judge Thursday that the results would come all at once, the way a stonecutter’s work does. “It seems like not a lot is happening, and then all of a sudden it does,” he said, according to CBS.

05

Why the Baltimore archdiocese is in bankruptcy

The Archdiocese of Baltimore filed for bankruptcy in 2023, two days before Maryland’s Child Victims Act took effect, the Banner reported. That law eliminated time limits for survivors to file lawsuits and made it easier to hold institutions accountable.

Lawmakers passed the Child Victims Act after the Maryland Office of the Attorney General released a report of more than 450 pages. It detailed how 156 priests and others committed “horrific and repeated abuse” as the Catholic Church looked the other way, according to the Banner. The attorney general found that more than 600 children were abused under the church’s supervision, CBS News Baltimore reported in April.

When the new law opened the courthouse doors, more than 900 lawsuits were filed against the Baltimore archdiocese, CBS reported. The bankruptcy put those lawsuits on hold and moved every claim into one federal case, where survivors’ compensation now depends on a negotiated plan.

06

Who still has to agree

A tentative agreement between the Baltimore archdiocese and the survivors’ committee is only one piece. The Baltimore archdiocese and the survivors are still negotiating with the insurance companies and with the parishes, schools and other affiliated entities, the Banner reported. In October, the mediation expanded to include those affiliates, according to the Daily Record.

The affiliates have been a sticking point. The survivors’ committee asked the court to treat the Baltimore archdiocese and its affiliates as a single entity for a settlement. In April, Judge Harner ruled that the affiliates are independent and, with certain disclosure requirements, may keep selling property, the Daily Record reported.

Insurance policies are one source of money for survivors, the archdiocese has said. In April, Hartford Insurance proposed a $100 million settlement, payable once the Baltimore archdiocese settles on a reorganization plan, CBS reported. Survivors urged the other insurers to follow Hartford’s lead. Attorneys told the court Thursday that a settlement was reached with another insurance company this week and that two more insurers are close.

There’s another obstacle. The Baltimore archdiocese and its insurers have filed more than 200 objections to survivors’ claims, arguing that some belong against a different entity or involve a person who was an adult at the time, among other reasons, according to the Daily Record.

07

The numbers in the bankruptcy case

These figures show how far apart the two sides have been, and why a tentative agreement matters:

  • About 1,000 people have filed claims in the bankruptcy, according to court records cited by the Banner.
  • $33 million was the fund the Baltimore archdiocese proposed in October 2025, or about $33,000 per survivor. Survivors rejected it and called it insulting, CBS reported.
  • About $1 million is what each survivor is seeking, according to CBS.
  • About $100 million in assets belong to the church, according to court documents cited by CBS.
  • $100 million is what Hartford Insurance proposed to pay in April.
  • Two competing settlement plans were rejected in August, when Judge Harner called them “patently unconfirmable,” the Daily Record reported.

In December 2025, the Baltimore archdiocese also decided not to use a charitable immunity defense that could have shielded it from paying survivors, CBS reported.

08

Survivors who are still waiting

About a dozen survivors came to the hearing, the Banner reported, though most left as the hours wore on. For some, time is the cruelest part of the bankruptcy case.

“We have lost more than 20 survivors who have passed away from the time this started, the bankruptcy process, until now,” Erin Maze, a survivor, told CBS News Baltimore. “It is exhausting,” she said. On Thursday, though, she said she felt positive. “The judge is setting her limit,” Maze told the Banner. “She is not going to let this go on and on.”

Teresa Lancaster, a longtime advocate for survivors and an attorney who has represented others in the case, sounded more guarded. “We’re at a standstill, quite frankly. The mediation continues, and they say they’re getting close, but the numbers don’t match up,” she told CBS. “I’ve been let down so many times for so many years. I’m cautious.”

Survivors have said the same thing for months. In April, outside the federal courthouse in Baltimore, Lancaster told CBS, “The bottom line is people have died waiting for this, and the church needs to be held accountable. They need to do it now.” Frank Schindler, another survivor, said, “Each day that survivors have been denied justice is another day of re-traumatization.”

The three, all members of the Abuse Survivors Coalition, said a settlement from the Baltimore archdiocese wouldn’t take all the pain away, but could still help. “It can help survivors get the help they need and start on a path of recovery,” David Lorenz said.

09

A timeline of the Baltimore archdiocese bankruptcy

These dates come from CBS News Baltimore, The Baltimore Banner and the Maryland Daily Record:

  • 2023: Maryland’s attorney general releases a report of more than 450 pages on abuse in the Archdiocese of Baltimore.
  • 2023: The Baltimore archdiocese files for bankruptcy two days before the Child Victims Act takes effect.
  • October 2025: The Baltimore archdiocese proposes a $33 million fund; survivors reject it.
  • December 2025: The archdiocese decides not to use a charitable immunity defense.
  • April 2026: A plan with Hartford Insurance’s $100 million offer is filed, and the judge rules the affiliates are independent.
  • June 2026: The judge denies the survivors’ request to pursue lawsuits in state court, for now.
  • August 2026: The judge rejects both sides’ competing plans as “patently unconfirmable.”
  • October 2026: Mediation expands to the parishes, schools and other affiliates.
  • November 16, 2026: The mediator reports a tentative agreement, subject to conditions.
  • November 19, 2026: Judge Harner presses both sides at a hearing that continues Friday.
  • End of January 2027: The mediator recommends keeping the “status quo” until then.

10

Five things survivors should know

If you’re one of the survivors in this case, or you love someone who is, here’s what the tentative agreement does and doesn’t change:

  1. A tentative agreement isn’t a final settlement. It’s between the Baltimore archdiocese and the survivors’ committee, and conditions remain.
  2. Any reorganization plan still has to be approved by the bankruptcy court, CBS reported.
  3. The insurers, parishes and schools are still negotiating, and their share will shape the final amount.
  4. More than 200 claims face objections. If you filed a claim, ask your attorney whether yours is one of them.
  5. You don’t have to wait for the court to get support. RAINN’s hotline is 800-656-4673, any hour.

If a child is being harmed today, call for help now. In Oregon, where Bloom is based, the Oregon Child Abuse Hotline is 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233).

11

Why this case matters beyond Maryland

Maryland’s Child Victims Act is part of a wider change. States have been reopening the courthouse doors that time limits once closed, and churches have answered in court and in bankruptcy.

Bloom has followed that change this week, from Rhode Island’s attorney general moving to defend a law reviving clergy abuse lawsuits to a $14.3 million jury award against the Oakland diocese. Each case asks the same question the Baltimore archdiocese now faces: whether survivors will be made whole while they’re still alive to see it.

12

What faith communities owe survivors

Bloom is a church, and churches should hear this case most clearly of all. The attorney general’s report described abuse that went on while the church “looked the other way,” in the Banner’s words. Repair begins where looking away ends.

Money matters, because survivors have carried the cost of this harm for decades. But Lancaster named something money can’t settle. “I haven’t really seen a plan from the archdiocese about how they’re going to prevent this from happening to future children,” she told CBS. I believe a church that harmed children owes survivors more than a check: it owes them the truth, and a promise that’s kept.

To every survivor reading this: what happened to you wasn’t your fault, and your story isn’t a line in a bankruptcy case. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

13

What happens next

The hearing on issues in the bankruptcy case continues Friday, November 20, according to the Banner. The mediator has recommended keeping the “status quo” through the end of January 2027 while the talks go on.

Attorneys say a final agreement with all parties will likely take until at least the end of January. Judge Harner has made clear she won’t wait forever, and the survivors’ committee could renew its request to sue in state court if talks stall, the Daily Record reported. Bloom’s Justice for Survivors desk will report the next step in the Baltimore archdiocese case as it comes.

14

What Bloom is doing

Bloom stands with survivors of abuse in every church and every institution, and believes accountability is part of healing, never the enemy of faith. Bloom’s newsroom follows these cases from the first filing to the last payment, so survivors don’t have to watch alone.

If this story stirs up your own pain, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach any hour, including RAINN at 800-656-4673 and 988 by call or text. Bloom’s support groups are a place to be known. If you’d like to help this reporting continue, a monthly gift sustains it, and a one-time gift helps too.

15

Frequently Asked Questions

Not yet. A mediator reported on November 16, 2026, that the Archdiocese of Baltimore and the survivors’ committee reached a tentative agreement subject to conditions. A final deal with all parties likely won’t come before the end of January 2027.

About 1,000 people have filed claims in the bankruptcy, according to court records cited by The Baltimore Banner.

It filed in 2023, two days before Maryland’s Child Victims Act took effect. That law eliminated time limits for survivors of child sexual abuse to file lawsuits.

No final figure exists. The Baltimore archdiocese proposed a $33 million fund in 2025, which survivors rejected, and Hartford Insurance proposed $100 million in April 2026. Survivors are seeking about $1 million each.

The insurance companies and the church’s parishes, schools and other affiliates are still negotiating with the Baltimore archdiocese and the survivors. One more insurer settled this week, and two others are close, attorneys said.

RAINN’s National Sexual Assault Hotline is 800-656-4673, any hour. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more people you can call or text.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.