
Newsroom·Wisconsin Legislature·News
Wisconsin Judge Wonβt Undo ADA Absentee Ruling, Orders Mediation
Wisconsin voters who can't read or mark a paper ballot still have a court ruling on their side. On November 18, a Dane County judge refused to undo it and gave both sides 90 days to mediate a fix.
Wisconsin voters who are blind, have low vision or cannot hold a pen will keep the court ruling that says the state’s paper-only absentee system leaves them out. On Wednesday, November 18, Dane County Circuit Judge Everett D. Mitchell denied the Wisconsin Elections Commission’s motion to reconsider his August 4 decision. That decision held that the absentee process denies voters with print disabilities the chance to cast a ballot privately and independently, in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act. He also ordered both sides into mediation.
Nothing changes at the ballot box yet. The judge did not order electronic ballots, and his order says so plainly: “The Court did not order WEC to implement electronic ballot delivery, marking, or return.” What changes is the clock. The commission and the voters now have 90 days to try to agree on how people with print disabilities can vote absentee in secret, with a trial waiting if they can’t. Here is what the order says, what it leaves open, and where voters can get help now.
01
What the judge decided about print disabilities
Judge Mitchell’s November 18 order runs nine pages, and it settles one question for voters with print disabilities: the August ruling stands. In that ruling, the court found no genuine dispute about any element of the voters’ basic case of discrimination under Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act, which bars public entities from shutting people out of their programs because of a disability.
The court found that Wisconsin’s absentee voting program, as set up in sections 6.87(3)(a) and 6.87(4)(b)(1) of state law, denies voters with print disabilities the opportunity to cast an absentee ballot privately and independently. It found that the denial happens because of their disabilities. It declared those two provisions invalid “to the extent they preclude WEC from providing voters with disabilities an opportunity to cast a ballot independently.” The Wisconsin Elections Commission, known as WEC, asked the judge to take that back. He refused, writing that the August decision “remains in full force and effect.”
Who counts as a voter with print disabilities? In this case, they are voters who, because of a disability, are incapable of “independently reading or marking printed materials,” as the state Court of Appeals described the claim in 2025. That includes people who are blind or have low vision, and people whose hands won’t hold a pen.
02
The voters with print disabilities who brought the case
Disability Rights Wisconsin, the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin and four voters with print disabilities filed the lawsuit on April 16, 2024. According to the August decision, one of the four voters is legally blind in both eyes and another is completely blind. A third has cerebral palsy that affects her movement and coordination. The fourth has spinal muscular atrophy, which has left him unable to hold a pen or pencil.
The voters are represented by Law Forward, Stafford Rosenbaum LLP and WilmerHale. The defendants are WEC, its administrator and its commissioners, who have been represented by the Wisconsin Department of Justice. The Wisconsin Legislature intervened in 2024 to defend the law, and AP reported in August that it is still opposing the lawsuit.
03
Why a paper ballot shuts some voters out of a secret vote
Every Wisconsin voter may vote absentee. Under the two provisions at issue, an absentee voter gets a paper ballot from the municipal clerk, marks it by hand, seals it in an envelope and returns it to the clerk, the August decision explains. The law tells the voter to mark the ballot “in a manner that will not disclose how the elector’s vote is cast.”
For voters with print disabilities, the process looks very different. State law lets a voter who cannot read or mark the ballot choose someone to help mark it, and the helper signs a certification on the ballot. The August decision found that this means the voter must reveal their choices and “trust that the third party will not tamper with the ballot, or otherwise interfere with the voter’s wishes.”
Think about what that asks of a person. Every other absentee voter marks the ballot so that no one sees the choice. A voter who is blind has to tell someone else, and trust that it is marked the way it was spoken. The court found that this denies an equal opportunity, and WEC did not challenge that finding in its motion.
Wisconsin once allowed more. Starting in 2000, clerks could send some absentee ballots electronically, but a 2011 law, Act 75, limited electronic delivery to military and overseas voters, leaving voters with print disabilities on paper, according to the 2025 Court of Appeals decision. Military and overseas voters from Wisconsin still get absentee ballots by email, AP reported in August.
04
What WEC argued, and why the judge said no
WEC did not ask the court to revisit its finding that voters with print disabilities lack meaningful access to absentee voting because of their disabilities, the order says. Its argument was about order and timing. WEC said the reasonableness of the voters’ proposed fix is part of what they must prove, so the court could not find a violation until that question and WEC’s defenses were decided.
WEC called the August ruling a manifest error of law, the standard it had to meet without new evidence. The judge heard argument by video on October 14. Quoting a Wisconsin appeals decision, he wrote that a manifest error “is not demonstrated by the disappointment of the losing party.”
The order gives several reasons for saying no. Under federal appeals cases WEC itself cited, the judge wrote, voters meet their first burden by proposing a fix that seems reasonable on its face. The court had already found that the voters “have indeed made a compelling case for the use of electronic ballots.” The dispute that remains, he wrote, comes from WEC’s own evidence about the burden and risks of the plan, and WEC carries that burden at trial.
The judge also pointed to what WEC acknowledged at the October hearing: “We agree that the statute currently forbids electronic absentee voting.” Whether a state statute must yield to federal law when it blocks compliance with the ADA is a question of law for the court, he wrote. “At most, WEC disagrees with the sequence in which the Court resolved the issues before it.”
WEC did not point to any decision of the Wisconsin Supreme Court or the U.S. Supreme Court that the August ruling ignored or misapplied, the order says. “Disagreement with the Court’s reasoning is not a manifest error of law,” the judge wrote.
05
What the order does not do
The ruling matters, and it has limits:
- It does not order electronic ballots. The court has not told WEC to deliver, mark or return ballots electronically for voters with print disabilities.
- It does not choose the fix. The judge wrote that his declaration addresses the statutes as a barrier and “does not resolve which modification Title II requires.”
- It does not end WEC’s defenses. WEC can still try to prove at trial that the voters’ plan would fundamentally alter the absentee program or impose an undue burden.
- It does not reach the constitutional claims. The judge said the ADA ruling is enough for now and left the voters’ state and federal constitutional claims for later, if they become necessary.
- It does not change how anyone votes yet. Until a new method is agreed or ordered, voters with print disabilities still use the paper process and the help options listed below.
06
The questions left for mediation or trial
The plaintiffs want WEC to give voters with disabilities “an electronic, accessible method to request, receive, and return an absentee ballot,” Law Forward said in a statement. Voters with print disabilities could then read and mark a ballot alone at home, using a device with assistive technology, as the 2025 appeals decision described the request.
The voters also asked the judge, if he reopened the August decision, to go further: to find a Rehabilitation Act violation too, to rule electronic delivery and marking reasonable as a matter of law, and to leave only electronic return for trial. Because he did not reopen it, he did not reach those requests and denied them without prejudice, so they can be raised again by a properly filed motion. At the hearing, WEC objected that the voters had always presented delivery, marking and return as a single accommodation, and the judge left that question open.
What remains for trial, if mediation fails, is whether the voters’ plan is reasonable in Wisconsin’s particular circumstances, and whether WEC can show it would fundamentally alter the absentee program or impose an undue burden.
07
How the court-ordered mediation will work
The voters asked for mediation at the close of the October hearing, and WEC did not object, according to the order. The judge wrote that the remaining issues, including which change will give voters with print disabilities a private and independent absentee ballot and how to carry it out “consistent with the security and administrative concerns WEC has raised,” are “well suited to negotiated resolution.”
The order sets out the steps:
- Good faith, on everything left. The parties must mediate all remaining issues in good faith, including the change or changes voters with print disabilities need and how to put them in place.
- A mediator within 14 days. The parties must jointly name an agreed mediator within 14 days, which falls on December 2. If they can’t agree, each side submits two names and the court picks.
- Ninety days to finish. “Mediation shall be completed within ninety (90) days of the date of this Order unless extended by the Court for good cause.” Ninety days from November 18 is February 16, 2027.
- Costs split. The voters and WEC divide the mediator’s costs equally.
- A report within 7 days. Within seven days after mediation ends, the parties file a joint status report saying whether the case is resolved in whole or in part, and what remains for trial.
- Then a status conference. The court will schedule what comes next, including a trial on anything still unresolved.
08
A timeline of the case
These dates come from the court decisions and AP’s reporting:
- 2000: Wisconsin clerks may begin sending some absentee ballots electronically.
- 2011: Act 75 limits electronic ballot delivery to military and overseas voters.
- April 16, 2024: Disability Rights Wisconsin, the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin and four voters with print disabilities sue WEC.
- June 2024: Judge Mitchell issues a temporary injunction allowing emailed ballots for voters with print disabilities who self-certify that they can’t read or mark a paper ballot without help.
- August 2024: The Court of Appeals puts that order on hold, and no ballots are emailed before the November presidential election.
- March 12, 2025: The District II Court of Appeals reverses the injunction. The voters choose to pursue the merits in circuit court instead of appealing.
- August 4, 2026: Judge Mitchell grants summary judgment on the ADA claim and declares the two statutes invalid to the extent they block an independent ballot.
- October 14, 2026: The judge hears argument on WEC’s motion for reconsideration, by video.
- November 18, 2026: He denies the motion and orders mediation.
- December 2, 2026: Deadline to name a mediator.
- February 16, 2027: Deadline to finish mediation, unless the court extends it.
The 2025 appeals ruling was narrow. It addressed only whether the injunction was warranted, holding that it would have “significantly disrupted the status quo,” under which emailed ballots went to military and overseas voters, “no one else,” AP reported.
09
How many Wisconsin voters have print disabilities
No one knows exactly how many people with print disabilities would use an accessible electronic ballot. Neither the voters nor WEC had an estimate of how many disabled voters would request absentee ballots electronically, AP reported in August.
The wider numbers are large. More than 1 million Wisconsin residents over age 18 have some kind of disability, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Nearly 100,000 Wisconsin adults have vision difficulties, according to state health statistics AP cited in 2025.
The gap at the polls is real, too. Disability Rights Wisconsin says Wisconsin has one of the largest turnout gaps in the country between voters with and without disabilities. In 2022, turnout was 62.6 percent for voters without disabilities and 50.9 percent for voters with disabilities. Nationally, about 25 percent of eligible voters have at least one disability, the group says.
10
What each side has said
“We are pleased that the Court confirmed, for a second time, that the ADA protects Wisconsin voters with disabilities,” Law Forward staff counsel Scott Thompson said in a statement on November 19. He added that “it is high time that WEC brings itself into compliance with the law.”
WEC’s position, as the order describes it, is that a violation should not be found until the reasonableness of the voters’ plan and WEC’s defenses are tried. Earlier in the case, the Wisconsin Department of Justice, representing the commission, argued that the emailed-ballot process was open to security risks and could cause confusion, AP reported in 2025. None of the sources Bloom reviewed carried a public statement from WEC on the November 18 order.
Senate Majority Leader Devin LeMahieu, a Republican, made a similar case after the 2025 appeals ruling, calling it a “victory for the rule of law and election security in Wisconsin.” He said: “Allowing courts to decide who can vote from home, using the internet, would weaken election integrity and hurt voters’ faith in our elections.”
11
What happens next
The next deadline is December 2, for naming a mediator. The two sides then have until February 16, 2027, unless the court grants more time, to agree on how voters with print disabilities will cast a secret absentee ballot.
If they settle all or part of the case, the joint status report will say so. If they don’t, Judge Mitchell will hold a status conference and set a trial on what remains, where WEC carries the burden on its undue-burden and fundamental-alteration defenses.
An appeal is also possible. The order states that it is “a final order for purposes of appeal,” and the judge noted that WEC “has preserved its position for appeal.” None of the sources Bloom reviewed said whether WEC will appeal. Bloom will follow the mediation and report what the parties tell the court.
12
What voters with print disabilities can do now
Until a court orders a new method or the two sides agree on one, the current rules apply. Here is what the Wisconsin Elections Commission and Disability Rights Wisconsin say voters with print disabilities can do today:
- Vote at your polling place with accessible equipment. “All polling places must have accessible voting machines available for use at the polling place on election day,” WEC says.
- Ask for curbside voting. WEC says polling places must fulfill any request to vote curbside, without leaving your vehicle.
- Bring someone you choose. At the polls, you may take anyone you choose into the voting booth except your employer, WEC says. For an absentee ballot, state law also rules out an agent of your employer and an officer or agent of your union, and the helper must sign the absentee certificate envelope.
- Ask your clerk for accommodations. WEC says voters may request accommodations from their local municipal clerk.
- Know the indefinitely confined option. If age, illness, infirmity or disability keeps you indefinitely confined, WEC says you can indicate that status and receive ballots for every election until you fail to return one or your status changes.
- Call the Disability Rights Wisconsin Voter Hotline. Call 844-347-8683 (844-DIS-VOTE) or email votingteam@drwi.org for disability-related voting questions, including help filing a complaint with WEC or the U.S. Department of Justice.
- Call WEC’s voter help line. Call 866-868-3947 (1-866-VOTE-WIS) or email elections@wisconsin.gov. Disability Rights Wisconsin lists this line for voting questions.
If you live with print disabilities and have ever handed your ballot to someone else and told them who you chose, you did nothing wrong. You voted with the tools the law gave you. A court has now said those tools are not equal to everyone else’s. The fix is not here yet, but your vote counts today, and it is worth casting.
13
What Bloom is doing
Bloom follows the ADA wherever it reaches public life: a federal appeals court reviving an ADA challenge to a city ordinance in Sedona, Arizona, and the Justice Department’s lawsuit against Lyft over riders with service animals. This week Bloom also explained what the new online passport pilot means for disabled applicants. I believe a secret ballot belongs to every voter, including voters with print disabilities who read with their fingers or their ears.
Bloom’s disability advocacy stands with people who are told to wait for access the law already promises. If this story weighs on you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight.
Reading a court order line by line, and coming back when the mediation ends, takes steady work. A monthly gift keeps Bloom on stories like this one all year, and a one-time gift helps too.
14
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 18, 2026, Dane County Circuit Judge Everett D. Mitchell denied WEC’s motion to reconsider his August 4 ruling. That ruling found that Wisconsin’s paper-only absentee process denies voters with print disabilities a private, independent ballot, in violation of the ADA. He also ordered the two sides into mediation.
No. The court has not ordered electronic delivery, marking or return for voters with print disabilities. Wisconsin law allows emailed absentee ballots only for military and overseas voters.
The parties must name a mediator within 14 days, or each proposes two and the court picks. Mediation must be completed within 90 days unless the court extends it, the two sides split the cost, and they file a joint status report within 7 days after it ends.
Whether the voters’ proposed electronic ballot is reasonable in Wisconsin’s particular circumstances, and whether WEC can prove it would fundamentally alter the absentee program or impose an undue burden. WEC carries the burden on those defenses.
The order states that it is a final order for purposes of appeal, and it notes that WEC preserved its position for appeal. None of the sources Bloom reviewed said whether WEC will appeal.
Call the Disability Rights Wisconsin Voter Hotline at 844-347-8683 (844-DIS-VOTE) or email votingteam@drwi.org. WEC’s voter help line is 866-868-3947, and your municipal clerk can arrange accommodations.
Sovereignty over Servitude. πΈ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Wisconsin Legislature · 20 November 2026Madison Prosecutor Wonβt Charge Officer Who Killed Corey Ruiz
Disability advocacy · 16 November 2026Medicaid Expansion Is Back on the Table in Four States. Can It Pass?
Trans advocacy · 6 November 2026Five States Elect Their First Trans Lawmakers, Washington Among Them