A parked white car with fresh snow heaped on its roof beside apartment buildings at dusk, for a report on Sedona's car-sleeping ban

NewsroomArizona LegislatureNews

Appeals Court Revives ADA Challenge to Sedonaโ€™s Car-Sleeping Ban

A federal appeals court says a Sedona woman whose disability sometimes keeps her out of her apartment can ask the city for an exception to its car-sleeping ban, and that the ADA reaches criminal ordinances.

A federal appeals court has revived a disabled woman’s challenge to Sedona’s car-sleeping ban. On November 12, 2026, the Ninth Circuit ruled in Beram v. City of Sedona that Sabrina Beram has standing to sue the Arizona city, and that Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act can require a city to accommodate a disabled person who can’t comply with a criminal ordinance. Judge Roopali H. Desai wrote the opinion for a three-judge panel.

Sedona’s car-sleeping ban makes it a crime to sleep in a vehicle on public or private property, punishable by up to six months in jail, a fine of up to $2,500, or both. Beram lives with what the court calls severe, chronic obsessive-compulsive anxiety, and on some nights it keeps her out of her own apartment. On those nights she sleeps in her car. The ruling doesn’t strike down the car-sleeping ban. It sends her case back to a trial judge, where she can argue that Sedona owed her an exception and Sedona can argue that it didn’t.

01

What the Ninth Circuit decided on the car-sleeping ban

The opinion is marked for publication, so it is precedent, not a one-off. KNAU reports that the car-sleeping ban ruling sets precedent for Arizona. Its reach is wider than that: the Ninth Circuit’s rulings cover nine states, Oregon, Washington and Idaho among them, as the Associated Press noted in its coverage of the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision on camping bans.

“We reverse the dismissal of the ADA claim,” Judge Desai wrote. The panel reached four conclusions that matter well beyond one Arizona city:

  • Being refused an accommodation is a real injury. The court held that the denial of a reasonable accommodation under the ADA is a concrete injury, and that Beram’s lost time, lost income and worsening mental health add to it.
  • Two warnings showed a credible threat. Her plan to keep sleeping in her car, two specific police warnings and the city’s record of citing others gave her standing to ask a court to stop enforcement of the car-sleeping ban against her.
  • The city, not only the landlord, is answerable. Because the car-sleeping ban reaches private property and forbids owners to allow car sleeping, her injury traces to Sedona.
  • The ADA reaches criminal ordinances. Title II can require a city to accommodate a disabled person’s inability to comply with a criminal law, just as it can with a civil code.

The panel affirmed one piece of the trial court’s ruling: the dismissal of Beram’s Eighth Amendment claim, which she abandoned after the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Grants Pass. It reversed the dismissal of her ADA claim and the refusal to let her amend it, and it sent the case back. She may now file a fifth amended complaint seeking damages and declaratory and injunctive relief under the ADA.

Judge Desai was joined by Judge Ana de Alba and by Judge Edward M. Chen, a district judge from the Northern District of California sitting by designation. The panel heard argument on June 23, 2025, vacated submission the next day, and resubmitted the case on November 12, 2026, the day it filed the opinion.

02

Why one Sedona resident sleeps in her car

The court describes Beram’s disability plainly. When she perceives unclean conditions in her apartment, she can’t go in, and the cleaning rituals that would let her return take hours. Court records cited by Capitol Media Services say she may need hours of cleaning to make her home “tolerable.”

When it’s too late to clean and sleep, she sleeps in her car in her apartment complex’s lot or, when there’s no space, in other public and private spaces in Sedona. Her earlier filings put it in one line. She “must sleep in her car because of her disability [obsessive-compulsive disorder] at least three nights per week,” Sedona Red Rock News reported in 2023.

Under Sedona’s car-sleeping ban, each of those nights is a misdemeanor. Yet the car is simply the place she can rest when her home, for reasons her disability sets, is out of reach.

The costs she describes are concrete. According to the opinion, Beram says she spent 115 to 135 hours looking for other places to sleep, that her mental health worsened, and that she lost income. She has not been arrested or charged.

03

How Sedona’s car-sleeping ban works

Sedona’s car-sleeping ban sits in Sedona City Code ยง 9.10.010. Its subsections (A) and (B) bar sleeping in a vehicle on public or private property. Subsection (D) makes it illegal for a property owner or agent to knowingly allow a violation. Subsection (K) makes a violation a class 1 misdemeanor, with a fine of up to $2,500, up to six months in jail, or both.

Two other features of the car-sleeping ban shaped this case. Subsection (E) bars an arrest unless a police officer or the property owner has first warned the person. Subsection (I) exempts certain parking for less than 24 hours with the consent of a government property owner, and the court held that it doesn’t cover what Beram does.

Beram has been warned twice under the car-sleeping ban, according to the opinion. The first time, at a public trailhead, an officer told her to leave and noted her file. The second time, at a park, an officer told her to leave and warned that she would be cited if she didn’t. The city has also cited at least two people for sleeping in cars on private property.

04

The exception Sedona refused

Beram didn’t start in court. She started by asking. The opinion says she wrote to the Mayor of Sedona seeking relief from enforcement of the car-sleeping ban when she sleeps in her car, and the city denied it. She later asked the city not to charge her for sleeping in her car at her own apartment complex, and the city denied that too.

Sedona Red Rock News reported that on February 22, 2021, City Attorney Kurt Christianson denied her request for an exemption, saying the city lacked authority to grant a blanket exemption and that the ADA didn’t apply. On the ADA, he said “the city is not in the business of providing housing.”

She sued in federal court on April 2, 2021, under the ADA and the Eighth Amendment. Community Legal Services filed the case on her behalf, and it named her landlord as well as the city, according to KNAU.

District Judge Diane J. Humetewa dismissed the case more than once. On May 18, 2023, she dismissed a proposed fourth complaint with prejudice. “The court finds this additional warning insufficient to show the threat of enforcement is imminent,” she wrote. Beram appealed.

The landlord’s part of the story changed along the way. The property manager threatened to end or not renew her lease and issued a lease addendum barring car sleeping, the opinion says. Beram later settled with the landlord, who agreed to guarantee her housing and let her sleep in her car when necessary. That deal can be undone if she or the owner is warned or charged under the car-sleeping ban.

05

Two warnings were “the first step of enforcement”

To sue before being prosecuted, a person has to show a credible threat that the law will be enforced against them. The trial court had found that Beram couldn’t show one under the car-sleeping ban. The Ninth Circuit disagreed, weighing three things: her concrete plan to keep sleeping in her car, the specific warnings she received, and the city’s history of enforcement.

The warnings did most of the work. Judge Desai wrote that the officers’ warnings were not mere threats of enforcement but “the first step of enforcement.” KNAU adds that the city had not said it would stop enforcing the car-sleeping ban against Beram when she sleeps in her car at her apartment.

The court gave the city’s past citations only slight weight. A history of enforcement counts only when it involves people in the same position, the court explained, and Beram pleaded no facts about the people Sedona had cited. The warnings to her were enough.

On injury, the panel was direct: “Discrimination under the ADA is generally an injury-in-fact.” Being refused a reasonable accommodation is itself the harm the law recognizes, before any arrest and before any fine.

Sedona also argued that any quarrel was between Beram and her landlord. The court rejected that. The car-sleeping ban criminalizes sleeping on private property and forbids owners to allow it, so the harm traces to the city, and an order against the city could fix it.

06

The ADA reaches criminal ordinances, too

The heart of the opinion is Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act, the part of the law that governs public entities like cities. Under its rules, a public entity must make reasonable modifications to its policies, practices and procedures when they are needed to avoid discriminating on the basis of disability. A city may refuse a change that would “fundamentally alter the nature of the service, program, or activity.”

Sedona argued that the ADA doesn’t apply to ordinances like its car-sleeping ban at all, and that applying it would undermine public safety. The Ninth Circuit rejected both arguments. It held that Title II applies when a city enforces a criminal ordinance, and that the benefits of public services can include mandatory activities such as complying with municipal codes.

The court leaned on its own earlier cases, among them McGary v. City of Portland, which held that Title II reaches the enforcement of a city’s code. It saw “no principled way to distinguish” a criminal ordinance from the civil codes the ADA already reaches. It declined to draw what it called “an arbitrary distinction.”

Public safety still matters, the court said, but in a different place. Concerns like Sedona’s go to the merits of the case and to the city’s defense that an accommodation would fundamentally alter its program. They aren’t a reason to say the ADA doesn’t apply.

That’s the shift. A city that wants to deny a disabled person an exception to a car-sleeping ban now has to defend that choice on the facts, in front of a judge. It can’t simply declare the ADA irrelevant to its criminal code.

07

Grants Pass closed one door, and the ADA opened another

The Supreme Court changed the law on sleeping outdoors in 2024. On June 28 of that year, in a case from Grants Pass, Oregon, the Court ruled 6-3 that bans on sleeping outside don’t violate the Eighth Amendment, even where shelter space is lacking, the Associated Press reported. Grants Pass had fined people $295 for sleeping outside.

Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote for the majority. Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented: “Sleep is a biological necessity, not a crime.” Since 2018, the Ninth Circuit had held that such bans violate the Eighth Amendment in places without enough shelter beds, and Grants Pass ended that line of cases.

Beram abandoned her Eighth Amendment claim after Grants Pass, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed its dismissal. What survived is her ADA claim against the car-sleeping ban, and it rests on a different idea.

The Eighth Amendment argument asked whether punishing sleep itself is cruel. The ADA argument asks something narrower and, for many disabled people, more useful: whether a city has to make room in its rules for one person whose disability makes compliance impossible on some nights. It doesn’t protect everyone who sleeps in a car. It protects a disabled person’s right to ask, and to have that request taken seriously.

08

What the car-sleeping ban ruling means in Oregon and Washington

Bloom Ministries is based in Salem, so the first question from our neighbors is whether any of this reaches them. It does, in a specific way. A published Ninth Circuit opinion is precedent across the circuit, and Oregon and Washington are in it.

The ruling doesn’t decide anything about an Oregon or Washington ordinance. What it settles is a principle: Title II of the ADA applies when a city enforces a criminal ordinance against a disabled person, and a city’s refusal to accommodate can be challenged in federal court. The case the panel relied on for that principle, McGary, was brought against the City of Portland.

After Grants Pass, a spokesperson for Portland’s mayor expected the decision’s effect to be limited because Oregon has separate legal limits on how cities can manage encampments, the AP reported. This federal ruling adds something different from those state limits. It gives a disabled person a way to ask for an exception tailored to them.

For people living in vehicles in Salem, Portland, Eugene, Seattle or Spokane, the practical lesson is the same one Beram’s case teaches under any car-sleeping ban in the circuit. Ask in writing. Keep the warnings. Keep the answers.

09

What the ruling does not do

It doesn’t strike down Sedona’s car-sleeping ban, and it doesn’t say Beram will win. On remand, Sedona can argue that the exception she wants would be unreasonable, or would fundamentally alter its program. A trial judge will decide.

It doesn’t give everyone a right to ignore a car-sleeping ban. The ADA claim belongs to a disabled person who needs a change in a rule because of that disability, and the remedy is an accommodation for that person.

It doesn’t settle the landlord question. At oral argument, Beram’s lawyer told the court that the property owner had stopped allowing her to sleep in her car out of fear of enforcement. The court set that aside because it wasn’t in the pleadings, so it may come up again in the trial court.

And it doesn’t end the case. Beram may now file a fifth amended complaint seeking damages and declaratory and injunctive relief. The case returns to the federal court in Arizona where it began in 2021.

10

How to ask a city for a reasonable accommodation

Beram’s case is a map for anyone whose disability collides with a city rule. Bloom is not a law firm, and this is not legal advice. But the record in her case shows what mattered:

  • Put the request in writing. Beram wrote to Sedona’s mayor. A written request, and a written refusal, gave the court something concrete to judge.
  • Name the need, not only the diagnosis. Say what your disability makes you unable to do, and name the specific change you’re asking for, such as permission to sleep in your car at your own home despite a car-sleeping ban.
  • Keep every warning. Write down the date, the place and what the officer said. Two warnings were the backbone of Beram’s standing.
  • Keep every answer. DREDF’s toolkit stresses a clear paper trail of requests and the government’s responses, which can matter later if damages are sought.
  • Get help early. Community Legal Services represented Beram. A legal aid office or a disability rights group near you can tell you how the law applies where you live.

The DREDF toolkit was written for advocates challenging California laws that criminalize homelessness, and it collects Ninth Circuit cases on unhoused people with disabilities. “Anti-camping laws may violate the ADA if they disparately impact or burden people with disabilities,” it says. It also describes a San Diego case over limits on living in RVs, in which the court found that enforcement burdened disabled residents more than others because they depended on their RVs to live.

We reported earlier this week on another appeals court ruling about accommodation requests, that one at work. The thread running through both is the same. The law asks institutions to bend for disabled people, and a request in writing is how that starts.

11

What Bloom is doing

Bloom’s newsroom will follow the car-sleeping ban case back to the trial court and link the filings as they come, so you can read them yourself. Bloom’s disability advocacy work starts from a conviction this case shares: a disabled person’s needs are not a nuisance to be cited away.

A ruling only helps the people who know about it. That’s why Bloom is building Bloom Resources: verified legal, healthcare, housing and benefits guides for trans and disabled people, dated, primary-sourced and free. You can help fund Bloom Resources.

If you’re sleeping in your car tonight, or afraid you soon will be, you don’t have to carry that alone. Call or text 988 at any hour, and Bloom’s crisis support page lists more help. If what you need is someone to listen or pray with you, Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

Reporting like this is paid for by readers who give a little every month. If it helped you, become a monthly supporter, or give once if that suits you better.

12

Frequently Asked Questions

On November 12, 2026, the Ninth Circuit revived Sabrina Beram’s ADA challenge to Sedona’s car-sleeping ban. It held that she has standing, and that Title II of the ADA can require a city to accommodate a disabled person who can’t comply with a criminal ordinance.

No. The car-sleeping ban still stands. The case goes back to the trial court, where Sedona can argue that the exception Beram wants would be unreasonable or would fundamentally alter its program.

Sedona City Code ยง 9.10.010 bars sleeping in a vehicle on public or private property and bars property owners from knowingly allowing it. A violation is a class 1 misdemeanor, punishable by up to six months in jail, a fine of up to $2,500, or both.

Yes, under this ruling. The Ninth Circuit held that Title II applies when a city enforces a criminal ordinance, and that safety concerns go to whether a requested accommodation is reasonable, not to whether the ADA applies.

The 2024 Grants Pass decision held that bans on sleeping outside don’t violate the Eighth Amendment. Beram dropped her Eighth Amendment claim after it. Her surviving claim asks whether a city must accommodate one disabled person, which is a different question under a different law.

The opinion is published, so it is precedent across the Ninth Circuit, whose rulings cover Oregon, Washington and seven other states. It doesn’t decide whether any Oregon or Washington ordinance is valid.

Write to the city, say what your disability makes you unable to do, and name the specific change you need. Keep copies of every request, warning and reply, and contact a legal aid office or disability rights group for help.

Sovereignty over Servitude.

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.