
Newsroom·Texas Legislature·News
Pregnant Workers Act Canโt Be Enforced Against Texas, Court Rules
The full Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that Congress passed the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act without a lawful quorum, keeping it blocked for Texas as an employer.
The State of Texas sued to stop the PWFA from being enforced against it as an employer.
A divided federal appeals court ruled on Friday, November 20, 2026, that Congress broke the Constitution when it passed the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, or PWFA, with hundreds of House members counted present by proxy. The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit voted 9-8 to keep the law blocked as to the State of Texas as an employer, according to the opinion.
The ruling doesn’t wipe the PWFA off the books. The court said its decision “extends no further than affirming the relief awarded by the district court,” which bars federal enforcement of the law against Texas itself. But the reasoning reaches far beyond one state, and pregnant workers deserve to know what it changes, what it doesn’t, and what they can do now.
01
What the Fifth Circuit decided
The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386, an appeal from the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Texas argued that the House’s pandemic-era proxy rule violated the Constitution’s Quorum Clause, so the House never validly passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023. Texas then asked for relief against just one part of that act: the PWFA.
The majority agreed with Texas on both of the key questions. It held that the old enrolled-bill rule, which treats a signed bill as conclusive proof of its passage, doesn’t block courts from hearing a constitutional challenge when no facts about the vote are in dispute. And it held that the Quorum Clause doesn’t allow absent members to be counted present through proxies.
Proxy presence “does not count,” Judge Cory T. Wilson wrote for the majority. The judgment of the district court, which had blocked the PWFA’s enforcement against Texas, was affirmed.
02
Who joined, and who dissented
Seventeen judges heard the case. Wilson wrote for nine: Chief Judge Elrod and Judges Jones, Smith, Willett, Ho, Duncan, Engelhardt and Oldham joined him.
Judge James E. Graves Jr. dissented, joined by Judges Stewart, Richman, Southwick, Higginson, Douglas and Ramirez. Judge Haynes dissented separately. The opinion says she “does not think it is appropriate to throw out the Federal House of Representatives in this arena.”
That’s a 9-8 split on a question about how Congress counts its own members. In Bloom’s reading, it’s the kind of division that often draws the Supreme Court’s attention.
03
How Congress passed the law in 2022
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the House adopted House Resolution 965 on May 15, 2020, letting members designate proxies to cast votes and record their presence, the dissent explains. The House kept that practice in the next Congress through House Resolution 8.
On December 23, 2022, the House passed the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 by a vote of 225 to 201, with one member voting present and four not voting, the majority wrote. Of the 427 members who recorded a vote, 226 did so by proxy. Fewer than half of the members were physically in the chamber.
Rep. Chip Roy of Texas said on the floor that the bill was “moving off the floor without a physical quorum present.” He asked how a quorum could exist when “there were 226 votes cast by proxy, i.e., not physically present in the Chamber.” The presiding officer answered that members voting by proxy were counted toward the quorum, as the House’s proxy voting rule allowed. The Senate passed the bill, and President Joe Biden signed it on December 29, 2022, HR Dive reported.
04
What the PWFA requires
The PWFA took effect on June 27, 2023, according to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. It requires a covered employer to provide a reasonable accommodation for a qualified worker’s known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions, unless it would cause an undue hardship.
The PWFA covers private employers and state and local governments with 15 or more employees, as well as Congress and federal agencies, the EEOC says. “Reasonable accommodations” are “changes in the work environment or the way things are usually done at work,” the agency explains.
The EEOC lists examples of reasonable accommodations, including:
- extra or longer breaks to drink water, eat, rest or use the restroom
- a stool to sit on, or a way to work while standing
- a changed schedule, such as shorter hours or a later start
- telework or a temporary reassignment
- leave for health care appointments, or to recover from childbirth
- light duty or help with lifting
05
Why the enrolled-bill rule didn’t stop the case
The federal government argued that courts can’t look behind a bill once it’s signed. It relied on Marshall Field & Co. v. Clark, an 1892 Supreme Court case that set out what lawyers call the enrolled-bill rule. Under that rule, a bill signed by the leaders of both houses is taken as proof that it passed.
The majority said the rule didn’t apply here. “There are no disputed facts regarding the House’s passage of the Act,” Wilson wrote, because both sides agreed the House reached a quorum only by counting proxies as present. Texas’s challenge, the court said, “depends solely on the Quorum Clause’s proper meaning.”
The government warned of the “uncertainty and disruption that would result if statutes could be invalidated on the basis of an alleged lack of quorum.” The majority said it was mindful of the respect owed to Congress under the separation of powers, but that it must remain “equally mindful of our own role.”
06
Why the majority said proxies can’t make a quorum
The Quorum Clause, in Article I, Section 5, says a majority of each House “shall constitute a Quorum to do Business.” The majority said the question was “only whether the Quorum Clause allows proxy presence to be included in a quorum count.” Its answer was no.
The majority leaned on United States v. Ballin, an 1892 Supreme Court case. It said the clause’s text, history and “unbroken historical application” show that members must be present to be counted. It also rejected the idea that the Rulemaking Clause, which lets each House set its own procedures, lets the House redefine who is present.
The majority took care to limit what it decided. The question, it wrote, was not whether Congress may vote by proxy, or whether the Constitution demands that members sit in the chamber. It was only whether an absent member’s proxy can count toward a quorum.
07
What the dissent said
Graves wrote that Texas was “attempting to veto Congress’s protections for pregnant workers and new parents while retaining millions in federal funding.” The dissenters said Congress used its own constitutional power to set its procedures during a national pandemic.
The dissent also pressed a question the majority left open. If the whole appropriations act was passed unconstitutionally, the dissenters asked, why should the court’s judgment reach only one small piece of a bill that funded much of the government? And how can Texas block the PWFA while keeping money it accepted under the same act?
Those questions matter. A ruling that one law was passed without a quorum invites challenges to other laws passed the same way, and courts will have to answer them one case at a time.
08
What the PWFA ruling changes, and what it doesn’t
The relief is narrow. The district court found that Texas was entitled to a permanent injunction of the PWFA’s enforcement “against it,” the opinion says, and the Fifth Circuit affirmed that judgment and nothing more. Texas first sought relief against two parts of the act, the PWFA and a $20 million appropriation for a Homeland Security pilot program, but the judgment the court affirmed concerns the PWFA.
That means the order protects the State of Texas as an employer. It doesn’t, by its terms, stop the EEOC from enforcing the PWFA against private employers in Texas or against employers in other states. Pregnant workers at a Texas company with 15 or more employees can still point to the PWFA, unless a later court order says otherwise.
For people who work for the State of Texas, the change is real. Federal enforcement of the PWFA against their employer stays blocked while the case goes on.
09
The long road of this case
The PWFA has been in court almost since it took effect. In 2024, a federal judge in Texas blocked its enforcement against the state, HR Dive reported. On August 15, 2025, a three-judge Fifth Circuit panel reversed, ruling that the enrolled-bill rule applied and that the Quorum Clause doesn’t require physical presence.
That panel decision put the PWFA back in force in Texas. In January 2026, the Fifth Circuit vacated the panel ruling and agreed to rehear the case with all of its active judges, HR Dive reported. Friday’s ruling is the result.
The law has faced other fights too. The EEOC issued its final PWFA regulation on April 15, 2024, and it took effect on June 18, 2024. HR Dive reported that the law has been heavily challenged since that rule concluded that abortion is among the conditions the law covers.
10
A timeline of the PWFA case
These dates come from the Fifth Circuit’s opinion, HR Dive and the EEOC:
- May 15, 2020: The House adopts House Resolution 965, allowing proxy voting and proxy presence.
- December 23, 2022: The House passes the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, with 226 members voting by proxy.
- December 29, 2022: President Biden signs the act, including the PWFA.
- June 27, 2023: The PWFA takes effect.
- 2024: A federal judge blocks enforcement of the PWFA against Texas.
- April 15, 2024: The EEOC issues its final PWFA regulation, effective June 18, 2024.
- August 15, 2025: A Fifth Circuit panel reverses and restores the law in Texas.
- January 2026: The full Fifth Circuit vacates the panel ruling and agrees to rehear the case.
- November 20, 2026: The full court rules 9-8 for Texas.
11
Rights the law spells out
The EEOC’s guidance lists what a covered employer can’t do under the law. It can’t refuse a reasonable accommodation for a known limitation unless that would cause an undue hardship. It can’t force a worker to accept an accommodation that wasn’t worked out through what the agency calls the “interactive process.”
An employer also can’t deny a job to a qualified worker because the worker needs an accommodation, the EEOC says. It can’t make a pregnant worker take leave if another accommodation would let the worker keep working. And it can’t punish or retaliate against someone for asking.
The “interactive process” sounds formal, but the EEOC describes it simply as the employer and the worker talking about what’s needed. “Workers do not need to use specific words to request an accommodation,” the agency says.
12
Pregnant workers have other protections
The PWFA isn’t the only law that protects pregnant workers. The EEOC says that in some situations, workers affected by pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions may also be entitled to an accommodation under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 or the Americans with Disabilities Act.
Other federal laws the EEOC enforces make it illegal to fire or otherwise discriminate against workers because of pregnancy, the agency says. The PWFA itself only governs accommodations. And the EEOC notes that more than 30 states and cities have their own laws requiring employers to accommodate pregnant workers.
Disabled workers will recognize the PWFA’s language. Reasonable accommodation and undue hardship are the same terms the Americans with Disabilities Act uses, and the EEOC’s guidance describes the law’s protections in terms of a worker’s “known limitations,” not a worker’s gender.
13
What pregnant workers can do now
If you’re pregnant or recovering from childbirth and need a change at work, here’s what the ruling and the EEOC’s guidance suggest:
- Know who your employer is. The Fifth Circuit’s order protects the State of Texas as an employer. If you work for a private company with 15 or more employees, the PWFA still applies to it, unless a later order changes that.
- Ask in writing. Put your request for an accommodation in an email or letter, and keep a copy of every reply.
- Name every law that may help. Title VII and the Americans with Disabilities Act may also require an accommodation in some situations, the EEOC says.
- Check your state and city. More than 30 states and cities have their own pregnant-worker laws, according to the EEOC.
- Contact the EEOC. The EEOC accepts charges under the PWFA, Title VII and the ADA. Check its filing deadlines early, because a late charge can end a claim.
14
What happens next
The federal government can ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the Fifth Circuit’s decision. Until a higher court says otherwise, the PWFA can’t be enforced against the State of Texas as an employer.
For everyone else, the PWFA stands. Bloom will follow the case, and any new challenge built on the Fifth Circuit’s reasoning, and will report what it means for the workers who depend on the law.
Bloom has covered how accommodations work, and fail, before. When a worker asked to work from home after a stroke and was refused, the EEOC stepped in. This week, the Fifth Circuit also issued a major Second Amendment ruling that Bloom reported on.
15
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with workers who carry life while carrying a full shift, including trans and nonbinary parents who are too often left out of the conversation. I believe no one should have to choose between a healthy pregnancy and a paycheck, and a water bottle at a desk shouldn’t depend on a quorum count.
If this ruling leaves you anxious about your job, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and Bloom’s support groups are a place to be heard.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading the court opinions that change workers’ lives, and a one-time gift helps too.
16
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 20, 2026, the full Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 that the House passed the PWFA without a lawful quorum because it counted members present by proxy. It affirmed an order blocking enforcement of the law against Texas.
Yes. The court said its decision goes no further than the district court’s order, which protects the State of Texas as an employer. The order doesn’t, by its terms, cover private employers or other states.
It’s the part of Article I, Section 5, of the Constitution that says a majority of each House is a quorum to do business. The majority held that absent members can’t be counted present through proxies.
It requires employers with 15 or more employees to provide reasonable accommodations for known limitations related to pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions, unless that causes an undue hardship.
Federal enforcement of the PWFA against Texas stays blocked. Title VII and the Americans with Disabilities Act may still require accommodations in some situations, the EEOC says.
The federal government can ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review it. Until then, the order blocking the PWFA’s enforcement against Texas remains in place.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Texas Legislature · 21 November 2026Justice Department Admits Deported Man Is a Citizen, Seeks Dismissal
Texas Legislature · 20 November 2026Texas Police Draw Millions in 287(g) Money With Few Strings Attached
Texas Legislature · 20 November 2026Texas Confirms Failed IV Attempts in Execution of Reinaldo Dennes