
Newsroom·Idaho Legislature·News
Pocatello Pays $4.5 Million to Family of Autistic Teen Shot by Police
Pocatello has finalized a $4.5 million settlement with the family of Victor Perez, the autistic 17-year-old its officers shot in his own backyard in 2025.
The city of Pocatello, Idaho, has paid $4.5 million to the family of Victor Perez, the autistic 17-year-old its police officers shot in his own backyard in April 2025. The family’s federal lawsuit, Family of Victor Perez v. City of Pocatello, was dismissed on Friday, November 20, 2026, KIFI Local News 8 reported, closing the case.
The settlement admits no fault, and no amount of money returns a son and grandson to the people who loved him. But it ends the legal chapter of a case that forced one Idaho city to change how its officers train for calls about people in crisis. Here’s what the settlement says, what happened that day, why no officer was charged, and what families of autistic people can do now.
01
What the Victor Perez settlement says
The settlement totals $4.5 million, KPVI reported. The city’s insurance covered $3 million, and the remaining $1.5 million came from existing reserve funds that the City Council approved in early November. The city says the agreement resolves the matter without an admission of fault or liability.
Court documents filed on October 26 show how the money is divided, according to CBS2 Idaho News, citing Local News 8. Luis Alicea, Victor Perez’s grandfather and guardian, will receive 60%. His mother, Wanda Alicea, and his sister will each receive 20%.
The city was notified on Friday of the court’s judgment of dismissal, KPVI reported. With that order, the Victor Perez lawsuit is over.
02
What the city says now
For a year and a half, Pocatello said little in public about the case. On Friday, Mayor Mark Dahlquist spoke. “Victor and the Perez family have been on my mind since that day,” he said. “His death has been painful for our community.”
The mayor acknowledged the silence. “I know it has been frustrating for the community that we have been unable to share more details,” Dahlquist said, according to Local News 8. The city waited until the civil case was fully resolved to speak, he said.
He ended with a promise and an admission. The agreement may bring “a sense of closure,” he said, “however we still have work to do together to improve how we respond when someone is in crisis.” Bloom agrees with the second half of that sentence, and will hold the city to it.
03
What happened to Victor Perez on April 5, 2025
On April 5, 2025, four Pocatello police officers answered a 911 call. The call described an intoxicated male threatening to stab others, Boise State Public Radio reported. CBS2 reported that neighbors had called about what appeared to be a family dispute outside the family’s home.
A neighbor’s video shows Victor Perez lying on the ground in his backyard holding a large knife, while three adults stand nearby trying to talk him down, Boise State Public Radio reported. When the officers arrived, he stumbled up toward them. They shouted at him to drop the knife, and when he didn’t, they fired.
Three officers fired handguns and one fired a beanbag round from a shotgun. They opened fire less than 20 seconds after running from their vehicles, discharging their weapons 14 times. Bodycam footage shows the officers were separated from Victor Perez by a four-foot chain-link fence when they shot him from 12 feet away.
An autopsy found 12 gunshot wounds, KPVI reported. Victor Perez went through several surgeries, including the amputation of a leg, before tests showed he lacked brain activity, the Associated Press reported. He was taken off life support and died about a week after the shooting.
04
Who Victor Perez was
Victor Perez was 17. His family described him to the Associated Press as nonverbal and autistic, and the AP described him as a boy with intellectual disabilities. His family has also said he had cerebral palsy.
His family said he had a history of behavioral incidents related to his autism, along with other mental and physical disabilities, CBS2 reported. In other words, he was an autistic teen having a hard day at home, with family members trying to calm him, when the police arrived.
His grandfather and guardian, Luis Alicea, spoke publicly for the first time in June 2025. Speaking in Spanish through an interpreter, he said “this is about a human being who was killed in his own home,” EastIdahoNews.com reported. “He was not an animal, and justice needs to be served,” he said.
05
Why no officer was charged
Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador’s office reviewed the shooting at the request of the Bannock County Prosecutor’s Office. The Eastern Idaho Critical Incident Task Force, with the Bannock County Sheriff’s Office as the lead agency, investigated, according to the attorney general’s office. Its Criminal Law Division added follow-up interviews and reviewed the whole case.
On September 3, 2025, the office said no officer would be charged. In a letter, Deputy Attorney General Jeff Nye wrote that the state couldn’t prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the officers broke the law and that their use of force was not justified, Boise State Public Radio reported.
Under Idaho law, officers may use deadly force if they perceive that they or someone else is in grave danger of death or bodily harm. Nye wrote that the state could consider only “the facts known or reasonably believed by the officers at the time of the shooting.”
Those facts were thin. The officers didn’t know Victor Perez’s age or that he had disabilities, and they acted on inaccurate information from dispatch, based on the 911 caller’s view from across the street, Boise State Public Radio reported. The station also reported that the review says the nonverbal teen most likely didn’t pose a threat to the officers.
06
What a criminal review can’t decide
The attorney general’s office was careful about the limits of its decision. Its role was to decide whether the state could prove a crime beyond a reasonable doubt. The office “does not make determinations about civil liability, employment discipline, or compliance with department policy,” its announcement said.
That’s why a civil case could go on after the criminal review closed. A prosecutor asks whether a jury could convict an officer of a crime. A civil rights lawsuit asks a different question: whether the city and its officers must answer for the harm they caused.
The family’s attorney told East Idaho News that the family wasn’t surprised by the result, and that it would amend its civil complaint based on the attorney general’s findings, Boise State Public Radio reported.
07
The family’s lawsuit over use of force
The legal fight began less than two weeks after the shooting. In April 2025, the Oakland, California, firm Burris, Nisenbaum, Curry & Lacy filed an administrative claim against Pocatello on behalf of the family, a precursor to a lawsuit, the Associated Press reported.
The claim said the officers used excessive force, and that the family “suffered emotional distress caused by witnessing the negligent conduct of the involved officers.” Attorney Ben Nisenbaum was blunt. “He wasn’t going after anyone,” he told the AP. “The officers just lined up and opened fire.”
In June 2025, the family filed its federal civil rights lawsuit against the Pocatello police, accusing the department of violating Victor Perez’s civil rights, EastIdahoNews.com reported. The suit raised questions about the officers’ use of force, CBS2 reported, including that the shooting happened within seconds of their arrival.
08
A council vote, and questions about openness
On Thursday, November 5, 2026, the Pocatello City Council voted unanimously to authorize the reserve funds to settle the case, CBS2 reported. The meeting’s public agenda didn’t say the money was meant for the Victor Perez case.
Council Member Dakota Bates said he was frustrated with how the city handled the case in public, according to CBS2. He said council members were urged not to talk about the case with local media, and he questioned how transparent the city had been.
“Few events in Pocatello history have generated this much public attention, pain and division,” Bates said at the meeting. He said the way the city resolved the case mattered to the family, the city, the community’s healing and “the public trust of this institution.”
Bloom agrees with him. When a city pays millions over a death at the hands of its police, the public deserves to know what it bought and why.
09
What Pocatello police say has changed
Since the shooting, the Pocatello police have brought in outside experts to train officers for autism-related calls, KPVI reported. The department has also put new training programs and procedures in place, according to Chief Roger Schei.
The city’s news release says the department’s “Crisis Intervention Team, De-Escalation, community-oriented policing, and scenario-based training continue to help officers respond to people in crisis,” Local News 8 reported. Schei said the department “will continue to seek out new ways to train our officers and staff.”
Training matters, and Bloom welcomes it. But the people who need it most are the ones who can’t explain themselves when an officer starts shouting. For them, training has to show up in the first 20 seconds, not in a news release after the funeral.
10
The KNOW ME File, explained
In February 2026, Pocatello launched the KNOW ME File, a voluntary program that gives police, fire and paramedics quick access to important information about the person they are helping, Local News 8 reported. The program was developed in part in response to the death of Victor Perez.
Participants can share preferred ways to communicate, sensory sensitivities, medical needs or conditions, emergency contacts and a photograph. Dahlquist said it’s “a great tool to provide more information that comes from the individual themselves or a family member.” Bannock County residents can enroll through the city of Pocatello’s website.
Jennifer Call, an attorney for the Perez family, said the KNOW ME File was one of the changes the family asked for in its lawsuit. “This is the first step,” she told Local News 8. The family also wanted de-escalation training taught more widely and “a call for more transparency in what is happening inside the department.”
11
What the Victor Perez case shows about crisis calls
The attorney general’s review turned on what the officers knew. They didn’t know Victor Perez was 17, autistic and nonverbal. An autistic teen who can’t speak can’t tell officers who he is. The information that reached them came from a 911 caller across the street, and it was wrong.
A voluntary file is one way to close that gap, and Pocatello deserves credit for building it. But it can’t be the only safeguard. Many families will never hear of the program, and a profile helps only when a dispatcher checks it and an officer has time to use it.
Bloom believes the deeper lesson is about time and distance. Victor Perez was behind a four-foot fence, with family members trying to calm him. Disabled people deserve officers who are trained to slow down when someone can’t follow commands, and leaders who measure success by the lives that come home.
12
A timeline of the Victor Perez case
These dates come from KIFI Local News 8, KPVI, CBS2, Boise State Public Radio, the Associated Press and EastIdahoNews.com:
- April 5, 2025: Four Pocatello police officers respond to a 911 call and shoot Victor Perez in his family’s backyard.
- April 2025: Victor Perez dies about a week later. Lawyers for his family file an administrative claim against the city.
- June 2025: The family files a federal civil rights lawsuit against the Pocatello police.
- September 3, 2025: Idaho’s attorney general announces that no officer will be charged.
- February 2026: Pocatello launches the voluntary KNOW ME File.
- October 26, 2026: Court documents show the city agreed to pay $4.5 million.
- November 5, 2026: The City Council votes unanimously to authorize $1.5 million in reserve funds.
- November 20, 2026: The court dismisses the case, and the city announces the settlement is final.
13
What families of autistic people can do now
If you love someone who is autistic, nonverbal or otherwise disabled, the story of an autistic teen shot in his own yard is hard to read. Here are steps that may help before a crisis comes:
- If you live in Bannock County, consider the KNOW ME File. You can share how your loved one communicates, sensory needs, medical conditions, emergency contacts and a photo through the city of Pocatello’s website.
- Ask your own police or sheriff’s office what it offers. Some departments run voluntary programs. Ask how dispatchers use the information and how officers are trained for disability calls.
- Tell the dispatcher about the disability. If you call 911 for a loved one in crisis, say plainly that the person is disabled, how they communicate and that they may not follow commands.
- Know the crisis line. For a mental health or suicide crisis, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.
- Write things down. If you believe police violated your loved one’s rights, keep records and talk to a civil rights attorney early. The Perez family’s lawyers filed an administrative claim with the city before they sued.
14
What happens next
The civil case is closed, and the settlement admits no fault. The officers weren’t charged, and the attorney general’s office says it doesn’t decide questions of employment discipline or department policy.
What remains is the work the mayor named: improving how Pocatello responds when someone is in crisis. The city says its officers now train with outside experts on autism-related calls and that its KNOW ME File is open to residents. Bloom will follow whether those promises hold, and report what Pocatello police do with them.
Bloom reported this week on another family’s grief, when a Madison prosecutor declined to charge the officer who killed Corey Ruiz. Different cities, the same question: what do we owe the people the system was supposed to protect?
15
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with disabled people and the families who love them. I believe Victor Perez should be alive today, and every autistic child deserves to grow up in a city whose officers know how to slow down. Bloom’s disability advocacy work exists for families like his, the same way Bloom stood with Hoosiers fighting to keep in-home care.
If this news is heavy for you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and you can call or text 988. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached, and Bloom’s support groups are a place to grieve with others.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom reporting on disability rights and police accountability all year, and a one-time gift helps too.
16
Frequently Asked Questions
Victor Perez was a 17-year-old from Pocatello, Idaho, whose family described him as nonverbal and autistic. Pocatello police officers shot him in his family’s backyard on April 5, 2025, and he died about a week later.
The settlement totals $4.5 million. The city’s insurance covered $3 million, and $1.5 million came from city reserve funds approved by the City Council.
No. The city says the agreement resolves the case without an admission of fault or liability.
No. Idaho’s attorney general announced on September 3, 2025, that the state couldn’t prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the officers committed a crime.
The court dismissed Family of Victor Perez v. City of Pocatello on Friday, November 20, 2026, after the settlement was finalized.
It’s a voluntary Pocatello program that lets residents share a loved one’s communication needs, sensory sensitivities, medical conditions, emergency contacts and photo with dispatchers and first responders.
The department says it brought in outside experts on autism-related calls and uses crisis intervention, de-escalation and scenario-based training.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Kentucky Legislature · 20 November 2026Kentucky SB 150 Trial Ends as Trans Students Await a Judge’s Ruling
Legislation · 20 November 2026UK Tribunal Confirms Secret Order to Apple Over Encrypted Data
Justice for survivors · 20 November 2026Canada’s Supreme Court: Survivors Don’t Have to Say No for It to Count