Empty school hallway lined with blue lockers, illustrating the SB 150 trial over Kentucky's school rules for transgender students

NewsroomKentucky LegislatureNews

Kentucky Families Take SB 150 to Trial Under the State Constitution

Families of transgender and gender-nonconforming students in Lexington go to trial on November 16, asking a Kentucky judge to strike SB 150's school rules under the state constitution.

On Monday, November 16, families of transgender and gender-nonconforming students in Fayette County Public Schools will ask a Kentucky judge to strike down the school rules in SB 150. Their challenge goes to a five-day bench trial, through Friday, November 20, before Judge Julie Goodman of Kentucky’s 22nd Circuit Court, 4th Division, Queer Kentucky reported. The families aren’t leaning on the U.S. Constitution this time. They’re leaning on Kentucky’s own.

That choice matters. SB 150 has shaped Kentucky classrooms since March 2023, when the General Assembly overrode Gov. Andy Beshear’s veto. It decides which restroom a child may use, whether a teacher can be required to use a student’s pronouns, and what a class may discuss. Casey Hinkle, the attorney leading the families’ case, told Queer Kentucky, “This case is the first (that we know of) to challenge the educational aspects of SB 150.”

01

What the SB 150 trial will decide

The case is John Doe et al. v. Fayette County Board of Education and Kentucky Attorney General Russell Coleman. The plaintiffs are families with trans and gender-nonconforming children in Fayette County Public Schools. Hinkle told Queer Kentucky that Coleman is named because the attorney general must be named in every case challenging a law’s constitutionality. The attorney general’s role is to defend SB 150, and Queer Kentucky noted that Coleman has been one of the law’s most vocal supporters.

A bench trial means there’s no jury. Judge Goodman alone will hear the evidence and decide whether SB 150’s school provisions can stand under the Kentucky Constitution. If the families win, Hinkle indicated the result would include “a court order declaring SB 150 unconstitutional and enjoining the Attorney General and Fayette County Board of Education from enforcing the law.”

This isn’t a new fight. The case began in September 2023, when the families of five trans and nonbinary Lexington students, ages 10 to 17, filed a class action in Fayette County Circuit Court, Louisville Public Media reported at the time. The children appear in court papers only under pseudonyms. More than three years later, their case reaches a courtroom.

02

What SB 150 requires inside Kentucky schools

A row of plain closed restroom doors in a quiet school corridor, illustrating SB 150's restroom rules
SB 150 requires Kentucky school boards to bar students from restrooms reserved for a different biological sex.

Start with the restroom. SB 150’s text requires each local school board to adopt policies that, at a minimum, do “not allow students to use restrooms, locker rooms, or shower rooms that are reserved for students of a different biological sex.” The law defines biological sex as “the physical condition of being male or female, which is determined by a person’s chromosomes, and is identified at birth by a person’s anatomy.”

A student who tells school officials that their gender differs from their biological sex, and whose parent gives written consent, must get “the best available accommodation,” the law says. That accommodation can’t include a restroom, locker room or shower room designated for the opposite biological sex while students of that sex are or could be present. The law’s examples include “access to single-stall restrooms or controlled use of faculty bathrooms, locker rooms, or shower rooms.”

Then pronouns. SB 150 says a local district “shall not require school personnel or students to use pronouns for students that do not conform to that particular student’s biological sex.” It also bars the Kentucky Board of Education and the Kentucky Department of Education from requiring or recommending pronoun policies that don’t match a student’s “original, unedited birth certificate.”

Then the classroom. The law bars instruction on human sexuality for children in grade five and below. For every grade, it bars “any instruction or presentation that has a goal or purpose of students studying or exploring gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.” It also forbids districts from adopting policies “with the intent of keeping any student information confidential from parents.”

The General Assembly wrote its reasons into the law. Its findings say students have “natural and normal concerns about privacy while in various states of undress.” They say shared restrooms across biological sex would create “a significant potential for disruption of school activities and unsafe conditions.” That’s the position the attorney general will defend this week.

SB 150 also bans gender-affirming medical care for transgender minors. That part isn’t on trial this week. It was challenged separately in federal court, and the families’ lawyers have taken a different road, as the sections below explain.

03

The families’ case under the Kentucky Constitution

An open leather-bound book on a library table, illustrating the Kentucky Constitution at the center of the SB 150 case
The families rely on Sections 1, 2, 3 and 183 of Kentucky's 1891 constitution.

The families’ claims rest on four sections of the Kentucky Constitution, according to Queer Kentucky. Sections 1, 2 and 3 set out Kentuckians’ fundamental rights and equal protection under the law. Section 183 sets out the state’s duty to its schools. Each is short, each dates to 1891, and each speaks plainly.

Section 1 begins, “All men are, by nature, free and equal, and have certain inherent and inalienable rights.” Third on its list: “The right of seeking and pursuing their safety and happiness.” Section 2 says, “Absolute and arbitrary power over the lives, liberty and property of freemen exists nowhere in a republic, not even in the largest majority.”

Section 3 adds, “All men, when they form a social compact, are equal.” And Section 183 is the promise every Kentucky parent counts on: “The General Assembly shall, by appropriate legislation, provide for an efficient system of common schools throughout the State.”

The families argue that SB 150 fails those guarantees because of the harm it causes trans and gender-nonconforming children, Queer Kentucky reported. Under Section 183, they argue the law keeps those students from a safe and fair education, especially through its restroom rules and its exclusionary provisions.

The 2023 complaint made the case in its own words. It said the rules on restrooms, pronouns and classroom speech violate students’ rights to public education and privacy under the Kentucky Constitution, and that SB 150 is sex discrimination under state law, Louisville Public Media reported. One line from it stays with you: “No child can attend a public school and be a student therein without ready access to a school restroom.”

The complaint went further on the classroom rules. On behalf of all Kentucky families, it argued that barring sex education in grade five and below harms students’ educational rights. It also argued that limits on classroom discussion of gender identity and human sexuality violate the free speech and freedom of thought protections in the Kentucky Constitution. Citing state Supreme Court precedent, the lawyers said the state must equip students with “sufficient self-knowledge and knowledge of his or her mental and physical wellness.”

The complaint also raised a practical question about privacy. School staff have no way to know a child’s chromosomes, the families’ lawyers argued, and they’re neither allowed nor qualified to inspect a student’s body. The lawyers also argued that state law bars school staff from checking birth certificates except to decide eligibility for sports teams.

04

What families and school staff told the court

The families’ court documents, shared with Queer Kentucky, describe children who “have been denied safe restroom access, misgendered by teachers and classmates without recourse.” They say the children have been excluded from enrichment activities and stifled in classroom discussion. According to those documents, the harm didn’t exist before SB 150.

The most striking line comes from the school system’s own people. “FCPS administrators and staff testified uniformly that the problems SB 150 purports to address did not exist before its enactment,” the families wrote. They added that “the law itself has created disruption, confusion, and harm to students.”

Fayette County Public Schools changed course in July 2023, bowing to SB 150 by barring trans students from restrooms that match their gender and ending sex education in elementary school, Louisville Public Media reported. It’s Kentucky’s second-largest school district. When the suit was filed, the district said it was “committed to providing a safe and welcoming environment for all students, working in partnership with families, and following the requirements of state law.”

The 2023 complaint described a 10-year-old trans girl who told her parents she would “hold it” until she got home rather than use the restroom at school, Louisville Public Media reported.

The families also brought in a scientist. Dr. Christia Spears Brown, a developmental psychologist, wrote in expert testimony that “LGBTQ+ youth are disproportionately harassed by their classmates, leading to heightened risks to their mental and physical health.” Her conclusion: “The evidence presented in this report suggests that SB 150 is not aligned with current research in developmental psychology, education, and social psychology.”

Pause there with me. A child who won’t use the restroom all day isn’t a policy abstraction. That child is trying to get through a school day carrying something no child should have to carry. The court will weigh the evidence, and it should. But the question underneath this case is simple: can a state make the school day harder for some of its children and still keep its promise of an efficient system of common schools?

05

Why the families went to state court

An empty wood-paneled courtroom with wooden benches, illustrating the SB 150 bench trial in Kentucky
In a bench trial there's no jury; the judge alone decides.

Kentucky families tried the federal courts first. The ACLU of Kentucky and NCLR, a national LGBTQ legal organization, challenged SB 150’s ban on gender-affirming care in federal court in Doe v. Thornbury, Queer Kentucky reported. The plaintiffs won a preliminary injunction blocking the ban, only to see that win reversed by a federal court in September 2023. The families’ state lawsuit was filed the same day a federal appeals court ruled to keep other provisions of SB 150 in place, Louisville Public Media reported.

That’s why this case is built differently. “If the federal courts are not going to be receptive to our pleas, let’s try the state courts,” Ernesto Scorsone told Queer Kentucky. Scorsone sits on the board of JustFundKy, a nonprofit focused on LGBTQ+-inclusive education that is fiscally supporting the challenge. “It’s an ongoing struggle,” he said.

Scorsone knows Kentucky’s courts from the inside. He’s a retired Fayette Circuit Court judge and a former state legislator, and as an attorney he led the legal team in Wasson v. Commonwealth, which found a Kentucky criminal law violated the state constitution. “Every case that’s brought up like this, we are trying to educate the judiciary,” he said.

Kentucky’s constitution has its own words about equality, arbitrary power and schools. These families are asking a Kentucky judge to read those words for Kentucky’s children. That’s the heart of the strategy.

06

What’s still unclear

The trial is scheduled to run through Friday, November 20. Queer Kentucky didn’t report when Judge Goodman is expected to rule, and Bloom won’t guess. Bloom will report the ruling when it comes.

The sources also don’t say how far a win would reach. The order the families seek would name the attorney general and the Fayette County Board of Education. Whether it changes practice in Kentucky’s other districts will depend on what the court actually orders and on what happens after that.

And neither source says whether either side plans to appeal. The attorney general’s job in this case is to defend SB 150. The families’ backers sound ready for a long road. “If we don’t win today, we’ll win tomorrow,” Scorsone said.

07

What this means for families in Oregon and Washington

Bloom is based in Salem, Oregon, and the contrast with Kentucky is stark. Oregon law, ORS 659.850, defines discrimination to include any act that unreasonably differentiates treatment based on traits that include “sexual orientation, gender identity.” It says, “A person may not be subjected to discrimination in any public elementary, secondary or community college education program or service.”

Washington’s law is just as direct. RCW 28A.642.010 prohibits discrimination in Washington public schools on the basis of sexual orientation, gender expression and gender identity, along with race, disability and other characteristics. The Kentucky trial won’t change either law. But it’s a reminder that what transgender students can count on at school can depend on which state line their family lives behind.

If your family is weighing a move, Bloom’s trans relocation page is there for you. No family should have to move to keep a child safe at school. Some do anyway, and they deserve clear, honest information when they make that choice.

08

What you can do this week

If you’re in Kentucky, follow the bench trial from November 16 through November 20. Queer Kentucky has said it will keep reporting on the case, and Bloom will report the outcome. Read the law for yourself, too; the bill runs nine pages, and knowing its exact words is a kind of protection.

If you’re the parent of a trans or gender-nonconforming student, know the one accommodation SB 150 itself promises. A student whose parent gives written consent must be offered the best available accommodation, which the law says can include a single-stall restroom. Ask your school, in writing, what that accommodation is, and keep a copy of the answer.

If you’re one of the transgender students living under this law: you aren’t the problem SB 150 says it’s solving. You deserve a school day without fear. If you need someone right now, The Trevor Project answers at 1-866-488-7386, Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860, and 988 by call or text. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more help.

09

What Bloom is doing

Bloom is following the SB 150 trial and will report Judge Goodman’s ruling. Bloom is also following the federal trial over the transgender military ban, because these cases rhyme. Families shouldn’t have to piece the law together from headlines.

That’s why Bloom is building Bloom Resources: verified legal, healthcare, housing and benefits guides for trans and disabled people, dated, primary-sourced and free. You can help fund Bloom Resources. Bloom also offers support groups, and if fear for your child is keeping you up at night, Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

Reporting like this lasts because people stand behind it month after month. Become a monthly supporter at whatever level feels right, or make a one-time gift if that fits better today.

10

Frequently Asked Questions

SB 150 is a 2023 Kentucky law that has been in force since the General Assembly overrode Gov. Andy Beshear’s veto in March 2023. It restricts which restrooms and locker rooms transgender students may use, limits pronoun requirements and classroom instruction on gender identity, and bans gender-affirming medical care for minors.

The bench trial is scheduled for November 16 through November 20 before Judge Julie Goodman of Kentucky’s 22nd Circuit Court, 4th Division, according to Queer Kentucky. In a bench trial, the judge alone decides the case.

They’re challenging SB 150’s school provisions under the Kentucky Constitution. Their attorney, Casey Hinkle, said a win would include an order declaring SB 150 unconstitutional and barring the attorney general and the Fayette County Board of Education from enforcing it.

No. This case targets the law’s education provisions. The care ban was challenged separately in federal court, where an early win for families was reversed in September 2023.

Kentucky’s constitution has its own guarantees. The families rely on Sections 1, 2 and 3, which cover fundamental rights and equality, and on Section 183, which requires “an efficient system of common schools throughout the State.”

Yes. SB 150’s school rules apply to schools under the control of local boards of education and charter school boards across Kentucky. This lawsuit was brought by families in Fayette County Public Schools.

The Trevor Project answers at 1-866-488-7386, Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860, and 988 by call or text. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more places to turn.


Sovereignty over Servitude.

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.