
Newsroom·Hawaii Legislature·News
Convicted Killer Indicted in Death of Transgender Prisoner in Hawaii
Denise Foster was near the end of a theft sentence when she was killed at Hawaii's largest prison. On November 17 a grand jury charged a man already serving life for two murders. Why was she housed within his reach?
Denise Foster expected to go home in September or October, her niece says. The 55-year-old was serving a five-year sentence for theft at Hālawa Correctional Facility, Hawaii’s largest prison, when she was killed there on August 4. On Tuesday, November 17, an Oʻahu grand jury indicted Jason McCormick, a 52-year-old man already serving life for two murders, on a charge of first-degree murder in the death of the transgender prisoner.
The charge is an accusation, not a conviction, and McCormick is presumed innocent. But it brings back the question her family has asked since August: why was a nonviolent, minimum-security transgender prisoner housed where she had contact with a maximum-security inmate who had killed twice before? Here is what the grand jury charged, who Denise Foster was, what federal and Hawaii rules say about housing a transgender prisoner, and what you can do three days before Transgender Day of Remembrance.
01
What the grand jury charged
The Hawaii Department of the Attorney General announced the indictment on November 17 in News Release 2026-62. An Oʻahu grand jury indicted McCormick for Murder in the First Degree “in connection with the death of fellow inmate Denise Foster” at Hālawa Correctional Facility on August 4, 2026, the release says.
First-degree murder carries a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. McCormick is already incarcerated at Hālawa Correctional Facility, where he is serving two consecutive life sentences in unrelated cases, and he is being held without bail on the new charge. Toni Schwartz, public information officer for the attorney general’s office, said in a written statement that he is still being held there without bail, Honolulu Civil Beat reported.
The release says McCormick “is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.” Civil Beat reported that the indictment itself gives no details about the case. Bloom reports the charge as a charge, and nothing in this report should be read as a finding of guilt.
Civil Beat and KHON2 both reported the indictment the same day. Some official statements and broadcast reports about the case used a former name for her, and some used the wrong pronouns. Bloom uses the name Denise and the pronouns she and her, as Civil Beat does and as her niece does when she speaks of her.
02
Who Denise Foster was
Denise Foster was 55. Civil Beat described her as a nonviolent, minimum-security inmate serving a five-year prison term for theft and unauthorized control of a propelled vehicle. She was sentenced on May 10, 2023, after pleading no contest to second-degree theft and unauthorized control of a propelled vehicle, Civil Beat reported in August. Her niece, Queenair Bulawan, said she had expected to be released in September or October.
Her lawyer, Nelson Goo, told Civil Beat in August that she had no record of violence and no known gang ties. He questioned “why Foster was housed in a prison module where she would have contact” with an inmate as dangerous as McCormick. “It doesn’t make sense,” he said.
Her family is still waiting for an explanation. Bulawan said the family has heard nothing from the prison system about what led to Foster’s death, and was not told about the indictment before it was made public. “Ever since she passed, nobody said anything,” Bulawan said. “We don’t know.”
The holidays will be the hardest part. Bulawan told Civil Beat that this is the season when Foster always went to family houses. “She always tried to give something to everybody,” she said. In August, her family said it plans to sue over her death.
A transgender prisoner is a person first: a niece’s aunt, a client to her lawyer, a woman with a release date. That is how Bloom will remember Denise Foster, and it is how this report tells her story.
03
The man charged in her death
McCormick, 52, is a maximum-security inmate. He was sentenced in 2013 to life in prison with the possibility of parole for the 1996 murder of Robert Henderson, a visiting University of Pittsburgh professor, Civil Beat reported.
He also pleaded guilty to premeditated first-degree murder in Arizona in the 2015 death of his cellmate, Jonathan Namauleg, 21, at the Saguaro Correctional Center. That conviction carries a life sentence without parole, to be served after he completes his life sentence for the Henderson murder. Those two cases are convictions. The killing of Denise Foster is, for now, a charge.
His record matters to the story of a transgender prisoner’s death for one reason above all: a prison is supposed to know it. Under federal standards, a prison’s intake screening weighs prior convictions for violent offenses and any history of violence inside when it judges whether an inmate poses a risk of sexual abuse to others. A two-time convicted killer and a nonviolent transgender prisoner ended up within reach of each other, and the state hasn’t said how.
04
Why was a transgender prisoner housed within his reach?
Hālawa Correctional Facility is a men’s prison. Civil Beat reported on November 17 that the prison system has not explained why Foster was housed in an area of the prison where she had contact with McCormick. Her lawyer asked in August. Her family is still asking. The indictment doesn’t answer it either.
The Hawaii Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s policy on the Prison Rape Elimination Act, effective January 1, 2024, sets the starting point. A transgender prisoner “will be housed based on their legal status as a male or female,” it says. Any exception is decided by medical and mental health practitioners, with input from program and security staff, beginning at intake.
The same policy takes the federal rule as its own. Placement is a case-by-case judgment of “whether a placement would ensure the offender’s health and safety,” it says. Designated staff must reassess each transgender prisoner’s placement twice a year “for the purpose of assessing any threats to the safety of the offender.” And a transgender prisoner’s own views about her safety must get serious consideration.
In a Community Voices essay in Civil Beat on September 22, Keke Walker and Isis Patiño Fernandez Usborne put the question plainly: “The first question we must ask is why Denise was placed in a men’s facility to begin with.” That was their opinion. The questions about her screening, her last review and who decided her housing are questions of fact, and only the state can answer them.
A family shouldn’t have to wait for a trial to learn why a transgender prisoner was placed where she was. The department has the screening records, the classification decisions and the twice-yearly reviews its own policy requires. Releasing what it can, without harming the criminal case, would be a start.
05
What the law says about housing a transgender prisoner
The federal standards under the Prison Rape Elimination Act begin with screening. Under 28 CFR 115.41, every inmate is assessed at intake, ordinarily within 72 hours of arrival, and reassessed within 30 days. The screening must consider whether an inmate’s criminal history “is exclusively nonviolent” and whether the inmate “is or is perceived to be gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender, intersex, or gender nonconforming.”
The same rule tells the prison to weigh prior convictions for violent offenses and any history of violence inside, in judging whether an inmate is at risk of being sexually abusive toward others. In other words, the standards put a transgender prisoner’s vulnerability and another inmate’s record in the same screening, so that someone looks at both.
28 CFR 115.42 then says how to use what the screening finds. Housing must aim at “keeping separate those inmates at high risk of being sexually victimized from those at high risk of being sexually abusive.” The agency “shall make individualized determinations about how to ensure the safety of each inmate.” For a transgender prisoner, it must consider case by case “whether a placement would ensure the inmate’s health and safety.”
Two more lines matter to every family with someone inside. A transgender prisoner’s placement “shall be reassessed at least twice each year to review any threats to safety experienced by the inmate.” And a transgender prisoner’s “own views with respect to his or her own safety shall be given serious consideration.”
These standards were written to prevent sexual abuse, and nothing in the public record says Foster was sexually abused. But they are the clearest national statement of what a prison owes a transgender prisoner: an individual look at who is safe where, a review at least twice a year, and a real voice for the person at risk. Hawaii’s own policy repeats each of those duties.
06
Hawaii’s first-degree murder law
Hawaii reserves first-degree murder for a short list of killings. Under Hawaii Revised Statutes section 707-701, the list includes intentionally or knowingly causing the death of more than one person in the same or separate incidents, and of “a person while the defendant was imprisoned.” The attorney general’s release doesn’t say which part of the law the indictment relies on.
A conviction brings a fixed sentence. “Defendants convicted of murder in the first degree are automatically sentenced to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole,” the statute’s official commentary says. The commentary also notes that Hawaii has abolished the death penalty.
For McCormick, a conviction would add a sentence of life without parole to the two life sentences he is already serving. For the family of Denise Foster, no sentence answers the question they keep asking. Only the prison system can do that.
07
A timeline of the case
These dates come from the attorney general’s release, Civil Beat’s reporting and Hawaii’s corrections policy:
- 1996: Robert Henderson, a visiting University of Pittsburgh professor, is killed. McCormick is sentenced to life with the possibility of parole for his murder in 2013.
- 2015: McCormick’s cellmate, Jonathan Namauleg, 21, is killed at the Saguaro Correctional Center in Arizona. McCormick later pleads guilty to premeditated first-degree murder.
- May 10, 2023: Denise Foster is sentenced to five years after pleading no contest to second-degree theft and unauthorized control of a propelled vehicle.
- January 1, 2024: Hawaii’s corrections policy on the Prison Rape Elimination Act takes effect, including its rules for housing a transgender prisoner.
- August 4, 2026: Foster, a transgender prisoner near the end of her sentence, is killed at Hālawa Correctional Facility.
- August 10, 2026: Civil Beat reports that her family is seeking answers and that no arrest has been made.
- September 22, 2026: A Community Voices essay in Civil Beat asks why she was placed in a men’s facility.
- November 17, 2026: An Oʻahu grand jury indicts McCormick for first-degree murder. He is held without bail.
- November 20, 2026: Transgender Day of Remembrance.
08
A pattern of deaths in Hawaii’s prisons
Foster’s death was not the first of its kind in Hawaii’s prisons. When Civil Beat reported on it in August, it called the case “the sixth murder or suspected murder of a Hawaiʻi inmate since May of 2024.” At the time, the state’s corrections director, Tommy Johnson, said no arrest had been made, and the Honolulu Police Department and the state Department of Law Enforcement were investigating.
Two online petitions circulated after the death of the transgender prisoner, calling on the state to create safeguards for transgender and vulnerable inmates. Together they gathered over 300 signatures, Civil Beat reported. One says no one should die “because the system refused to ask whether they were safe.” It calls for “gender-affirming, safety-based housing policy” in Hawaii’s prisons “before another life is lost.”
The pattern Bloom sees reaches beyond Hawaii. Across the country, the question of where a transgender prisoner is housed keeps reaching courts, as it did in the Colorado jail case in which the Supreme Court vacated a lower-court ruling on November 9. The answer is written in the federal standards already: look at each person, ask where they are safe, and check again.
09
What happens next
McCormick remains at Hālawa Correctional Facility, held without bail on the new charge of killing a transgender prisoner. The attorney general’s release named no date for his next court appearance. Bloom will follow the case and report each step as the court record shows it.
The questions the state hasn’t answered are the ones that matter for every transgender prisoner in Hawaii:
- How did Hālawa screen and classify Denise Foster and McCormick, and when was her housing last reviewed?
- Was Foster asked where she felt safe, as federal standards and the department’s own policy require?
- Has the department reviewed how it houses each transgender prisoner since August 4?
- Will the family get the records they need for the lawsuit they said they plan to bring?
10
What you can do, and saying her name on November 20
If someone you love is a transgender prisoner, ask in writing for a safety review. Federal standards and Hawaii’s policy both say a transgender prisoner’s own views about safety must get serious consideration, and that placement must be reassessed at least twice a year. Hawaii’s policy names a department PREA coordinator and a facility PREA compliance manager. Write to the warden and to both, and keep copies.
Put every threat on paper. Write down the date, who was involved and what was said or done, and send it to the facility. A record made at the time is the strongest evidence a family has later. Bloom’s report on the November 9 Supreme Court order explains where the law on housing transgender inmates stands.
Keep November 20. Transgender Day of Remembrance began on November 20, 1999, as a vigil for Rita Hester, a 34-year-old African American transgender woman killed in Boston the year before, according to HISTORY. It began in part because news coverage “misgendered and deadnamed Hester, taking their cue from the police report.” The first observance came about largely through the efforts of the activist Gwendolyn Ann Smith.
Say Denise Foster’s name at a vigil this week, and say it rightly. Bloom’s Transgender Day of Remembrance report explains why names matter.
If this news is heavy for you, call Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, or call or text 988.
11
What Bloom is doing
Bloom has followed what happens to transgender people in custody all month: the Supreme Court’s November 9 order in a Colorado jail housing case, Ruby Corado’s bid for early release from federal custody, and the federal women’s prisons that kept failing after Dublin closed. Denise Foster’s name belongs in that record, and so does the question of why a transgender prisoner was left within reach of danger. I believe a woman near the end of a theft sentence should have come home for the holidays.
If this story stirred grief or fear in you, you don’t have to hold it alone. Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call tonight, and Bloom’s support groups meet people where they are. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
Following a case like this one, from the grand jury back to the rules that should have protected her, takes time. A monthly gift keeps Bloom on these stories all year, and a one-time gift helps too.
12
Frequently Asked Questions
Denise Foster was a 55-year-old transgender prisoner serving a five-year sentence for theft at Hālawa Correctional Facility in Hawaii. She was killed there on August 4, 2026, and her niece said she had expected to be released in September or October.
An Oʻahu grand jury indicted Jason McCormick, 52, on November 17, 2026, for first-degree murder in the death of the transgender prisoner. He is already serving two consecutive life sentences for two earlier murders, and he is presumed innocent of the new charge unless proven guilty.
Life in prison without the possibility of parole. Hawaii law reserves first-degree murder for a short list of killings, including the killing of a person by someone who is imprisoned.
Hawaii’s corrections policy says a transgender prisoner is housed based on legal status as male or female unless medical, mental health and security staff decide otherwise. The prison system has not explained why Foster was housed where she had contact with McCormick.
The Prison Rape Elimination Act standards at 28 CFR 115.42 require a case-by-case decision about whether a placement ensures the person’s health and safety, a review at least twice a year, and serious consideration of the person’s own views about safety.
November 20 each year. It began in 1999 as a vigil for Rita Hester, a transgender woman killed in Boston in 1998.
Call Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, or call or text 988. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more people to call.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Legislation · 20 November 2026UK Tribunal Confirms Secret Order to Apple Over Encrypted Data
Justice for survivors · 20 November 2026Canada’s Supreme Court: Survivors Don’t Have to Say No for It to Count
Justice for survivors · 20 November 2026Judge Strikes HUD’s $1.3 Billion Shift Away From Permanent Housing