
Newsroom·Arizona Legislature·News
Appeals Court Pauses Order to Bring Man Back From Equatorial Guinea
A man protected from torture in Egypt was deported to Equatorial Guinea, where court records say guards beat him. On November 20, an appeals court let the government leave him there while it appeals an order to bring him back.
A man an immigration judge found would likely be tortured in Egypt will stay, for now, in Equatorial Guinea, the country the United States sent him to instead. On Friday, November 20, 2026, a panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit paused a federal judge’s order requiring the Department of Homeland Security to facilitate his return, while the government appeals a ruling that his third-country deportation violated due process.
The courts identify him only by his initials, A.M.A.S. The record says he was flown to Equatorial Guinea on April 28 with no chance to object to where he was going, and that he has since been held under armed guard and beaten there. The panel’s unsigned order didn’t explain its reasoning, and Judge Graber dissented in large part. Here’s what this third-country deportation case is about, what the stay changes, and what comes next.
01
What the Ninth Circuit decided on November 20
The third-country deportation case is A.M.A.S. v. Mullin, No. 26-6950. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin is the named defendant, and the panel was Judges Graber, Bennett and H.A. Thomas.
The panel’s order is a single paragraph. As the party asking for a stay, the government “bears the burden of showing that the circumstances justify” one, the panel wrote, under four factors the Supreme Court set in 2009. Its conclusion: “Having considered the Nken factors, we find that they support the issuance of a stay.”
Those factors ask whether the government made a strong showing it’s likely to win, whether it’ll be irreparably harmed without a stay, whether a stay will substantially injure the other side, and where the public interest lies. The majority didn’t say how it weighed any of them. Judge Graber wrote that the order grants the motion “Without explanation.”
02
The third-country deportation case at a glance
- The person: A man from Egypt, admitted to the United States in 1998 and a lawful permanent resident from 2021.
- The protection: In 2025, an immigration judge deferred his removal to Egypt under the Convention Against Torture.
- The removal: On April 28, 2026, DHS sent him to Equatorial Guinea instead, a third-country deportation he had no chance to challenge.
- The ruling: On October 6, a federal judge in Arizona found that the way his third-country deportation was carried out violated his Fifth Amendment right to due process, and ordered DHS to facilitate his return.
- The stay: On November 20, the Ninth Circuit put that order on hold while the government appeals.
- The dissent: Judge Graber would have paused only the parts that went beyond what the Supreme Court approved in 2025.
- What’s next: The appeal continues, and on December 9 the Supreme Court hears a related third-country deportation case.
03
Who A.M.A.S. is, in the court’s words
He was admitted to the United States in 1998 and became a lawful permanent resident in 2021, Judge Graber’s dissent says, citing the district court. In January 2024, after a conviction for aggravated assault and possession of a synthetic narcotic, the government moved to remove him to Egypt.
In 2025, an immigration judge ordered him removed to Egypt. But the judge found a clear probability that he’d be tortured there, and granted deferral of removal under the Convention Against Torture. The government didn’t appeal that decision, and it kept him detained.
NPR reported that the immigration judge’s order protected him from return to Egypt, “where he could be persecuted for his sexuality.” The court’s order doesn’t discuss the reasons for his protection.
“He does not contest his removability,” Judge Graber wrote. “Rather, he objects to the lack of due process afforded him with respect to the place of removal.” That’s the heart of this third-country deportation case. It isn’t about whether he can be deported, but whether the government can choose where without letting him be heard.
04
What the Convention Against Torture protects
The Convention Against Torture is a treaty the United States Senate ratified, and federal regulations apply it in immigration court. Under those rules, torture means “severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental,” inflicted on purpose by, or with the consent or acquiescence of, a public official, according to 8 CFR 1208.18.
When an immigration judge finds a person more likely than not to be tortured in a country, the person is entitled to protection from being sent there, says 8 CFR 1208.16. That protection takes one of two forms, withholding of removal or deferral of removal. People barred from withholding, such as someone convicted of what the law calls a “particularly serious crime,” get deferral instead.
Deferral is the thinner shield. It applies only to the country where torture is likely, which leaves room for a third-country deportation. Under 8 CFR 1208.17, the judge must tell the person they “may be removed at any time to another country where he or she is not likely to be tortured.”
05
What third-country deportation means
A third-country deportation sends a person to a country that isn’t their own and isn’t the one named in their removal order. Federal rules allow it. The torture rules don’t stop the government from removing a person “to a third country other than the country to which removal has been withheld or deferred,” section 1208.16 says.
So who decides that the new country is safe, and does the person get to say otherwise before the plane leaves? That’s the question A.M.A.S. raised, and it’s the question in every third-country deportation.
The government has paid Equatorial Guinea “to take deportees like him,” Judge Graber wrote. NPR reported that the administration “has made deals with over 30 countries to deport migrants to places where they have no ties or connections.” Third-country deportation is no longer rare. Reversing one is.
06
April 28: a third-country deportation he couldn’t question
On April 28, 2026, the government removed A.M.A.S. to Equatorial Guinea, a country in central Africa where, NPR reported, he has no ties. He was told where he was going shortly before the flight, the dissent says.
When he asked for a reasonable-fear interview, “he was told it was too late, and he was carried onto the plane,” Judge Graber wrote, drawing on the district court’s findings. “Plaintiff had no opportunity to challenge the choice to send him to that country.”
That’s what makes this third-country deportation different from a removal to Egypt. An immigration judge heard his fear of Egypt and agreed. When he asked to be heard about Equatorial Guinea, he was told it was too late.
07
What the record says happened in Equatorial Guinea
What followed his third-country deportation comes from the district court’s findings as Judge Graber’s dissent recounts them, and from NPR’s reporting on court filings.
Equatorial Guinean officials held him with other deportees under armed guard at a decommissioned hotel from April to September 2026, the record says. The deportees faced beatings and death threats. Officials also threatened to send deportees back to the countries they’d been protected from, and did that to a group of Ethiopian citizens, the dissent says.
In August, he told his lawyer that he and other detainees had been assaulted at gunpoint for speaking to the press. On September 5, his lawyer received a video showing officers aiming guns at him. On September 11, she learned he’d been arrested and was being held incommunicado. As of September 15, she didn’t know where he was.
The district court called the central facts unrebutted. He has been “held under armed guard; threatened at gunpoint; and arrested, beaten, and held incommunicado,” Judge John Hinderaker wrote in his October 6 order, as NPR quoted it.
08
The district court found a due process violation
A.M.A.S. sued on September 15. He claimed his removal violated his Fifth Amendment right to procedural due process and was unlawful under the Administrative Procedure Act. On October 6, Judge Hinderaker of the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona ruled on the constitutional claim alone.
He held that removing A.M.A.S. “without notice of the country of removal and a meaningful opportunity to raise a country-specific fear-based claim” violated due process, the dissent says. He ordered the government to facilitate his return so he could dispute where he’d be sent. In the weeks after, the court issued “increasingly specific orders,” the dissent says.
On Friday, October 9, the government said in a filing that it was “beginning the process to facilitate” his return, NPR reported. NPR called it “a rare case of the government working to reverse a third-country deportation.” DHS told NPR it would comply with lawful court orders and that he’d continue to receive due process, but “he will not remain in the U.S.”
09
Why the government asked for a stay
The government appealed the third-country deportation ruling. DHS filed an emergency request with the Ninth Circuit in October, the Arizona Daily Star reported. A motions panel issued a temporary administrative stay and sent the request for a stay pending appeal to the merits panel, the dissent says.
The Star also reported that a DHS-contracted plane landed in Equatorial Guinea in October and left without him. “Defendants must address this discrepancy,” Judge Hinderaker wrote, after the landing appeared to contradict a government declaration.
In its stay motion, the government leaned on the Supreme Court. It argued that the justices’ September stay in a class-action third-country deportation case, DHS v. D.V.D., “squarely controls” this one, Judge Graber wrote. It also argued that a class action and an earlier judgment bar his case, and that it may remove a person to any country without notice or a fear interview.
10
What Judge Graber’s dissent said
“Because the government has failed to meet the standards that we must apply to a motion for a stay pending appeal, I dissent,” she wrote. A stay pending appeal is an “extraordinary remedy,” she noted, quoting her court’s precedent.
She began with irreparable harm to the government, which she called dispositive. “The district court’s order requires the government to facilitate the return of a single individual from a single country,” she wrote. “There is no possible irreparable harm here. In my view, it is not even a close call.”
She rejected the government’s comparison, writing that “the government’s equivalence of this case and D.V.D. strains credulity.” That case, she wrote, in essence ended a whole third-country deportation program. This one asks for one passenger’s return.
She found no strong showing that the government would win on any of its five arguments. And on the balance of harms, she wrote that the government’s interests “pale in comparison to the benefit of removing Plaintiff from a gravely dangerous and torturous situation.”
11
Where the dissent agreed with the government
Judge Graber didn’t dissent in full. She wrote that the district court’s first order “appears to have applied Abrego Garcia faithfully,” but that “the government is likely correct that the court’s later orders overstepped, micromanaging the government’s efforts.”
So she’d have paused those later orders. “I would grant a stay only to the extent that the district court’s orders exceed the remedy described in Abrego Garcia,” she wrote. The government asked instead for “a full stay of all aspects of all orders issued by the district court,” and the majority granted its motion.
12
The remedy the Supreme Court approved in 2025
On April 10, 2025, the Supreme Court ruled in Noem v. Abrego Garcia. The government had acknowledged that removing Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia to El Salvador was illegal. The Court said the lower court’s order properly required the government to facilitate his release from custody there.
The Court also told the lower court to clarify its order “with due regard for the deference owed to the Executive Branch in the conduct of foreign affairs.” That’s the line Judge Graber drew in this third-country deportation appeal. Facilitating a return is allowed. Micromanaging the government’s foreign affairs isn’t.
13
How DHS v. D.V.D. shapes third-country deportation
DHS v. D.V.D. is a class action from a federal district court over DHS guidance that allows third-country deportation when a person can’t be sent home, Judge Graber explained. On June 23, 2025, the Supreme Court stayed a preliminary injunction in that case. Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson, dissented: “In matters of life and death, it is best to proceed with caution.”
On February 25, 2026, the district court there set the guidance aside, and the First Circuit later affirmed. On September 29, 2026, the Supreme Court stayed that judgment and took the case, then set it for argument on December 9, its docket shows. Justices Sotomayor, Kagan and Jackson would have denied the stay.
The justices told the parties to argue whether the district court had jurisdiction, whether it could grant classwide relief, and whether the guidance is lawful under the immigration statute, the Due Process Clause and the torture convention’s rules. Judge Graber wrote that the stay’s lesson for A.M.A.S. is “vague at best,” because his is one person’s due process claim, not a challenge to the guidance.
14
What the stay changes, and what it doesn’t
The stay means DHS doesn’t have to facilitate the return of A.M.A.S. while its appeal is pending. He stays in Equatorial Guinea, where, Judge Graber wrote, his “continued sojourn” has caused “considerable personal harm” and likely will continue to.
The stay doesn’t decide the appeal. It doesn’t reverse the district court’s finding that his third-country deportation violated due process. And it doesn’t touch his protection from removal to Egypt, which the government never appealed.
A stay decides where he waits, not how the appeal ends. For a man in his position, the waiting is the danger.
15
A timeline of the third-country deportation case
These dates come from the Ninth Circuit’s order, the Supreme Court’s records and NPR:
- 1998: A.M.A.S. is admitted to the United States.
- 2021: He becomes a lawful permanent resident.
- January 2024: After a conviction, the government seeks his removal to Egypt.
- 2025: An immigration judge orders him removed to Egypt but defers removal under the Convention Against Torture.
- June 23, 2025: The Supreme Court stays a preliminary injunction in DHS v. D.V.D.
- February 25, 2026: A federal court in Massachusetts sets aside DHS’s third-country deportation guidance.
- April 28, 2026: DHS removes A.M.A.S. to Equatorial Guinea.
- September 15, 2026: He sues in federal court in Arizona.
- September 29, 2026: The Supreme Court stays the D.V.D. judgment and agrees to hear the case.
- October 6, 2026: Judge Hinderaker finds a due process violation and orders DHS to facilitate his return.
- October 9, 2026: The government says it’s beginning the process to facilitate his return.
- November 20, 2026: The Ninth Circuit grants a stay pending appeal, with Judge Graber dissenting in large part.
- December 9, 2026: The Supreme Court hears DHS v. D.V.D.
16
Read the order yourself
The Ninth Circuit published the 17-page order in A.M.A.S. v. Mullin on November 20, with Judge Graber’s dissent. The dissent lays out the record in this third-country deportation case plainly, in the court’s own words.
17
What we don’t know yet
The majority’s reasons are unknown. The order sets no date to argue or decide the appeal.
His condition today isn’t in the order. In October, the government said in sworn filings that officials were still trying to locate him, the Arizona Daily Star reported. Bloom couldn’t open the district court’s opinion in this third-country deportation case, so its words appear here as the dissent and NPR quote them.
18
What you can do
If you or someone you love has a removal order and protection under the Convention Against Torture, these steps can help you prepare for a possible third-country deportation:
- Keep copies of the immigration judge’s decision where a lawyer and family can reach them.
- Know that deferral covers one country. The rules allow removal elsewhere, so ask a lawyer now what you’d say if DHS named a new country.
- Write down a lawyer’s phone number on paper, not only in a phone.
- Find free legal help. The Justice Department’s List of Pro Bono Legal Service Providers names nonprofits and attorneys who’ve committed to “at least 50 hours per year of pro bono legal services” before their immigration court.
- Follow the cases: Ninth Circuit No. 26-6950, and the Supreme Court’s December 9 argument in DHS v. D.V.D.
19
What happens next
The government’s appeal of the third-country deportation ruling continues in the Ninth Circuit. Unless a court changes the stay, the government doesn’t have to bring A.M.A.S. back while the appeal is decided.
The Supreme Court’s ruling in D.V.D. could bear on his case. The Court “might agree with the government, but it might not,” Judge Graber wrote. Bloom will report each ruling on third-country deportation as it comes.
Bloom has followed changes to immigration court rules, including the Justice Department’s 10-day appeal deadline. And the Ninth Circuit’s power to pause a ruling while an appeal runs shaped the Venezuelan TPS case this week.
20
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reads the orders so you don’t have to guess what they say. We’ll follow A.M.A.S. v. Mullin, DHS v. D.V.D. and every third-country deportation case that reaches the courts.
I believe due process isn’t a courtesy the government extends to people it favors. It’s the promise that no one is sent into danger without being heard first, and it belongs to every person the government holds in its hands, including people with a criminal record.
If this story stirs fear for you or someone you love, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading court records like this one, and a one-time gift helps too.
21
Frequently Asked Questions
It granted the government’s motion to stay a district court order that required DHS to facilitate the return of A.M.A.S. from Equatorial Guinea after his third-country deportation. The stay lasts while the government’s appeal is pending.
It’s a removal to a country that isn’t the person’s own and isn’t the country named in their removal order. Federal rules allow it, even for people protected from removal to their home country.
In 2025, an immigration judge found a clear probability that he’d be tortured in Egypt and deferred his removal there under the Convention Against Torture. The government didn’t appeal.
No. The unsigned order says only that the four factors from the Supreme Court’s 2009 case “support the issuance of a stay.”
She wrote that the government hadn’t met the standard for a stay and showed no irreparable harm. She’d have paused only the district court’s later orders that went beyond the remedy the Supreme Court approved in Abrego Garcia.
No. The government’s appeal continues, and the stay doesn’t reverse the district court’s finding of a due process violation.
The government argued that the Supreme Court’s September 29 stay in that third-country deportation case controls this one. The Court hears D.V.D. on December 9.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Arizona Legislature · 20 November 2026Survivors Ask Supreme Court: Who Decides What Clergy Must Report?
Arizona Legislature · 14 November 2026Appeals Court Revives ADA Challenge to Sedona’s Car-Sleeping Ban
Nevada Legislature · 21 November 2026Nevada Plastics Maker to Pay $250,602 Over Sexual Harassment Charges