
Newsroom·Colorado Legislature·News
Supreme Court Sends Transgender Jail Case Back to the Tenth Circuit
On Nov. 9 the justices vacated a ruling that let a trans woman challenge a Colorado jail's housing policy. What the order does, what it doesn't, and what families can do.
This article discusses sexual abuse. It contains no graphic detail. Support: RAINN 800-656-4673; child abuse in Oregon 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233).
The Supreme Court on Monday threw out a federal appeals ruling that had let a transgender woman’s lawsuit against a Colorado county jail move forward, and told the lower court to take another look. The case, Roybal v. Griffith, asks how the Constitution treats jails that house transgender inmates by the sex they were assigned at birth. In a two-sentence entry on its November 9 order list, the Court sent the case back to the Denver-based Tenth Circuit “for further consideration in light of” two of its own recent transgender rulings.
No justice wrote separately, and none noted a dissent. The rulings the order names are Skrmetti, the 2025 decision that upheld state restrictions on gender-affirming medical care for minors, and B.P.J., the 2026 decision that upheld state bans on transgender athletes on girls’ and women’s teams. The Justice Department had told the justices that those rulings give “clear guidance” that the jail’s housing policy can’t be challenged. For transgender inmates and the people who love them, Monday’s order doesn’t settle that question. It hands it back to the court that answered it in 2025.
01
What the Supreme Court did on November 9

The entry appears on the Court’s order list for November 9, among its summary dispositions, as docket No. 25-442. El Paso County’s sheriff had asked the justices to review the Tenth Circuit’s 2025 decision. The Court’s entry does three things at once:
- It grants the sheriff’s petition for review.
- It vacates the Tenth Circuit’s judgment.
- It remands the case to the Tenth Circuit “for further consideration in light of” the B.P.J. and Skrmetti decisions.
The order cites both precedents in full: West Virginia v. B.P.J., 609 U.S. 958 (2026), and United States v. Skrmetti, 605 U.S. 495 (2025).
Nothing in the entry says the Tenth Circuit got the law wrong, and nothing in it says the jail’s policy is lawful. It sets no rule for housing transgender inmates anywhere. What it does is wipe out the appeals court’s judgment as a whole, so every claim that judgment revived goes back to the same court to be decided again.
USA Today reports that the Justice Department urged exactly this outcome, because the Tenth Circuit ruled before the Supreme Court decided its two recent transgender cases. The sheriff argued that prison administrators are “subject to inconsistent mandates on how to classify and house transgender inmates.”
02
A pretrial detainee, a men’s unit and a lawsuit
The case began in 2020 at the El Paso County jail. Darlene Griffith, a transgender woman, was held there before trial, according to the ACLU of Colorado, which filed a friend-of-the-court brief in the case in 2023. She challenged her assignment to the men’s unit and the jail’s refusal of women’s commissary items, arguing that the jail classified her by the sex she was assigned at birth. USA Today reports that she has lived openly as a woman for more than 20 years.
Her lawsuit also alleges harm that the housing decision made possible. She alleges that she was sexually assaulted by a male inmate, and that male deputies searched her frequently. Those are allegations. The case is still at its earliest stage, where the question is whether a complaint may go forward, not whether every claim in it is true.
Bloom won’t add to what the public record says; those details belong to her. The legal questions underneath them are the ones the courts are deciding: how closely judges should examine a jail’s decision to house transgender inmates by birth sex, and what limits the Constitution places on cross-gender searches.
03
What the Tenth Circuit decided in 2025

On February 19, 2025, a three-judge panel of the Tenth Circuit revived part of the lawsuit. The panel was Judges Tymkovich, Ebel and Rossman. Judge Rossman wrote the majority opinion, and one member of the panel dissented.
The district court had dismissed the complaint. It applied rational-basis review to the equal-protection claim, relying on an earlier Tenth Circuit case, Brown v. Zavaras.
The majority disagreed. It held that the jail’s housing and commissary policies classify people by sex, so they must be reviewed under intermediate scrutiny rather than rational basis. Relying on Fowler v. Stitt and Bostock, it reasoned that treating transgender women differently from cisgender women is sex discrimination.
The majority’s conclusion was direct: “Ms. Griffith has stated a plausible Equal Protection claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983.” For transgender inmates, that was the opinion’s central move. It treated a jail’s housing policy as a sex classification that the jail must justify under intermediate scrutiny.
The panel also left questions open on purpose. “We need not decide whether any other policies trigger heightened scrutiny,” the majority wrote. It did not decide whether transgender status is itself a quasi-suspect class, as the ACLU of Colorado had urged, and it declined to treat Turner v. Safley as controlling, noting that the parties hadn’t briefed it.
The dissent would have affirmed the dismissal in full. As the majority described it, the dissent argued that Turner “compels our application of rational basis review to sex-based classifications in prisons and jails.”
On the remaining claims, the panel drew lines. It reinstated the equal-protection claim against the sheriff in his official capacity, but held that the individual officers had qualified immunity because the law was not clearly established. It affirmed the dismissal of a conditions-of-confinement claim, finding no plausible allegation of deliberate indifference. And on the searches, the majority concluded that “we must reinstate the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment cross-gender search claims.”
Those search claims ran against the sheriff and one deputy, and a separate claim that the same deputy’s search was abusive was allowed to proceed. The majority weighed how intrusive each search was against the jail’s reason for it.
04
Skrmetti and B.P.J.: the two rulings the order names
In United States v. Skrmetti, decided in 2025, the Supreme Court upheld state restrictions on gender-affirming medical care for minors, as JURIST summarized that precedent when the Court decided its 2026 transgender athletes cases.
Those cases came down on June 30, 2026, when the Court decided West Virginia v. B.P.J. together with Little v. Hecox. By a vote of six to three, in an opinion by Justice Kavanaugh, it held that neither Title IX nor the Equal Protection Clause requires schools to let transgender athletes compete on girls’ and women’s teams. It reversed the Fourth and Ninth Circuits and sent both cases back.
The majority called “safety and competitive fairness” important interests that the state laws served. Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson, dissented in part, arguing that the lower courts should first have resolved disputed questions of fact.
Legal Voice notes that the decision “does not require every state to adopt similar laws,” and that the ruling is confined to school sports. Neither precedent, in other words, was about jails.
So why would decisions about sports teams and medical care reach transgender inmates in a county jail? USA Today reports the Justice Department’s answer: under “clear guidance” from those rulings, the jail’s housing policy can’t be challenged. Its lawyers wrote that prisons, like sports and medicine, are an area where “everyone agrees” some sex-based classifications are permitted.
That’s an argument, not a holding. But the order asks the Tenth Circuit to measure its 2025 reasoning, and the protection it gave transgender inmates, against both precedents, and both upheld the state laws in question.
05
What changes for transgender inmates now
The order doesn’t set a rule for housing transgender inmates, and it doesn’t approve or forbid any jail’s policy. What it changes is the status of this case. The 2025 judgment that let Ms. Griffith’s equal-protection and search claims go forward is gone, and the Tenth Circuit must take those claims up again.
The possible answers are already on the table. The 2025 majority held that this jail’s sex-based housing and commissary policies must survive intermediate scrutiny. The dissent said Turner requires rational-basis review in prisons and jails. The Justice Department says the newer rulings mean the housing policy can’t be challenged at all.
For transgender inmates, the difference between those answers is the difference between a policy the jail must justify and a policy the courts will largely defer to. The order doesn’t choose between them. It tells the court that chose in 2025 to choose again, with Skrmetti and B.P.J. in front of it.
The cross-gender searches deserve their own attention. The 2025 majority found the search claims against the sheriff and one deputy plausible, and those claims now return to the Tenth Circuit with everything else in the vacated judgment. Cross-gender searches are where a housing policy stops being abstract for transgender inmates, and in this case that question is open again.
06
Behind the caption, a person
Strip away the docket number and the doctrine, and this case is about a woman who asked to be housed with other women and was told no. She says what followed caused her real harm. Courts will decide what the Constitution required of the jail. Nobody needs a court to say that her safety mattered.
Transgender inmates are easy to forget. They’re held out of sight, under rules most people never read, in systems built around someone else’s idea of who they are. An order that sends their case back for another look is, at the very least, a reason for the rest of us to look too.
07
Federal prisons are a separate fight
The county jail case isn’t the only one. USA Today reports that President Trump directed the federal Bureau of Prisons last year to house inmates by biological sex, and that incarcerated transgender women are challenging that order. A separate dispute over medical care for transgender inmates reached the Supreme Court this fall.
In Trump v. Kingdom, the Bureau of Prisons asked the justices to pause a lower-court order blocking a February 2026 policy that would bar transgender inmates from hormone therapy and “social accommodations.” On October 21, 2026, in an unsigned one-sentence order, the Court declined, SCOTUSblog reported. Justices Alito and Thomas indicated that they would have granted the request.
That left in place an August 26, 2026, order by Senior U.S. District Judge Royce Lamberth barring the bureau from putting the policy into effect. The litigation continues. For transgender inmates in federal custody, the rules on care and the rules on housing are moving through the courts on separate tracks.
08
What state law can still do
A ruling about what the federal Constitution permits isn’t the last word on what a state may protect. Legal Voice’s guide to the sports decision makes that point for Washington. There, it notes, the Washington Law Against Discrimination still bars discrimination based on gender identity and gender expression in health care, housing and employment.
That guide is about schools, health care, housing and employment, not jails, so families shouldn’t read it as a promise about custody. But it’s a reminder that how transgender inmates are treated isn’t decided in federal court alone. State lawmakers, state courts and county sheriffs make choices of their own about transgender inmates.
Bloom is based in Oregon. A Supreme Court order in a Colorado case doesn’t change Oregon law. If someone you love is held in an Oregon jail or prison, ask the facility in writing for its policy on housing and searching transgender people, and keep the answer.
09
What families and advocates can do

Few readers will ever stand in the Tenth Circuit’s courtroom. But a few steps are within reach of almost anyone who loves one of the transgender inmates held in a jail or prison today.
- Write down every housing request and every answer, with dates and the names of the staff involved.
- Ask the facility, in writing, for its policy on housing and searching transgender inmates, and keep a copy.
- Put any concern about a search or a housing decision in writing to the facility, and keep a copy of what you send.
- Contact a civil-rights organization or a lawyer. The ACLU of Colorado filed a brief in this very case.
- If someone has been sexually assaulted, RAINN answers at 800-656-4673.
None of this guarantees an outcome. All of it builds a record, and a record is what any lawyer will ask for first.
If you’re carrying this news for someone behind bars, you don’t have to carry it alone. Trans Lifeline answers at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, and the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by call or text at 988. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more help.
10
What Bloom is doing
Bloom’s newsroom will follow Roybal v. Griffith back to the Tenth Circuit, report what the court decides for transgender inmates, and link the filings so you can read them yourself. You’ll find that coverage in the Trans Advocacy newsroom.
We explained the B.P.J. decision when Washington voters passed Initiative 638, and we wrote a pastoral guide to the passport ruling when another Supreme Court decision reached trans Americans’ daily lives. If your family is weighing whether to stay where you are, start with Bloom’s Trans Relocation page.
And if this story touches something heavy in you today, fear for someone in custody or grief over harm already done, Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
11
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 9, 2026, the Court granted the El Paso County sheriff’s petition, vacated the Tenth Circuit’s 2025 judgment and sent the case back for further consideration in light of the B.P.J. and Skrmetti decisions. No justice wrote separately or noted a dissent.
No. The order doesn’t decide that question or approve any jail’s policy. It tells the Tenth Circuit to decide the case again in light of the Court’s recent transgender rulings.
In February 2025, a divided panel held that the jail’s housing and commissary policies classify by sex and must face intermediate scrutiny. It also let cross-gender search claims against the sheriff and one deputy go forward. The order vacates that judgment.
Skrmetti, decided in 2025, upheld state restrictions on gender-affirming medical care for minors. B.P.J., decided on June 30, 2026, held that states may bar transgender athletes from girls’ and women’s teams.
The Justice Department argued that those rulings give “clear guidance” that the jail’s housing policy can’t be challenged. The Tenth Circuit must now decide whether that is right for this case.
Not directly. Federal prison policies are the subject of separate lawsuits, and in October 2026 the Supreme Court declined to let the Bureau of Prisons enforce a policy barring transgender inmates from hormone therapy while one of those cases continues.
Keep written records of every housing request and answer, ask the facility in writing for its policy on housing and cross-gender searches, and contact a civil-rights organization or a lawyer. If someone has been sexually assaulted, RAINN answers at 800-656-4673.
Trans Lifeline answers at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline by call or text at 988, and RAINN at 800-656-4673. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Colorado Legislature · 17 November 2026Supreme Court Turns Away Challenge to Colorado’s Misgendering Rules
Trans advocacy · 11 November 2026Jeffco Lawsuit Paused: What the Federal Promise Covers, and Doesn’t
Trans advocacy · 11 November 2026DOJ Official Behind Trans Care Subpoenas Resigns: What Stays