
Newsroom·Washington Legislature·News
Washingtonβs Attorney General Hires an Outside Firm to Defend I-638
Washington Attorney General Nick Brown appointed the firm Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner to defend I-638, the new ban on trans girls in girls' school sports, three weeks before it takes effect.
I-638 is set to take effect on December 3, in the middle of a school sports season.
Washington Attorney General Nick Brown said on Thursday, November 12, that his office will not defend I-638 itself and has appointed an outside law firm, Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, to defend I-638 on behalf of the state. I-638 is the voter-approved initiative that bars transgender girls from girls’ school sports and is set to take effect on December 3.
Brown cited potential conflicts of interest. The decision comes three days after the ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice and Pacifica Law Group sued to block the law in King County Superior Court. It means a private national firm, not the state’s own lawyers, will now defend I-638 in the case that decides whether trans girls can keep playing this winter.
Following this story: Washingtonβs Initiative 638. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.
-
Seattle School Board Clears the Way for Legal Action Over I-638
-
Washington’s Attorney General Hires an Outside Firm to Defend I-638
-
Jeffco Lawsuit Paused: What the Federal Promise Covers, and Doesn’t
-
Parents, Teachers and TransFamilies Sue to Block Washington’s I-638
-
Five States Elect Their First Trans Lawmakers, Washington Among Them
-
Initiative 638 Passes in Washington: What It Does and What Comes Next
01
What Attorney General Nick Brown decided
In a news release on November 12, Brown said: “I have therefore decided to appoint an outside law firm, Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner.” The firm will act as a Special Assistant Attorney General, the release says, a step the office describes as common when it can’t handle a case itself because of a conflict, a need for specialized expertise, or its workload.
Brown framed the choice to have someone else defend I-638 as a way to keep two duties apart. “My personal views do not dictate what laws get defended or the strength of that defense,” he said. He added that he is “confident that this approach will best ensure that I-638 is appropriately defended.”
The release doesn’t name the lawyers at the firm, the terms of the appointment or what it will cost. It doesn’t say which of the three reasons applies here. KUOW reports that Brown said his office is declining to defend I-638 because of potential conflicts of interest.
Two days earlier, KUOW had reported that the Attorney General’s Office would defend I-638. Thursday’s announcement changes who stands up for the law in court, though not the state’s obligation to have it defended.
02
Why the office stepped aside
The office’s own record explains the conflict question. Brown’s release says his office has spent the last two years defending transgender Washingtonians, has won cases against the federal government over access to healthcare, and has defended state laws that give transgender people equal protection. “We will not and cannot abandon that work,” he said.
KUOW reports that Brown said appointing outside counsel lets his office keep its focus on equal protection for transgender people. The tension is easy to see: an office can’t easily argue for trans students in one courtroom while it is asked to defend I-638 against trans students in another.
Critics saw a different problem. KUOW reports that some argued the office has opposed trans athlete bans in other settings, including by joining out-of-state lawsuits, and so could not be trusted to defend I-638 with full force. Critics also noted that Brown’s former firm, Pacifica Law Group, is on the plaintiffs’ legal team.
The office’s history on this exact question is public. On October 31, 2025, Brown led a coalition of 12 other attorneys general, Oregon’s among them, in a brief to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit that supported Minnesota’s policy letting transgender youth play on teams that match their gender identity. “I believe strongly in protecting the rights of all Washington kidsβincluding transgender youth,” he said then.
An office that argued that position a year ago would now be asked to defend I-638, which takes the opposite approach. That is the conflict of interest in plain terms, and it is the strongest argument for handing the job to someone else.
An outside law firm can make sense to both sides for that reason. A conflict of interest doesn’t have to mean bad faith. It means a lawyer’s other loyalties could reasonably be questioned, and the fix is to hand the case to someone without them.
The release also acknowledges the vote. Brown said voters changed Washington’s approach to school sports, and that many other state laws still protect transgender people.
03
The lawsuit the firm will answer
The firm’s first task is a lawsuit already moving fast. KUOW reports that the ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice and Pacifica Law Group filed it on the night of Monday, November 9, against the state, in King County Superior Court.
The plaintiffs include five families with daughters who play school sports, two of whom are trans girls. The Washington Education Association, the state’s largest teachers union, and TransFamilies, a nonprofit that supports families of transgender children, are also plaintiffs. KUOW reports that seven parents of trans and cisgender girls ages 11 to 17 in Seattle Public Schools are among the plaintiffs and are not named.
The suit argues that I-638 and its sex verification process are discriminatory, violate the Washington state Constitution and violate students’ right to privacy. It asks King County Superior Court to act quickly and block enforcement before December 3.
The suit also makes a practical argument. Students without a consistent health care provider could face costly or unnecessary lab tests or exams, it says, and the December 3 start date would force hurried medical appointments in the middle of a season. The teachers union says its members would have to carry out and explain the verification rules.
Adrien Leavitt, a staff attorney at the ACLU of Washington, argues that I-638 would amend Washington’s anti-discrimination law, which includes gender identity and expression, without saying so in its text, KUOW reported on November 10. That argument is the one the outside firm will most likely have to meet head-on to defend I-638.
04
Four claims the firm must answer to defend I-638
The complaint filed in King County Superior Court names the State of Washington as the only defendant. The plaintiffs are listed as Doe families on behalf of their children, TransFamilies and the Washington Education Association. To defend I-638, the firm will have to answer four claims under the Washington Constitution.
- Privacy, Article I, Section 7. The complaint quotes the clause directly: “No person shall be disturbed in his private affairs, or his home invaded, without authority of law.”
- Equal rights, Article XXXI. The plaintiffs claim the initiative violates Washington’s Equal Rights Amendment.
- Education, Article IX, Section 1. The plaintiffs claim the initiative violates the right to education in Washington’s Constitution.
- Amendment rule, Article II, Section 37. The plaintiffs argue I-638 amends the Washington Law Against Discrimination, the state’s equal educational opportunity law and a parental rights statute without setting out the changes, as the constitution requires.
The plaintiffs ask for a preliminary injunction before the December 3 effective date, a permanent injunction after that, a declaration that the initiative is unconstitutional, and their attorneys’ fees and costs.
The complaint’s summary of the stakes is blunt: “The Initiative requires every girl to prove her sex before participating in girls’ sports.” It also alleges: “The Initiative will forcibly out transgender girls.” Those are the plaintiffs’ allegations, and the firm hired to defend I-638 will contest them.
05
How the verification would work
The complaint describes the process in detail. Any student who joins a girls’ team must submit verification of sex from her own health care provider, who signs a consent form or statement. The verification must rest on one or more of three criteria: reproductive characteristics, genetic makeup, or naturally produced testosterone levels. The complaint says that could mean a physical exam, genetic testing or blood testing.
According to the complaint, the medical eligibility form is uploaded to a school district web portal. Boys’ teams have no comparable requirement, so the burden falls only on girls. The plaintiffs allege that the process would expose students’ transgender or intersex status to classmates, coaches and school staff.
Proponents read the same process differently, as the section below explains. But anyone who will defend I-638 in court will have to explain why this verification design survives Washington’s privacy clause.
06
What I-638 requires, and when
I-638 bans transgender girls from girls’ K-12 school sports in Washington. KUOW reported on November 10 that the measure was set to pass with 56% of the vote in the November 3 election, and on November 12 that voters had approved it.
The initiative’s sex verification process is at the center of the case. KUOW reports that a girl would have to obtain a medical exam, a hormone test or a chromosome test to verify her sex at birth before joining a girls’ team. That requirement applies to every girl who wants to play, not only to trans girls.
Washington has let students play on teams that match their gender identity for nearly 20 years, KUOW reports. I-638 is set to take effect on December 3.
The Washington Interscholastic Activities Association, which runs school sports, will decide how to bring its rules in line with the law. KUOW reports that the WIAA says it will follow state law and is prepared to make “necessary changes” by December 3.
The lawsuit adds one more piece of history. It says the Attorney General’s Civil Rights Division reviewed a similar WIAA proposal last spring and concluded it would violate state law, KUOW reports. The WIAA didn’t adopt that proposal.
07
The proponents’ case
Fairness requires saying what I-638’s backers argue. The initiative says its aim is to preserve the integrity and fairness of women’s interscholastic sports, KUOW reports. The outlet also notes that research on school-aged athletes is inconclusive.
Darren Littell, executive director of Let’s Go Washington, which backed the measure, said the opponents’ privacy claims rest on “false assumptions.” He told KUOW that doctors already know whether a child is transgender, and that schools could be told only whether a student is eligible for girls’ sports, without any other private information.
Supporters of the measure also have a stake in who will defend I-638. Voters approved it, and a ballot measure’s backers usually want the strongest possible defense in court. The appointment of an outside law firm answers that concern on paper. Whether it answers it in practice will show in the briefs the firm files in the coming weeks.
For supporters, the question now is whether an outside law firm will defend I-638 as hard as they expect. For opponents, the question is whether the law survives the privacy and constitutional claims at all.
Bloom reports both arguments because both will be in front of the judge. Bloom’s view is plain: a rule that makes every girl prove her sex before she can play costs trans girls the most, and asks something of every girl.
08
What happens before December 3
The calendar is tight for anyone trying to defend I-638 or block it. The plaintiffs want the court to block I-638 before December 3, three weeks from today. KUOW’s reporting doesn’t give a hearing date.
The firm appointed to defend I-638 now has to get up to speed on a case already filed, a law about to take effect and a state constitution that the plaintiffs say protects students’ privacy. Whatever King County Superior Court decides on emergency relief, an appeal is possible.
Meanwhile, the WIAA says it’s preparing the changes the law requires, whoever is chosen to defend I-638 and however the court rules on emergency relief. Schools may begin asking families about eligibility before a judge rules. If that happens, families will be making decisions in real time.
09
What trans students and families can do now
If you’re a trans student in Washington, or the parent of one, here’s where things stand tonight, as a new firm prepares to defend I-638. I-638 is not in effect yet. Its start date is December 3. A lawsuit asking the court to block it is pending, and the state’s defense is now in the hands of an outside law firm.
A few steps can help while lawyers on both sides prepare to argue about I-638:
- Keep playing and practicing. Nothing changes before December 3 unless a court or the WIAA says so.
- Read anything your school or the WIAA sends about eligibility, and keep copies.
- Don’t hand over medical records or agree to tests before you’ve talked to someone you trust about your rights.
- If you’re a coach or a teacher, ask your district how it plans to handle the verification forms, where they will be stored and who will be able to see them.
- Reach out to the ACLU of Washington or Legal Voice, two of the groups representing the plaintiffs, if you have questions about your child’s situation.
If your family is weighing whether to stay where you are, Bloom’s Trans Relocation page is a place to start. If this week is weighing on a trans young person you love, Trans Lifeline answers at 877-565-8860 and The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more.
10
What Bloom is doing
Bloom’s newsroom will follow the challenge to I-638, and the outside firm’s effort to defend I-638, through King County Superior Court and any appeal, and report each ruling with the filings linked so you can read them yourself. We first explained the measure when Initiative 638 passed, and covered the I-638 lawsuit the day it was filed.
You’ll find all of it in the Trans Advocacy newsroom. Bloom is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon, and Washington’s trans kids are our neighbors.
11
Frequently Asked Questions
Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, a national law firm that Attorney General Nick Brown appointed on November 12, 2026, as a Special Assistant Attorney General to defend I-638 on behalf of Washington state.
Brown cited potential conflicts of interest, KUOW reports. His office has spent two years defending transgender Washingtonians, and his former firm, Pacifica Law Group, represents the plaintiffs.
Yes. Brown said his personal views don’t dictate which laws get defended, and that the outside firm will defend I-638 on the state’s behalf.
It bars transgender girls from girls’ K-12 school sports in Washington and requires girls to verify their sex at birth through a medical exam, a hormone test or a chromosome test before joining a girls’ team.
December 3, 2026, unless a court blocks it first. The plaintiffs have asked King County Superior Court to act before that date.
Five families, including two with trans daughters, plus the Washington Education Association and TransFamilies, represented by the ACLU of Washington, Legal Voice and Pacifica Law Group.
Keep playing until the law’s start date, keep copies of anything the school or the WIAA sends, and talk to someone you trust before agreeing to any test or sharing medical records.
Four claims under the Washington Constitution: privacy under Article I, Section 7; the Equal Rights Amendment in Article XXXI; the right to education in Article IX, Section 1; and the amendment rule in Article II, Section 37.
Sovereignty over Servitude. πΈ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.


