
Newsroom·Washington Legislature·News
Seattle School Board Clears the Way for Legal Action Over I-638
The Seattle School Board voted unanimously to let Seattle Public Schools take legal action over Initiative 638, which bars trans girls from girls' school sports starting December 3.
The Seattle School Board voted unanimously on Monday, November 9, to let Seattle Public Schools take legal action over Initiative 638, the voter-approved law that bars trans girls from girls’ school sports. The law takes effect December 3. The board says the district can’t carry it out without breaking other state laws, and it wants a court to decide.
The resolution doesn’t say what kind of legal action the district will take, and it doesn’t stop the clock. But it makes Washington’s largest school district the first public school system to formally prepare for a courtroom fight over I-638. Here’s what the Seattle School Board approved, what the superintendent says comes next, and what families should know with less than three weeks to go.
Following this story: Washington’s Initiative 638. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.
-
Seattle School Board Clears the Way for Legal Action Over I-638
-
Washington’s Attorney General Hires an Outside Firm to Defend I-638
-
Jeffco Lawsuit Paused: What the Federal Promise Covers, and Doesn’t
-
Parents, Teachers and TransFamilies Sue to Block Washington’s I-638
-
Five States Elect Their First Trans Lawmakers, Washington Among Them
-
Initiative 638 Passes in Washington: What It Does and What Comes Next
01
What the Seattle School Board approved
At a special meeting, the Seattle School Board adopted Resolution No. 2026/27-11, which allows the district to hire legal counsel and take any legal action necessary to protect students and school interests, FOX 13 Seattle reported. The vote gave Superintendent Ben Shuldiner the authority to act, KUOW reported.
The resolution says I-638’s requirements apply only to girls’ athletics and could subject girls to scrutiny and privacy invasions that boys don’t face, FOX 13 reported. The Seattle School Board’s resolution also raises concerns about the legal, financial and administrative costs for public schools, KOMO News reported.
The Seattle School Board had already voted to oppose the initiative in September, KOMO reported. Monday’s resolution restated that position and reaffirmed the board’s commitment to schools that are “safe, inclusive, affirming, and supportive for all children,” according to district leaders.
02
Why the Seattle School Board says it can’t simply comply
Director Joe Mizrahi, a lead sponsor of the resolution, said Seattle School Board members swear an oath to uphold the U.S. Constitution and the laws that protect students from discrimination, KUOW reported.
“Right now, I don’t see how we can implement the requirements of Initiative 638 without violating those other laws and constitutional protections,” Mizrahi said, according to KUOW. “It raises serious questions about equal protection, student privacy, and whether we’re creating additional barriers for female student athletes to participate in school activities.”
“We can’t pick one new law to follow and disregard other laws,” he said. “When those laws potentially conflict, we actually have a system for resolving those conflicts, and that’s called the courts.”
KIRO 7 reported that Mizrahi put it this way: “We think that it conflicts with many, many other laws in the Washington books and possibly the Washington Constitution.” He told FOX 13 that if the district implemented I-638 as written, “we think it could set us for a lawsuit for violating those laws.”
Mizrahi also said the vote wasn’t a “moral judgement” on Seattle parents who voted for the initiative, KUOW reported. “In Washington state, we don’t have a pre-initiative process to say if something is a valid law or not,” he said. “People can vote for whatever they want, and then we have to figure out how to actually administer that.”
03
What the superintendent says comes next
Shuldiner spoke publicly about the Seattle School Board vote the next day. He said the district’s legal options include filing a lawsuit, writing an amicus brief, or holding legal conversations with litigants, including the ACLU, which has already sued over the measure, KOMO News reported on November 10.
“I firmly support the board’s action in giving me authority to take legal action,” Shuldiner said, according to KOMO. “I really believe what they are asking me to do is get clarity.”
He also said he respects the vote. “I very much believe in following the will of the people and the law,” Shuldiner said. “My job is to focus on all 50,000 of our children in creating a safe, warm and loving environment.”
The next step, he told FOX 13, is legal advice. “We need to now talk to the general counsel as well as outside counsel,” Shuldiner said.
04
What the resolution doesn’t do
The Seattle School Board’s vote is an authorization, not a lawsuit. The Seattle School Board resolution doesn’t specify what legal action Seattle Public Schools will take, KIRO 7 reported, and KOMO reported that no timeframe was given for that decision.
“We did not direct what type of legal action. I think that is left to, obviously, the folks who know the attorneys in the room,” board President Gina Topp said, according to KOMO.
Topp also acknowledged that the Seattle School Board resolution doesn’t stop I-638 from taking effect. “I don’t think that this stops the clock anyways, but I do think looking at some of the legal action that’s possible, hopefully we can maybe gain a little bit more time here,” she said, according to KIRO 7.
05
How the Seattle School Board got here
The vote didn’t come out of nowhere. The Seattle School Board unanimously adopted a resolution opposing I-638 in September, before voters decided, The Center Square reported. After the measure passed on November 3, the board scheduled a special meeting for the following Monday.
The agenda called for a closed-door session with legal counsel about potential litigation, followed by a vote in public, according to The Center Square. When the Seattle School Board’s vote came, the mostly quiet audience, some holding flags and signs supporting trans youth, applauded, KUOW reported. A smaller group of the measure’s supporters heckled board members as they left.
That split in the room mirrors the split in the state. I-638 won statewide, and Seattle’s school leaders opposed it from the start. The Seattle School Board is now trying to answer a question voters didn’t settle: how a school district follows one law without breaking others.
06
What supporters of I-638 say
Supporters of the initiative say it protects fairness and safety in girls’ sports, and several came to Monday’s meeting to oppose the Seattle School Board’s move.
“It’s very frustrating,” said Amy Sousa, who supported the measure, according to KIRO 7. “We fought really hard to stand up for fairness for our girls.” Sousa, who lives in Clark County, told KUOW that “35 out of 39 counties voted to pass this.”
Dawn Land, another supporter at the meeting, asked FOX 13: “Why are they not willing to support the will of the voters now?”
Hallie Herzberg, a spokesperson for Let’s Go Washington, the political committee that backed the measure, told KUOW the law is set to take effect on December 3 whether Seattle Public Schools “wants it to or not.” In a statement to The Center Square, Herzberg said districts that don’t follow the law after December 3 “will be in violation of the law.”
Bloom reports their position because readers deserve to know what both sides will tell a judge. Bloom’s own view is plain: a rule that makes every girl prove her sex before she can play costs trans girls the most, and asks something of every girl.
07
Where the court case stands
The Seattle School Board’s vote came the same day a separate challenge was filed. On November 9, the ACLU of Washington, along with a coalition of parents, educators and advocacy groups, sued in King County Superior Court to stop I-638 before it takes effect, The Columbian reported. Bloom covered the I-638 lawsuit the day it was filed.
On Thursday, November 12, Attorney General Nick Brown appointed an outside firm, Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner, to defend I-638 on behalf of the state, The Columbian reported. Bloom explained that decision in our report on who will defend I-638.
The Seattle School Board vote gives Seattle Public Schools a choice. It can file its own case, join the existing one with a brief, or work with the plaintiffs already in court. Shuldiner’s comments suggest the district hasn’t decided.
08
What I-638 requires
Washington voters approved I-638 on November 3 with about 56 percent of the vote statewide, The Columbian reported. It requires students who want to play on girls’ teams to verify their sex at birth, and boys aren’t subject to any similar requirement.
The verification would happen through the sports physical. According to the initiative’s text, as “part of the required routine sports physical examination, a health examination, consent form or other statement signed by the student’s personal healthcare provider must verify the student’s biological sex,” relying on reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup or testosterone levels, The Columbian reported.
Proponents argue that the measure doesn’t require or authorize the intrusive exams, genetic tests or blood tests that opponents warn about, according to The Columbian. Opponents say the text speaks for itself. That disagreement is part of what the courts will be asked to settle.
09
How many students are affected
The number of trans girls the law targets is small. There are an estimated 10 transgender student-athletes competing across the state each year, according to a spokesperson for the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association, The Columbian reported.
“However, we acknowledge that there are likely others we are not aware of,” WIAA spokesperson Sean Bessette said, according to The Columbian. The association doesn’t keep a definitive count, he said.
The verification rule reaches much further. Every girl who wants to play on a girls’ team would need a provider’s statement. That’s why the Seattle School Board framed its concern around all girls, not only trans girls, and why the lawsuit already filed in King County includes families of girls who aren’t trans.
10
The midseason problem
Some opponents say the timing alone will cause trouble. Terah Ebie, president of the Vancouver-based Queer Community Network, told The Columbian that thousands of girls are already in the middle of a season and have already turned in their sports physicals.
“The school districts are in a really precarious position where, in order to be in compliance with the law, are they going to pause the sports games statewide for all of these girls so that they can get cleared again?” Ebie said.
Ebie also said verification could be out of reach for students without consistent health coverage, The Columbian reported. And when The Columbian asked several local health care providers how verification would work in practice, they declined to comment.
11
Other districts are watching
Mizrahi said it’s likely “a lot” of other districts are looking to Seattle as the state’s largest district, KUOW reported. That makes the Seattle School Board’s next step a signal for districts across Washington. KOMO reported that board members said other districts could follow Seattle’s lead, though Seattle Public Schools is acting on its own for now.
Not every district sees it the same way. On the same night as the Seattle School Board vote, the Battle Ground School Board in Clark County was set to consider a parent’s resolution asking it to fully adopt I-638, The Center Square reported. The reports Bloom reviewed don’t say how that board acted.
A spokesperson for Evergreen Public Schools in Vancouver told The Columbian that districts expect to receive direction from the WIAA and the Office of Superintendent of Public Instruction.
12
What happens before December 3
I-638 takes effect December 3 unless a court puts it on hold or strikes it down. The plaintiffs in the King County case have asked for relief before that date. The Seattle School Board has given its superintendent authority to act, but the district hasn’t said when, or how.
In the meantime, the WIAA will decide how to bring public school sports rules in line with the law, KUOW reported. Families may start hearing from schools about eligibility before any judge rules.
13
What families can do now
If you’re a trans student in Washington, or the parent of one, I-638 isn’t in effect yet. Keep playing and practicing. Nothing changes before December 3 unless a court or the WIAA says so.
Read everything your school or the WIAA sends about eligibility and keep copies. Ask your athletic director, in writing, what the sports physical will require after December 3. Before any exam, ask your health care provider what the form will ask for, what they’ll record and who’ll see it.
If you’re the parent of any girl who plays school sports, the same steps apply to you. The verification rule doesn’t only reach trans girls.
If your school asks for new medical paperwork before December 3, it’s fair to ask why, and to ask what happens to the information afterward. Write down who told you what and when. If a coach or administrator pressures your child, a calm written question to the principal or district often gets a clearer answer than a hallway conversation.
14
What’s still unclear
It’s unclear what legal action Seattle Public Schools will take, or when. The superintendent has named three options, and the Seattle School Board hasn’t set a timeline.
It’s also unclear whether a King County judge will rule on emergency relief before December 3. The coverage Bloom reviewed doesn’t report a hearing date, and Bloom will report one as soon as it’s set. And it’s unclear how the WIAA will write its rules, or how quickly schools will start asking families for new paperwork.
15
What Bloom is doing
Bloom will follow I-638 through King County Superior Court, every move the Seattle School Board and other districts make, and the WIAA’s rules, and report each step with the sources linked so you can read them yourself.
If this week is heavy for your family, you’re not alone. Trans Lifeline is at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project is at 1-866-488-7386, and 988 is there by call or text. Bloom’s crisis support page lists more help.
Bloom’s reporting runs on people who give a little every month. Become a monthly supporter, or give once if that fits your life better.
16
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 9, 2026, the Seattle School Board unanimously adopted Resolution No. 2026/27-11, which lets Seattle Public Schools hire lawyers and take legal action over Initiative 638.
Not as of the reports Bloom reviewed. Superintendent Ben Shuldiner said the options include a lawsuit, an amicus brief or legal conversations with litigants, including the ACLU.
No. Board President Gina Topp said the resolution doesn’t stop the clock. I-638 takes effect December 3 unless a court puts it on hold.
Board members say I-638 conflicts with state laws on student privacy, equal access and discrimination, and possibly the Washington Constitution, and that the requirements fall only on girls.
It requires a health care provider to verify a student’s sex as part of the sports physical before she can play on a girls’ team. Boys face no similar requirement.
A WIAA spokesperson estimated about 10 trans student-athletes compete statewide each year, while acknowledging there are likely others the association isn’t aware of.
Keep playing, keep copies of anything your school sends, and ask in writing what the sports physical will require after December 3.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Washington Legislature · 12 November 2026Washington’s Attorney General Hires an Outside Firm to Defend I-638
Trans advocacy · 11 November 2026Jeffco Lawsuit Paused: What the Federal Promise Covers, and Doesn’t
Trans advocacy · 11 November 2026DOJ Official Behind Trans Care Subpoenas Resigns: What Stays