A bronze statue of service members raising an American flag at the end of a park path, illustrating the transgender military ban trial

NewsroomTrans advocacyNews

DOJ Asks Judge to Keep Hegseth’s Words Out of Trans Military Ban Trial

The Justice Department asked a federal judge on Friday to keep Pete Hegseth's own words about transgender people out of the January trial on the transgender military ban.

The Justice Department asked a federal judge on Friday, November 13, 2026, to keep Secretary Pete Hegseth‘s own words about transgender people from being used as proof that the transgender military ban was driven by animus. The request came in a stack of pretrial motions in Talbott v. United States, the case transgender service members brought against the transgender military ban in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia.

The government doesn’t deny the words are his. It argues they’re about a medical diagnosis, not about who trans people are. With a two-week bench trial set to begin January 4, 2027, before Judge Ana C. Reyes, what she lets into the record will shape the answer to the question underneath this whole case: whether the transgender military ban targets a condition, or targets people.

01

What the Justice Department asked Judge Reyes to exclude

The key filing is titled “Defendants’ Motion in Limine #2 to Exclude Certain Statements to Prove Animus.” A motion in limine asks a judge to rule before trial on what evidence may come in. This one targets two sets of words: language in Executive Order 14183, the January 27, 2025 order that launched the transgender military ban, and phrases Hegseth used in his book, The War on Warriors, and in speeches and social media posts.

From the executive order, the motion expects the service members to point to the words “honesty,” “humility,” “integrity” and “false gender identity.” From Hegseth, it names “trans lunacy,” “dudes in dresses” and a slur Bloom won’t print. The Justice Department argues all of it is irrelevant under Federal Rule of Evidence 401. Even if it’s relevant, the motion says, the danger of “unfair prejudice” and confusion substantially outweighs its value under Rule 403.

The filing doesn’t claim Hegseth never said these things. It argues that his statements are “all tied to the medical condition of gender dysphoria,” and that the executive order ties its language to the “medical, surgical, and mental health constraints on individuals with gender dysphoria.” A footnote says the service members oppose the motion.

It was one of several motions the government filed the same day in the transgender military ban case. Others ask Judge Reyes to read the transgender military ban only by its written terms and to bar testimony from two of the service members’ expert witnesses: a former Pentagon personnel chief and a retired Army major general. The Advocate reported on the filings Sunday.

02

Hegseth’s sworn answers, in his own words

Attached to the motion are Hegseth’s written answers to ten questions from the service members’ lawyers, called interrogatories. He signed them on October 28, 2026, declaring “under the penalty of perjury” that they’re true. He signed as Secretary of War; a footnote says that title is used “conterminously” with Secretary of Defense.

Asked whether transgender people should be allowed to serve, Hegseth answered that people with “a current diagnosis or history of, or exhibiting symptoms consistent with, gender dysphoria” shouldn’t serve without a waiver. “To the extent transgender people fall into that category, they should not be permitted to serve,” he wrote. In his own words, that’s the reach of the transgender military ban.

Asked which statements in Executive Order 14183 he personally disagrees with, he wrote one word: “None.” Asked whether testosterone can be given to service members without undermining readiness, he wrote “Yes,” for those with “a clinical diagnosis of testosterone deficiency.” The contrast sits plainly on the page, because the government’s other motion describes the policy as drawing lines around “cross-sex hormone therapy.”

Asked about “trans lunacy,” he wrote that he’s concerned “with any condition that impacts combat readiness and efficacy.” Asked about a May 6, 2025 post on X reading “No More Trans @ DoD,” he said it referred to the Supreme Court’s decision that day in Shilling v. Trump, which let the transgender military ban move forward. “I, like many others, occasionally use the term ‘trans’ as shorthand for individuals with gender dysphoria,” he wrote.

Asked why he believes being transgender is “weird,” Hegseth answered that “men cannot be women and women cannot be men,” and he called gender dysphoria “a mental health condition.” Asked why service members can’t use pronouns that differ from their birth sex, he wrote: “Sex is immutable and unchanging.”

If you’re a trans service member or veteran reading these words, they don’t land on paper alone. They land on careers, on families, on the oath you took. Sworn answers aren’t the last word on who you are. They’re evidence, and a judge will weigh them.

03

Why animus matters in the transgender military ban trial

In constitutional cases, animus means a desire to harm a group. When Judge Reyes first blocked the transgender military ban in March 2025, she called it “soaked in animus and dripping with pretext,” The Advocate reported. The government now wants Hegseth’s statements kept out of the transgender military ban trial as proof of that animus.

The motion rests on a demanding standard. Citing the 2018 travel-ban case, Trump v. Hawaii, it argues a court may infer animus only when a policy has no purpose but a “desire to harm.” If a legitimate reason can be found, it says, the court “must accept” the government’s independent justification.

It leans hardest on Mullin v. Doe, a 2026 Supreme Court decision about Haiti’s Temporary Protected Status. There, the Court held that heated statements by President Trump and then-Secretary Noem weren’t enough to show the decision was driven by race. The motion quotes the Court’s observation that political discourse by prominent public figures is now “increasingly couched in terms that would have scandalized the public just a short time ago.”

It also cites a September 25, 2026 D.C. Circuit decision, Anthropic PBC v. Department of War, which held that Hegseth’s “pungent” statements about a technology company didn’t undercut the department’s national-security reason. And it compares Hegseth’s words to Justice Clarence Thomas’s concurrence in West Virginia v. B.P.J., the Supreme Court’s 2026 decision on state sports laws.

The service members see the record differently. Their expert witness, Ashish Vazirani, wrote that under the earlier policy he was “not aware of any cases of reduced cohesion or readiness based on the service of a transgender service member.” That’s the question the trial is meant to answer: whether the medical framing explains the transgender military ban, or whether the record shows something else.

04

A diagnosis or a people? The second motion

The companion filing, Motion in Limine #1, asks Judge Reyes to decide whom the transgender military ban classifies by reading only its “operative terms.” The government argues the 2025 policy, like the Carter, Mattis and Austin policies before it, draws lines based on a medical condition, gender dysphoria, and related treatments. “There is nothing suspect about those classifications,” it says.

For support, it cites United States v. Skrmetti, the Supreme Court’s 2025 decision applying rational-basis review, the most forgiving test, to a state law barring hormones to treat gender dysphoria in minors. It also cites Anderson v. Crouch, a 2026 Fourth Circuit ruling on Medicaid coverage, which held that a line drawn at the diagnosis doesn’t turn on “sex or transgender status.”

The motion’s central argument comes from the sports case. There, it says, the Supreme Court looked past legislative findings about “gender identity” and examined what the laws actually did, concluding that they “classify on the basis of biological sex.” In the government’s view, the executive order and Hegseth’s posts are like those findings: they can’t change what the transgender military ban’s written terms say.

The service members’ position, as the motion describes it, is that the transgender military ban “discriminates based on transgender status.” The government’s answer, borrowed from the Fourth Circuit, is that courts “cannot presume discriminatory intent” just because gender dysphoria occurs only in transgender people. Judge Reyes will decide how much of the wider record she needs to see before she answers that.

05

The fight over who gets to testify

Two more motions in the transgender military ban case target the service members’ experts. Motion in Limine No. 6 seeks to bar Ashish Vazirani, who served as acting under secretary of defense for personnel and readiness from September 2023 to January 20, 2025. The government calls his views “those of a former political appointee who disagrees with a policy” his successors have implemented.

Vazirani’s 35-page rebuttal report, filed as an exhibit, puts the share of service members with a gender dysphoria diagnosis at an estimated 0.2 percent. During his tenure, he writes, about 5 percent of the force was non-deployable at any given time for medical, administrative or legal reasons. He reports the department spent about $52 million on transition-related care over fiscal years 2015 through 2024, an average of $5.2 million a year against a Military Health System budget of about $60.2 billion in fiscal 2024.

That’s less than 0.01 percent of the budget, by his math. The government wants those opinions kept out of the transgender military ban trial, arguing that prior policies aren’t at issue and that his views aren’t reliable.

Motion in Limine No. 8 targets retired Major General James Young, a former chief of staff of the Army Reserve. His report argues that the voluntary separation pay offered under the transgender military ban is “effectively zero” once federal law recoups it from later VA disability compensation and military retired pay. The government calls that opinion “misleading at best and irrelevant in any event.”

Both motions lean on Goldman v. Weinberger, a 1986 Supreme Court case, to argue that outside experts’ views on military discipline are “quite beside the point.” The government also argues that Young’s opinion that each plaintiff is more likely than not to receive a VA disability rating rests on a single household phone survey of veterans.

06

What separation pay and VA benefits mean for discharged service members

Here’s the practical piece for anyone separated under the transgender military ban, or afraid they will be. Separation pay is governed by Section 1174 of Title 10 of the U.S. Code. If you later receive VA disability compensation, the law says you can’t be denied it because you took separation pay. But it also requires a deduction from that compensation equal to the separation pay you received, minus the federal income tax withheld from it.

The same section requires deductions from later military retired or retainer pay, in monthly installments the Secretary of Defense sets, until the separation pay is repaid. The government’s position is that it applies this framework to trans service members separated under the transgender military ban the same way it applies it to anyone else who received voluntary separation pay. Young’s position is that, for these service members, the math leaves almost nothing behind.

If you’re facing separation, talk with a lawyer or an accredited veterans service officer before you sign anything about separation pay. The details depend on your record, and the court fight doesn’t change the statute.

07

What happens next in the transgender military ban case

The court’s July 27, 2026 scheduling order set a pretrial conference for December 7 at 11 AM and a bench trial from January 4 through January 15, 2027. A bench trial means Judge Reyes, not a jury, will decide the facts. The Advocate reported Sunday that the trial is still set to begin January 4.

An October 21 order moved several deadlines. It set November 20 for oppositions to motions in limine, recorded that the parties agreed to skip replies, and gave the government until November 17 to move for summary judgment. The motions themselves say a November 6 minute order adjusted the schedule again, and that order’s details aren’t in the filings Bloom reviewed.

Meanwhile, the transgender military ban is in force. Hegseth’s own answers note that the Supreme Court’s May 6, 2025 decision in Shilling v. Trump allowed it “to move forward.” The D.C. Circuit put Judge Reyes’s 2025 injunction on hold, first briefly and then with a formal stay pending appeal in December 2025, according to The Advocate.

Shannon Minter of NCLR, one of the lead lawyers for the service members alongside GLAD Law, put the stakes this way to The Advocate earlier this year: “These service members deserve their day in court, and the public deserves to know what is driving the ban.”

08

What’s still unclear

Judge Reyes hasn’t ruled on any of the November 13 motions, and the service members’ written oppositions weren’t in the record Bloom reviewed Sunday. It isn’t clear whether she’ll settle the evidence questions before trial, or take the evidence in and decide later how much weight it deserves.

It also isn’t clear how far the Supreme Court’s 2026 decisions reach into the transgender military ban case. The government reads the sports case and the Haiti case as closing the door on using officials’ words to show what a policy targets. Whether that reasoning controls a policy written and defended by one official, whose sworn answers are now in the record, is a question no court has answered in this case.

Bloom also couldn’t confirm, from the sources it reviewed, whether the D.C. Circuit has decided the government’s appeal of the 2025 injunction. When those answers come, they’ll decide what the transgender military ban means for the people still wearing the uniform.

09

What Bloom is doing

Bloom will keep following the transgender military ban case in court and reporting what Judge Reyes decides, with the documents linked so you can read them yourself. Our earlier reports on HHS’s gender dysphoria rule and on federal workers’ FEHB coverage fight follow other federal policies that turn on the same diagnosis.

If this news is heavy for you, you don’t have to carry it alone. Bloom’s crisis support page is there for you, and you can call Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, or 988 by call or text. Bloom’s support groups are a place to be with people who understand. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

Questions about separation pay, VA ratings and discharge paperwork are exactly what Bloom Resources is being built to answer: verified legal, healthcare, housing and benefits guides for trans and disabled people, dated, primary-sourced and free. You can help fund Bloom Resources as it takes shape.

Reporting like this, documents first and people always, is carried by readers who give a little each month. Become a monthly supporter if you can, or make a one-time gift if that fits your life better.

10

Frequently Asked Questions

It’s the trial in Talbott v. United States, where trans service members challenge the 2025 policy barring people with a current diagnosis, history or symptoms of gender dysphoria from serving without a waiver. Judge Ana C. Reyes will decide whether the policy can lawfully stand.

It’s a request asking the judge to rule before trial on whether certain evidence can be used. The government filed several in the transgender military ban case on November 13, 2026, including one to exclude Pete Hegseth’s statements as proof of animus.

No. The government’s motion doesn’t dispute them; it argues they refer to the medical condition of gender dysphoria. Hegseth’s sworn answers say he uses “trans” as shorthand for people with gender dysphoria.

The July 27, 2026 scheduling order set a bench trial from January 4 through January 15, 2027, with a pretrial conference on December 7, 2026. The Advocate reported on November 15 that the trial is still set to begin January 4.

Yes. The Supreme Court’s May 6, 2025 decision in Shilling v. Trump allowed the policy to move forward, and the D.C. Circuit stayed Judge Reyes’s 2025 injunction while the government appealed.

Under Section 1174 of Title 10, a veteran who took separation pay can still receive VA disability compensation, but an amount equal to the separation pay, minus the federal income tax withheld, is deducted from it. A lawyer or accredited veterans service officer can explain how that applies to you.

Trans Lifeline (877-565-8860), The Trevor Project (1-866-488-7386) and 988 (call or text; press 1 for the Veterans Crisis Line) are there now. If the transgender military ban is weighing on you, Bloom’s crisis support page and support groups are open to you too.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.