
Newsroom·California Legislature·News
Chino Valley Board Bars Trans Girls From Girlsโ Sports and Restrooms
Trans girls in Chino Valley schools would lose girls' teams, restrooms and locker rooms under a policy passed 4-1 Thursday night. A day earlier, the state attorney general's office warned in writing that it conflicts with California law.
Transgender girls in the Chino Valley Unified School District would be shut out of girls’ teams, restrooms and locker rooms under a policy the Chino Valley school board approved 4-1 on Thursday night, November 19, 2026, the Los Angeles Times reported. One day earlier, California’s attorney general’s office had warned the board in writing that the policy conflicts with state law. At the meeting, board president Sonja Shaw ripped up that letter.
It was Shaw’s last meeting as president. For the roughly 26,000 students in this San Bernardino County district, the policy now defines sex strictly by biology at birth, for sports, for every restroom and locker room, and for rooms on overnight school trips. California law has said the opposite since 2013. Here is what the Chino Valley board approved, what the law says, what the Supreme Court did and didn’t decide, and what families can do now.
01
What the Chino Valley board approved
The policy is titled “Fairness in Girls’ Athletics and Privacy in Sex-Based Facilities,” EdSource reported before the vote. It passed 4-1 during a three-hour meeting at district headquarters, the Times reported.
Board member Andrew Cruz cast the only no vote. He first tried to delay the vote so the board’s incoming members could weigh in, according to the Times, and Shaw called his actions “cowardly.” Shaw, who gave up her seat to run for state superintendent of public instruction, told the room, “I’m not giving up or giving in,” as supporters applauded.
Separating students by sex was already Chino Valley Unified policy. The difference, the Times explained, is that the old policy and state law let students take part and use facilities consistent with their gender identity. The new one doesn’t.
02
What the policy says
Here is what the Chino Valley policy does, as the Times and EdSource described it:
- Sex is defined strictly by biology at birth, and that definition decides who may play on girls’ teams.
- All facilities, including restrooms and locker rooms, must be separated by biological sex, and so must rooms on overnight school trips.
- The district checks a student’s sex against enrollment records. If the record is unavailable or has been amended, the student must bring an original birth certificate or a signed statement from a health care provider, based on a routine sports physical.
- Disputes go to a designated district administrator.
- The policy bars any examination beyond routine preparticipation physicals, EdSource reported.
- Students, parents or employees may report concerns through the district’s Title IX grievance procedures.
- The district may not discipline students or staff who decline to compete against, or share a facility with, a student the policy classifies as male.
- Any student who asks gets a single-user facility or private accommodation, with no questions asked.
Read those lines slowly and you can see who carries the weight. A transgender girl would lose her team. A transgender student of any kind would lose the restroom and the locker room that match who they are, every school day, and would room by birth sex on every overnight trip.
03
What California law says
California answered this question in its Education Code more than a decade ago. Section 221.5(f) says a student “shall be permitted” to “participate in sex-segregated school programs and activities, including athletic teams and competitions, and use facilities consistent with his or her gender identity,” and it adds, “irrespective of the gender listed on the pupil’s records.”
That rule has stood since 2013, EdSource reported. A second law, Education Code section 220, bars discrimination based on gender identity in any program or activity of a school that receives state financial assistance.
The state’s high school sports body follows the same line. California Interscholastic Federation Bylaw 300.D provides that students should be able to take part in CIF activities consistent with their gender identity, the education law firm Liebert Cassidy Whitmore wrote. Put plainly, the Chino Valley policy says the opposite of what the Education Code says, and the Times reported that the measure conflicts with California law.
04
Why the attorney general warned Chino Valley
On Wednesday, November 18, Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent wrote to Chino Valley Unified. Because the proposed policies conflict with the Education Code, he wrote, “the Board should reject the proposal, or at the very least, delay the vote.” He asked for time to discuss how the district understood state law to apply, the Times reported.
The board did neither. Shaw ripped up the letter during the meeting, and she answered on X that federal law trumps state law, aiming her words at Attorney General Rob Bonta. “I will never back down from protecting our daughters. You picked the wrong fight with this mom,” she posted.
Before the meeting, Shaw had shared a California Department of Justice letter stating that the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decisions don’t automatically invalidate state laws, EdSource reported. “Federal law is supreme,” Shaw replied, tagging Bonta. “Look it up.” She also said the board had received a cease-and-desist order from the California Teachers Association.
Chino Valley’s own teachers asked the board to stop, too. In a letter this week, the Associated Chino Teachers urged the board to reject or postpone the policy. Union president William Renner said there “are unintended consequences of what she is asking our teachers, educators, and coaches to do.”
05
What the Supreme Court decided, and what it left open
Shaw built her case on the Supreme Court. On June 30, 2026, in West Virginia v. B.P.J. and Little v. Hecox, the Court upheld West Virginia’s and Idaho’s laws limiting girls’ and women’s teams by biological sex.
The vote was 6-3, and Justice Kavanaugh wrote for the Court, Faegre Drinker’s summary notes. The Court held that such teams are permissible under both Title IX and the Equal Protection Clause.
Permissible isn’t the same as required. As the Times put it, “while the court permitted states to have such policies, it didn’t require them.” The Court also declined to decide whether Title IX lets schools include transgender girls on girls’ teams, Liebert Cassidy Whitmore wrote. So California may keep its own rule, and its rule points the other way.
Shaw says California is violating the Court’s recent rulings. On X she said she hopes Chino Valley can provide a “decisive California test case,” according to EdSource, and a blueprint for other districts.
06
A federal court has already looked at California’s law
The federal government tried to force California’s hand and lost the first round. On June 2, 2025, the U.S. Department of Justice sent letters to all of California’s local school agencies telling each it had to certify that it would not carry out CIF’s Bylaw 300.D, the law firm Lozano Smith wrote. California refused, and the government sued the California Department of Education and CIF.
On August 31, 2026, U.S. District Judge Cynthia Valenzuela of the Central District of California dismissed that lawsuit with prejudice, according to Liebert Cassidy Whitmore. She found that Title IX never gave California clear notice that taking federal school money meant excluding transgender girls from girls’ teams. She didn’t decide whether California’s rules comply with Title IX.
The United States has appealed, and the case is pending in the Ninth Circuit, Lozano Smith reports. For now, the firm says, California law and Bylaw 300.D remain in effect.
07
Chino Valley has been here before
This isn’t the first time the Chino Valley board and the attorney general have met over transgender students. In August 2023, Bonta sued over Board Policy 5020.1, which required schools to tell parents when a student asked to use a different name, pronoun or facility. A court blocked it in October 2023, and the board rescinded it on March 7, 2024, the attorney general’s office said.
In a final ruling the attorney general announced on September 11, 2024, the San Bernardino County Superior Court found that the policy violated California’s equal protection clause and Education Code section 220. The court recognized that “there is nothing wrong or pathological with being transgender or gender non-conforming,” the attorney general’s office said. Bonta warned other districts that “discriminatory policies will not be tolerated in our educational institutions.”
The disputes haven’t ended. The Times reports Chino Valley Unified’s parent notification policy is still tied up in litigation, and advocates have challenged its library book policy with the California Department of Education. In April 2025, the board voted to file complaints against the state and Gov. Gavin Newsom, one of them over transgender athletes, and passed a resolution calling on CIF to change its rule, KVCR reported.
Chino Valley isn’t alone in California, either. That same month, the Redlands Unified board voted 3-2 for a motion to bar transgender athletes from girls’ sports, CBS Los Angeles reported. Its district spokesperson said any action would be evaluated to make sure it complied with the law.
08
Who spoke, and what they said
The Chino Valley meeting was loud on every side. One-minute public comments ran well over an hour, and most scheduled speakers supported Shaw, the Times reported. Sophia Lorey, outreach director for the California Family Council and a former collegiate athlete, thanked Shaw for “going out with a bang.”
Shaw framed the vote as protection. “Our daughters should never have to surrender their privacy, dignity, or opportunities,” she said in a press release quoted by EdSource. In another, quoted by the Times, she said, “Chino Valley is not going to sit on the sidelines and wait for someone else to lead,” and that the district could “give other school districts a blueprint to follow.”
Critics saw a last-ditch effort. Lisa Greathouse, co-founder of Chino Valley Defenders of Public Education, called it “a slap in the face to voters” and said it would likely lead to costly legal battles. Naomi Minogue of the same group told EdSource, “It’s her last hurrah,” and called the policy “harmful and divisive.”
Arne Johnson of Trans Kids Belong said Shaw is “forcing her district to adopt a policy that is clearly illegal by California law.” He predicted, “It will be overturned,” but only after costing the district millions.
09
Who this policy reaches
Here’s the part a headline can miss. Greathouse said no transgender athletes are known to be playing girls’ sports in the district, and Minogue told EdSource she doesn’t know of any transgender athlete who is out in Chino Valley Unified. So the sports rule may touch no one on a team today.
The facilities rule reaches further. Every transgender student in Chino Valley needs a restroom during the school day, and some will travel overnight on school trips. Under this policy, the district’s records and a district administrator decide which door they walk through.
And the reporting rule reaches every girl in Chino Valley. Students, parents and employees can raise a concern through the Title IX grievance process. Former Chino Valley teacher Kristi Hirst warned the Times that “girls who don’t look as feminine as what other people think they should are going to be targeted and complained about.” A girl doesn’t have to be transgender to be questioned. She only has to look different to someone watching.
That’s the human why. Behind each line of the policy is a student who may now be asked to prove something about her body before she can run a race or use a restroom.
10
A timeline of Chino Valley’s fight over transgender students
These dates come from the attorney general’s office, the Times, EdSource, KVCR, Liebert Cassidy Whitmore and Lozano Smith:
- 2013: California law lets students take part in school programs, including sports, consistent with their gender identity.
- August 2023: Bonta sues over Chino Valley’s parent notification policy.
- October 2023: A court blocks the policy.
- March 7, 2024: The board rescinds it.
- September 11, 2024: The attorney general announces a final ruling that the policy violated state law.
- April 2025: The board votes to file complaints against the state and the governor, one of them over transgender athletes.
- June 30, 2026: The Supreme Court upholds West Virginia’s and Idaho’s sports laws.
- August 31, 2026: A federal judge dismisses the government’s Title IX suit against California; the government later appeals.
- November 3, 2026: Shaw loses her race for state superintendent.
- November 18, 2026: The attorney general’s office urges the board to reject or delay the policy.
- November 19, 2026: The board approves it, 4-1.
11
What happens next for Chino Valley
Neither the Times nor EdSource reported when the policy takes effect. The Times reported that the vote sets up an immediate conflict with Bonta’s office, which has gone to court against this district before. As of early Friday, Bloom had found no public statement from the attorney general’s office on the vote.
The Chino Valley board itself is about to change. Shaw’s term ends next month, EdSource reported, and her husband, Chris Shaw, lost his race to replace her. Incumbent Shaun Smith also lost. Even so, conservatives keep a 3-2 majority, which the Times said makes it seem likely that policies Shaw drove could persist.
The larger fight continues in the Ninth Circuit, where the federal government is appealing the dismissal of its Title IX suit against California. Whatever happens there, California’s Education Code still says what it says, and families can use it.
12
The view from the Pacific Northwest
The Chino Valley vote lands in a month of change for school sports in the West. In Washington, voters passed Initiative 638, and girls now need a signed sex attestation by December 3 to keep competing. Families, teachers and TransFamilies have asked a King County judge to block the law before it takes effect, with a hearing set for December 3.
In Oregon, an outgoing state representative has said his group is working on a possible ballot measure on trans girls in school sports. In Colorado, the state told schools they don’t have to verify athletes’ sex under Proposition 134. In New York, an appeals court struck down Nassau County’s ban.
The difference matters. Washington’s voters changed their state’s law. In Chino Valley, a local board has adopted a rule that the state’s own lawyers say conflicts with the law that governs it.
13
What families in Chino Valley can do
If you’re a student or parent in Chino Valley Unified, or you care about one, here’s what the record shows you can do:
- Know the law. Education Code section 221.5(f) protects a student’s right to play and use facilities consistent with gender identity. Keep a copy.
- File a complaint with the district. Under the state’s Uniform Complaint Procedures, a student, parent or interested organization files a discrimination complaint with the district first, within six months of the incident, the California Department of Education says.
- Watch the clock. The district has 60 days to investigate. If you disagree with its findings, you can appeal to the state within 30 days. The state’s Education Equity office answers at eeucpo@cde.ca.gov or 916-319-8239.
- Tell the attorney general. The Public Inquiry Unit takes calls at 800-952-5225, toll-free in California, and has online forms.
- Keep a record. Save every notice, email and form, and write down dates, names and what was said.
- Speak up. Board meetings are public, and the district posts video of them, including the November 19 meeting.
- Stay close to your student. If they’re scared or hurting, Trans Lifeline (877-565-8860), The Trevor Project (1-866-488-7386) and 988 (call or text) answer any hour.
14
What Bloom is doing
Bloom will follow the Chino Valley policy and report what the state, the courts and the district do. I believe no girl should have to prove her body to an administrator before she can run a race with her friends, and no student should have to wonder which restroom is safe to use.
If this news is heavy for you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour, and Bloom’s support groups are a place to be known. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps Bloom watching school boards in every state, and a one-time gift helps too.
15
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 19, 2026, the board voted 4-1 for a policy that defines sex by biology at birth for girls’ sports, restrooms, locker rooms and overnight trips. Andrew Cruz voted no.
California’s attorney general’s office says it conflicts with the Education Code. Section 221.5(f) lets students play and use facilities consistent with their gender identity.
In June 2026, the Court said states may limit girls’ teams by biological sex. It didn’t require them to, and California’s law goes the other way.
Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent wrote on November 18 that the board should reject the proposal or at least delay the vote. Sonja Shaw ripped up the letter at the meeting.
It would use enrollment records. If a record is missing or amended, the student would need an original birth certificate or a provider’s signed statement from a routine sports physical.
Neither the Los Angeles Times nor EdSource reported a start date. Bloom will report it when the district or a court sets one.
File a discrimination complaint with the district within six months, appeal to the California Department of Education within 30 days of the district’s findings, and contact the attorney general’s Public Inquiry Unit at 800-952-5225.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
California Legislature · 19 November 2026California Was Warned About 3 Educators and Let Them Keep Working
California Legislature · 18 November 2026Jury Awards $14.3 Million Against Oakland Diocese in Clergy Abuse Case
California Legislature · 16 November 2026Supreme Court Leaves First Amendment Win for UC Researchers in Place