
Newsroom·California Legislature·News
Supreme Court Leaves First Amendment Win for UC Researchers in Place
The justices won't hear the appeal. A ruling that canceling research grants to punish viewpoints likely violates the First Amendment stands. Here's what changes.
The Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear the federal government’s appeal in a fight over canceled research grants at the University of California. The order is one line long: “Petition DENIED.” That line leaves standing a Ninth Circuit ruling that the government likely broke the First Amendment when it cut off scholars’ grants because of the views their work expressed.
It isn’t a final ruling on every grant in the country, and it doesn’t settle the case. But it means the researchers who lost their research grants for promoting diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility keep the protection a lower court gave them, and it puts a principle in plain view. The government can choose what to fund, but it can’t cancel money already awarded to punish a point of view.
01
What the Supreme Court did on Monday
The case is listed on the Supreme Court’s docket as No. 26-210. The government asked the justices to take it on August 18, 2026. The researchers answered on October 19, the government replied on October 27, and the petition went to the justices’ private conference on November 13. On November 16, the docket shows a single entry: “Petition DENIED.”
Reuters reported that none of the nine justices publicly noted a dissent. The grants at stake add up to about $59 million in federal money for researchers across the University of California system. The researchers are represented by Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California, Berkeley School of Law.
“I am obviously delighted that the court denied” the government’s petition, Chemerinsky told Reuters. He said the Court’s action means the lower court’s ruling stands, and that research grants cut off because of the perceived viewpoint of the work must continue to be restored.
A denial like this one isn’t an opinion. The justices didn’t explain their reasons, and they didn’t announce a rule for the whole country. What they did was decline to disturb the Ninth Circuit’s decision, so that decision now governs the case as it goes back to the trial court.
02
Why the research grants were cut
The story starts with executive orders signed in January 2025. According to the Ninth Circuit’s opinion, Executive Orders 14151 and 14173 sought to eliminate diversity, equity and inclusion programs, and diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility programs, from all aspects of the federal government. A third order, Executive Order 14168, directs that “[f]ederal funds shall not be used to promote gender ideology.”
In April 2025, three agencies sent form letters to UC Berkeley that, in the court’s words, “purported to terminate” the plaintiffs’ research grants. The agencies were the Environmental Protection Agency, the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities. The EPA letter said each grant “no longer effectuates the program goals or agency priorities.”
The appeals court found the selection wasn’t random. It described the humanities endowment’s termination policy as one that “focused first on identifying open grants that focused on or promoted” environmental justice, diversity, equity and inclusion, diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility, and “gender ideology.” In other words, the research grants were picked by the ideas they carried.
Reuters, citing court papers, reported that the terminated research grants included projects to foster discussion about racial equity in science education and to expand science education opportunities for Indigenous youth. Those are teaching projects, the kind of work that invites more people into science. They were canceled in the middle of the work.
On June 4, 2025, the researchers filed a class action in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California on behalf of University of California scholars whose grants had been or soon would be terminated. U.S. District Judge Rita F. Lin granted a preliminary injunction and provisionally certified two groups of researchers. She ordered the three agencies to reinstate the research grants while the case went forward.
03
A timeline of the research grants case
- January 2025: Executive Orders 14151, 14168 and 14173 direct agencies to end diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility programs and to stop funding what the orders call “gender ideology.”
- April 2025: The Environmental Protection Agency, the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities send form letters to UC Berkeley terminating research grants.
- June 4, 2025: University of California researchers file a class action over the canceled research grants.
- 2025: Judge Rita F. Lin grants a preliminary injunction, provisionally certifies two classes and orders the research grants reinstated.
- November 14, 2025: A Ninth Circuit panel hears argument in San Francisco.
- May 26, 2026: The Ninth Circuit affirms the injunction for the DEI Termination Class on First Amendment grounds and reverses it for the Form Termination Class.
- August 18, 2026: The government asks the Supreme Court to review the decision.
- November 16, 2026: The Supreme Court denies the petition, and the Ninth Circuit’s ruling on the research grants stands.
Each step in that timeline is a public record. That matters, because the strongest protection anyone has against a government that overreaches is a record clear enough for a court to read. The researchers built that record, grant by grant, and three levels of federal courts have now looked at it.
04
How the Ninth Circuit read the First Amendment
The government appealed. A three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit (Judges Richard A. Paez, Morgan B. Christen and Roopali H. Desai) heard argument in San Francisco on November 14, 2025. The panel filed its opinion on May 26, 2026, and it split the case in two.
The first group, called the Form Termination Class, lost. Those researchers argued that the form letters were arbitrary under the Administrative Procedure Act. The panel held that their claim was really about enforcing a promise to pay money, which belongs in a different court under a law called the Tucker Act. It followed the Supreme Court’s August 2025 order in a case about National Institutes of Health grants, which turned on that same procedural question.
The second group, the DEI Termination Class, won. These researchers argued that the government ended their research grants because of the viewpoints the work expressed. The panel agreed that they’re likely to succeed on that First Amendment claim. Its central sentence is short: “Because the agencies’ termination of grants is aimed at the suppression of viewpoints with which the government disagrees, it likely violates the First Amendment.”
The panel also explained what made this viewpoint discrimination and not ordinary budgeting. The agencies picked particular grants for termination regardless of the programs that funded them, and they made the decision based on the recipients’ perceived expression of diversity, equity, inclusion, accessibility or environmental justice viewpoints. That’s a judgment about speech, not about money.
Finally, the panel held that Judge Lin didn’t overstep when she ordered the grants reinstated. Putting the research grants back, it said, was necessary to give the researchers complete relief. That’s the order the government asked the Supreme Court to undo, and the order that stands after Monday.
05
What the denial does, and what it doesn’t
Here’s what Monday’s order does. It leaves in place the Ninth Circuit’s holding that canceling research grants to suppress disfavored viewpoints likely violates the First Amendment. It keeps the injunction for the DEI Termination Class in force. And it sends the case back to Judge Lin’s courtroom, where the researchers’ claims will be decided on a full record.
Here’s what it doesn’t do. It doesn’t decide the merits of the case for good, because a preliminary injunction is a ruling about likely outcomes, not a final judgment. It doesn’t revive the claims of the Form Termination Class, which lost on the Tucker Act question. And it doesn’t reach the National Institutes of Health cuts, which the Supreme Court allowed in August 2025 on procedural grounds, as Reuters noted.
The Ninth Circuit’s decisions bind the federal courts in its region, which includes Oregon, Washington, Idaho and California. That matters in the Pacific Northwest. A researcher at a public university in Oregon whose grant is canceled for its viewpoint now has a published appeals-court opinion on point.
The ruling doesn’t say the government must fund everything. The government still decides which programs to create and which applications to approve. The line the Ninth Circuit drew is narrower and older than this case. Once the public’s money is awarded, the government can’t take it back to silence the ideas it doesn’t like.
06
Who these research grants reach
It would be easy to read this as a fight among universities and agencies. It isn’t. Research grants pay for the classroom programs, the community studies and the outreach that decide who gets invited into science, history and public health. When those grants are canceled for their viewpoint, the people who lose first are the people the work was built to reach.
Look at the word list the agencies used. The executive orders targeted “diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility.” Accessibility is how disabled students and scholars get through the door. A funding screen that treats the word as a red flag doesn’t only cut programs; it tells disabled researchers that the conditions of their work are suspect.
The same screen named “gender ideology,” a term taken from Executive Order 14168. Trans scholars and the researchers who study trans health know what it means when their subject is named as a reason to stop funding. This ruling doesn’t settle every question about those grants. It does say the Constitution has something to say when the government picks research to cancel by the ideas it contains.
And this isn’t a partisan principle. The First Amendment protects the scholar whose work the government likes today and the scholar whose work it dislikes tomorrow. Viewpoint discrimination is dangerous in anyone’s hands, which is exactly why the Constitution forbids it. Bloom reports that rule the same way no matter who holds power.
07
What researchers and readers can do
If you’re a University of California researcher whose research grants were terminated, the first question is which group you belong to. The Ninth Circuit described two provisionally certified classes: researchers whose grants ended by form letter without a grant-specific explanation, and researchers whose grants ended because of the DEI executive orders. Only the second group keeps the injunction after Monday.
Your university’s research office is the place to start, because it tracks which research grants were restored and when. The researchers’ lawyers are listed on the Supreme Court docket, and the case number in the trial court is 3:25-cv-04737. Write down the dates on any letter you received, and keep copies of every notice.
If you’re a researcher outside California, the ruling still matters. The Ninth Circuit’s reasoning about viewpoint discrimination is now a published decision that the Supreme Court declined to review. A scholar in Oregon or Washington who believes their research grants were canceled for the ideas in the work can show that opinion to a lawyer.
And if you’re simply a reader who cares about free speech, the lesson is plain. Public research grants belong to the public. When the government cancels them because of the ideas inside, the First Amendment has something to say, and the courts are listening.
08
What’s still unclear
The Supreme Court gave no reasons, so it’s unclear how the justices see the First Amendment question. A denial can reflect many things, including timing and the early stage of the case. Readers shouldn’t treat it as a ruling that the government lost on the merits.
It’s also unclear how many University of California research grants are fully restored today, and whether any project lost staff or time it can’t recover. Reuters put the total at about $59 million. The full list of affected research grants is in the trial court record, which Bloom hasn’t reviewed.
It’s also unclear how agencies will handle new applications on the same subjects. The Ninth Circuit’s ruling concerns grants already awarded and then canceled, not decisions about which proposals to fund next. Watch the next funding cycle closely.
Finally, it’s unclear whether the government will pursue the Form Termination claims in the Court of Federal Claims or press other arguments at trial. Bloom will follow the case as it moves forward in Judge Lin’s courtroom and report each new ruling.
09
What Bloom is doing
Bloom is a registered 501(c)(3), and we don’t endorse or oppose any party or candidate. We report on government power when it touches the rights of the people we serve, and the right to speak and study without punishment for your viewpoint belongs to all of them. Our newsroom has followed other court fights over executive actions, and we’ll keep the record straight on this one.
Bloom Resources is our coming library of verified legal, healthcare, housing and benefits guides for trans and disabled people, dated, primary-sourced and free. A plain guide to your First Amendment rights when public money is involved belongs there, and you can help build Bloom Resources so it reaches people sooner.
If the news is heavy today, you don’t have to carry it alone. Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach right now: Trans Lifeline 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project 1-866-488-7386, and 988 by call or text.
Reporting like this runs on people who give a little every month. Become a monthly supporter, or give once if that fits your life better.
10
Frequently Asked Questions
It declined to hear the government’s appeal in No. 26-210. That leaves in place the Ninth Circuit’s ruling that canceling University of California research grants to suppress viewpoints likely violates the First Amendment.
Not yet. The ruling being left in place is a preliminary injunction, which protects the researchers while the case continues. The trial court will decide the claims on a full record.
The Ninth Circuit’s opinion names the Environmental Protection Agency, the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities. Each sent form letters to UC Berkeley in April 2025.
It’s when the government treats speech differently because of the opinion it expresses. The Ninth Circuit found the grant terminations were likely aimed at suppressing viewpoints the government disagreed with.
No. The Supreme Court allowed the NIH cuts in August 2025 on procedural grounds. This case concerns grants from the EPA, the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities.
Yes. The Ninth Circuit’s published decisions bind the federal courts in its region, including Oregon, Washington and Idaho, so researchers in the Pacific Northwest can rely on it.
Yes. The government chooses which programs to create and which applications to approve. What the Ninth Circuit rejected was canceling money already awarded in order to punish a point of view.
Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the University of California, Berkeley School of Law, is counsel of record for the researchers at the Supreme Court. He told Reuters he was delighted the Court denied the petition.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
California Legislature · 16 November 2026Hundreds of Women Accuse a Cedars-Sinai Doctor of Sexual Abuse
Justice for survivors · 17 November 2026Federal Prisons Closed Dublin, but Sexual Abuse of Women Didn’t Stop
Colorado Legislature · 17 November 2026Supreme Court Turns Away Challenge to Colorado’s Misgendering Rules