A stone church steeple lit by the setting sun above autumn trees, framed by bare branches, for a report on a former Rhode Island priest's no contest plea

NewsroomRhode Island LegislatureNews

Former Rhode Island Priest, 86, Avoids Prison With No Contest Plea

A former Rhode Island priest, 86, will serve no prison time on charges of molesting a boy in 1989 and 1990, after a no contest plea on November 19. Rhode Island sets no time limit to charge these crimes, and survivors can still report.

This article discusses sexual abuse. It contains no graphic detail.

A man who told the Diocese of Providence in 2019 that a priest had abused him as a boy spoke directly to that former priest in Rhode Island Superior Court on Thursday, November 19, 2026. James M. Silva, 86, entered a no contest plea to one count of first-degree and one count of second-degree child molestation. He won’t go to prison.

Superior Court Judge Richard Raspallo dismissed the other nine charges and imposed a 10-year suspended sentence with probation, The Boston Globe and The Providence Journal reported. Silva must register as a sex offender, and the judge issued a no-contact order. The charges date to 1989 and 1990, when Silva held a leadership post in the Diocese of Providence. Here’s what the no contest plea means, why it didn’t end in prison, and how survivors in Rhode Island and everywhere else can report abuse and find support.

01

The no contest plea at a glance

  • The plea: nolo contendere, or no contest, to one count of first-degree and one count of second-degree child molestation.
  • The sentence: 10 years, suspended, with probation. No prison time.
  • The conditions: sex-offender registration and a no-contact order.
  • The rest of the case: the judge dismissed the other nine charges in a 2021 indictment.
  • The years: 1989 and 1990, when the boy was under 14.
  • The report: the survivor went to the Diocese of Providence in 2019, and it referred the matter to the Rhode Island State Police.
  • The prosecutors: the attorney general’s office had asked for prison earlier, but didn’t object on the record to the no contest plea.

02

What happened in court on November 19

Silva “pled nolo contendere to one count of first-degree child molestation” and one count of second-degree child molestation, The Providence Journal’s Katherine Gregg reported in a story carried by Yahoo News. The Globe described the same no contest plea as covering “one count each of first-degree and second-degree child molestation sexual assault.”

Judge Raspallo “dismissed the other nine charges and handed down a 10-year suspended sentence,” the Globe reported. Silva was “ordered to register as a sex offender,” the Journal said, and “The judge also issued a no-contact order.” WJAR NBC 10, citing court documents, reported the sentence as 10 years of probation.

The prosecutor, Jonathan Burke, told the judge what the state would have proven had the case gone to trial, the Journal reported. With the no contest plea, there won’t be a trial. The case that began with a grand jury five years ago ended with a sentence on the day the survivor spoke.

03

The charges from 1989 and 1990

The Journal reported that Silva abused “a 12-year-old boy he had agreed to watch in the evenings.” When the attorney general’s office announced the indictment in 2021, it said Silva was charged with abusing “a male victim under the age of 14 between 1989 and 1990.”

At the time, Silva was “Interim Director and Assistant Director at the Office of Ministerial Formation” in the Diocese of Providence, serving “from 1986 until 1991,” the attorney general’s 2021 release said.

Bloom won’t describe the abuse, and nothing in this story needs it. What matters is simple. A boy’s evenings were placed in a priest’s care, and the state charged that priest with abusing that trust. The no contest plea means a court has now sentenced him on two of those charges.

04

The survivor’s words in court

The man who was that boy read a statement in court and spoke to Silva directly. “I have forgiven you but I will never forget,” he said, as WJAR and the Globe reported. He also told Silva, “May God forgive you,” according to the Journal.

“This day was a long time coming for you and I’m glad it’s here,” he said. He also spoke of the lasting harm he has carried, WJAR reported.

Bloom doesn’t name survivors of sexual abuse, even when they’ve spoken in public and other outlets have printed their names. His words belong in this story. His name doesn’t need to.

05

What a no contest plea means

In Latin, nolo contendere means “I do not wish to contend,” the Legal Information Institute at Cornell Law School explains. In plain English, it’s a no contest plea.

With a no contest plea, the defendant “does not accept or deny responsibility for the charges but waives the right to a trial and agrees to accept the penalty,” LII says. The court still sentences the defendant, as Judge Raspallo did on November 19.

LII also explains how a no contest plea differs from a guilty plea. It “cannot be used against the defendant in another cause of action.” Silva and the Diocese of Providence face civil lawsuits from other men, the Globe reported, so that difference may matter outside the criminal court.

06

A no contest plea with a suspended sentence still counts

Rhode Island has its own rule for some no contest pleas. Under Rhode Island General Laws § 12-18-3, when a person pleads nolo contendere and is placed on probation, “the plea and probation shall not constitute a conviction for any purpose” once probation ends without a violation.

That protection has limits. The same section says, “This section shall not apply to any person who is sentenced to serve a term in the adult correctional institutions” or “who is given a suspended or deferred sentence in addition to probation.”

Silva’s no contest plea came with a 10-year suspended sentence and probation. By the statute’s own words, the rule that can keep a no contest plea from counting as a conviction doesn’t reach a sentence like his.

07

What a 10-year suspended sentence means

A suspended sentence is a prison term that hangs over a person on probation. Under Rhode Island General Laws § 12-19-9, if a judge finds by a “fair preponderance of the evidence” that someone violated probation, the judge may “Remove the suspension and order the defendant committed on the sentence previously imposed, or on a lesser sentence.”

The judge may also choose to “Continue the suspension of a sentence previously imposed.” In plain words, Silva doesn’t serve the 10 years unless he breaks the court’s conditions and a judge decides to impose them.

What begins now is real. Silva must register as a sex offender. The no-contact order is in force. And for the length of his probation, the suspended sentence stays on the books.

08

Why the state didn’t object to the no contest plea

The attorney general’s office “had recommended prison time at previous pre-trial conferences and a hearing,” the Journal reported, “but did not object on the record to the plea.”

Neither the Journal, the Globe nor WJAR reported a statement from the attorney general’s office explaining that choice. When Bloom checked the office’s latest press releases on November 21, none announced the no contest plea. The public record doesn’t say why the office didn’t object, and Bloom won’t guess.

What the record does show is this. The office brought the case, a grand jury indicted, and the case ended with a sentence on two counts rather than a trial.

09

How the case came to light in 2019

“The victim kept the abuse secret for decades,” the Journal reported. In 2019, he contacted the Diocese of Providence, which referred the matter to the Rhode Island State Police, the Journal said. The diocese’s director of communications, Michael F. Kieloch, told the Globe in an email that the diocese reported the accusations to police and the attorney general’s office. That report is where the road to this week’s no contest plea began.

That was the right thing for the diocese to do. A church that receives a report like this one owes it to the person reporting, and to every child still in its care, to put it in the hands of people who can investigate.

2019 was also the year the attorney general’s investigation of the diocese began. “The investigation began in 2019 when, as a result of a Memorandum of Understanding between the Attorney General” and former Bishop Thomas J. Tobin, the diocese agreed to produce internal records, the office said in March 2026.

10

From indictment to no contest plea

The case followed “an investigation by the Office of the Attorney General and the Rhode Island State Police,” the 2021 release said. “On November 3, 2021, the Statewide Grand Jury returned a sealed indictment” against Silva.

The 11-count indictment charged “two counts of first-degree child molestation and nine counts of second-degree child molestation.” Silva was 81. He was arraigned before Superior Court Associate Justice Maureen B. Keough, his bail was set at $50,000 with surety, and the court issued a no-contact order.

“An indictment, information, or complaint is merely an allegation,” the office wrote then. “This is the third case this Office has brought against a clergy member based on child sexual abuse allegations,” Attorney General Peter Neronha said. Five years later, two of those counts ended in a no contest plea and a sentence.

11

No statute of limitations for these crimes in Rhode Island

Rhode Island General Laws § 12-12-17 begins, “There shall be no statute of limitations for the following offenses.” The list includes “first-degree child molestation sexual assault, second-degree child molestation sexual assault.”

Under that law, a report made decades later can still become a criminal case. Silva’s did, and it ended this week in a no contest plea. For survivors who’ve carried something for years, this may be the most important fact in the story: in Rhode Island, it’s not too late to tell the police.

Other states set their own rules, and the statute of limitations for a criminal case is different from the deadline for a civil lawsuit. If you live elsewhere, ask your local police or a survivors’ advocate what applies to you.

12

Silva’s earlier case in the 1990s

This week’s no contest plea wasn’t Silva’s first time in a criminal court. He “was removed from the ministry in 1993 and pleaded guilty to second-degree sexual assault in 1995,” the Globe reported.

In that case, WJAR reported, he “received a suspended sentence of seven years along with probation,” and he served no jail time. Neither outlet said who was involved in the 1995 case, and Bloom won’t speculate.

Thirty-one years apart, two Rhode Island cases against Silva have ended in a suspended sentence. Survivors will draw their own conclusions from that. The record speaks for itself.

13

What the attorney general’s report found

On March 4, 2026, Neronha’s office published a report on child sexual abuse in the Diocese of Providence. Investigators “identified 75 credibly accused clergy,” who “reportedly abused over 300 victims from 1950 to 2011,” the March release said. They “reviewed over 250,000 pages of records produced by the Diocese.”

“Child sexual abuse in the Diocese of Providence occurred on an abhorrent, staggering scale,” Neronha said. “This must never happen again.”

The office “brought criminal charges against four current and former priests for child sexual abuse,” the release said, and three were awaiting trial. Silva was one of those three, the Journal reported, and his case has now ended in a no contest plea. The other two cases are still pending. Those men “are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.”

14

The civil cases and the revival window

The criminal case is separate from a wave of civil lawsuits. “Close to 200 civil lawsuits have been filed since a revival window opened on July 1,” the Journal reported, under a law that gave survivors two years to bring decades-old claims.

The man who spoke in court is a plaintiff in at least three lawsuits against the diocese, the Journal reported. “Two other men have also filed lawsuits against Silva and the Providence Diocese,” according to the Globe. Those claims haven’t been decided.

The diocese says reviving expired claims violates the Rhode Island Constitution, and Bloom reported on November 18 that Rhode Island’s attorney general moved to defend the law reviving clergy abuse lawsuits. That fight is about civil responsibility. The no contest plea was about criminal accountability, a different question under different rules.

15

What accountability looks like decades later

Accountability that comes more than 30 years late rarely looks like a film’s last scene. Here it looked like a record: a grand jury indictment, a no contest plea, a sex-offender registration, a no-contact order and a 10-year suspended sentence. It didn’t look like prison.

It also looked like a man speaking in open court to the person charged with harming him, and being heard. Some survivors will read this story and feel the sentence was too light. Others will hear something stronger than any sentence in his words. Both responses are honest.

Faith doesn’t ask survivors to pretend they aren’t hurt. Forgiveness, when someone chooses it, is a gift they give. It isn’t a debt they owe, and it never cancels the call for justice.

Bloom has followed survivors’ cases against other dioceses this month, from a $14.3 million jury verdict against the Oakland Diocese to a tentative deal with abuse survivors in Baltimore.

16

A timeline of the case

These dates come from the attorney general’s office, the Globe, the Journal and WJAR:

  • 1986 to 1991: Silva serves as interim director and assistant director of the diocese’s Office of Ministerial Formation.
  • 1989 and 1990: The years of the charged abuse of a boy under 14.
  • 1993: Silva is removed from ministry.
  • 1995: Silva pleads guilty to second-degree sexual assault and receives a seven-year suspended sentence with probation.
  • 2019: The survivor reports to the Diocese of Providence, which refers the matter to the State Police. The attorney general’s review of diocese records begins.
  • November 3, 2021: A statewide grand jury returns a sealed 11-count indictment.
  • November 2021: Silva, then 81, is arraigned. Bail is set at $50,000 with surety.
  • March 4, 2026: The attorney general publishes his report on the diocese.
  • July 1, 2026: The two-year revival window for civil claims opens.
  • November 19, 2026: Silva enters a no contest plea and receives a 10-year suspended sentence with probation.

17

Read the records yourself

These are the primary documents behind this story:

  1. The attorney general’s November 9, 2021 indictment announcement, with the counts, the years and the arraignment.
  2. The attorney general’s March 4, 2026 report announcement, with a link to the full report.
  3. Rhode Island’s statute of limitations law, § 12-12-17.
  4. The law on a no contest plea followed by probation, § 12-18-3.
  5. The law on probation violations and suspended sentences, § 12-19-9.

Bloom relied on the reporting of the Journal, the Globe and WJAR for what happened at the no contest plea hearing on November 19.

18

How to report clergy abuse in Rhode Island

The attorney general’s office directs anyone reporting child sexual abuse by a clergy member to the Rhode Island State Police Special Victims Unit’s dedicated clergy abuse hotline, 401-764-0142. The office and the State Police set it up as “a channel for anyone to confidentially report” information about abuse by clergy.

If a child is in danger right now, call 911. Outside Rhode Island, call your local police or your state’s child abuse hotline. In Oregon, call the Oregon Child Abuse Hotline: 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233).

Who must report abuse, and whether clergy are among them, is its own fight. Bloom reported this week on survivors who asked the Supreme Court who decides what clergy must report.

19

A checklist if you’re thinking about reporting

  • When you’re ready, write down what you remember, with years and places. It doesn’t need to be perfect.
  • Keep any letters, emails, photos or records that mention the person or the place.
  • Choose who you want beside you: a friend, an advocate, a pastor or a counselor.
  • In Rhode Island, call the State Police clergy abuse hotline at 401-764-0142, or Day One’s helpline at 1-800-494-8100.
  • Remember that criminal charges and civil lawsuits follow different rules and deadlines. Ask a lawyer about a civil claim separately.
  • Rest. Reporting is a step, not a test you have to pass in one day.

20

Where to get support right now

In Rhode Island, Day One runs “The 24/7 Victims of Crime Helpline” at 1-800-494-8100, according to Day One. Its advocates offer “confidential support, information, and advocacy over the phone,” and it also helps “non-offending friends and family members looking for support.”

Anywhere in the country, call RAINN at 800-656-4673, Trans Lifeline at 877-565-8860 or The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, or call or text 988. Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach any hour.

Bloom’s support groups are a place to be heard. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.

21

What happens next

With the no contest plea entered, Silva’s probation, registration and no-contact order begin now. If he violates his probation, a judge may impose some or all of the suspended sentence under § 12-19-9.

The criminal cases against two other priests from the attorney general’s investigation are still pending, the Journal reported. They’re presumed innocent unless proven guilty.

The civil cases go on, and so does the constitutional fight over the revival window. Bloom will keep following the Diocese of Providence cases and report what the courts decide.

22

What Bloom is doing

Bloom reports these cases so survivors can see the whole record in one place: the no contest plea, the law and the way to report. I believe every survivor who speaks, whether in a courtroom or a kitchen, deserves to be heard, and no institution’s reputation is worth a child’s safety.

If this story stirred up something heavy, you don’t have to carry it alone tonight. A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading court records and statutes for survivors, and a one-time gift helps too.

23

Frequently Asked Questions

On November 19, 2026, the former priest entered a no contest plea to one count of first-degree and one count of second-degree child molestation in Rhode Island Superior Court. The judge dismissed nine other charges.

A no contest plea, or nolo contendere, means the defendant doesn’t accept or deny responsibility, but gives up a trial and accepts the penalty. The court still imposes a sentence.

No. After his no contest plea, Judge Richard Raspallo imposed a 10-year suspended sentence with probation, ordered sex-offender registration and issued a no-contact order.

Rhode Island’s rule that keeps some no contest pleas from counting as convictions doesn’t apply to anyone given a suspended sentence in addition to probation. Silva received a suspended sentence with probation.

No. Rhode Island law lists first-degree and second-degree child molestation sexual assault among the offenses with no statute of limitations.

Call the Rhode Island State Police Special Victims Unit’s clergy abuse hotline at 401-764-0142. If a child is in danger now, call 911.

In Rhode Island, call Day One’s 24/7 helpline at 1-800-494-8100. Anywhere in the country, call RAINN at 800-656-4673, or call or text 988.

Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸

Support this work

Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.

Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.

Give monthlyGive onceGifts are tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law.