
Newsroom·Wisconsin Legislature·News
Judge Lets Former Students’ Title IX Suit Against Oconto Falls Proceed
Five former students can try to prove their Wisconsin school board kept a policy of deliberate indifference to sexual misconduct. Here's what the judge decided and what you can do.
Five former students who say teachers and coaches in Wisconsin’s Oconto Falls Public School District abused or harassed them can keep suing the district’s school board under Title IX, a federal judge ruled on Friday, November 20, 2026. In a 47-page decision and order, U.S. District Judge Byron B. Conway refused to dismiss their Title IX claims in the Oconto Falls lawsuit. He held that a school board can be liable for its own policy of deliberate indifference to sex discrimination, even when no official knew of a particular student’s abuse.
The same order dismissed the former students’ constitutional claims and a retaliation claim over a letter the board sent to district families. Everything the former students say remains an allegation, and no court has decided whether it’s true. Here’s what the judge decided in the Oconto Falls lawsuit, what it means for survivors who sue their schools, and what students and parents can do now.
01
What the judge decided in the Oconto Falls lawsuit
The order’s final paragraphs settle it. “The motion is denied with respect to Counts 1 through 3 and Counts 5 and 6 and granted in all other respects,” Judge Conway wrote.
Counts 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6 are the Title IX claims of five former students: Amanda Watzka, Grace Williams, Brooke La Count, Kayla Kasper and Jesse Kasal. Those Title IX claims go forward. Count 7, a Title IX retaliation claim, and Count 8, a constitutional claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, are dismissed.
WLUK’s report on Saturday led with the claims the judge threw out. Those dismissals are real, but they’re the smaller half of the Oconto Falls lawsuit ruling.
02
The Oconto Falls lawsuit ruling at a glance
- Title IX claims of five former students: go forward, on what the judge calls a pre-assault official policy theory.
- Constitutional bodily-integrity claims under Section 1983: dismissed for all plaintiffs.
- Title IX retaliation claim over the board’s letter to families: dismissed.
- The only minor plaintiff: dismissed as a party, because the judge rejected both of her claims.
03
Who is suing, and what they say happened
The Oconto Falls lawsuit is formally Watzka et al. v. The Board of Education of Oconto Falls Public School District, No. 1:26-cv-00392, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin. The board is the only defendant. No teacher or coach is a party.
According to the order, Watzka alleges a tech education teacher groomed her over three years and sexually assaulted her in 2012. La Count alleges an assistant volleyball coach began abusing her in 2013, when she was 15. Williams alleges the same coach made sexual advances toward her at the coach’s home in 2018, when she was 17.
Kasper alleges years of sexual misconduct by one teacher and sex-based favoritism by another before she graduated in 2012. She never reported it, “believing that no one would act on her report,” the order says. Kasal alleges a drama teacher subjected him to repeated massages in his junior and senior years, conduct the judge said would plausibly amount to sexual assault.
The third amended complaint in the Oconto Falls lawsuit goes further. It describes “thirty-five years of sexual abuse, grooming, and misconduct” and alleges that at least twelve teachers and staff members groomed or abused at least twenty-one identified victims between 1988 and 2025. The judge called these “merely allegations that neither the defendant nor the individuals accused of wrongdoing have had an opportunity to challenge.”
04
Why the usual Title IX path failed
Title IX bars sex discrimination in federally funded education. But a school isn’t automatically liable when a teacher abuses a student. Under Supreme Court precedent, a student can recover money only when an official with “authority to institute corrective measures” knew of the abuse and was deliberately indifferent.
That bar is high. The order quotes the Seventh Circuit calling it “difficult to meet,” and says deliberate indifference “amounts to a standard of criminal recklessness.”
Each Title IX claim in the Oconto Falls lawsuit failed on that path. One former student had confided in a teacher, but the judge found no sign the teacher had power to act for the board. Wisconsin teachers must report suspected abuse to law enforcement or child protective services, the order notes, “not school administrators.” Another student’s report reached a school resource officer, who works for the local police department, not the district.
05
What a pre-assault official policy claim is
The Title IX claims in the Oconto Falls lawsuit survived on a second path, which the judge calls a pre-assault official policy theory. Instead of asking whether the board knew about one student’s abuse, it asks whether the board’s own way of handling sexual misconduct was itself discrimination.
“Neither the Supreme Court nor the Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit has directly considered this theory of liability,” the order says. But the Sixth, Ninth and Tenth Circuits “have accepted variations of the theory,” along with a handful of district courts in the Seventh Circuit.
The best-known version is the Ninth Circuit’s 2020 decision in Karasek, against the University of California. Judge Conway agreed with its core. “The court agrees that a pre-assault official policy claim is cognizable under Title IX,” he wrote.
06
How the judge narrowed the theory
Judge Conway’s version is “perhaps somewhat narrower” than the Ninth Circuit’s. The reason is a 2022 decision by the full Seventh Circuit, which held that “Title IX does not permit institutional liability based solely on knowledge of the risk of future misconduct.”
So the judge dropped one piece of the Ninth Circuit’s test, the idea that a policy “created a heightened risk.” Under his reading, a former student must show three things. The school kept a policy, formal or informal, of deliberate indifference to sex discrimination. That policy caused the student to suffer discrimination by a teacher or another person. And the harm was severe enough to cut the student off from their education.
Courts “must scrupulously and narrowly apply this exception,” he wrote, so the theory doesn’t turn into automatic liability for whatever an employee does. That’s the bar every plaintiff in the Oconto Falls lawsuit now has to clear.
07
Why a school’s silence can itself be discrimination
The judge’s reasoning reaches something many survivors know in their bones. He asked readers to consider a school with a policy of never investigating reports of sex discrimination, or of punishing any student who reports it. “Either policy would both embolden perpetrators and deter victims from seeking redress,” he wrote.
Under the usual rule, such a school might never be liable, because no one would dare report. The judge called that an “absurd result.” Policies like these violate Title IX, he wrote, “because they are themselves discriminatory.”
If you were ever told to keep quiet, or watched someone punished for speaking up, this is the legal name for what you felt. A school’s silence isn’t neutral. That’s the idea at the center of the Oconto Falls lawsuit, and a federal court has said it can be the discrimination itself.
08
The judge’s doubts, and why the claims survived anyway
This isn’t a finding that the board did anything wrong. “Watzka’s allegations leave significant doubt as to whether she will ultimately be able to prove” that the board kept such a policy, he wrote.
For many incidents in the Oconto Falls lawsuit, there’s no allegation that any administrator knew, he said. Others “reflect negligence” at best. He called the board’s promotion of an employee despite teachers’ allegations of sexually inappropriate conduct perhaps “the highest profile and most relevant incident,” yet wrote that “Title IX does not require schools to blacklist professionals based on any accusation of sexual misconduct.”
So why did these Title IX claims survive? The board argued only that the theory isn’t available at all, not that these former students had failed to plead it. “Accordingly, the issues identified above are not properly before the court,” the judge wrote.
09
Why time limits matter for survivors in Wisconsin
Many survivors don’t come forward for years, so the clock matters. Under Wisconsin Statutes section 893.53, which governs these federal claims, the deadline was six years until April 5, 2018, when the legislature cut it to three. For a claim that arose while the survivor was a minor, the clock doesn’t start until the survivor becomes an adult, the order says.
In the Oconto Falls lawsuit, the policy theory made a real difference. A claim based on a teacher’s knowledge would be too late, the judge wrote, because Watzka “for more than a decade” knew of her injury and the basis for the board’s liability.
But the judge ruled that a pre-assault official policy claim doesn’t accrue until a student knows, or has reason to know, about the school’s policy. Watzka alleged she didn’t learn of it until 2025. Whether that’s true can’t be decided on a motion to dismiss.
10
Why the constitutional claims were dismissed
The Oconto Falls lawsuit also claimed, under Section 1983, that the board violated the former students’ Fourteenth Amendment right to bodily integrity.
The judge agreed that “any manner or degree of sexual assault violates due process,” and found that several of the alleged acts would plausibly count as sexual assault under Wisconsin law. But a school board is liable under Section 1983 only for its own policy or custom.
Describing the policy as indifference to all sexual misconduct “proceeds at too high of a level of generality,” he wrote. And none of the former students in the Oconto Falls lawsuit plausibly tied their harm to a board policy or custom.
He found what Kasper described “certainly inappropriate” but not severe enough to violate the Constitution. What the minor plaintiff alleged was “offensive and inappropriate,” he wrote, but not a constitutional violation.
11
The letter to families and the retaliation claim
On April 1, 2026, the day after the second amended complaint in the Oconto Falls lawsuit was filed, the board sent a statement to district families, the complaint says. It spoke of “the plaintiffs who were actually victimized by the misconduct of individuals.” It also said, “A Google search reveals just how this Chicago attorney licensed by the Illinois State Bar tends to practice.”
The former students’ lawyer is Cass T. Casper of the Disparti Law Group, according to the complaint. Judge Conway called the board’s comments about him “decidedly outside the norms of litigation.” He said it was hard to read them as anything but “transparent attempts to garner disdain and suspicion for counsel for being from outside the local community.”
Still, he ruled the statement wasn’t severe enough to count as retaliation. Quoting a 2018 Fourth Circuit decision, he wrote that “an educational institution and its administrators are entitled to defend against accusations of discrimination.”
One part of the retaliation ruling reaches survivors far beyond the Oconto Falls lawsuit. The judge held that former students can bring such claims, because “retaliation that deters former students from seeking redress for past discrimination is proscribed by Title IX.”
12
What the school board argues
The board says its defense in the Oconto Falls lawsuit is about the law, not the conduct. It filed its motion “not to argue that sexual misconduct is acceptable or ever tolerated in its schools,” its brief says, but because “as a matter of law it cannot be financially liable for the acts of reprehensible teachers.”
“Teachers who engage in sexual misconduct should face consequences,” the brief says. In its reply brief, the board argued “it is unlikely that the Seventh Circuit would recognize such a claim.”
In its April statement, the board said the allegations had either never reached a school official or had been “previously investigated and either resulted in corrective action or found to lack merit.” It added, “We want to reiterate our support for those who have been victimized.”
13
Two criminal cases connected to the Oconto Falls lawsuit
Separately, two former staff members named in the Oconto Falls lawsuit have faced criminal charges. They’re the only staff members Bloom names.
Brynn Larsen, the former substitute teacher and volleyball coach whom La Count and Williams accuse, pleaded no contest to a reduced charge of third-degree sexual assault and was sentenced in April 2021 to two years in prison, WLUK reported. Wisconsin Public Radio reported that the plea was for the assault of La Count. Williams’s allegations about the coach remain allegations.
Gayle Gander, the drama teacher Kasal accuses, was an English teacher and director of the performing arts center. He faces 11 charges involving seven students, including child enticement and sexual misconduct by a school staff member, WLUK reported in April. He has pleaded not guilty and is presumed innocent. WLUK reports a plea hearing is scheduled for March 9.
WPR reported in June that the other staff members named in the complaint hadn’t been criminally charged, so Bloom refers to them by role only.
14
What the ruling means for Wisconsin and the Seventh Circuit
A district judge’s ruling in the Oconto Falls lawsuit binds only this case. But it’s a careful written decision that other judges can weigh, and it arrives where the Seventh Circuit hasn’t spoken.
For survivors, the Oconto Falls lawsuit offers a road map. Under this ruling, a Title IX claim doesn’t always have to prove that a principal knew about one student. It can ask whether the school’s whole pattern of response was the discrimination. That road is narrow, and the judge said so.
Wisconsin lawmakers have acted, too. In March 2026, Gov. Tony Evers signed two grooming bills, WPR reported, including one that requires school policies and training on how staff communicate with students.
15
What Title IX requires of schools before abuse happens
Every federally funded school must name at least one employee as its “Title IX Coordinator,” federal regulations say. Schools must tell students and parents that person’s name or title, office address, email and phone number, and display it on the school’s website.
“Any person may report sex discrimination, including sexual harassment,” the rule says, and a report “may be made at any time.”
The U.S. Department of Education says Title IX covers “sex-based harassment,” “sexual violence” and “retaliation,” on its Title IX page. In Wisconsin, all school employees are also mandated reporters of suspected child abuse, WPR reported.
16
What happens next in the Oconto Falls lawsuit
The former students argued they’re entitled to “the opportunity for discovery, evidentiary hearings or even a trial,” the board’s reply brief noted. For five claims in the Oconto Falls lawsuit, that door is open. Unless the court sets a different time, a defendant whose motion to dismiss is denied must answer within 14 days after notice, under Rule 12.
To win, each former student must prove what the judge doubted: a real policy of deliberate indifference, and a link between that policy and their harm. Whether the claims were filed in time is still open. The former students have demanded a jury trial, their complaint says.
The court’s case page posts the major filings in the Oconto Falls lawsuit, and Bloom will follow it.
17
A timeline of the Oconto Falls lawsuit
Key dates, from the court’s records, WLUK and WPR:
- 2012: Watzka alleges a teacher sexually assaulted her.
- 2013: La Count alleges a coach began abusing her; a report to the athletic director led to a talk about “boundaries,” the order says.
- 2014: Police investigate; the coach and the student both deny a sexual relationship.
- 2018: Williams alleges the same coach made sexual advances toward her.
- April 2021: The coach, Larsen, is sentenced to two years in prison.
- March 11, 2026: Former students file the Oconto Falls lawsuit.
- April 1, 2026: The board sends its statement to district families.
- May 13, 2026: The judge allows a third amended complaint.
- November 20, 2026: The judge lets five Title IX claims go forward.
- March 9: A plea hearing is scheduled in Gander’s criminal case, WLUK reports.
18
What students and parents can do
You don’t need a lawsuit to use your rights:
- Find your school’s Title IX coordinator. The name and contact details must be on the school’s website and in its handbook.
- Report in writing to someone with power to act. The Oconto Falls lawsuit ruling shows that telling a teacher or a school resource officer may not count as telling the school board. Write to the Title IX coordinator, the principal or the superintendent, and keep a copy.
- If a child may be in danger, contact law enforcement or child protective services. In Wisconsin, “contact the county or tribe where the child or child’s family lives,” the Department of Children and Families says.
- File with the Office for Civil Rights. “Anyone may file a complaint,” and it must ordinarily be filed “within 180 days of the last act of discrimination,” OCR says.
- Ask a lawyer about deadlines early. Wisconsin’s three-year limit, and when the clock starts, shaped the Oconto Falls lawsuit.
- Get support. RAINN’s hotline is 800-656-4673. Oregon Child Abuse Hotline: 855-503-SAFE (855-503-7233).
19
A pattern Bloom has followed this week
Bloom reported this week that Minnesota found Bemidji schools failed to protect students from staff, and that California was warned about three educators and let them keep working.
Bloom also reported on four men suing Glen Mills Schools and Pennsylvania over childhood abuse. Each asks the question at the heart of the Oconto Falls lawsuit: what does an institution owe a child before anyone is brave enough to report?
20
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with every survivor who’s been told to stay quiet. I believe a child who finds the courage to speak deserves an adult who listens, and a school that acts.
If this story stirs up your own memories, you aren’t alone. Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call at any hour, and Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading 47-page rulings like the Oconto Falls lawsuit decision so survivors don’t have to, and a one-time gift helps too.
21
Frequently Asked Questions
Judge Byron B. Conway let the Title IX claims of five former students go forward on November 20, 2026. He dismissed their constitutional claims under Section 1983 and a Title IX retaliation claim.
Only the Board of Education of Oconto Falls Public School District. No teacher or coach is a defendant.
It’s a Title IX theory that a school can be liable for its own policy of deliberate indifference to sex discrimination, if that policy caused a student’s harm. The student doesn’t have to prove that an official knew about their specific abuse.
No. At this stage a court assumes the allegations are true. The judge wrote that Watzka’s allegations leave significant doubt she can prove such a policy.
Write to your school’s Title IX coordinator, and contact law enforcement or child protective services if a child may be in danger. You can also file with the Office for Civil Rights, ordinarily within 180 days.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Wisconsin Legislature · 20 November 2026Madison Prosecutor Won’t Charge Officer Who Killed Corey Ruiz
Wisconsin Legislature · 20 November 2026Wisconsin Judge Won’t Undo ADA Absentee Ruling, Orders Mediation
Disability advocacy · 16 November 2026Medicaid Expansion Is Back on the Table in Four States. Can It Pass?