
Newsroom·Trans advocacy·News
Kelantan Charges Trans Woman With ‘Posing as a Woman’ Over a Kaftan
A trans woman in Kelantan, Malaysia, pleaded not guilty Sunday to "posing as a woman" by allegedly wearing a long kaftan, a charge that carries up to two years in prison. She's due back in court January 24, 2027.
A trans woman in the Malaysian state of Kelantan pleaded not guilty on Sunday, November 22, 2026, to a charge of posing as a woman, which prosecutors say she committed by wearing a long, ankle-length kaftan with shoulder-length hair. The charge, under Section 19(1) of the Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code (I) Enactment 2019, carries a fine of up to RM3,000, up to two years in prison, or both, Malaysia’s national news agency, Bernama, reported.
Prosecutors first charged her with “changing gender” and then replaced it with the posing as a woman charge, the rights group Justice for Sisters says, and it wants every charge against trans women in Kelantan dropped. She’s free on bail and due back in court on January 24, 2027. Here’s what the law says, what Malaysia’s own courts have said about laws like it, and why a rule about what a person may wear in one Malaysian state reaches trans people far beyond it.
01
The posing as a woman case at a glance
Seven facts from the record:
- The charge: posing as a woman, under Section 19(1) of the Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code (I) Enactment 2019.
- The allegation: wearing a long, ankle-length kaftan with shoulder-length hair at a homestay in Kampung Hutan Pasir, Ketereh, at midnight on January 14, 2026.
- The plea: not guilty to posing as a woman, entered Sunday before Judge Wan Mohd Firdaus W. Ibrahim of the Kota Bharu Lower Syariah Court.
- The penalty if convicted: a fine of up to RM3,000, up to two years in prison, or both.
- Bail: RM1,500 with two sureties.
- The next date: January 24, 2027, for mention.
- The earlier charge: “changing gender” under Section 18 of the same law, according to Justice for Sisters.
02
What happened in the Kota Bharu court
The hearing took place at the Lower Syariah Court in Kota Bharu. Sunday is a working day there. Weekends in Kelantan fall on Friday and Saturday, “allowing residents to perform Friday prayers without hindrance,” The Star has reported.
The posing as a woman charge was read out before Judge Wan Mohd Firdaus W. Ibrahim, and she pleaded not guilty, Bernama reported. Kelantan Deputy Syariah Prosecutor Syafika Mat Husin conducted the prosecution, and two Syariah lawyers represented her.
Everything in the charge is an allegation. She has pleaded not guilty, and no court has found that she did anything at all. As Bernama reported it, the charge of posing as a woman describes a garment, a hairstyle, a place and an hour. It doesn’t allege that anyone was harmed.
03
Why Bloom isn’t printing her name
Bernama’s report on the posing as a woman case names her and calls her a man. Bloom follows Justice for Sisters in calling her a trans woman, and we aren’t printing her name, her age or any detail that could identify her beyond what the charge itself alleges.
Justice for Sisters asked the press for that care. In its statement, the group urged the media to use “appropriate terminology” and to avoid sensational coverage of court cases involving trans people, Free Malaysia Today reported. The group said it had documented serious consequences, including self-harm, from coverage that misgenders trans women.
“We strongly urge the media to end media tabloid practices, including persistent pursuit to capture trans women’s photos,” the group said, according to Focus Malaysia. You won’t find her photo here.
04
What the posing as a woman law says
Section 19 of the Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code (I) Enactment 2019 is titled “Male person posing as female.” Its first subsection makes it an offence for any man who “wears woman attire or poses or acts like a woman,” according to the enactment’s English text.
Kelantan’s posing as a woman offence reaches beyond the street. It covers conduct “in any public place or in any private place publicly visible or accessible,” the text says. The English text doesn’t define “woman attire.” The enactment applies in Kelantan and to Muslims only, and where the Malay and English versions conflict, the Malay version prevails.
Section 19 doesn’t stop at fines and prison. A court that convicts may, instead of or on top of a sentence, order up to 240 hours of community service. It may also order a person into counselling, or to be held for up to six months in a rehabilitation centre, Islamic counselling centre, charitable home, mosque or similar institution.
That order is “for the purpose of education and the person shall repent in accordance with hukum syarak,” the section says. Hukum syarak is Islamic law as the enactment applies it. Section 20 mirrors Section 19 for “any woman who wears man attire or poses or acts like a man.”
05
From “changing gender” to posing as a woman
Justice for Sisters says the Kelantan Syariah prosecution department amended the charge against her. It first charged her with changing gender under Section 18 of the Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code, then replaced that with the posing as a woman charge under Section 19, Free Malaysia Today reported.
Section 18 makes it an offence for any person who “changes his or her gender,” or changes another person’s gender, “without syarii cause,” a phrase that means without a reason Islamic law accepts. Justice for Sisters said Section 18 could let authorities carry out unnecessary medical examinations to decide a person’s gender.
In February 2026, Malaysian outlets reported that a Kelantan Syariah court had handled its first case under Section 18. A source from the state’s Islamic religious affairs department said the person was detained during an operation at an event involving a group of trans people, The Star reported, citing Sinar Harian.
The published reports don’t say whether that February case and Sunday’s hearing involve the same woman, and Bloom can’t confirm it. At the time, a Kelantan state executive councillor, Mohd Asri Mat Daud, declined to share details. “In this matter, I have to safeguard all parties who are being acted against,” he said, according to The Star.
06
What Justice for Sisters is asking for
Justice for Sisters is a Malaysian rights group that works with trans and gender diverse people. In its statement on the posing as a woman charge, the group said both Section 18 and Section 19 violate rights the Federal Constitution guarantees, including equality, personal liberty, dignity and freedom of expression, Free Malaysia Today reported.
“These laws deeply violate the ability of trans and gender diverse people to self-determine their identity,” the group said. It said Section 19, the posing as a woman provision, criminalises trans women for their gender identity and gender expression.
The group described both laws as “deeply problematic and violate fundamental rights safeguarded under the Federal Constitution,” Focus Malaysia reported. Justice for Sisters called for:
- all charges against trans women in Kelantan to be dropped;
- the state to review the two provisions;
- a moratorium on enforcing them;
- ethical, factual reporting on court cases involving trans people.
In February, the group’s founder, Thilaga Sulathireh, was monitoring the first changing gender case closely. She warned that such laws open up more space for “violations of privacy, personal integrity, and autonomy over our own bodies,” The Rakyat Post reported.
07
How Malaysia’s two court systems work
To understand a posing as a woman charge, it helps to know that Malaysia runs two legal tracks side by side. “Sharia courts interpret and apply Islamic law and secular courts rule on civil and criminal matters,” BenarNews explained. State legislatures pass the Islamic laws, and Parliament passes the secular ones.
That’s why one state can write its own offences for its Muslim residents. Kelantan’s 2019 enactment was gazetted in 2020, The Rakyat Post reported. It came into force in November 2021 with 68 sections, 33 more than the version passed in 1985, Malay Mail reported.
In 2022, groups including Sisters in Islam, Legal Dignity and Justice for Sisters released a report accusing the enactment of “further victimising groups who are already marginalised,” Malay Mail reported. The report named single women, people in the beauty trade and trans women among those it targets.
08
A court once struck down a law like this
Kelantan’s posing as a woman law isn’t the first of its kind to reach Malaysia’s courts. The southern state of Negeri Sembilan had Section 66 of its Syariah Criminal Enactment 1992. It punished “any male person who in any public place wears a woman’s attire or poses as a woman,” Human Rights Watch reported.
Three trans women who’d been charged under Section 66 repeatedly brought the challenge. They lost in the Seremban High Court in 2012. Then, on November 7, 2014, a three-judge Court of Appeal panel ruled unanimously in their favor.
“We hold Section 66 of the Negri Sembilan Shariah Criminal Enactment 1992 as invalid and unconstitutional,” Justice Mohd Hishamuddin Mohd Yunus said, according to Malay Mail. The court found the law violated personal liberty, equality, freedom of movement and freedom of expression.
The judges called the ban “degrading, oppressive and inhuman,” Human Rights Watch reported. They wrote that trans people would break the law “the very moment they leave their homes to attend to the basic needs of life.”
09
Then the Federal Court set it aside
The victory didn’t last. On October 8, 2015, Malaysia’s Federal Court reversed the ruling “on wholly procedural grounds,” Human Rights Watch reported. The court said the women should have sought permission from a Federal Court judge when they began their challenge.
“The court has thrust trans people back into a legal limbo,” said Aston Paiva, the women’s lawyer. The Federal Court didn’t decide whether the law was constitutional. It ruled on how the case had been brought.
Justice for Sisters says the story didn’t end there. In the 2019 case of Alma Nudo Atenza, a nine-judge Federal Court panel described the 2015 decision as per incuriam, or wrongly decided, the group said, according to Free Malaysia Today. The group cites that history in its case against the posing as a woman charge in Kelantan.
10
What the Nik Elin ruling decided, and what it didn’t
On February 9, 2024, Malaysia’s Federal Court ruled 8-1 that 16 provisions of the Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code were “void and invalid,” BenarNews reported. The case was brought by a lawyer, Nik Elin Zurina Nik Abdul Rashid, and her daughter. “It also shows that the federal constitution is supreme,” she said after the ruling.
The court’s reasoning was about power, not religion. The question was whether the Kelantan legislative assembly had acted within the powers the Federal Constitution gives states, The Rakyat Post reported. Then Chief Justice Tun Tengku Maimun Tuan Mat said “the decision does not undermine the position of Islam or the Shariah Court in the country.”
Malaysia’s religious affairs minister, Mohd Na’im, said the position of the “Sharia court in Malaysia is steadfast,” BenarNews reported. Neither Section 18 nor Section 19 was among the 16 provisions struck down, according to a list published by Malay Mail. The posing as a woman section stayed on the books.
11
Kelantan’s new Syariah law
In August 2026, Kelantan’s state assembly passed the Syariah Criminal Offences (Kelantan) Bill 2026, The Star reported. It replaces the 16 provisions the Federal Court struck down.
The new law keeps offences much like the changing gender and posing as a woman sections. It prohibits Muslim men from wearing women’s clothing, or attire traditionally associated with women, or behaving like a woman in public or in places visible to the public, The Star reported. A matching clause covers women. Both carry a maximum fine of RM3,000, up to two years in jail, or both.
Bloom couldn’t confirm from the published reports whether the new law has taken effect. Sunday’s posing as a woman charge was framed under the 2019 enactment, Bernama reported.
12
A timeline of the posing as a woman law and this case
These dates come from the court report and the outlets cited here:
- October 11, 2012: The Seremban High Court rejects a challenge by trans women.
- November 7, 2014: The Court of Appeal declares Section 66 unconstitutional.
- October 8, 2015: The Federal Court reverses on procedural grounds.
- 2019: In Alma Nudo Atenza, the Federal Court calls the 2015 decision per incuriam, according to Justice for Sisters.
- 2020: Kelantan’s Syariah Criminal Code (I) Enactment 2019 is gazetted, and it comes into force in November 2021.
- February 9, 2024: The Federal Court strikes down 16 Kelantan provisions, 8-1.
- January 14, 2026: The date of the alleged conduct in this case.
- February 4, 2026: Outlets report Kelantan’s first Section 18 “changing gender” case.
- August 2026: Kelantan’s assembly passes a new Syariah offences bill.
- November 22, 2026: A not-guilty plea to the posing as a woman charge.
- January 24, 2027: The case returns for mention.
13
Why a law about clothing reaches trans people everywhere
A posing as a woman law can sound like a local quirk. It isn’t. The Human Dignity Trust, a legal charity based in London, counts 13 countries that criminalise the gender identity or gender expression of trans people with “cross-dressing,” “impersonation” and “disguise” laws, its criminalisation map says. Malaysia is one of them.
Within Malaysia, Kelantan’s posing as a woman offence isn’t unique. In 2014, Human Rights Watch reported that all 13 Malaysian states prohibited Muslim men from dressing as women. “The laws, enforced by state Islamic Religious Departments, do not define what constitutes transgender dressing or posing,” it said.
The United States has its own history. In 1848, Columbus, Ohio, barred anyone from appearing in public “in a dress not belonging to his or her sex,” PBS NewsHour reported. More than 40 U.S. cities passed similar laws in the decades that followed.
PBS opened its timeline with the 2014 Malaysian ruling, and it noted that someone perceived as male could technically be arrested in New York for “impersonating a female” as recently as 2011. Most of those U.S. laws have since been overturned. “Arresting cross-dressing people was mainly just a form of police harassment,” Susan Stryker, then a University of Arizona professor, told PBS.
A rule about clothing never needs to name trans people to fall on them. It falls on whoever is seen, and a trans woman is seen every time she leaves home in the clothes that are hers.
Bloom has reported this week on how governments decide who counts. In India, West Bengal Police will vet who counts as transgender for state jobs, and India’s Supreme Court ordered Delhi to drop gender from teacher job ads. In Europe, Portugal is weighing repeal of its Self-Determination Act.
14
Faith, law and dignity
Bloom is a ministry, and we take religious law seriously. Kelantan’s Syariah courts are part of how many Malaysian Muslims order their lives, and Malaysia’s then Chief Justice was careful to say that striking down state provisions didn’t undermine Islam or its courts. This story isn’t a story about a faith. It’s a story about what a state does, in its name, to one woman charged with posing as a woman.
Challenges to the enactment have come from within Malaysia’s Muslim community too. Malay Mail described the 2024 challengers as a “Muslim duo,” and Sisters in Islam joined the 2022 report. Faith and dignity aren’t rivals, and many believers in every tradition hold both.
I believe no one should face prison for the clothes they wear, and that a woman’s dignity doesn’t depend on a court agreeing she’s a woman.
15
What happens next
The case returns to the Kota Bharu Lower Syariah Court for mention on January 24, 2027. A mention is a procedural date, not a trial. She remains free on bail of RM1,500 with two sureties.
If the posing as a woman charge goes to trial and ends in a conviction, the court could impose a fine of up to RM3,000, up to two years in prison, or both. Under Section 19(2), it could also order community service, counselling or up to six months in a rehabilitation centre, instead of or alongside that sentence.
Justice for Sisters has called for the posing as a woman charge to be dropped and for the state to review the law. Neither the Kelantan Syariah prosecution department nor the state government had responded publicly as of Sunday, in the reports Bloom read. Bloom will report the January date.
16
What you can do
From far away, you can still do something real:
- Don’t share her name or her photograph. If a post you see names or misgenders her, don’t amplify it.
- Use the words she and Justice for Sisters use: she’s a trans woman, and the posing as a woman charge is an allegation.
- Read the posing as a woman law yourself. Section 19 of the Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code is short and public.
- Talk about gender expression in your own community, including your congregation.
- Watch for January 24, 2027, and for any word from Justice for Sisters on whether the charge stands.
- If this news hits close to home, reach out. Trans Lifeline is at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, and you can call or text 988.
17
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reports on trans lives around the world, from Delhi to Lisbon to Kota Bharu, because a law in one place teaches every other place what’s possible. Bloom will keep following the posing as a woman case. This month we also reported on the 62 trans people remembered in this year’s Remembrance Report.
If this story leaves you afraid or grieving, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call any hour. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached. A monthly gift keeps this reporting going week after week, and a one-time gift helps too.
18
Frequently Asked Questions
It’s an offence under Section 19(1) of the Kelantan Syariah Criminal Code (I) Enactment 2019. It applies to any man who wears woman attire or poses or acts like a woman in public, or in a private place visible or accessible to the public.
Prosecutors allege she was posing as a woman by wearing a long, ankle-length kaftan with shoulder-length hair at a homestay in Ketereh at midnight on January 14, 2026. She pleaded not guilty on November 22, 2026.
A fine of up to RM3,000, up to two years in prison, or both. The court can also order community service, counselling or up to six months in a rehabilitation centre.
Justice for Sisters says prosecutors first charged her with changing gender under Section 18, then amended it to posing as a woman under Section 19. The published reports don’t explain why.
In February 2024, it struck down 16 provisions as beyond the state’s powers. Sections 18 and 19 weren’t among them.
Yes. In 2014, the Court of Appeal declared Negeri Sembilan’s Section 66, a similar posing as a woman law, unconstitutional, but the Federal Court set that ruling aside on procedural grounds in 2015.
The posing as a woman case returns to the Kota Bharu Lower Syariah Court for mention on January 24, 2027.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Trans advocacy · 22 November 2026West Bengal Police to Vet Who Counts as Transgender for State Jobs
New York Legislature · 22 November 2026Liverpool Superintendent Apologizes but Keeps Gender Memo in Place
Trans advocacy · 21 November 2026India’s Top Court Orders Delhi to Drop Gender From Teacher Job Ads