
Newsroom·Kentucky Legislature·News
Kentucky SB 150 Trial Ends as Trans Students Await a Judge’s Ruling
Transgender students and their families finished making their case against Kentucky's SB 150 school rules on Friday. Now a Lexington judge decides, after written briefs due December 21.
Transgender students in Lexington, Kentucky, finished making their case against SB 150 on Friday, November 20, 2026, and now they wait. The evidence closed Friday afternoon in the SB 150 trial in Fayette Circuit Court, where students aged 10 to 17 and their families argue the 2023 law’s school rules violate the Kentucky Constitution, the Lexington Herald-Leader reported.
There were no closing arguments. Lawyers have 30 days to file written briefs, due December 21, and a decision “could be weeks away,” the Herald-Leader reported. Judge Julie Muth Goodman, who heard the case without a jury, also refused requests from the state and the school district to throw the case out. Here is what the five days of testimony showed, what the judge must decide, and what comes next.
Following this story: Kentucky’s SB 150. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.
01
What happened at the SB 150 trial
The SB 150 trial began Monday, November 16, before Judge Goodman as a bench trial. In a bench trial, there’s no jury: the judge hears the evidence and decides the outcome alone, the Herald-Leader explained.
Over five days, Goodman heard from parents, students and social psychologists about how SB 150 did, or didn’t, affect students in Fayette County Public Schools. The families sued the Kentucky attorney general’s office and the school district, according to the Herald-Leader.
The students and their families first sued the Fayette County Board of Education and the attorney general’s office in September 2023, The Advocate reported, citing the Herald-Leader. That means the SB 150 trial comes more than three years after the case began. Bloom reported on the start of the SB 150 trial last week.
02
What SB 150 does in Kentucky schools
SB 150 passed in 2023 over Gov. Andy Beshear’s veto. Beshear vetoed it on March 24, 2023, and it became law five days later when the legislature overrode him, The Advocate reported.
The law reaches far beyond schools. It bans gender-affirming care for trans minors, restricts classroom teaching on gender and sexuality, bars districts from asking teachers and staff to use a trans student’s pronouns, and requires districts to adopt restroom policies that keep trans students out of restrooms matching their gender, according to the Herald-Leader.
This case targets the school provisions. SB 150 requires school boards to adopt restroom policies based on sex assigned at birth, and it bars districts from requiring staff or students to use pronouns that differ from the sex on a student’s original birth certificate, The Advocate reported. More than 40,000 students attend public schools in Fayette County, according to the district’s website, as The Advocate noted.
03
What the families are asking
The plaintiffs, all of whom attended Fayette County schools, say SB 150 violates their fundamental right to public education, their right to privacy, free speech, freedom of thought and rights of conscience, the Herald-Leader reported.
The families are asking Judge Goodman to block the rules from being enforced, WUKY reported, citing the Herald-Leader.
These are state constitutional claims, brought in a state court. That matters. The federal courts have been an uncertain place for trans students lately, and families in several states have turned to their own state constitutions for protection.
04
What the students told the judge
One of the transgender students, identified in court only by the pseudonym “Child Noe,” testified about his life at school since SB 150 took effect, the Herald-Leader reported. The Advocate described him as a 17-year-old transgender boy. Bloom uses only the name the court uses.
Under the school’s policy, Noe may use only the girls’ restroom or a gender-neutral one, the Herald-Leader reported. He said there are only three gender-neutral restrooms at his school, so using one can mean waiting in line and risking being late to class.
So he goes once a day, if at all. He testified that he holds off drinking water at school so he won’t need a restroom, according to the Herald-Leader. On school trips, he said, he was required to sleep in a separate area near the girls.
“It affected me in the way that not only have I lived under this law, but I have lived through it,” Noe said, according to the Herald-Leader. “I have watched it be developed and added to.”
He described what it’s like to be the subject of a public argument. “I have watched people sit in a room and argue about who I am and who my parents are,” he told the court. “It is hurtful, it is shameful.”
Noe’s testimony was some of the most direct evidence in the SB 150 trial about what the restroom rule means in practice. It’s one thing to read a statute. It’s another to hear a teenager explain the arithmetic of a school day built around a single restroom visit.
A teenager shouldn’t have to ration water to get through a school day. Whatever a court decides about the law, that testimony is a picture of what the SB 150 trial is about: not ideas, but children and their daily lives.
05
What a school employee saw
A Fayette County Public Schools employee testified that SB 150’s passage created confusion and fear among staff who didn’t know how to properly, or legally, interact with their students, the Herald-Leader reported.
Melissa Stewart, a dropout prevention and student success specialist, testified that teachers and students were fearful about using preferred pronouns and gender-affirming restrooms, and about teaching curriculum that promotes diversity. She previously worked as a unity specialist in the district’s office of student belonging and success, which supported LGBTQ+ students and other groups. That office no longer exists, the Herald-Leader reported.
“There are less conversations, and fear took hold in the classrooms and everything got a lot quieter,” Stewart said.
She also described what students lost when that office closed. Students from that group were no longer able to walk into the building and be seen by teachers “as who they were regardless of anything else,” she testified, according to the Herald-Leader.
The district itself acknowledged the change in a court filing. A transgender student had been able to use the girls’ restroom until the state law required the district to stop allowing her to do so, the district said, according to The Advocate, citing the Herald-Leader. That filing sits at the center of the SB 150 trial: a school that had found a way to include a student, until the legislature told it not to.
06
The state’s defense
The defense called its own experts on Thursday and Friday, including social psychologists who testified that SB 150 doesn’t harm students, according to the Herald-Leader.
The attorney general’s office argued the law wasn’t designed to hinder transgender students but to protect the free speech rights of students, teachers and staff. “There is no authority in Kentucky that says under state constitution that speech can be compelled from a speaker that believes they are false,” said Aaron Silletto, a lawyer for the office, according to the Herald-Leader.
Silletto argued that the pronoun rule “only impacts those who would have a disagreement with those pronouns and preferred names.” In other words, the state’s position in the SB 150 trial is that the law protects people who don’t want to use a student’s pronouns, and that the state constitution doesn’t allow the government to compel that speech.
Supporters of the law have long framed the restroom rules as common sense. When the bill passed in 2023, Sen. Max Wise told colleagues “there are school districts that cannot legislate on their own common sense in bathrooms and locker rooms and shower rooms,” WUKY reported.
07
The school district’s position
Fayette County Public Schools argued it shouldn’t be in the case at all. The district was just following the law the General Assembly passed, and there’s nothing it can do, said Susan Sears, a lawyer for the district, according to the Herald-Leader.
“Hands are tied, and we are caught in the crosshairs,” Sears said. She said the district “turned flips to try and accommodate the law,” and couldn’t think of other relief it could give the students beyond applying the policies the statute requires.
That argument puts the district in an unusual spot. Its own employee testified about fear in the classrooms, and its own filing described a student who lost restroom access because of SB 150. Yet the district says the law, not the district, is what the students should be fighting. The judge kept the district in the SB 150 trial for now.
08
The judge kept the case alive
After the families presented their evidence, the school district asked the court to dismiss it as a defendant, and the attorney general’s office asked that the claims be dismissed entirely, the Herald-Leader reported.
Goodman denied both requests. At the close of evidence, she told the lawyers that their thorough preparation had made a “tough decision” easier, according to the Herald-Leader.
Denying those motions doesn’t tell anyone how Goodman will rule. It does mean she’ll decide the SB 150 trial on the full record, after both sides file their briefs.
09
How Bloom is reporting the SB 150 trial
Court filings in this case aren’t online. A representative for the Fayette Circuit Court Civil Division told The Advocate that the office provides copies of case documents only in person or by mail.
So Bloom’s account of the SB 150 trial relies on reporters who sat in the courtroom, above all the Lexington Herald-Leader, with additional reporting from WUKY and The Advocate. Every quote in this story comes from their published reports, and Bloom will read the judge’s ruling itself when it’s issued.
10
Why the Kentucky Constitution matters here
Kentucky’s constitution includes an education provision, and the families are leaning on it. “Kentucky is one of the few states that actually has an education provision in their constitution,” Ernesto Scorsone, a former state lawmaker who serves on the board of Just Fund Kentucky, a group backing the students, told Fox 56, according to WUKY.
“It’s essential that part of that must include safety for kids. And that’s all kids, even trans kids,” Scorsone said.
The families also raise privacy, speech, thought and conscience claims under the state constitution, WUKY and the Herald-Leader reported. A ruling on those claims would interpret Kentucky’s own founding document, not federal law. Bloom reported this week on a similar path in Montana, where a state judge blocked SB 437, the law defining sex as binary.
11
What happens next in the SB 150 trial
Here is what comes next, based on the Herald-Leader’s reporting:
- December 21, 2026: Written briefs are due from both sides, 30 days after the evidence closed.
- After the briefs: Judge Goodman decides whether SB 150’s school restroom and pronoun rules violate the Kentucky Constitution. The Herald-Leader reported a decision could be weeks away.
- After the ruling: The losing side could ask a higher court to review it.
The briefs will be the lawyers’ last word. Each side will use the record from the SB 150 trial to argue what the Kentucky Constitution requires, and the judge will weigh five days of testimony against those arguments.
Until then, SB 150’s school rules remain in effect. Transgender students in Fayette County will keep living under the policies Noe described while the judge writes.
12
What the SB 150 trial means for families
For the families in this case, the SB 150 trial was a chance to be heard in full. Parents and students told a judge, under oath, what three years under the law have looked like. The state and the district answered. Now the record exists, whatever the ruling says.
For families elsewhere in Kentucky, the SB 150 trial is a reminder that the law’s school rules can be tested in court on the evidence. Judge Goodman’s ruling will apply to this case, but the questions she answers about the Kentucky Constitution, education, privacy and conscience will be read across the state.
And for trans students watching from anywhere, the SB 150 trial offers something harder to measure. Young people stood up in a courtroom and described their own lives in their own words. That takes courage at any age.
13
A timeline of the SB 150 trial
These dates come from The Advocate, the Herald-Leader and WUKY:
- March 24, 2023: Gov. Andy Beshear vetoes SB 150.
- March 29, 2023: The legislature overrides the veto, and SB 150 becomes law.
- September 2023: Lexington students and families sue the Fayette County Board of Education and the attorney general’s office.
- November 16, 2026: The SB 150 trial begins in Fayette Circuit Court.
- November 20, 2026: Evidence closes, and the judge denies motions to dismiss.
- December 21, 2026: Written briefs are due.
14
What you can do
If you’re a trans student in Kentucky, or you love one, here’s what you can do while the court decides:
- Know your school’s current policy. SB 150’s rules remain in effect until a court says otherwise.
- Keep a simple record if the policy affects your school day, such as missed class time. Families’ experiences were central evidence at this trial.
- Ask your school what accommodations exist, like gender-neutral restrooms, and where they are.
- Follow the SB 150 trial. Briefs are due December 21, and Bloom will report the ruling.
- If you’re struggling, reach out. Trans Lifeline answers at 877-565-8860, The Trevor Project at 1-866-488-7386, and 988 by call or text.
15
What Bloom is doing
Bloom stands with the students who told a Kentucky judge the truth about their school days, and with the parents who stood beside them. I believe no child should have to choose between a drink of water and getting to class on time, and I’m grateful these families had the courage to say so under oath.
If this news weighs on you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach any hour, and Bloom’s support groups are a place to be known. A monthly gift keeps Bloom in courtrooms like this one, and a one-time gift helps too.
16
Frequently Asked Questions
The evidence closed on November 20, 2026. There are no closing arguments; written briefs are due December 21, and then Judge Julie Muth Goodman will rule.
It challenges SB 150’s school restroom and pronoun rules under the Kentucky Constitution, including the rights to education, privacy, free speech, freedom of thought and conscience.
Transgender students aged 10 to 17 who attended Fayette County Public Schools, and their families. They sued the school district and the Kentucky attorney general’s office.
No. Goodman denied the school district’s request to be dismissed and the attorney general’s request to dismiss the claims.
There’s no set date. Briefs are due December 21, and the Herald-Leader reported a decision could be weeks away.
They aren’t online. The Fayette Circuit Court Civil Division provides copies only in person or by mail, The Advocate reported.
Yes. Its school rules remain in effect unless the court blocks them.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Kentucky Legislature · 15 November 2026Kentucky Families Take SB 150 to Trial Under the State Constitution
Legislation · 20 November 2026UK Tribunal Confirms Secret Order to Apple Over Encrypted Data
Justice for survivors · 20 November 2026Canada’s Supreme Court: Survivors Don’t Have to Say No for It to Count