
Newsroom·New Jersey Legislature·News
New Jersey Sues DHS Over Stonewalled Delaney Hall Civil Rights Probe
At least three people have died in custody at Delaney Hall. New Jersey says it has waited more than three months for Homeland Security to answer a subpoena about detainees' medical care, and now it's suing.
At least three people have died in custody at Delaney Hall, the privately run immigration jail in Newark. For more than three months, New Jersey says, the federal government has refused to answer a single subpoena asking how the people held there get medical care, so on Tuesday the state took Homeland Security to federal court.
Attorney General Jennifer Davenport’s lawsuit doesn’t ask a judge to close the facility. It asks a judge to make the Department of Homeland Security decide, at last, whether it will let the state see the records. In a statement, Davenport said that what her office has received from the company and the department “for months” is “plain stonewalling.”
01
What New Jersey is asking the court to do
The state wants a federal judge to declare that Homeland Security violated the Administrative Procedure Act by unreasonably delaying its response to the subpoena, and to set a deadline for the department to respond, the New Jersey Monitor reported. In the attorney general’s words, New Jersey is asking the court to compel DHS to communicate a decision on compliance.
The lawsuit names Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, David J. Venturella, a senior official at Immigration and Customs Enforcement, and their agencies as defendants, according to the Monitor.
That narrow request matters. The state isn’t yet asking a judge to rule on conditions inside Delaney Hall. It’s asking for the information it says it needs to finish a civil rights investigation that began in August. A deadline wouldn’t decide what the records show, but it would end the waiting.
02
What investigators say they have found
The investigation opened on August 7, 2026, under the New Jersey Civil Rights Act and the New Jersey Law Against Discrimination, according to the attorney general’s announcement. It focuses on whether employees of The GEO Group, which owns and operates Delaney Hall, violated the civil rights of people detained there.
Even without the records, the state says its investigation has identified reports of serious problems. The attorney general’s office listed them:
- deficiencies in medical intake and screening
- failures to provide medications for chronic conditions
- inadequate responses to medical emergencies
- failures to protect people from physical and sexual harm
- denial of accommodations for people with disabilities
- routine denial of language interpretation services
Detainees have also complained of buggy or improperly prepared food and of contagion controls too weak to stop illness from spreading, the Monitor reported. Based on what it has gathered so far, the state believes there is a serious risk of further harm to people held at Delaney Hall, “including additional death and disease,” the attorney general’s office said.
The disability finding deserves its own line. A person who uses a wheelchair, needs a hearing aid or depends on daily medication doesn’t stop needing those things in detention. Failing to accommodate a disability in a place where people can’t leave is a civil rights question in its own right.
03
Three deaths, a hunger strike and growing scrutiny
The state issued its subpoena after at least three people died in GEO Group’s custody at Delaney Hall, the attorney general’s office said. Public reports have alleged inadequate medical care, the rapid spread of communicable diseases and unreasonable exposure to violence, according to the office.
People held at Delaney Hall staged a hunger strike over treatment by guards last summer, and critics have called for the facility to close, the Monitor reported.
Yolanda N. Melville, director of the state’s Division on Civil Rights, said people held there and the families of those who died “have shared extremely troubling accounts.” Detention, she said, doesn’t strip anyone of their rights. People held there “do not waive their constitutional and legal right to receive adequate medical care or to be protected from violence,” Melville said, and the federal government’s silence “speaks volumes.”
Davenport put it plainly. “There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall,” she said, adding that the state will keep working to ensure “these civil detainees are treated with the dignity and decency that all people are entitled to under the law.”
04
Why the subpoena has gone unanswered
The subpoena went to GEO Group in August and sought records on the medical care provided to detainees, the attorney general’s office said. GEO Group declined to comply, saying Homeland Security’s internal regulations required the department’s authorization first, and said it had forwarded the subpoena to the department’s general counsel.
New Jersey disagrees. The state’s position is that GEO Group, as a private business operating on its own property within New Jersey, doesn’t need federal permission to comply with a state subpoena, according to the attorney general’s office and the Monitor.
The state went to Homeland Security directly anyway. For more than three months, despite multiple follow-ups, the department has not authorized production of any information or said whether it will, the attorney general’s office said.
In an October 20 letter attached to the lawsuit, Davenport told Homeland Security officials that “DHS’s failure to respond is part of a troubling and repeated pattern of stonewalling requests for information regarding conditions at Delaney Hall,” the Monitor reported.
05
What Homeland Security and GEO Group say
Homeland Security’s media team sent the Monitor an unattributed statement that denied some of the state’s claims but didn’t address the subpoena. “ICE is regularly audited and inspected by external agencies,” the statement said, adding that Delaney Hall “complies with all required state and local laws.”
The department’s statement also said that all detainees receive “proper meals, quality water, blankets, medical treatment,” and opportunities to communicate with family and lawyers. A GEO Group spokesman, Christopher V. Ferreira, declined to comment and referred questions to Homeland Security, the Monitor reported.
Bloom reports those statements in full fairness. The point of a subpoena is to let records, not press statements, settle what happened inside Delaney Hall.
06
A pattern of closed doors
The lawsuit describes the subpoena fight as one piece of a larger pattern. According to the Monitor’s account of the complaint, Homeland Security and GEO Group officials prevented Newark leaders from inspecting Delaney Hall for safety codes and barred state health inspectors.
They also refused Gov. Mikie Sherrill’s request to speak with detainees during a controlled tour of the jail in June, and rebuffed other officials trying to carry out oversight, the lawsuit says. A separate state lawsuit over the barred health inspection, filed five months ago, is still being litigated.
The pattern reaches beyond Newark. One day before the Delaney Hall suit, Davenport told two federal judges that Homeland Security had refused to release details about a planned immigrant detention center in a Roxbury warehouse, the Monitor reported. Courts paused that project in May for an environmental review, and Justice Department lawyers said in a court filing that they are cooperating with the state’s requests.
The Roxbury details show how much the state says it can’t see. Homeland Security bought the 470,000-square-foot warehouse in February and signed a $31.8 million contract this month to convert it into a processing center for detained migrants, the Monitor reported. A Justice Department lawyer said ICE signed a contract on November 5 for the facility’s maintenance, design and environmental analysis.
The state and Roxbury Township sued in March to stop the plan. In the status report filed Monday with U.S. District Judges Jamel K. Semper and James B. Clark III, Davenport warned that if the government has already committed resources, any coming environmental assessment would be “mere window dressing for a decision that has already been made.”
07
A timeline of the Delaney Hall oversight fight
- Summer 2026: People held at Delaney Hall stage a hunger strike over treatment by guards.
- June 2026: The state sues after health inspectors are barred from Delaney Hall, and the governor’s request to speak with detainees on a tour is refused.
- August 7, 2026: New Jersey opens its civil rights investigation and subpoenas GEO Group for medical care records.
- October 20, 2026: Davenport writes to Homeland Security about its “troubling and repeated pattern of stonewalling.”
- November 13, 2026: The state announces more than $20 million for legal help for immigrants facing detention or deportation.
- November 16, 2026: In a separate case, Davenport tells federal judges Homeland Security won’t release details on the Roxbury warehouse plan.
- November 17, 2026: New Jersey sues Homeland Security over the unanswered Delaney Hall subpoena.
08
Why this case matters beyond New Jersey
People held at Delaney Hall are civil detainees, as the attorney general’s office describes them, not people serving criminal sentences. Their rights don’t stop at the gate, as Melville said.
A state civil rights investigation is one of the few independent ways the public can learn what happens inside a privately run detention center. If a company can decline a state subpoena by pointing to a federal agency, and the agency simply never answers, that check stops working. This lawsuit tests whether it can. That question matters in every state where a private company runs a detention center for the federal government.
Amy Torres, executive director of the New Jersey Alliance for Immigrant Justice, called the suit “a great development.” It doesn’t give any answers yet, she told the Monitor, but it shows the attorney general’s office “is using all levers of the law to pursue answers.” Her group wants people released and taken out of what she called “those unsafe conditions,” the Monitor reported.
Bloom has followed the same tension in other courts this week, from a class action accusing ICE of warrantless arrests in Virginia to a new 10-day deadline for most immigration appeals. The common question is whether the people with the least power still get the protections the law promises.
09
What happens next in the Delaney Hall case
The lawsuit is the start of a court fight, not the end of one. Here is what to watch:
- Homeland Security’s answer. The department will respond to the complaint in federal court, and that response may be the first time it explains its silence on the subpoena.
- A possible deadline. New Jersey wants the judge to set a date by which the department must decide whether GEO Group can produce the Delaney Hall records.
- The inspection case. The state’s separate lawsuit over the barred health inspection is still being litigated, the Monitor reported.
- Roxbury. The standoff over the planned warehouse detention center continues before Judges Semper and Clark.
- The investigation itself. The civil rights investigation goes on with or without the records, and the state has already described what it has heard from detainees and families.
None of this brings back the people who died. But a record, once produced, can tell families the truth and tell lawmakers what has to change.
10
What you can do if someone you love is held at Delaney Hall
If a family member or friend is detained at Delaney Hall, these steps can help:
- Ask about free legal help. New Jersey’s deportation defense initiative funds free legal advice for low-income immigrants, including people held at Delaney Hall, through Legal Services of New Jersey, the American Friends Service Committee, and the law schools at Rutgers and Seton Hall, the Monitor reported.
- Know who else is funded. The state also funds the Office of the Public Defender, Church World Service, Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Newark and the International Rescue Committee, among others.
- Write things down. Keep a dated record of medical needs, missed medications and every call or visit, and share it with the person’s lawyer.
- Name disability needs early. If your loved one needs a disability accommodation, put the request in writing and keep a copy.
- Ask about language access. If your loved one needs an interpreter, ask their lawyer to raise it. The state’s investigation lists routine denial of interpretation as one of the problems at Delaney Hall.
New Jersey’s commitment to that legal help grew this year. Gov. Mikie Sherrill included $20.2 million for the deportation defense initiative in the current state budget, more than double last year’s amount, and $13 million of it goes to the four main partners, the Monitor reported on November 13.
Sherrill said immigrants should not face the legal system “without anyone in their corner.” Human Services Commissioner Stephen Cha, whose office oversees the program, said the state wants people facing detention or deportation to have “meaningful access to counsel and the opportunity to be heard.”
If you’re carrying this alone and it’s too heavy, reach out: Trans Lifeline 877-565-8860 ยท The Trevor Project 1-866-488-7386 ยท 988 (call or text).
11
What Bloom is doing
Bloom follows detention oversight the way it follows every civil rights story: from the record, with no party in the frame. When the court rules on New Jersey’s request, Bloom will report what the judge decides and what the records show about Delaney Hall, if they are ever produced.
For the families of those who died, the wait for answers is its own grief. No fight over a subpoena should let anyone forget that this case is about people, and about whether the ones who had the least power were cared for.
If this story weighs on you, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can reach today, and Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached for anyone grieving a death in custody.
Independent reporting on detention depends on readers. A monthly gift keeps Bloom in these courtrooms week after week, and a one-time gift helps too.
12
Frequently Asked Questions
Delaney Hall is a privately run immigration detention facility in Newark, New Jersey, owned and operated by The GEO Group.
The state says the department has failed for more than three months to respond to a subpoena seeking records on detainees’ medical care. It wants a judge to set a deadline for a decision.
At least three people have died in custody there, according to the attorney general’s office and the New Jersey Monitor.
Reports of problems with medical intake, medications, emergency response, protection from harm, disability accommodations and language interpretation, the attorney general’s office said.
An unattributed department statement said ICE is regularly audited and that Delaney Hall complies with all required state and local laws. It didn’t address the subpoena.
GEO Group says it does under Homeland Security regulations. New Jersey says a private business on its own property in the state doesn’t.
No. This lawsuit asks a judge to make Homeland Security decide on the subpoena. Critics have separately called for the facility to close, the New Jersey Monitor reported.
The state’s deportation defense initiative funds free legal advice for low-income immigrants through Legal Services of New Jersey and other groups, the New Jersey Monitor reported.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Louisiana Legislature · 20 November 2026Appeals Court: Second Amendment Covers Selling Guns, Not Just Owning
New York Legislature · 20 November 2026New York Delays Medicaid Work-Rule Cutoffs to July 2027
Minnesota Legislature · 20 November 2026Minnesota Finds Bemidji Schools Failed to Protect Students From Staff