
Newsroom·Trans advocacy·News
Appeals Court Shields 27 Transgender Troops From Pentagon Discharge
A federal appeals court has barred the Pentagon from discharging 27 transgender troops who sued, some already headed for career-ending boards. The Supreme Court weighs the government's appeal December 4.
Twenty-seven transgender troops who sued over the Pentagon’s ban can keep serving, at least for now. On Tuesday, November 17, a divided federal appeals court in Washington refused the Trump administration’s request to hold off while it asks the Supreme Court to take the case, and it put its own June ruling into effect the same day.
For these transgender troops, the timing mattered. The Pentagon had already placed them on administrative leave, and several were scheduled to appear before boards that would decide whether to end their careers, The Advocate reported. Their lawyers say the 27 have served more than 130 years between them and earned more than 80 commendations. The order doesn’t lift the military ban for anyone else, and the Supreme Court considers the government’s petition on December 4.
Following this story: the transgender military ban. Every Bloom report on it is listed here, newest first.
01
What the appeals court decided for transgender troops
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, known as the D.C. Circuit, voted 2-1 to deny the administration’s request for a stay, the Associated Press reported. Judge Robert Wilkins and Judge Judith Rogers formed the majority. Judge Justin Walker, who dissented from the June ruling, voted to grant the delay.
The court then issued its mandate, the step that put its June decision into effect. The Advocate reported that the mandate gave the plaintiffs immediate protection while the administration asks the Supreme Court to hear the case. The AP described the order as blocking the Pentagon from forcing more than two dozen transgender troops out of the military, several months after the same court found the ban was unlawfully imposed.
In plain words, the Defense Department can’t discharge these 27 transgender troops under the ban while their case continues. The government has admitted that each of them served honorably and met military standards, The Advocate reported. Shannon Minter, legal director of the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, called them “decorated troops who have met every standard the military sets.”
Minter, who argued the appeal for the troops in January, summed up the day in one line: “Today, the D.C. Circuit said no.” A spokesperson for Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s office declined to comment on the ruling, according to the AP.
02
The people behind Talbott v. United States
The lead plaintiff, Nicolas Talbott, was an Army Reserve second lieutenant when he stood with other transgender troops outside the federal courthouse in Washington in February 2025, according to The Advocate. Since then, his name has traveled from Judge Reyes’s courtroom to the D.C. Circuit and now to the Supreme Court.
Their records are the strongest part of their case. The government doesn’t dispute them: it has admitted that each plaintiff served honorably and met military standards, The Advocate reported. Those are the transgender troops the Pentagon was moving to separate.
GLAD Law and the National Center for LGBTQ Rights represent them, alongside Wardenski P.C., Zalkind Duncan & Bernstein LLP, Kropf Moseley Schmitt PLLC and O’Melveny & Myers LLP. At the Supreme Court, their counsel of record is Jonathan D. Hacker of O’Melveny & Myers, according to the docket.
03
Who the order protects, and who it leaves out
The protection is real, and it’s narrow. In June, the panel upheld Judge Ana Reyes’s preliminary injunction for plaintiffs already serving and lifted it for plaintiffs who were trying to enlist, The Advocate reported. The AP summed it up: the decision bars the military from removing current service members named in the lawsuit, but it doesn’t allow new transgender recruits to join.
Judge Wilkins drew the same line on Tuesday. He noted that the June majority opinion was narrower than the injunction the Supreme Court paused in 2025, according to the AP. Here is who stands where today:
- Covered: the 27 serving plaintiffs in Talbott v. United States, according to their lawyers. The Pentagon can’t discharge these transgender troops under the ban while the case goes on.
- Not covered: plaintiffs who were trying to enlist. The June decision lifted the injunction for them, so the enlistment ban stands.
- Not covered: transgender troops who aren’t plaintiffs. The military ban still governs their service, and their careers remain at risk.
- Still open: the government’s Supreme Court petition, No. 26-272, and a two-week trial set to begin January 4, 2027.
That third group should hold every reader’s attention. The Advocate reported that Judge Reyes has indicated she would certify a class, so the trial’s outcome could reach transgender troops across the country whose careers are still on the line after Tuesday’s order.
04
Why two judges refused the Pentagon’s delay
The question before the panel was whether keeping these 27 people in uniform would hurt the government in a way that couldn’t be undone. Judge Wilkins wrote that the administration hadn’t shown how retaining the plaintiffs would cause irreparable harm to the government or endanger national security, the AP reported.
The Advocate’s account of the order adds a pointed detail. The Pentagon had three opportunities to explain what danger these transgender troops posed: before the trial judge, on appeal, and again when it asked for the delay. Each time, Wilkins wrote, the government pointed to national security but never named a risk that letting them stay would create.
Wilkins also rejected the broader idea that blocking an executive policy harms the government all by itself. “To the extent the government suggests that any injunction against the Executive Branch imposes irreparable harm, I am also unpersuaded,” he wrote.
Then he turned to waivers. Under the policy, anyone who had ever “attempted to” transition was ineligible for a waiver, and the government said social transition counted, The Advocate reported. That means the pronouns a service member once used could outweigh a commander’s own judgment that the military needs that person.
Judge Walker saw it differently. His June dissent said judges lack the power to second-guess the decision to exclude transgender troops, the AP reported, and on Tuesday he would have granted the delay.
05
What the government admitted, and why it matters
Strip away the procedure, and one fact stands out. The government has admitted that each of the 27 transgender troops served honorably and met military standards, The Advocate reported. That concession mattered to Judge Wilkins, and it should matter to anyone who wants to understand this case.
If these service members meet every standard, the dispute turns on whether the policy’s medical framing can justify removing them anyway. The AP reported that Hegseth’s policy presumptively disqualifies people with gender dysphoria, the distress a person feels when their assigned gender and gender identity don’t match. The administration has defended the ban as a medical standard tied to readiness, The Advocate reported.
Jennifer Levi of GLAD Law, which represents the transgender troops with the National Center for LGBTQ Rights, answered that framing directly. “The court saw this policy for what it is: a ban demeaning an entire group of people, dressed up in medical language,” she said in a statement.
06
How the case got here: a timeline
The Talbott case has moved through three courts in less than two years. These are the dates that matter for transgender troops and their families:
- January 2025: President Donald Trump signs an executive order claiming that transgender service members’ identity conflicts with “an honorable, truthful, and disciplined lifestyle.” Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth then issues a policy that presumptively disqualifies people with gender dysphoria.
- March 2025: U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes rules that the order likely violates the troops’ constitutional rights and enters a preliminary injunction.
- March 27, 2025: A federal court in the Western District of Washington enters a separate preliminary injunction in a case brought by Commander Emily Shilling and others.
- May 6, 2025: The Supreme Court stays the Washington injunction while the Shilling appeal continues, which let the Pentagon begin enforcing the ban.
- January 2026: Shannon Minter argues the Talbott appeal before the D.C. Circuit.
- June 1, 2026: A divided D.C. Circuit panel finds the policy likely violates equal protection. It keeps the injunction for serving plaintiffs and lifts it for those seeking to enlist.
- August 27, 2026: The government asks the Supreme Court to review that decision.
- November 2, 2026: The transgender troops file their brief opposing review.
- November 16, 2026: The government files its reply, and Judge Reyes orders internal records produced within 28 days.
- November 17, 2026: The D.C. Circuit denies the delay 2-1 and issues its mandate. The Supreme Court distributes the petition for its December 4 conference.
- December 4 and 11, 2026: The justices’ next two private conferences.
- January 4, 2027: A two-week trial is scheduled to begin before Judge Reyes.
07
What the Supreme Court weighs on December 4
On December 4, the justices won’t decide whether the ban is lawful. They’ll decide whether to hear the government’s appeal at all, in a case docketed as No. 26-272.
The government’s case is blunt. In its petition, Solicitor General D. John Sauer called the D.C. Circuit’s decision “gravely erroneous” and argued that its “reasoning cannot be squared with this Court’s precedents or deference to the military,” SCOTUSblog reported.
In its reply, filed November 16, the Justice Department argued that courts owe military leaders deference on readiness. It also said that taking the case now “would signal to the district court that it should stay a trial that should not be happening in the first place,” according to The Advocate.
Lawyers for the transgender troops asked the Court to stay out. They called the D.C. Circuit’s decision “narrow” and temporary, and they argued the ruling is right because hostility to transgender people, not “military judgments,” drove the ban, SCOTUSblog reported.
Don’t expect a same-day answer. For several years, the Court has generally waited to grant a petition until the justices have considered it at two conferences, SCOTUSblog noted, and the next conference after December 4 is December 11. The AP observed that Tuesday’s order could set the stage for the issue to return to the Supreme Court, which let the ban take effect through its May 6, 2025 order in the Shilling case.
08
What could happen next for transgender troops
There are three paths from here, and transgender troops and their families should know each one:
- The justices deny review. The D.C. Circuit’s June decision stands, the 27 plaintiffs keep their protection, and the January trial goes forward.
- The justices take the case. The Court would hear the government’s appeal. The Justice Department has already argued that granting review now would signal the trial court to stay the January trial.
- The justices wait. Under the Court’s usual practice of considering a petition at two conferences, nothing may happen until December 11 or later, and the trial date holds unless a court moves it.
Whatever the justices do, the November 17 order protects only the people who sued. Every other transgender service member is waiting on the trial, the Supreme Court, or both. That’s why the next seven weeks matter so much.
09
The January trial and the records Judge Reyes ordered
While the petition waits, the trial court keeps moving. On November 16, Judge Reyes gave the administration 28 days to turn over internal records about the policy and authorized the troops’ lawyers to question former Army Secretary Dan Driscoll under oath, The Advocate reported. The two-week trial is scheduled to begin January 4, 2027.
Bloom reported on November 15 that the Justice Department had asked Judge Reyes to keep Defense Secretary Hegseth’s past words out of that trial. That fight over evidence is now running alongside the fight at the Supreme Court.
The trial may matter most to the people Tuesday’s order doesn’t reach. Because Judge Reyes has indicated she would certify a class, The Advocate reported, a ruling after trial could speak for transgender troops nationwide, not only the named plaintiffs.
The ban’s reach doesn’t stop at the water’s edge, either. Bloom reported on November 16 that the U.S. policy is keeping trans Australian sailors out of submarine training under the AUKUS partnership.
10
What transgender troops and their families can do now
If you serve and you’re not a plaintiff, the military ban still applies to you today. Here is what Bloom would tell a friend in your boots:
- Talk with a lawyer before any board. Find an attorney who handles military separation cases before you sign anything or answer a board’s questions.
- Keep your record close. Save copies of evaluations, awards and medical records. In this case, the government’s admission that each plaintiff served honorably and met standards carried real weight.
- Mark the dates. The justices meet December 4 and December 11, and the trial opens January 4, 2027.
- Don’t carry it alone. Waiting on a court to decide your career is heavy. Lean on the people who love you, and reach out if the weight gets to be too much.
For families, spouses and friends of transgender troops, the work is presence. Ask how they’re doing, then listen without rushing to fix it. Help keep the paperwork straight, and remind them that a policy or a court date can’t erase years of honorable service.
If you’re in crisis or need someone right now: Trans Lifeline 877-565-8860 ยท The Trevor Project 1-866-488-7386 ยท 988 (call or text).
11
What Bloom is doing
Bloom follows Talbott v. United States from the record: the petition, the briefs, the mandate and, in January, the trial. Every Bloom report on the military ban sits in the “Following this story” box near the top of this page, newest first.
If this news lands hard, start with Bloom’s crisis support page, and if you’d like company in the waiting, look at Bloom’s support groups. Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
Reporting like this stays free because readers carry it. A monthly gift keeps Bloom on this case from the December 4 conference through the January trial, and a one-time gift helps too.
12
Frequently Asked Questions
It can’t discharge the 27 serving plaintiffs covered by the November 17 order while their case continues. For transgender troops who aren’t plaintiffs, the ban still applies.
No. The D.C. Circuit’s June 1 decision lifted the injunction for plaintiffs who were trying to enlist, so the enlistment ban remains.
The justices will consider whether to hear the government’s appeal, docketed as No. 26-272. The Court generally considers a petition at two conferences before granting it, and the next one is December 11.
Judge Robert Wilkins wrote that the government hadn’t shown how keeping these transgender troops would cause irreparable harm or endanger national security. Judge Judith Rogers joined him, and Judge Justin Walker would have granted the delay.
A two-week trial is scheduled to begin January 4, 2027, before U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes in Washington.
GLAD Law and the National Center for LGBTQ Rights represent the plaintiffs, alongside several private law firms, The Advocate reported.
Bloom lists every report on the military ban in the “Following this story” box on this page, newest first.
Sovereignty over Servitude. ๐ธ
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Georgia Legislature · 20 November 2026Augusta Man Gets Life Without Parole for Killing Felycya Harris
New York Legislature · 20 November 2026Liverpool Students Walk Out Over Rule to Tell Parents About Gender
Montana Legislature · 20 November 2026Montana Judge Blocks SB 437, the Law Defining Sex as Binary