
Newsroom·Connecticut Legislature·News
New Haven Will Pay $30 Million to Two Men Wrongly Convicted of Murder
George Gould lost more than 26 years to prison for a killing he didn't commit, and Ronald Taylor died before his name was cleared.
George Gould spent more than 26 years in prison for a 1993 killing he didn’t commit. Ronald Taylor, convicted with him, died of cancer in 2011, long before a court cleared his name. On Friday, November 20, 2026, the City of New Haven, Connecticut, announced that it will pay $30 million to settle their federal civil rights lawsuits: $18 million to Gould and $12 million to Taylor’s estate. Gould’s lawyers call it the largest individual wrongful conviction settlement in Connecticut history.
The city apologized, and the mayor warned that its wrongful conviction settlements will weigh on taxpayers for 20 years. Gould said “no amount of money could make up for the decades I spent wrongfully incarcerated.” Here’s how one witness’s statement sent two men to prison, why it took three decades to undo, what Connecticut offers people after a wrongful conviction, and what you can do.
01
The wrongful conviction settlement at a glance
- Who’s paid: $18 million to George Gould and $12 million to the estate of Ronald Taylor.
- When: reached November 13, 2026, and announced November 20, the Hartford Courant reported.
- What’s still needed: probate court approval of the estate’s share, the city’s Litigation Settlement Committee, and a Board of Alders vote to borrow the money.
- What the plaintiffs give up: both lawsuits, and every claim against the city and the former officers they sued.
- The pattern: the fourth and fifth wrongful conviction lawsuits New Haven has settled in three months, for $77 million in all.
02
What New Haven agreed to pay
The deal resolves the consolidated federal cases of George Gould and the Estate of Ronald Taylor against the City of New Haven, the New Haven Independent reported. Gould sued the city and eight former detectives, or their estates, on June 11, 2025, the Independent reported then. Mary Murphy-Taylor, Taylor’s widow and the administrator of his estate, filed her own wrongful conviction lawsuit that June.
“In exchange for these payments,” the joint statement says, Gould and Murphy-Taylor “will withdraw their separate complaints with prejudice and fully release all claims” against the city and its employees, “including the individual defendants named in the lawsuits.”
Both were represented by the civil rights firm Neufeld Scheck Brustin Hoffmann & Freudenberger, with Richard Emanuel for Gould and Michael Jefferson for the estate, the firm’s release says.
03
What the mayor and Gould said
Mayor Justin Elicker apologized in the city’s statement. “Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor spent years of their lives in jail for crimes they did not commit,” he said. “The City, the State and the courts all failed them.” He added that “we are deeply sorry for the decades of pain and suffering that Mr. Gould and Mr. Taylor have experienced.”
“Unfortunately, Mr. Taylor did not live to see this day or his conviction vacated,” Elicker said. He also said “the allegations in these cases do not involve the New Haven Police Department of today.”
Gould said he’s “relieved to have finally reached the end of my legal ordeal.” He hopes his case “causes the New Haven Police Department to examine its current practices,” he said, “and ensure that no one else ever has to endure a wrongful conviction.”
04
A killing on Grand Avenue in 1993
Early on July 4, 1993, Eugenio Vega, 51, was shot and killed inside La Casa Green, the store he owned on Grand Avenue in New Haven’s Fair Haven neighborhood, according to the National Registry of Exonerations and the Connecticut Supreme Court. The city’s statement and some news reports spell his first name Eugenia; the court records say Eugenio.
Gould was 31 and Taylor 35, the registry says. Police found no physical evidence connecting either man to the killing behind this wrongful conviction, the Independent reported. Mr. Vega’s family lost him that morning, and nothing in this settlement changes that.
05
How one witness’s statement became a wrongful conviction
On July 29, 1993, police arrested a woman in a prostitution sting, the registry says. Police later said she told them she’d seen Gould and Taylor leave the store, and she picked them out of a photo lineup. She was the only eyewitness against them. Bloom isn’t naming her: she’s a private person who was in addiction and under arrest when police took her statement.
At the January 1995 trial, her account reached the jury through a videotaped deposition recorded in a hospital. The prosecutor told jurors the case “rises and falls” on her testimony, the state’s Conviction Integrity Unit recounted. On February 1, 1995, the jury acquitted both men of murder but convicted them of felony murder, robbery and conspiracy. Each was sentenced to 80 years.
06
What the jury never heard
At a habeas corpus trial in 2009, the witness took it back. “I wasn’t there. I lied,” she testified, the registry says. She said she’d been in heroin withdrawal during hours of questioning, and that detectives said they’d lock her up unless she told them what they wanted to hear.
She testified that detectives offered to drive her to buy heroin if she placed the men at the scene, that she picked them out of the photo array by following detectives’ body language, and that officers then gave her $60 for drugs. The prosecution and police hadn’t disclosed before trial that she’d been given money to buy heroin, the registry says. That nondisclosure is at the center of the wrongful conviction lawsuits.
07
Freed in 2010, then sent back
On March 17, 2010, Superior Court Judge Stanley Fuger Jr. found the recantation credible and vacated both convictions on the ground of “actual innocence,” the registry says. A second witness who’d testified at trial recanted too. Both men walked out on bond on April 1, 2010.
The state appealed. On July 19, 2011, the Connecticut Supreme Court reversed, holding that “actual innocence requires affirmative evidence that the petitioners did not commit the crimes,” not just proof that the case against them had fallen apart.
The justices saw the cost. The recantations “may demonstrate that there no longer is any credible evidence that the petitioners did commit the crimes,” they wrote. Still, “Discrediting the evidence on which the conviction rested does not revive the presumption of innocence.” The wrongful conviction stood.
08
Ronald Taylor didn’t live to see it
Gould went back to prison on August 8, 2011. Taylor didn’t. He was dying of colon cancer that he developed and suffered from while in prison, his lawyers say, and he was allowed to stay home. He died on October 25, 2011.
“Mr. Taylor died in 2011 of cancer he developed in prison and was never able to see his name cleared,” said Nick Brustin, the family’s lawyer. His wrongful conviction was vacated 13 years after his death. On Friday, the mayor offered his widow his “deepest condolences.”
09
Why the wrongful conviction stood for another decade
In 2011, the witness gave police a video-recorded statement taking back her recantation, saying a defense investigator had confused her, threatened her and given her gifts, the registry says. When police brought her the transcript, she refused to sign it and said that statement was false.
At the second habeas corpus trial in 2012, the witness invoked her Fifth Amendment right and didn’t testify, so the judge saw only her original account. On September 18, 2012, Judge Samuel Sferrazza denied the petition.
In 2013, a jury convicted the investigator of bribery of a witness and witness tampering. At that trial, testifying under immunity, the witness said her 2009 recantation was the truth. The Appellate Court upheld the habeas denial in September 2015, and Gould stayed in prison.
10
How George Gould came home
On May 4, 2021, Judge Gerald L. Harmon cut Gould’s sentence from 80 years to 26, and Gould “had already served more than twenty-six years in custody,” the Conviction Integrity Unit’s report says. He was paroled the next day.
In March 2022, his lawyers asked the unit to review his wrongful conviction claim. Its staff report, dated May 16, 2023, laid out the recantations, the investigator’s conviction and new interviews without deciding who was telling the truth. The unit “leaves the weight to be given to the inconsistencies” in the witness’s accounts to the local state’s attorney, it said.
11
How the convictions fell
On February 1, 2024, New Haven State’s Attorney Jack Doyle, citing that report, asked Judge Harmon to vacate Gould’s convictions, the registry says. The judge did, then dismissed the case. Gould told the judge “it’s been a long road, a long road to get a clean record.”
On October 10, 2024, Doyle asked the court to vacate Taylor’s conviction too. The motion was granted, and the case was dismissed. For both men, the wrongful conviction was undone at the request of the same state’s attorney’s office that had prosecuted them.
12
The evidence that surfaced in another wrongful conviction trial
In a deposition in Stefon Morant’s wrongful conviction lawsuit, a former New Haven police lieutenant who was a defendant in the Gould and Taylor suits admitted the witness was in obvious heroin withdrawal, the firm says. He also admitted that after getting her statement he drove her to her dealer and handed her $60, the firm says, and officers then “hid the truth for decades.”
In May 2026, a federal jury in Morant’s case found that New Haven police had a practice of hiding evidence that could damage their cases in the early 1990s, and awarded him $38 million, Connecticut Public reported. The city is appealing.
“We are grateful for some closure for our clients, but this monetary award is too little too late,” Brustin said. Only after the Morant verdict, he said, “did the City come to its senses and settle Mr. Gould’s and Mr. Taylor’s case.” The lawyers also say police failed to investigate another man with a motive, who they say later confessed to relatives. He has never been charged, so Bloom isn’t identifying him.
13
How a wrongful conviction happens
Each of these patterns from the Gould and Taylor case can produce a wrongful conviction:
- One witness and no physical evidence. “There was no DNA evidence, no fingerprint evidence, no ballistics evidence,” Gould’s lawyers told the state.
- Pressure in the interrogation room. The witness was in withdrawal and under arrest, and detectives told her she couldn’t leave until she said what they wanted, the plaintiffs’ firm says.
- A suggestive lineup. She said she followed the detectives’ cues in the photo array.
- Favors the defense never learned about. Money for drugs is exactly what a jury needs to judge a witness.
The Supreme Court’s 1963 ruling in Brady v. Maryland holds that “the suppression by the prosecution of evidence favorable to an accused upon request violates due process” when the evidence is material. Its 1972 ruling in Giglio v. United States applied that to a key witness: “nondisclosure of evidence affecting credibility falls within this general rule.”
In 2011, David Borden, the Connecticut Supreme Court justice who wrote a 2005 ruling on eyewitness evidence, told lawmakers that wrong witness identifications were exposed in 75% of the first 270 DNA exonerations nationally, the CT Mirror reported.
14
What Connecticut law offers after a wrongful conviction
Connecticut pays exonerees through its Claims Commissioner under section 54-102uu of the General Statutes, as amended by Public Act 25-57. A person qualifies when a conviction is vacated or reversed and the case is dismissed on “grounds of innocence or grounds consistent with innocence,” or because of serious official misconduct.
The wrongful conviction formula is fixed: 200 percent of the state’s median family income for each year in prison, adjusted for inflation, which the Claims Commissioner may raise or lower by 25 percent. Awards over $35,000 go to the General Assembly, which has 45 days to confirm, deny or send them back. The state may also pay for job training, counseling and tuition.
A claim must be filed within two years of the pardon or dismissal. In April 2025, the Claims Commissioner awarded Gould $6.7 million for his wrongful conviction, WFSB reported. A person who accepts a state award must give up other claims against the state.
The city argues the state’s formula is why a wrongful conviction lawsuit against a city costs more. “There is no such limitation on the compensation a plaintiff can receive from a municipality through a lawsuit,” its statement says.
15
What it costs New Haven
The city plans to borrow the full $30 million. When the 1993 killing was investigated, the city had no insurance for this kind of claim, and state law requires it to pay the individual defendants’ legal fees too, its statement says.
New Haven caps its borrowing at $30 million a year, Elicker said, but these five wrongful conviction settlements add $77 million in new debt. Repaying it will cost at least $116 million over 20 years, or $6 million to $7 million a year, as much as the city’s Parks Department budget.
Elicker wants the state to share the cost of each wrongful conviction. “Former police officers and former prosecutors are both responsible,” he said. He noted the state appealed the 2010 ruling, yet “the City is paying over twice as much as the State in compensation.” The state has awarded $24.7 million in these five cases, the city says.
16
What has changed in New Haven policing
The city’s Friday statement didn’t announce any new police policy. In February 2025, Police Chief Karl Jacobson told the CT Mirror that changes in procedure and technology had raised the standards for recording witness and suspect interviews in their entirety. Officers use random, sequential photo arrays in which they can’t see which photo the witness is viewing, he said.
Connecticut set standards for eyewitness identifications in 2011, rules meant to prevent another wrongful conviction. “Our police department today is a very, very different police department than in the 1990s,” Elicker told the CT Mirror then. The plaintiffs’ lawyers aren’t convinced. The city’s stance, Brustin said after the Morant verdict, “in my view suggests that the problems that existed then have not gone away.”
17
Five settlements, and more wrongful conviction lawsuits waiting
Before Friday, New Haven settled with Adam Carmon for $16.5 million and with Vernon Horn and Marquis Jackson for $15.25 million each, the Independent reported. Carmon said New Haven detectives coerced him into making false statements, Connecticut Public reported.
Three more wrongful conviction lawsuits from the same era are pending: Morant’s, with its $38 million verdict on appeal; one by Alder Troy Streater seeking $100 million; and one by Charles Coleman Jr.
18
Timeline: three decades of a wrongful conviction
- July 4, 1993: Eugenio Vega is killed in his Grand Avenue store.
- February 1, 1995: A jury convicts Gould and Taylor of felony murder.
- December 2006: The witness tells a defense investigator she wasn’t at the scene.
- March 17, 2010: A habeas corpus judge finds the men actually innocent.
- July 19, 2011: The Connecticut Supreme Court reverses.
- October 25, 2011: Ronald Taylor dies of cancer.
- May 5, 2021: Gould is paroled after his sentence is cut to 26 years.
- February 1, 2024: Gould’s convictions are vacated and his case dismissed.
- October 10, 2024: Prosecutors move to vacate Taylor’s conviction, and the court grants it.
- June 2025: Gould and Taylor’s estate sue the city.
- November 13, 2026: The settlement is reached.
- November 20, 2026: The city announces it.
19
What happens next
The estate’s $12 million needs the New Haven Probate Court’s approval. Then the city’s Litigation Settlement Committee must approve both settlements, and the Board of Alders must approve borrowing the money, the city says.
Taylor’s estate’s wrongful conviction claim with the state is still pending, the city says. Elicker said he’ll press state lawmakers so cities don’t carry “such a disproportionate and overwhelming share” of the cost. Morant’s appeal and two more lawsuits remain open.
20
What you can do
- If someone you love is serving a Connecticut sentence for a crime they didn’t commit, write to the Connecticut Innocence Project / Post Conviction Unit, 55 Farmington Avenue, 8th Floor, Hartford, CT 06105, or call (860) 258-4940. It helps people who can’t afford a lawyer, are factually innocent, have a sentence of at least ten years with five or more years left, and have new evidence, its request page says.
- Know what the national Innocence Project takes. It reviews cases by mail only and focuses on cases where DNA testing can prove innocence, its intake page says. For other cases, it points people to the Innocence Network.
- Ask for a review of a possible wrongful conviction. A convicted person, a lawyer or a representative may ask the Conviction Integrity Unit in the Office of the Chief State’s Attorney to review a case, under the unit’s protocol.
- Mind the deadline. After a wrongful conviction is vacated and the case dismissed, a claim with the Claims Commissioner must be filed within two years.
- Watch the Board of Alders vote on borrowing for these settlements, and tell your state lawmakers how you think the cost should be shared.
- Make room for people coming home. Someone freed after decades needs work, a home and patience, and neighbors can help.
21
Police accountability cases Bloom has followed
This wrongful conviction settlement joins a week of reckonings over police power. Pocatello, Idaho, agreed to pay $4.5 million to the family of Victor Perez, an autistic teen shot by police. In Madison, a prosecutor declined to charge the officer who killed Corey Ruiz, and in Paris, a court convicted three officers of a racist assault on Michel Zecler.
22
What Bloom is doing
Bloom reports these cases because a wrongful conviction doesn’t end at the prison gate. It follows a man home, and sometimes it outlives him. I believe a city that says “we are deeply sorry” out loud is doing something holy, and I pray it’s a step toward never needing to say it again.
If this story stirs grief or anger for you or someone you love, Bloom’s crisis support page lists people you can call at any hour, and Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
A monthly gift keeps Bloom reading the court records behind stories like this one, and a one-time gift helps too.
23
Frequently Asked Questions
$30 million: $18 million to George Gould and $12 million to Ronald Taylor’s estate. It still needs probate court, committee and Board of Alders approvals.
A jury convicted Gould and Taylor in 1995 on the word of a single eyewitness, who later recanted and said police pressured her while she was in heroin withdrawal. No physical evidence tied them to the crime.
He died of colon cancer on October 25, 2011, months after the Connecticut Supreme Court reversed the ruling that had freed him. His conviction was vacated in 2024.
The Claims Commissioner awarded Gould $6.7 million in April 2025. The estate’s claim for Taylor is still pending.
The Connecticut Innocence Project / Post Conviction Unit in Hartford takes requests by letter and at (860) 258-4940. The national Innocence Project takes cases by mail, mainly where DNA testing can prove innocence.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Disability advocacy · 21 November 2026Indiana Won’t Pause Medicaid Work-Rule Cutoffs; New Hampshire Will
Legislation · 20 November 2026Judge Blocks Connecticut’s ICE Mask Ban and Use-of-Force Law
Connecticut Legislature · 12 November 2026Connecticut Advocates Move to Protect Community First Choice