
Newsroom·Colorado Legislature·News
No Diagnosis Needed to Ask for More Leave, Appeals Court Rules
On Nov. 6 the Tenth Circuit revived a fired worker's ADA case. What the ruling says about notice, a few more weeks of medical leave, and how to ask for it.
A federal appeals court ruled on Friday that a worker doesn’t have to name her exact diagnosis to put her employer on notice that she has a disability, and that her request for a few more weeks of medical leave could be a reasonable one under the Americans with Disabilities Act. In a published opinion filed November 6, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit revived a lawsuit the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission brought against A & A Appliance, Inc., which does business as Appliance Factory. The company fired a sales associate at its Thornton, Colorado, store in June 2020, two days after her medical leave ran out.
A federal district court in Colorado had ended the case before trial. The Tenth Circuit reversed and sent it back, holding that “a reasonable jury could find that Ms. Javanzad put Appliance Factory on notice that she had a disability.” The ruling doesn’t decide whether she had a disability under the law, and it doesn’t find the company liable. For disabled workers who run out of medical leave before they run out of illness, it says something plain: you don’t need a finished diagnosis to be heard.
01
What the Tenth Circuit decided on November 6

The case is Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. A & A Appliance, Inc., No. 25-1451, an appeal from the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado. The panel was Judges Matheson, McHugh and Federico, and Judge McHugh wrote the court’s opinion. The court marked the opinion for publication, which makes it precedent for the federal courts of the Tenth Circuit. You can read the opinion in full.
The opinion’s opening tells the story in two sentences. “The district court granted summary judgment in Appliance Factory’s favor on all claims,” it begins. Then: “we reverse the district court’s grant of summary judgment and remand for further proceedings.”
The court made two holdings that matter for every worker on medical leave:
- Notice without a diagnosis. A jury could find that the employee told the company enough about her condition to put it on notice of a disability, even though no diagnosis had been confirmed when she asked for more time.
- More leave as an accommodation. Her request for a few more weeks of medical leave, the court held, “was a plausibly reasonable accommodation request under the ADA.”
The EEOC’s lawsuit also included claims of disparate treatment and retaliation. The district court had rejected those “for the same reasons” it rejected the accommodation claim. According to the opinion, those claims rise or fall with the accommodation claim, and the Tenth Circuit reversed the grant of summary judgment, so the case goes back to the District of Colorado.
02
Twelve weeks of FMLA, then a request for a few more
According to the opinion, Appliance Factory hired her in February 2019 as a sales associate at its Thornton store. In March 2020 she took medical leave, first because her son had pneumonia and then because she fell sick herself. On March 26 she told the company’s HR specialist she was “really sick,” with a cough and shortness of breath. She sent a note from her primary-care doctor confirming COVID-19 symptoms and advising her to stay home.
Her time off ran under the Family and Medical Leave Act, and her 12 weeks were set to end on June 8, 2020. Her recovery wasn’t a straight line. On April 13 she felt “much better” and had a doctor’s note clearing her for full duty. Three days later she wrote that her “body got weak again.” On April 19 she also wrote that she needed more time on FMLA because she couldn’t find daycare during school closures.
By May 12 the problem had a new shape. “My stomach has a problem after I encountered the virus,” she wrote. She told HR an endoscopy was scheduled and asked whether she could extend her medical leave. HR replied that she still had time left of her 12 weeks, “so let’s see what happens with your doctor before we discuss any other steps.” A May 13 doctor’s note said she should stay out until her symptoms improved and she had the results of her planned procedures.
On June 1 she emailed that the endoscopy had moved to June 9, asked about her options if her Family and Medical Leave Act time ran out, and said she “needed more time.” Her FMLA time ended June 8. On June 9, the day of her procedure, HR wrote: “If you are unable to return, I understand if you need to resign at this time.” She didn’t reply.
Appliance Factory fired her by letter on June 10, 2020. Her endoscopy and biopsies later confirmed mild gastritis, the opinion says.
03
The phone call she couldn’t easily make

Part of this case turns on how she was able to communicate. On June 2, HR emailed and texted her: “I do need to speak with you over the phone, so please call me today.” Phone records described in the opinion show a five-minute call that afternoon. HR testified she didn’t recall it. The employee testified that she said, “I’m going to have an endoscopy done, and I need more time.”
She also testified that she told HR she had difficulty speaking and stomach pain, and that she “needed a few weeks” and would come back after the results. Three days later she wrote: “I saw your missed call and I wasn’t able to respond because I have difficulty speaking.” According to the opinion, HR didn’t answer that email, because HR and other staff insisted on a phone call. On June 8 she wrote again, apologizing that “some days I have difficulty speaking,” and asked about a leave of absence.
Bloom is disabled-led, and we know this pattern by heart. A worker who can’t talk on the phone puts everything in writing, and the people who hold her job keep asking for a call. The Tenth Circuit didn’t write a rule about phone calls. But it counted what she wrote, and the one call she did make, as evidence a jury could weigh.
The court also restated what an employer owes a worker when the picture isn’t clear. Where notice is ambiguous, it wrote, quoting an earlier decision, “the employer must ask for clarification.” Once a worker shares enough to suggest an accommodation may be possible, “both parties have an obligation to proceed in a reasonably interactive manner.” Lawyers call that the interactive process, and it runs both ways.
04
How the court found notice without a formal diagnosis
A reasonable accommodation claim starts with notice. “A failure to accommodate claim requires that the employer be on notice that the employee had a disability for which she needed accommodation,” the court wrote. Unless a disability is obvious, the worker has to tell the employer about it before the employer can be held responsible.
The Tenth Circuit pointed to four kinds of evidence that a jury could weigh:
- her emails and text messages to HR describing her symptoms;
- her doctor’s note describing her limits at work;
- the June 2, 2020, phone call;
- the termination letter itself, which acknowledged her “gastrointestinal disorder.”
Appliance Factory argued that her messages showed “only general health issues of unknown severity or duration.” The court disagreed. “These were not the type of vague, generalized symptoms that the Sixth Circuit examined in Hrdlicka,” it wrote, pointing to another appeals court’s case. A worker who writes that she can’t breathe, has stomach pain and has trouble speaking isn’t describing a passing cold.
The court was careful to say that a jury might still side with the company. “A jury may ultimately not agree with Ms. Javanzad that she sufficiently informed Appliance Factory of her condition,” it wrote. That’s the point of sending a case to trial: the people who decide facts get to decide them.
05
Why a formal diagnosis wasn’t required
This is the heart of the ruling. The court held that “an employee need not provide the name of the disabling condition or the specific diagnosis to put an employer on notice.” It added: “Nor does the employee need to use the word ‘disabled.'”
The ADA, the court noted, “does not require clairvoyance” from employers. But it doesn’t demand a finished diagnosis from workers either. Relevant information, the court wrote, quoting another circuit, “could include, among other things, a diagnosis, a treatment plan, apparent severe symptoms, and physician-imposed work restrictions.”
Read that list slowly. A diagnosis is one item on it, not the price of admission. A worker on medical leave whose doctors are still running tests—as hers were, with an endoscopy on the calendar—can still describe severe symptoms and a doctor’s limits on her work. HR Dive summed it up: “Conversely, the 10th Circuit noted that a formal diagnosis is not necessary in this context.”
For many disabled people, the name of the condition comes last. Tests get rescheduled, and symptoms come and go, the way hers did in April. A rule that required a confirmed diagnosis before a worker could ask for medical leave would shut out exactly the people who are sickest and least sure. The Tenth Circuit’s opinion doesn’t do that.
06
“A few weeks” isn’t an open-ended request
Appliance Factory’s other argument was that she’d asked for “a wholly indeterminate extension of leave.” The district court agreed that an indefinite leave wasn’t a plausibly reasonable request. The Tenth Circuit held the opposite: “her request for additional leave was a plausibly reasonable accommodation request under the ADA.”
The words matter. Under the Tenth Circuit’s test, a worker must show “(1) she is disabled; (2) she is otherwise qualified; and (3) she requested a plausibly reasonable accommodation.” The EEOC argued on appeal that a jury could find her request for “a few weeks” of additional medical leave reasonable. She tied her return to a dated procedure and its results, not to a vague someday.
That distinction runs through the law of medical leave. Employers aren’t required to hold a job open forever. But a short, bounded extension tied to a doctor’s plan isn’t forever, and the Family and Medical Leave Act’s 12 weeks aren’t the ceiling on what the ADA can require.
07
What the EEOC’s guidance says about medical leave
The ruling fits the EEOC’s own guidance, Employer-Provided Leave and the Americans with Disabilities Act, issued May 9, 2016. It’s a technical assistance document, and by its own disclaimer it doesn’t have the force of law. But it tells workers and employers how the agency that enforces the ADA’s job protections reads it.
Here’s what the guidance says about medical leave:
- An employer “must consider providing unpaid leave to an employee with a disability as a reasonable accommodation if the employee requires it,” unless that would cause undue hardship.
- That duty applies even when a worker has used up the medical leave an employer offers, including leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act. Following the FMLA “does not necessarily meet an employer’s obligation under the ADA.”
- “The fact that any additional leave exceeds what is permitted under the FMLA, by itself, is not sufficient to show undue hardship.”
- When a worker asks for medical leave, or more medical leave, for a health condition, “the employer must treat the request as one for a reasonable accommodation under the ADA.”
- “An employer may not penalize an employee for using leave as a reasonable accommodation.”
The guidance on medical leave has limits too. “Reasonable accommodation does not require an employer to provide paid leave beyond what it provides as part of its paid leave policy.” And undue hardship can include leave “without a specified or estimated end date.” That’s why an estimate—”a few weeks,” “after my test results”—can carry so much weight.
08
What this ruling doesn’t decide
It doesn’t decide whether she had a disability under the ADA. The court said so directly: “Although we decline to decide whether Ms. Javanzad created a genuine factual dispute as to whether she had a cognizable disability,” it left that question for the district court on remand.
It doesn’t find that Appliance Factory broke the law. A reversal of summary judgment means the EEOC’s claims may go forward, not that they’ve been proved. It doesn’t require any employer to grant medical leave without end. And it doesn’t bind courts outside the Tenth Circuit.
HR Dive put the wider lesson for employers this way: “The decision demonstrates the complexity surrounding the intersection of the FMLA and ADA.” Employers that treat the end of FMLA leave as the end of the conversation now have a published appeals court opinion telling them it may not be.
09
What it means for workers in Oregon and beyond
Bloom is based in Salem. Oregon’s federal courts sit in a different circuit, so this ruling isn’t binding on them. But the ADA is the same federal law in Portland as in Thornton, and the EEOC’s guidance on medical leave isn’t limited to one region. Courts that aren’t bound by a published opinion can still read it and find its reasoning persuasive.
For Oregon workers, the practical lesson is the same as anywhere. What you write down, when you write it, and what your doctor puts on paper can decide whether your request for medical leave is treated as a request for a reasonable accommodation. If your body won’t let you talk on the phone, your emails can still carry your claim.
Bloom has reported on other ADA cases this month, including a University of Michigan student’s disability claim that survived a motion to dismiss on November 9.
10
How to ask for more medical leave under the ADA

None of this is legal advice, and no step guarantees an outcome. But the record in this case shows what can matter:
- Put it in writing. Email or text HR, and keep copies of everything you send and receive, with dates.
- Say it’s about your health. Describe your symptoms and what you can’t do. The Tenth Circuit said you don’t have to name a diagnosis or use the word “disabled.”
- Give your medical leave an end date, even an estimate. Tie it to something real, like a test, a procedure or a follow-up visit. “A few weeks” with a reason is very different from “I don’t know.”
- Send your doctor’s notes. A note that describes your limits at work is one of the four kinds of evidence the court weighed.
- If you can’t talk by phone, say so in writing. Ask to handle the conversation by email, and keep that request.
- Ask what they need. Invite the interactive process: ask HR, in writing, what information would help them decide.
- Get help if your medical leave request is refused or you’re fired. The EEOC enforces the ADA’s job protections, and a lawyer or legal aid group can tell you what deadlines apply to you.
Every one of these steps builds a record. In this case the record is what kept a fired worker’s claim alive.
11
Sick, scared and still a worker
Strip away the docket number and this is a story disabled people know too well. You get sick. Your doctors don’t have an answer yet. Your medical leave clock runs while the tests get rescheduled, and the people who hold your job want a phone call you can’t make. Then a letter comes.
The ADA’s promise is that a person isn’t disposable because their body is slow to explain itself. Friday’s ruling doesn’t keep that promise for her yet. It gives her case a chance to be heard by a jury, and it tells employers across the Tenth Circuit that a worker’s words count before a lab report does.
12
What Bloom is doing
Bloom’s newsroom will follow EEOC v. A & A Appliance back to the District of Colorado, report what the court decides about this worker’s medical leave, and link the court record so you can read it yourself. You’ll find that coverage in the Disability Advocacy newsroom.
On November 9 we reported that the Justice Department sued Lyft under the ADA, another case that tests what federal disability law demands in daily life. Bloom is disabled-led, and you can read more about Bloom’s disability advocacy. We’ll keep naming the courts, the laws and the dates so you can check every word.
And if this story touches fear of losing your work while you’re sick, Faith in Bloom offers pastoral care with no condition attached.
13
Frequently Asked Questions
On November 6, 2026, the court reversed a grant of summary judgment for Appliance Factory and sent the EEOC’s ADA case back to the District of Colorado. It held that a jury could find the fired worker put the company on notice of a disability, and that her request for more medical leave was plausibly reasonable.
Not to put your employer on notice, according to this ruling. The Tenth Circuit said an employee “need not provide the name of the disabling condition or the specific diagnosis,” and doesn’t need to use the word “disabled.”
It can. The Tenth Circuit held that this worker’s request for a few more weeks of medical leave was a plausibly reasonable accommodation request, and the EEOC’s 2016 guidance says that going past the FMLA’s limit, by itself, isn’t enough to show undue hardship.
No. The EEOC’s guidance says employers needn’t grant leave that would cause undue hardship, and that leave without a specified or estimated end date can weigh toward hardship. That’s why giving an estimated return date matters.
No. The court decided only that the EEOC’s claims may go forward. It didn’t decide whether she had a disability under the ADA, and it said a jury might ultimately side with the company.
It isn’t binding on Oregon’s federal courts, which sit in a different circuit. But the ADA and the EEOC’s guidance on medical leave are federal, and other courts can find the Tenth Circuit’s reasoning persuasive.
Ask for medical leave in writing, describe your symptoms and limits, give an estimated return date tied to your treatment, send your doctor’s notes and keep copies of everything. If you’re refused or fired, contact the EEOC or a lawyer.
Sovereignty over Servitude. 🌸
Support this work
Everything Bloom publishes is free to read and free to share.
Bloom Ministries is a registered 501(c)(3) in Salem, Oregon. Monthly giving is what lets us say yes before the money is in hand.
Keep reading
Colorado Legislature · 17 November 2026Supreme Court Turns Away Challenge to Colorado’s Misgendering Rules
Trans advocacy · 11 November 2026Jeffco Lawsuit Paused: What the Federal Promise Covers, and Doesn’t
Trans advocacy · 11 November 2026DOJ Official Behind Trans Care Subpoenas Resigns: What Stays